10 ms·
Why So Many Police Are Handling the Protests Wrong
- awillen 6y agoI feel like some upfront setting of expectations would really, really be helpful here. If you're planning to arrest people after curfew, explain that in clear terms: "Our curfew is at 8pm, so we will start asking groups to disperse at 7:30. At 8pm, no large assemblies will be permitted, and police will begin arresting people in large groups at that time. We understand some people will engage in civil disobedience, and if they are cooperative with the police, they will be arrested peacefully. If any protesters start taking action that endangers police (e.g. throwing bricks or running at police unexpectedly), they will be met with force and arrested. Because it can be difficult for police to determine the perpetrator of violence, additional crowd control tactics such as tear gas may be used, so we strongly encourage you to self-police and prevent any violence towards police. After 8pm there will be a 30 minute grace period for those who are not gathered in groups but are in the process of heading home. At 8:30pm, anyone who remains on the street will be detained." I think it would really help both in terms of outcomes as well as the perception of police if they gave this kind of clear description of what's going to happen. As it stands now, the curfews aren't enforced with any kind of regularity, so they just cause confusion.
- jdavis703 6y agoA much simpler policy would be to have no curfew at all. As someone who has participated in protests for 5 out of the last 6 days and was tear gassed, I can tell you that protestors are much more peaceful when the cops keep a distance. Once the armor shows up and the tear gassing starts protestors get angry.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoI haven't been protesting but there should be an exception for when police escalate. I've watched videos of peaceful protestors getting shield bashed by police which causes them to get really angry and then they get a beat down for being angry about it. It's a pretty human response to get angry when someone gets physically aggressive towards you.
- awillen 6y agoI also agree with this. It seems like in the majority of cases at this point, the curfew does nothing but create unnecessary conflict. It almost creates an objective for protesters - to be serious about what they're protesting, they need to stay out after the curfew. I think curfews do have a place when there's massive looting happening and the police need the streets clear so they can prevent it, but there hasn't been enough looting in several days to justify curfews.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoThe case that will be made is that the curfew has caused the reduction in looting, by sending the most nonviolent protestors home and making it easier to distinguish those looting.
- awillen 6y agoExcept there are still extremely large protests in DC/NY/LA after curfew but the looting appears to have stopped.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoWhile I decline to specifically endorse that logic at this time, I don't think it is necessarily is in conflict with your observation. The crowd dynamics of protestors protesting after curfew and of that of looters may be quite different: one crowd, versus many smaller groups dispersed in the city, spreading out, with a mix of protesting and opportunistic looting (sometimes in the same group and sometimes not).
- rb808 6y agoMaybe in areas where there have been no looting. In NYC its pretty frustrating to see midtown being looted and police having to babysit protesters that should be at home.
- mindslight 6y agoThe police don't "have to" be occupied with protestors. The police are prioritizing punishing peaceful protestors for speaking out against them, while deprioritizing going after looting as its presence actually helps the police narrative.
- stunt 6y agoLook at their gears and equipment. The whole riot-police industry only focuses on anti-riot training and strategies. They don't practice for peaceful protests. They aren't designed for that and you can see it just by looking at what they are wearing and holding. An armed protest without riot-police presence is normally more quiet than a peaceful protest with their presence. It was a wrong call to send them to a peaceful protest in the first place. They should have published a proper schedule and location for the protest and let people to share their voices. Police shouldn't guard the protesters. That's a recipe for chaos. They should guard the city, businesses, and take care of safety of protesters. And it gets worst when the government focus is pushing police harder and harder to end the protest instead of helping them by telling people that their voice has been heard. Police under pressure starts overreacting to protesters instead of taking care of looters which has nothing to do with protesters. No matter how much they try to control. Often they just get tired, things get messy and overwhelming and they start to beat people. Now sadly there are also a small number of police force that are just waiting for a day to have an opportunity to enjoy and exercise all the anti-riot trainings they had with their fancy equipment. And that's where you see stupid unnecessary violence from police and no sign that they regret doing that.
- aspenmayer 6y agoAre curfews compatible with otherwise law-abiding constitutionally-protected protests? What’s the caselaw on protests? I remember during OccupySF, curfews were ineffective at ending the protest, but I don’t know if any legal ruling was ever made as to if the curfew was applicable or binding to the protests.
