9 ms·
US schools lay off hundreds of thousands
- viburnum 6y agoYou know who’s not laying off anyone? The military. Local funding of schools is ridiculous. Education benefits the whole nation. Educational investments shouldn’t be dictated by transient economic conditions.
- tyree731 6y ago> Educational investments shouldn’t be dictated by transient economic conditions. Could someone not make the same argument about the national defense? Education is funded largely by local taxes, and local tax revenues are being gutted, so there isn't much that can be done here without nationalizing public education.
- catalogia 6y ago> "Could someone not make the same argument about the national defense?" I took that to be the point they were making.
- buzzkillington 6y ago>Education is funded largely by local taxes, and local tax revenues are being gutted, so there isn't much that can be done here without nationalizing public education. This should be the case. Having each state decide it's education is in the long term more dangerous than having each state have it's own army. Imagine if half the country had textbooks that made the Confederates out to be misguided but well meaning... oh wait.
- abootstrapper 6y agoNot sure why you’re being downvoted. I’m from the south and was taught as a child that the confederates fought for “states rights” and slavery was a subplot. Many years later I realized that was bullshit. I wished I could go back in time and call my teacher on it.
- chadash 6y agoIt was fought over states rights. Their rights to allow slaves. Misleading, but not exactly untrue.
- dorchadas 6y agoYep. I teach in a rural school in the South. We still have Social Studies teachers claiming the Civil War had nothing to do with slavery. It's really damn frustrating. Though textbooks? We haven't had textbook updates in years at this point. Since I was in the school, and I graduated 10 years ago.
- JackFr 6y agoI have friends and in-laws Who still maintain that. Honestly the myth of the lost cause was drilled into the culture for a hundred years.
- disposekinetics 6y agoI think the current system leads to too much stagnation. Let each state be a laboratory of democracy and hope the winning ideas spread instead of mandating a top down approach.
- Spartan-S63 6y agoI don't think we should be opposed to nationalizing education. A common curriculum would help mobility when it comes to families moving across state lines. It would also ensure uniform funding and plentiful opportunities to poorer and rural schools.
- imgabe 6y agoMaybe, but it would require a constitutional amendment to enact. The Constitution is explicit about which powers the Federal government has and everything else is delegated to the states. Education is not one of them.
- tyre 6y agoA large majority of the current US government is made up of things outside the constitution as written. The underpinning of most government agencies is the commerce clause, and even then there is a question of whether Congress delegating to administrative agencies is constitutional. For example, the FCC, the FDA, the FAA—these powers aren't in the constitution and I'm not saying that because there weren't cell phones or airplanes in 1789.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> For example, the FCC, the FDA, the FAA—these powers aren't in the constitution All three regulate different aspects of interstate commerce.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago"You don't get any federal funding unless you do X Y and Z."
- nostromo 6y ago> common curriculum You mean something like Common Core? We have that.
- dorchadas 6y ago
- malwarebytess 6y ago>Could someone not make the same argument about the national defense? The US's definition of National Defense is actually playing world police for corporate profit. With that in mind it shows that they are superficially similar only.
- a4wtaw4tawtawt 6y agopost like it's 2003?
- RhysU 6y agoNational Defense is a luxury good until it isn't. Moreover, it is not something that can be purchased on short notice.
- darksaints 6y agoProtecting our nation from harm is easy to do. Nearly every nation in the world does it pretty well, and they do it with tiny fractions of our budget. The key is to not run around the world occupying nations and starting new wars every other day. War is and always will be asymmetric. Our military isn't expensive because we need it to be, it is expensive because it is an invasion and occupying force.
- jeffbee 6y agoThe ONE TIME that US national defense actually worked it was very much purchased on short notice.
- culturestate 6y agoUnfortunately, "there are two oceans between us and any potential aggressors" is no longer a viable defensive posture. If you're gonna be drawn into a war today it's unlikely to come with years of lead time.