- mc32 6y agoI think the police can disperse when they think violence will escalate. Say you have opposing factions protesting each other (let’s say people seeking independence versus those who want to remain a colony somewhere). Should police just allow them to beat each other or instill some order?
- viklove 6y agoShould doesn't matter, are curfews legal?
- mc32 6y agoWell curfews are enforced at the municipal level. Some places have teen curfews and such and I’m not sure they have been struck down everywhere, so I think the lagality varies by jurisdiction. It is an interesting question with intersectionality with remain in place orders as well. Can the gov keep you from going places? Seems most states have had some shelter in place orders.
- freeone3000 6y agoNY state has suspended Habeas Corpus and federal forces in DC have violated the ENTIRE bill of rights (including the third!) so I think legal/illegal is a bit of a moot point to make.
- ceejayoz 6y agoWait, where has the Third Amendment been violated? I think you're getting wires severely crossed there. The National Guard is staying at hotels, but the government'll certainly be paying for that lodging. https://dcist.com/story/20/06/03/federal-troop-lodging-at-marriott-marquis-and-other-local-hotels-shuttled-to-d-c-protests-on-tour-buses/ https://dcist.com/story/20/06/03/federal-troop-lodging-at-ma... There's a dispute over who pays (Feds vs DC): https://twitter.com/maustermuhle/status/1268921612595875846 https://twitter.com/maustermuhle/status/1268921612595875846
- xxpor 6y agoHere's what's actually happening: the cops say there's a curfew and they're arresting everyone at 8. Except then they kettle everyone at 7:30 so you can't leave. They then arrest you at 8 for breaking curfew.
- awillen 6y agoYep, I've been seeing that in NY, and it baffles me. The cynical part of me thinks they want to arrest people, but that just seems too stupid at this point. The city leadership has to know that doing this is only causing the protests to continue. Maybe cynicism is the right approach, but people usually act in their own self interest, and it's very much in the self interest of the politicians running the city to not have police out there beating people and to get crowds to disperse peacefully. Just baffling and terrible.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> The city leadership has to know that doing this is only causing the protests to continue. City leadership doesn't have control. Fired cops get reinstated. When criticized or acted against, they retaliate against civilian leadership. https://twitter.com/MplsWard3/status/1267891878801915904 https://twitter.com/MplsWard3/status/1267891878801915904 > Politicians who cross the MPD find slowdowns in their wards. After the first time I cut money from the proposed police budget, I had an uptick in calls taking forever to get a response, and MPD officers telling business owners to call their councilman about why it took so long. https://gizmodo.com/nypd-union-doxes-mayors-daughter-on-twitter-1843813751 https://gizmodo.com/nypd-union-doxes-mayors-daughter-on-twit... > A New York City Police Department union known for its controversial attacks against Mayor Bill de Blasio tweeted out the personally identifying information of his daughter on Sunday night, including a residential address and her New York State ID number. https://www.cityandstateny.com/articles/politics/new-york-city/meet-men-who-scared-de-blasio-away-police-reform.html https://www.cityandstateny.com/articles/politics/new-york-ci... > Lynch’s most infamous comment, the one that many believe set New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio running scared from the cause of police reform, came after a man shot two NYPD officers in Brooklyn in 2014. The slain officers’ “blood on the hands starts at City Hall in the Office of the Mayor,” Lynch said. The PBA president blamed de Blasio because the mayor acknowledged, in the wake of Garner’s death, that racially disparate policing exists in New York City. Cops subsequently turned their back on de Blasio at the slain officers’ funeral, and the mayor has sided with the cops ever since. > But to understand why the mayor does what he does, one must understand what he’s up against. On Monday, The City reported that since 2015 the PBA has spent upwards of $1.4 million on lobbying and campaign contributions. In addition to conventional political advocacy for their interests, as City & State noted in a 2019 cover story, “the cops also have the power to undermine a mayor by refusing to do their job.” In December 2014, when Lynch blamed the two officers’ murders on de Blasio, NYPD officers made two-thirds fewer arrests and wrote 94% fewer tickets than they had during the same period the year before. The PBA has also moved to block new policies intended to increase transparency and accountability, for example by suing to prevent the release of body camera footage.
- zbrozek 6y agoThat sounds like a good approach to reduce tragic outcomes _right now_, but I can't help but feel that it's also oppressive. I don't want there to be curfews at all, because that's not freedom. I'm just glad that my municipality doesn't have them, though I have to be careful these days about where I bike because some nearby ones do.
- the_gastropod 6y agoCurfews cannot be enforced as you're suggesting. There are people who need to be out past curfews (e.g., hospital workers, delivery drivers, doormen, etc.) So police already cannot indiscriminately arrest anyone on the streets past curfew. So the whole notion of curfew is inherently unclear and hard to enforce. Additionally, the essential workers who work overnight hours also tend to be disproportionately minorities—the same people police disproportionately arrest and brutalize. Curfews are another really misguided attempt to quell otherwise peaceful protests, and only serve to escalate tensions.
- mc32 6y agoDo people on their way to work not avoid protests? I know I would. I know protests can turn on a dime at any moment. Police can get you, protesters can misidentify you, etc.
- ceejayoz 6y agoSome don't have the option. https://www.pix11.com/news/local-news/manhattan/mayor-blasts-arrest-of-delivery-worker-caught-on-video-on-upper-west-side https://www.pix11.com/news/local-news/manhattan/mayor-blasts... > Mayor Bill de Blasio spoke out overnight after videos went viral on social media Thursday appearing to show a delivery worker being arrested by police in Manhattan while making a delivery past the city's 8 p.m. curfew.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gentryb 6y agoLiving in the center of a mid-sized city - this isn't always possible. When doing volunteer health assessments at the local homeless shelter, I came across several situations where there isn't a clear path to get to my destination that doesn't involve people protesting (literally surrounded at times).
- pizzazzaro 6y ago
- mimikatz 6y agoI completely agree. Two other big causes of problems that I never see brought up are. Clear rules about what is allowed/causes a response. You routinely hear protesters complain we did nothing and the police started firing tear gas or moving in on the crowd. What they don't know is if the fence between the two sides gets pushed or moved police consider that aggression and respond. That's just an example, but when both sides understand the rules it makes things safer another thing common language to communicate through the two sides. Police are abusive when clearing the streets, they push and club people, they spray them when they turn around and stop moving. A protester isn't going to know what is happening and it is human nature to turn around and ask, which police respond to by hitting them. It is a bit of insanity.
- katbyte 6y agoWhen you announce curfew, at curfew you’re doing a lot wrong.
- jdc 6y ago[...] if they are cooperative with the police, they will be arrested peacefully. If only..
- adamsea 6y agoThere's actually very little confusion; police are unaccountable and behave as such. You realize that the heart of the issue has nothing to do with rules, conventions, or regulations, right? You could create all those rules you listed, and then so many police would just ignore them, abuse or harm people (especially people of color), and their colleagues would not intervene.
- 0xB31B1B 6y agoA better way to set expectations would be to not equip the cops with riot and war gear face shields, batons, tear gas etc. Equip them with cargo shorts, dad style new balance shoes, and polo shirts. The police should be there to deescalate, not escalate. There are a lot of studies that show that "the uniform makes the man" and by outfitting someone in war gear, they are primed to "go to war". It sounds insane, but in the 70s, menlo park changed their police uniforms from the standard issue to suit and tie, and not only did incidents of officer involved violence go down by like 50%, but citizen on citizen violence also went down by like 30%. The reality is, the people have a right to peacefully assemble, so setting expectations that the cops are going to beat the shit out of people in a peaceful assembly is morally wrong and unconstitutional.
- mindslight 6y agoAnother thing to point out about gear specifically that doesn't seem to be getting talked about: All of those full face respirators the cops are wearing would also work great for healthcare workers, who are still dealing with COVID-19. Specifically anything with pink cartridges has a P100 particulate filter, the highest level of filtration (99.97% vs N95 95%). When you see a picture of cops wearing or holding respirators, you should think of the nurses, EMTs, and vulnerable people that have been deprived of that PPE, just so the cops don't have to think about which direction the wind is blowing before they open fire on peaceful protestors.