- xtracto 6y agoAnericans live so scared!
- mhh__ 6y ago> Could someone not make the same argument about the national defense? > national defense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures#Total_military_spending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_... I'm not as against military spending as some people, but almost 800 billion dollars is too much
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoHow much would be appropriate? What weapons systems should be canceled? Serious question. I would agree that $800B seems ridiculously high, and yet it's not easy to tease apart what should be cut.
- starik36 6y agoKeep in mind that the personnel and benefits take up 39% of the cost.
- ludston 6y agoDeciding that would be the job of the military wouldn't it? That's how cuts usually work. If they need some random on HN to tell them how to do that then they probably shouldn't have the job in the first place.
- latch 6y agoA lot of experts argue for and against aircraft carriers. The against (or at least not so many) argument seem more compelling to this layman.
- ikeyany 6y agoWhatever funding goes to military displays at sporting events can be cut for once. We never had flyovers and 7th-inning-stretch-salutes-to-heroes 20 years ago.
- pfranz 6y agoThe argument that always comes up is that those flights are necessary because they're flight time required for training and public events are recruiting tools since we have a volunteer force. However, reducing the number of pilots/planes mean fewer training missions and reducing the military headcount reduces the need for recruitment.
- yalogin 6y agoYeah but the US pays for national defense only to fund corporations continuously with unneeded weapon manufacturing so that the respective politicians in those districts can keep winning. There is really no national defense reasons there.
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoWhat's an example of an unneeded weapons system?
- chadash 6y agoF-35 program. There are much better uses for $1.5 trillion.
- pfranz 6y agoIt was pretty widely circulated that tanks were still being manufactured that were not wanted by the military: https://www.foxnews.com/politics/army-says-no-to-more-tanks-but-congress-insists https://www.foxnews.com/politics/army-says-no-to-more-tanks-...
- yalogin 6y agoI thought this was common knowledge to everyone and not at all controversial :) There are multiple reports over the years that the military is not asking for weapons but they are being assigned 100s of billions worth. If you are interested please dig it out.
- madengr 6y agoFederal revenue will be gutted too, it’s just that the states can’t print money.
- pmorici 6y agoFederal tax revenues are also being gutted its just that the federal government has the magical power of having control over the currency in which they issue their debt.
- MattGaiser 6y agoWould you really want national school funding given how Republicans behave? Sure, there might not be layoffs, but the system would be perpetually mediocre.
- readhn 6y agoMilitary spending trend is up for multiple decades.. regardless of who is in oval the office. Obama, or Trump, or Bush. There is no difference for the war machine in the long run, it keeps on working: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States#/media/File:Defense_spending.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_...
- teruakohatu 6y agoAre you an American (I am a New Zealander) but my understanding is that the military is the responsibility of the federal government and the federal government is not laying off workers. Meanwhile teachers are funded and employed by state and local government. It is apples to oranges. The argument should be who should employ and fund teachers and if the States are willing to give up some control and taxation to the feds in exchange for ???
- throwaway1777 6y agoThis is mostly correct although some schools do receive federal funding.
- mysticpipuo 6y agoWhen you or your loved ones or your friends are devastated by the layoffs and shutdown. When you are hurting and frustrated by everything that’s going on. Just remember. It’s the Chinese government that did this.
- nameless912 6y agoOh fuck off with this xenophobic bullshit.
- scollet 6y agoI think they were being facetious.
- nameless912 6y agoThat's giving them a LOT of credit. I'm not buying it.
- onefuncman 6y agoEven if you take it as facetious, it's shitposting. The punchline is insipid and uninspired.
- mysticpipuo 6y agoXeonophobic? By calling out the cause of all the chaos? I don’t understand why people keep defending Chinese government. With feeble reframing like racism. Try this: why are you attacking hitler Germany? That’s xenophobic
- kalium-xyz 6y agoSome people are okay with slave labor and the numerous crimes against humanity done by the past and current mainland chinese government. That or they think you are pro / against some politicians. Not all hn members are from the USA but a large portion of people in the US seem unaware of other english speaking countries or even people with second languages, who do not hold the opinions of politicians in regard to their own.
- gizmo686 6y agoSetting aside the specific merits of education funding; it makes no sense for any government spending to follow transient economic conditions. If anything, we want government spending to be inversely correlated with economic conditions, so it should go up during economic downturns.
- badrabbit 6y agoSorry but most military spending is not going to paying salaries. If your point is that defense budget should be smaller then I agree with that, but the last you want during an economic crisis is cutting back on defense/military. The economy depends on peace and geopolitical stability,not being able to respond properly to a crisis requiring military action can lead to scenarios that exasperate economic recovery. My view is, when the economy does better, additional revenue should not be allocated to defense spending.
- thrown2020 6y agogo fuck yourself
- rayiner 6y agoThe military is funded nationally for obvious reasons. But education is necessarily local; there are few things more personal to a community than the education of its children. We don’t need bureaucrats in DC deciding how kids in South Dakota are educated.
- viburnum 6y agoFinancing and control are separate things. Social Security is national but recipients spend it however they want. And there’s already federal mandates in education without funding, some good, some bad.
- DuskStar 6y ago> Financing and control are separate things. I'm not so sure this is true - or at least it's not true in practice. Look at "Obamacare" - the lever it used to control state medical regulations was federal medical funding, and that's not an uncommon situation. Federal highway funds are also a pretty well-known case of funding providing control. IMO even if there was a "fund all the schools with no control" bill passed and signed this year, in ten years (when everyone is dependant on federal school funding) that "no control" provision would be looking pretty doomed.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoThey can go to military school. One nation, one mission, one thought! Wouldn't even have so much to unlearn then. Ye olde new deal... Oorah! edit: notice to self: need to rewatch Starship Troopers
- pvaldes 6y ago> You know who’s not laying off anyone? The military I would not bet about it. Military robots are in the way. Even if the budget is increased, machines eventually will replace a lot of the current people.
- DuskStar 6y agoAnd how would you propose to set budgets, or teacher salaries? Should the teacher in rural Montana be paid the same as the one in downtown NYC? For that matter, "funding" is also "control" - do you think many states or cities are going to be eager to hand over their curriculae to the federal government?
- viburnum 6y agoFederal government does cost of living adjustments all the time, it’s not rocket science. Local control and national funding is a completely possible policy choice. There are tons of examples.
- DuskStar 6y ago> Local control and national funding is a completely possible policy choice. There are tons of examples. I can think of a few examples of national control and national funding, or local control and local funding, but not national funding without national control. What are you thinking of?
- achn 6y agoWait, public schools for children are not funded by the government in the US?
- MattGaiser 6y agoThey are not funded by the national government. They are mostly funded by city and county governments, with some money from state governments. Basically each city or county is mostly responsible for paying for the education of the children within its boundaries. EDIT: I am slightly off on the percentages. See the comment below.
- tomweingarten 6y ago"On average, 8% of revenues are federal, 47% from the state, and 45% locally sourced" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_school_funding_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_school_funding_in_the_U...
- achn 6y agodeleted
- drstewart 6y agoYou realize this is exactly the same as how schools are funded in Canada, correct? You have provincial funding, not federal funding. >Public schools are the responsibility of individual provincial departments of education and funded mainly from local and provincial taxes, with some federal funds. https://www.justlanded.com/english/Canada/Canada-Guide/Education/Public-Schools#:~:text=There%20isn't%20a%20federal%20government%20controlled%20or,state%20school%20system%20in%20Canada.&text=Public%20schools%20are%20the%20responsibility,taxes%2C%20with%20some%20federal%20funds https://www.justlanded.com/english/Canada/Canada-Guide/Educa....