- gwd 6y agoThat all sounds perfectly reasonable, but there's still a problem: police using force against people not doing anything obviously wrong. That loses the police their legitimacy, and makes protesters more angry and less likely to obey; leading to more force, leading to more anger. Imagine this scenario: Maybe 80% of the protesters are totally planning on going home at 8pm. You have 15% who are stubborn and don't like to be told what to do; they'll go home at 9pm if they're asked to insistently, just to show that you're not their boss. And 5% who are downright looking for a confrontation and won't go home until it's clear they won't get one. What happens when you apply your rubric? Well, when you apply your force at 8:30, those 15% move from the "stubborn" camp to the "confrontational" camp. In the 80%, there will be people who see the unnecessary violence, and move to the "stubborn" camp; in addition to people who tried to get home by 8:30 but couldn't for whatever reason. Now you've got 30% of your protesters in the "confrontational" camp. The police get more defensive, and start doing stupid things like shooting people before 7:30. Congrats, now 40% of the people are in the confrontational camp. Malcolm Gladwell recently posted a chapter from a book he wrote, concerning The Troubles in Northern Ireland, as a podcast recently; it addresses one of the core assumptions in your suggestion, that people are simple cost-benefit calculators, and so that with enough force, you can make impose your will on people. It never really turns out the way people think it will. https://podbay.fm/podcast/1119389968/e/1591088400 https://podbay.fm/podcast/1119389968/e/1591088400
- dragontamer 6y agoThe main issue is that the Police have lost legitimacy. Mostly due to our confusing structure in the USA. https://twitter.com/sunriseon7/status/1267587976986427393 https://twitter.com/sunriseon7/status/1267587976986427393 Same incident, different camera angle: https://twitter.com/benyc/status/1267587033783992322 https://twitter.com/benyc/status/1267587033783992322 . We can see the first officer shield-bashing the crew unprovoked, and a 2nd officer come in to baton-smack the reporter. As members of the press, they are morally obligated to be there, recording what is going on. And it is pretty clear that the Police charge and attack the cameracrew in this instance. ---------- This was the stupid decision of two officers. However, we can bet that this "stupid decision" will go unpunished. Which is the entire point of the protests. The Police do not seem to have any mechanism for feedback in these circumstances, and can do whatever they want. The protesters now want this officer to be punished. But once again, we have no mechanism to punish police officers in the USA. ------ A few more aggravating factors: * DC has a ton of different police departments due to the confusing structure of the city / not a state / seat of the federal government. Case in point: were these officers Secret Service? DC Park police? Metropolitan Police Department ? Unclear who to blame right now. * Its unclear because these officers in this instance taped over their badges and identification. We don't know the names of the cops in riot gear, we don't know who they were working for. We don't know the chain of command. * This happened roughly 45-minutes BEFORE curfew. The President (or really: Attorney General Barr) seemed to want the area cleared for a Press Briefing on Monday, but this fact was not clearly communicated to the protesters, nor to members of the press. * Given all the advantages Police officers have in the justice system, it is unlikely that if we press charges (even if we managed to get the names of the officers in this incident) that the courts would ever be on our side. The courts overwhelmingly take the side of officers. I will note: there's clearly one officer who is holding back his colleague in this instance, who provides room for the cameraman and the reporter to escape. There are "good guys" in the police department, but it is increasingly looking like a minority. ------ The "Go home before curfew" argument doesn't work in these circumstances. With protesters (and reporters) getting bashed long before the curfew, its only natural for the protesters to not respect the curfew anymore.
- klyrs 6y ago> If you're planning to arrest people after curfew, explain that in clear terms... Who writes that notice? A coalition of the foot soldiers who are doing the actual arrests, or some high-minded politician sitting behind a desk? Because that politician can't actually make promises about the behavior of the police. De Blasio has been denying that well-documented cases of abuse have happened, and saying that if such a thing were to happen, it'd surely be punished. We've yet to see any accountability for NYPD. Statements are nice. Actions matter.
- gremlinsinc 6y agoAccording to the FBI, there's been a move by white supremacists to essentially take over the police of this country: https://www.justsecurity.org/70507/white-supremacist-infiltration-of-us-police-forces-fact-checking-national-security-advisor-obrien/ https://www.justsecurity.org/70507/white-supremacist-infiltr... Cops seem to enjoy beating up protesters, and I think that's the real problem.
- drewbug01 6y agoI agree, in general, that clear expectations lead to better outcomes. But what you've described is dystopian: - curfew: a curfew is an extreme tactic that deprives many people of their civil liberties without due process. There are legitimate reasons for curfews to exist at times, but dispersing peaceful protest is not one of them. - use of tear gas: this is (quite literally) prohibited under the Geneva protocol even in times of war. - "difficult for police to determine": this suggests that because the job is difficult, the police have leeway to indiscriminately punish whomever is nearby. Again - I understand why you'd make the argument you made, but the fatal flaw is that it is founded on an utterly dystopian premise. The response from police across the country is unjustified, and a rank violation of everything that Americans supposedly hold dear.
- awillen 6y agoSure, I don't disagree with any of this - especially with the almost entirely peaceful protests the last couple of days, curfews are entirely inappropriate. My point is only to say that if they're going to use them, communicating expectations would lead to better outcomes. But yeah, 100% same page, especially with regard to tear gas.
- unethical_ban 6y ago> Disproportionate use of force can turn a peaceful protest violent, research shows. I would like to RTFA soon, but just glancing at this, I'll agree with it. I thought to myself that if I were a peaceful protester that got a real taste of police brutality like I've seen online, I would make sure I was out every day, and I would be a lot more angry than I am as someone who "just" cares about civil rights.
- mc32 6y agoProblem is backing down. When you’re in a heightened state of alertness and your body has primed you for fight/flight, it’s hard for either side to calm down. Even in domestic disputes where people know each other and at least think they’ve “loved” each other and care. It’s hard to back down. So seeking confrontation is the problem from both sides. Some people want to protest, some want to confront. And the police prepare for worst case ... which means confrontation which escalates... Then you have opportunists who just want a fight .
- walls 6y agoIf only there were some kind of training that could help peace officers maintain the peace... Oh well, guess this is as good as we can do.
- mc32 6y agoTraining helps. But it’s hard to overcome instincts. Domestic abusers (not always people prone to violence) are sent to classes and often get in the same situation again, even after training and knowing the legal consequences.
- danaris 6y agoSending in police equipped with riot gear, tear gas, and military-grade equipment, from precincts riddled with white supremacists and officers with known (but ignored) histories of excessive force, results very predictably in the situations that we have seen. Sure, it's hard to overcome instincts, but it's far from impossible, and most of the police that have been actively creating these problems haven't even started trying.
- cududa 6y agoMilitary seems to do relatively decent job at training that compared to cops, and it's not like the cops are down the barrel of guns. Just water bottles and some bricks
- 6y ago
- yters 6y agoIf I were a cop going to confront protesters who could be armed, and represent a group known for executing cops, have currently killed one cop, and are generally causing chaos, I might want to bring a little more than my work clothes. Just saying the cops' perspective is not totally incoherent...
- pwthornton 6y agoYes, like that elderly man they pushed over in Buffalo who fractured his skull. You never know when these unarmed old people are going to try to end your life! https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/05/us/buffalo-police-suspension-shoving-man-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/06/05/us/buffalo-police-suspension-... The protestors are not a group known for executing cops. Unless this was just a straight up racist dog whistle about black people. That has no basis in fact. The protestors are overwhelmingly peaceful.
- yters 6y agopeople claiming to be acting on behalf of blm have executed a number of cops, and i believe some of their leaders have called for the same micah xavier johnson is one security guard dave underwood was executed a few days ago but you also bring up a good point some protesters could be gang bangers who do have a vendetta out for cops
- ceejayoz 6y ago> have currently killed one cop When/where did this occur? > represent a group known for executing cops Which group would this be?
- umvi 6y agoJust like you should drive defensively, you should protest defensively too. A pair of ballistic-grade safety glasses for starters would go a long way (the kind industrial workers use to protect their eyes from flying ball bearings). I keep reading stories about reporters losing eyes to rubber bullets, when it is completely preventable.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoArrest and charging of the criminals (who happen to be police as well) firing rubber bullets at people's heads would also help. But yes, safety gear as a backup.
- delusional 6y agoDrive defensively, but if a drunk driver hits your car and kills you, it's still their fault. Wear safety glasses, but if a police officer hits you and takes out your eye, it's still their fault. I agree with you that wearing safety gear might be a great idea. That still says something terrible about the American police system, and it shouldn't be necessary.