- slavik81 6y agoThere's an enormous difference between provincially funded and locally funded, though. In Alberta at least, the funding is effectively entirely provincial. There aren't any significant spending disparities based on the local neighbourhood's ability to pay.
- rantwasp 6y agoit’s puzzling to me since I don’t understand who is going to replace the teachers. how is this going to work? also I feel like the priorities are totally wrong. on one side we invest in things that don’t matter or are harmful. on another we screw people that have a meaningful contribution to society
- readhn 6y agoits always been done this way.
- wmf 6y agoThe article says class sizes will double. But since classes will be through Zoom, teachers can just mute students who misbehave!
- rantwasp 6y agoso we’re gonna have 2 failures. doubling the class size and remote “learning”. what a mess
- MattGaiser 6y ago> it’s puzzling to me since I don’t understand who is going to replace the teachers. Another remaining teacher. Class sizes will increase.
- throwawaysea 6y agoIn some ways I view this as an opportunity for society. I would be happy to have a return to decentralized schooling or alternate models with more choice, rather than a one size fits all model that is increasingly being co-opted by political actors to propagandize children with certain views or values.
- throwgeorge 6y ago>rather than a one size fits all model that is increasingly being co-opted by political actors to propagandize children with certain views or values like all of the propaganda about the round earth and the efficacy of vaccines right?
- horsemessiah 6y agoYou wouldn't believe this if you didn't grow up in a stable home.
- tropdrop 6y agoAnd children who don't have parents with resources to "alternative models," deserve poor education? (I'm assuming you mean a stay-at-home parent who chooses to teach home-schooling because all that's necessary for the survival of this theoretical family is only 1 income earner, not 2). For reference, this is NOT an insignificant percentage of the US population [1]. 1 - https://www.financialsamurai.com/the-median-net-worth-of-us-households-over-time-has-gone-nowhere/ https://www.financialsamurai.com/the-median-net-worth-of-us-...
- avsteele 6y agoTitle: about teachers. Anecdotes: about teachers. Buried in the article: Susanna Loeb, a professor of education at Brown University, said she believes most of the 469,000 laid off in April were non-teacher personnel, as districts tend to fire teachers last If schools aren't open, a lot of janitorial, cafeteria worker, etc... are probably being laid off.
- MattGaiser 6y agoAt least in my province (in Canada), "non-teacher personnel" included all the academic support staff for learning disabled kids and academic assistants.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoWhile their numbers are non-trivial, students with disabilities (of whatever stripe) are a very small portion of the student body.
- Balgair 6y agoLike all things, it depends. My SO has had classrooms with >50% of the kids on IEPs. My SO has also had classrooms with <10% of the kids on IEP. The school generally has about 25% of the kids on IEPs.
- DuskStar 6y ago> The school generally has about 25% of the kids on IEPs. That really just sounds like the definition of IEP has been stretched beyond all reason.
- Balgair 6y agoNot really. The whole district is kinda like this. The kids really do need the help. The reasons for that need are all unique to each kid, but the underlying reason is poverty. They don't have enough to eat, their parents are incarcerated, their home life is horrific, they don't sleep enough, they get beat up by authority figures, etc. Add up any few of the reasons, and they'll clearly need an IEP, then add in trauma and PTSD stuff, and ... well. Mind, some are just fine through all the mess, and some need help even for less extreme issues. All people are distinct. Giving kids the little help they can get at school due to these life-long circumstances is well warranted.
- tengbretson 6y agoIt's odd to me that there is this bizarre certainty on hacker news that within 20 years the most common occupation, truck driving, will be nearly entirely obsolete, yet in an era where almost all human knowledge is available online for free, the idea that the education apparatus will either stay the same or continue to grow is somehow a given.
- coliveira 6y agoFive years ago there was the widespread belief that in 5 years most cars would be self driven. This was in fact the main reason for investors to give Uber extreme high valuation. As we see in this case, and many others, technology doesn't advance as fast as some of us wish.