- thomascgalvin 6y agoThere are an array of reasons. 1. The "broken windows" fallacy taken to its extreme: > The broken windows theory is a criminological theory that states that visible signs of crime, anti-social behavior, and civil disorder create an urban environment that encourages further crime and disorder, including serious crimes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_windows_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_windows_theory Police see themselves as the "thin blue line" between chaos and social order, and believe that they must put down and resistence, immediately, decisively, and violently. But, this is a fallacy. In NYC, for example, major crimes fell when the NYPD stopped is "proactive policing" policy. https://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-proactive-policing-crime-20170925-story.html https://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-proacti... 2. Militarization. The police are no longer trained to "protect and serve;" they're trained to occupy and battle. They see citizens as the enemy, and treat them as such. They are being told to "dominate the battlespace," which is what you say about an enemy you want to destroy, not a community you want to protect. This extends to their equipment, as well. There are too many SWAT teams, too many tanks, too many tools of violence, and when you have those tools, they will be used. Part of this is because of government budgeting - if you don't use it, why should they give you more money - and part of this is because we have fetishised violent police action. A lot of this started with COPS, but "police being action heroes" is an entire genre of reality TV now. You can find videos of the police officers gleefully destroying buildings because a suspect might be inside. 3. Personal immunity. Police face no repercussions for their actions. If a police office targets the wrong house, tosses a flashbang into a baby's crib, and shoots the mother ... nothing happens. There is no justice, there is no recourse. Police are violent because they can be violent, with impunity. This is driven in large part by police unions, who make it essentially impossible to fire a police officer, even for the worst behavior. 4. Personality. The job of police officer attracts the kind of person who should not be a police officer. People who want power over others, people who want a license to use violence, simply cannot be trusted with that power. This issue is greatly compounded by the above points; if you take someone with violent fantasies, give them military grade weaponry, teach them that their neighbors are an enemy who will murder them with the slightest provocation,and tell them that they will never face any consequences for their actions, what do you expect to happen?
- 6y ago
- 082349872349872 6y agoOdd that tacticool US police, despite copying the look, don't attempt to learn how the US military behaves: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23347453 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23347453 "2-54. Scalable effects concepts are a measured approach in response to a crowd gathering. By recognizing a use-of-force policy, soldiers must be taught and understand that they use the minimum force necessary. Without the appearance of a graduated response, the gathering crowd may consider actions as excessive, causing a possible escalation of hostilities or violence." Then again, even within the LE world, the information is available, eg https://www.chirontraining.com https://www.chirontraining.com
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoIt's GI Joe cosplay minus the laser guns.
- gowld 6y agoMeanwhile, at your local PD, they are learning how to protect the "sheep" (that's you, civilian) under the method called, and I swear I am not making this up, Killology. https://www.killology.com/ https://www.killology.com/
- 082349872349872 6y agoShouldn't that be Phonosology? Miller has some thoughts on the sheepdog metaphor: http://chirontraining.blogspot.com/2017/11/sheepdogs.html http://chirontraining.blogspot.com/2017/11/sheepdogs.html (he has thoughts on lots of things, up to and including how to deescalate when one is amped on adrenaline. I sometimes think that in a more just world, he'd have been an academic intellectual, but am glad that in ours, he choose his parents poorly, and wound up working in law enforcement —due to a financial glass ceiling— otherwise we'd probably have no one who is both familiar with the problems LE practitioners face and has the inclination to theorise upon how the approaches might be improved)
- adamsea 6y agoFrom the article: 'Couper, the creator of the Madison Method, said, “It’s this whole attitude of, ‘We keep order because we kick ass, and it’s us against them.’ (...) We've got to root those people out and say, ‘Look, this is the job that we expect. This is how a democracy is policed. If you can't buy into it. I'm sorry. You just have to find another job.’”'
- 4636760295 6y agoThe police don't exist to protect the general public, they exist to protect rich people and their property. Politicians know this, and they allow the police to project an aura of fear because it helps them maintain control of the population with a relatively small force. The US is a plutocracy: it's a country governed largely by the rich, through lobbying, gerrymandering, and a constant information war to convert the least intelligent voters to their side. There's a reason why people who are bad at evaluating facts objectively and often believe in conspiracy theories, and also those who are rich, tend to vote for one particular side.
- danaris 6y agoMaybe this is how it is. Most of us believe it's not how it should be. And it's definitely not what the law says it is.