- npunt 6y agoThat's because if you know anything about education, you know it's about human relationships as much as it is about pouring knowledge into empty vessels.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoI actually think the are two separate concepts, and I'm pretty sure a AI could teach kids the times tables and test spelling. My kids know a hell of a lot about the video games they play, and they didn't need a human relationship to tech them how everything works.
- npunt 6y agoTech can definitely teach some things to some people, but among other things it cannot create the context for teaching. This issue has been pretty well explored in the edtech community for a long time, and of course pedagogical research for much longer. If you're interested in learning more check out sources like EdSurge, which I started as a place to explore these issues.
- jay_kyburz 6y ago
- eanzenberg 6y agoOpen up already. The lockdown has been a sham, with scientists and researchers already acknowledging no difference between areas that locked down and areas that didn’t. Enough is enough. How much more suffering does the world need to endure over bad models and bad policy.
- thrown2020 6y agoI love that these fucking socialists are downvoting you. It speaks so much on how fucking stupid the average HN person is. "I'm going to go get VC funding by being a fucking piece of shit blue checkmark twitter bitch fascist asshole".
- bradly 6y agoI live in San Diego and this is sadly just more of the same. Public schools cut non-essential programs and then PTAs in upper and upper-middle class neighborhoods raise money from parents to add those programs back to their specific school. When time comes to vote on taxes to increase education budget, they are confused, as the public school system in San Diego is working great for them and their community. You shouldn’t be able to tell the income level of a neighborhood simply by looking at a picture of a public school, but in San Diego county, that is absolutely the case.
- tyoma 6y agoCalifornia pays for schools (at least the operational costs) at the state level since 2013 (https://www.cde.ca.gov/fg/aa/lc/lcffoverview.asp https://www.cde.ca.gov/fg/aa/lc/lcffoverview.asp). Local districts can propose bond measures, but there is no guarantee they will be accepted, even in rich districts. The school bond for Poway Unified was rejected on this past ballot. What is really going to hurt district finances is enrollment. The State pays districts based on student enrollment. If students do not show up due to COVID fears, that represents a lot of lost money. Many students will not be showing up this upcoming school year.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- techslave 6y agoand the stock market is still on a tear...
- missedthecue 6y agoBetter sell all my holdings in public schools
- makeitrein 6y agoJust watched Bryan Caplan give a talk about how the majority of our education system's resources are spent towards a "signaling arms race". What once required a high school diploma requires an undergraduate degree. What once required an undergraduate degree requires graduate school. Most of your time spend in school is learning skills that the labor market cares little for. Not wholly convinced by his conclusion that entirely defunding education is the path forward, but it's a perspective I found very interesting! Here's the interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hZylJp-pHo&t=495s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hZylJp-pHo&t=495s
- toomuchtodo 6y agoFunding education through employer taxes based on the education requirements they desire was an idea that I heard that might have some merit. You want someone with a bachelors? You pay X amount per year for that employee. A masters? Even more. You expose the employer to the cost of their desire, and thereby suss out if it is a want or a genuine need. Very similar to carbon taxes. If the tax is more expensive than on the job training, employees will get on the job training, possibly through an apprenticeship.
- MattGaiser 6y agoWould that alter employer behavior or just job descriptions? They could just set their employer talent management system to filter out applicants without those degrees.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoIf you employ them, and they have the credential, you still pay the tax regardless of job req contents.
- Breefield 6y agoThe Elephant In The Brain has a chapter on education which clearly draws a lot from Bryan's book The Case Against Education. Interestingly Bryan Caplan was one of book's pre-publishing reviewers.
- zaroth 6y ago> Robert Hull, chief executive of the National Association of State Boards of Education, which represents states’ interests, told Reuters most class sizes actually will shrink when schools reopen. That is because of COVID-19 and the need for social distancing. One adaptation will be to have students come to school, on a staggered basis, only on certain days of the week, and possibly receive video instruction other days. He predicted that some of these changes would be permanent. I have a 2nd and 5th grader, going into 3rd and 6th grade. I can say from first and second-hand experience that the social, emotional, and intellectual damage being caused to young children by closing schools is absolutely frightening. This is to say nothing of the tremendous cost to households who aren’t able to adjust work schedules around their children not being in school. Or even of the children where school is their respite and dependable source of a decent meal. If there are days where my children are not allowed to go to school in the fall, those are days my kids and I will be spending protesting either in front of the school, or in front of the State House. If from my ultra privileged position I can see significant emotional and intellectual damage being done to my kids from this policy, I have a hard time imagining the widespread costs and impact that closing schools is having across society.
- jwilber 6y agoCould also do with cutting police funding. A local city in WA spends 53% of their budget on police[0]. Imagine if just a fraction of that went to education? I’d love to see solid studies on the efficacy/use of police budgeting. At a cursory glance, it’s an easy dataset with which to mislead: is crime going down because budgets are going up? Probably not. But without a solid study, we can’t say for sure. Still, I think we can agree: 53% is way too high (NYC in 2017 was 8% [1]). [0] https://mobile.twitter.com/jesusonah/status/1268650880800223235 https://mobile.twitter.com/jesusonah/status/1268650880800223... [1] https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccarthy/2017/08/07/how-much-do-u-s-cities-spend-every-year-on-policing-infographic/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccar...
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoBut a lot of money is wasted in education, as well. There are incompetent teachers with too much seniority to fire, for example, who are at the top of the pay scale, and with nice pensions waiting for them when they do retire. Many competent ones as well, but it's a big enough problem that basically every teacher I've ever met can tell you stories.
- tryptophan 6y agoMy mother is a teacher, and the stories she tells me make me really doubt our public education system. Administrators only care about 'passing' students so that they can 'graduate'. Helping students during standardized exams? Happens. Passing students with a 14% score in the class so they can graduate? Was forced to do that. Teachers that don't teach, but try to be 'cool' and play phone games with the kids? Ok. Admins implementing shitty policies because they read a paper by some idiot phD? Yup. Tons of busywork for teachers, designed to wear them out and get them to just play along with the 'pass everyone' game? A stack of that. And this is supposedly the best school in the county...many houses in the $mills$ nearby.
- ikeyany 6y agoI'm curious about the true total cost of pensions for jobs like teachers and cops.
- Fiveplus 6y agoOn-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.* Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic. *https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- MattGaiser 6y ago> anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. These layoffs could compromise the ability of millions of children to be curious. Is protecting future intellectual curiosity sufficiently interesting?
- ikeyany 6y agoThe future of education is relevant to intellectual curiosity.
- doggydogs94 6y agoIt is ironic that smaller class sizes will require many more teaching professionals. And here we are laying off people.
- egberts1 6y agoThey should start with cutting the upper staff, (and their cushy expensive retirement package) of their school district. This would pave way for hiring more teachers and restoring the arts, music, shop classes back into vogue.
- jake_morrison 6y agoI think we need a common online learning platform for K-12. That at least gives everyone the same access to the best lecturers, independent of the low education budgets from poorer areas, as well as e.g. AP classes that they can't get locally. It reduces the need for "redundant" teachers there just to deliver a mediocre lecture. Teachers are still needed to provide individual help, something that doesn't scale as easily as online lectures. That could be done locally or remotely. Students need a computer and internet access. Providing them with that is cheaper than trying to fund local teachers and buildings, though. Then we need some way to provide the social aspects provided by schools, sports, chemistry labs, as well as all the other services like food and counseling which are not part of education but are provided by the school system. The same thing applies to the university system. I think this is the way out of the current cost explosion/bubble.
- RickJWagner 6y agoIt's an interesting time, for sure. My son just finished his academics to be a teacher, his next step is a semester of student teaching. But it's not certain if classes will convene in the fall.