- 4636760295 6y agoI agree. What worries me is that the law seems to be ignored by authorities. Thus, we need to think about whether the authorities should have authority in the first place. They like to wave the banner of the constitution, but only when it serves their purpose and narrative. I'm in favour of direct digital democracy, rather than powerful politicians who refuse to act.
- 082349872349872 6y agoThe "Bob Roberts" movie has aged well.
- 082349872349872 6y agoBe careful with asking people to do what the law says. King (Martin, not Rodney) said[1] "[a]ll we say to America is to be true to what you said on paper". Kennedy suggested[2] a world "where the strong are just and the weak secure and the peace preserved". If he were alive today, I'm sure JFK would have half a mind to ask "how could you elect such a schoolyahd president?" [1] https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/king-papers/documents/ive-been-mountaintop-address-delivered-bishop-charles-mason-temple https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/king-papers/documents/ive... [2] https://nationalcenter.org/KennedyInaugural.html https://nationalcenter.org/KennedyInaugural.html (incidentally, Earl Warren has an interesting history; he once became Governor of California by winning both the D and R primaries)
- toyg 6y agoThe analysis assumes the police actually wants to de-escalate things and they are just mis-handling protests. That's not necessarily true.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sillywalk 6y agoBeating/gassing/terrorizing peaceful protesters en-masse, is THE POINT. Especially when so many cop unions are totally unaccountable, and run by cowardly authoritarian sadists. Brown shirts for Trump. Who are the rioters? The cops.
- sleepysysadmin 6y agoHumans are social beings. Quarantines, unemployment, essential workers under additional stress and social isolation are all creating a far more tenuous situation than say last summer. Flipside, Police who have had to deal with people fake sneezing on them and avoiding the virus; still working everyday because they are essential. They are on edge. Now add in the fact that governments have used the virus as a way to shutdown protests. Hong Kong? Gaza? Albania? Sudan? Yellow vests? BLM? Venezuela? Unprecedented amounts of unemployment means people can get out and protest and they've been couped up for how long? They'll be getting out to protest. We are in the spring, wait until the summer and fall. It's going to be huge; and then the US election happens between turd sandwich and giant douche.
- wayneftw 6y agoPolice handle many things wrongly. I just got back from the store where I held the door open for a police man as he entered... and he wasn't wearing a mask. I waited until he got out and I asked him "No mask?" to which he replied "Why?" and I said "The sign says No Mask, No Service" (and everybody else was wearing one) and this asshole replies "I wasn't buying anything." I laughed at him and drove off.
- flyGuyOnTheSly 6y agoSo you began your interaction by holding the door open for another human being, and you ended it a few minutes later by confronting them about a personal choice of health and safety, thought them to be an asshole, and laughed at them due to their response? And you're so proud of that interaction that you are posting it in a comment on HN right now? For all you know the officer was called into the store for an urgent matter. Be kind to others, and you'll lead a much happier and fulfilling life.
- wayneftw 6y ago> So you began your interaction by holding the door open for another human being, and you ended it a few minutes later by confronting them about a personal choice of health and safety, thought them to be an asshole, and laughed at them due to their response? Yep. It's not a personal choice though... it's well-known that wearing masks prevents the spread of disease. How is it that you are ignorant of this fact? > And you're so proud of that interaction that you are posting it in a comment on HN right now? That's what you got out of that?? Okay... You seem to be having trouble differentiating a plain description of a brief interaction with a cop who was clearly in the wrong with "pride". > For all you know the officer was called into the store for an urgent matter. Too urgent to take 2 seconds to put a mask on for everybody's safety???? When he wasn't running into the store? That's not urgent... Sorry buddy, but you're clearly wrong. Perhaps you should re-think your position. > Mind your own business, be kind to others, and you'll lead a much happier and fulfilling life. I'm white, I live in a great neighborhood, I got a huge house, a pool, a boat, 3 cars, my job is very fulfilling, I make 6 figures working full-time from home doing something I love... my family is wonderful, I have hobbies, friends, I travel... thanks for your concern, but I'm not sure how much happier I can get, lol ;) I'm honestly doing so well and my life is so easy that I feel guilty at times. Sorry that you got triggered by this. Perhaps you should consider taking your own advice? Please do... thanks.