16 ms·
More than half of American retailers didn't pay their rent in April and May
- rwmj 6y agoPurely as a thought experiment, if we suspended mortgage repayments for N months and rental payments for N months, what bad (or good) effects might we see?
- christkv 6y agoA collapse of the banks I suspect and having to rescue them again.
- formercoder 6y agoBanks shouldn’t have a ton of this stuff on their balance sheets because of post ‘08 changes. The more likely parties to be damaged are asset managers.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Banks shouldn’t have a ton of this stuff on their balance sheets I don't understand what you mean - banks issue millions and millions of mortages.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoBut they don't keep the mortgages. They sell most or all of them.
- formercoder 6y agoCorrect, they package them up in CDOs and sell them off.
- Ididntdothis 6y agoThis would make sense to me. Why are some businesses being shut down and have to deal with income losses and others like landlords can keep going and demand their income? This seems fundamentally unfair to me.
- freeone3000 6y agoAh, but comrade, paying rent itself is inherently unfair. It allows for profit off merely having bought something sooner than another had a chance to. If the rent stops now, why should the rent start back up?
- Ididntdothis 6y agoIt should start up when the renter is not forbidden by government to make money to pay rent.
- airza 6y agoI guess you're being sarcastic, but what value is being provided to society by having landlords rent houses out to people who would rather buy them?
- viscanti 6y agoThe opportunity cost of the downpayment (and also the fact that lots of people wouldn't have the money for a down payment anyway). Generally the returns from property investing are relatively low compared to other investments.
- nradov 6y agoAnyone who wants to buy a rental house is free to do so. Just make an unsolicited purchase offer to the landlord for more than the net present value of all expected future rental income. Most landlords are willing to sell their properties, even when they're not currently listed on the market.
- airza 6y ago
- willcipriano 6y agoIt would probably be hard to find a rental during that period, as legally you wouldn't have to pay to occupy the space. Though landlords might be cash strapped enough to let you move in to get the down payment.
- kimjongtrill 6y agoAs long as the people that did pay get theirs back.. that’s cool.
- mkolodny 6y agoPeople who make a living by renting out a room/floor would need government assistance to survive.
- monocasa 6y agoYes, most places I've seen suspending rent and mortgage are also giving continuing monetary assistance as well.
- rwmj 6y agoWhy? They wouldn't be paying rent to their landlords either.
- bosie 6y agobecause they aren't running at cost/deficit but make actual money (profits). those would now be gone too.
- jdm2212 6y agoThe whole banking system would collapse like in 2007-2008 because "everyone stops paying mortgages all at once" is basically what happened then. Renters stop paying their rent so landlords go broke. Landlords stop paying their mortgages. Mortgage-backed securities go into default. Anyone with lots of exposure to mortgage-backed securities folds. Their counterparties in all sorts of financial arrangements can't collect (insurance, bonds, you name it). Credit markets dry up, and all the Main Street businesses that are rolling over some of their debt find they can't borrow, so they file for bankruptcy. Normally, they'd take out loans to make it through bankruptcy and restructure... but no loans are available, so they liquidate. EDIT: worth noting that this is less likely now than in '07-'08 because the Federal Reserve has been buying up bonds like crazy (that basically means financial institutions, governments and businesses are often able to get unlimited cheap credit) but if they scaled that back or stopped doing it, things are already so bad there would've been a credit crisis in March or April without a national rent/mortgage freeze. So imagine how much worse it would be with one.
- 5ociety 6y agoIt kind of sounds like we need a different money system?
- 5ociety 6y agoand whose better at designing systems than you and me?
- Ididntdothis 6y agoWe may do better than the bankers who like to design fragile systems as long as they can make boatloads of money :)
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoUnless you're an expert at designing systems as complicated as the entire economy, maybe a lot of people.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoUltimately it will damage the banks that hold the mortgages.
- ameister14 6y agoYou'd see a devaluing of the underlying property, so you'd be upside down on your mortgage. Property owners would stop taking care of buildings in terms of rentals, so maintenance would be a significant issue. There are a lot of bank loans using a real estate asset as collateral - those would now be significantly riskier for the banks to hold, so new loans would probably stall and/or become more restrictive, slowing growth. Municipal services would start to take a hit next, since a lot of the property taxes go to things like schools and waste disposal. On the flip side, people not paying their rent would have more money in their bank accounts to cover an unforeseen medical bill. I doubt retail would increase by that much if quarantining was still in place, though.
- MobileVet 6y agoI asked Paul Krugman this on Twitter and he didn’t reply unfortunately. Yes to halting the entire chain (mortgage included)but maintaining the interest.
- fortran77 6y agoThere's still property tax. I'm a commercial landlord with no mortgage, but a hefty property tax bill.
- chkaloon 6y agoI am afraid we are in a real Wile E Coyote moment here. You know, where he's suspended in air for a few seconds before he goes crashing to the ground? Our crash may come in the fall when UI payments stop and the rent floats become unsustainable. About the time the second wave hits. https://66.media.tumblr.com/bbbf0aec68490ae2679ef489709c3d18/tumblr_nhuh59FSDw1r2ad2vo1_500.gif https://66.media.tumblr.com/bbbf0aec68490ae2679ef489709c3d18...
- ikeyany 6y ago> fragile ... the word is fragile. We've built an insanely fragile economy. Take a look. There's been no war. 100% of the (not so great) US infrastructure that was there before SARS-COV-2 is still there. We've lost about 100k people, which is horrific but in the scheme of things at "USA" scale, and with the skewed demographics, not much of a hit to the economy. And yet the economy is staggering and it's likely to get worse. Why? Because people have stopped doing things We've built an entire economy around people doing things they don't really need to do. In and of itself, that's not so bad, but we've also built an economy with so little resilience, so much fragility, so little spare capacity that the mere fact of people stopping doing a bunch of stuff has the potential to cause complete economic disaster for, what 15-20M Americans? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23328234 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23328234
- MattGaiser 6y ago> There's been no war. 100% of the (not so great) US infrastructure that was there before SARS-COV-2 is still there. The infrastructure may not be physically destroyed, but it is effectively out of commission. Same with everything from warehouses to meat cutting plants. You could make the same argument if a gas attack were used on a factory instead of a bomb.
- pjc50 6y agoThis was Keynes' point: the productive capacity is there, it's the question of putting it to work somehow.
- 6y ago
- aazaa 6y ago> Bed Bath & Beyond, Famous Footwear, H&M, and the Gap, AMC and Regal movie theaters, and 24 Hour Fitness gyms have all missed payments, jeopardizing the stability of their property management companies and municipal governments that rely on property taxes, The Post's Heather Long reported. All roads lead to the Federal Reserve. Stores defaulting on rent payments starves landlords for cash. Landlords unable to service mortgages or pay taxes starves banks and state/local governments. Banks starved for money turn to the Fed for bailouts. States starved for cash turn to Washington. Washington issues bonds which the Fed buys because nobody in their right mind would buy 10 or 30 year Treasuries with the goal of holding to maturity. The Fed's balance sheet has exploded higher (>20% GDP), with no end in sight: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL Where does it all lead? There are two options: 1. Default on the national debt. 2. Currency depreciation. The most likely outcome is (2). One way or another, the dollar is headed lower. Perversely, this could be great for stocks, bonds, and other assets nominally. The problem is the size of the dollar depreciation that would be required to bring the Fed's balance sheet back under control. The only problem is that the dollar happens to be the world's reserve currency. As the Fed does its best to slaughter the dollar bull, every other country is printing money as fast as possible to depreciate their own currencies. Nobody knows where this mess ends.
- ngold 6y agoThere is also 32 trillion sitting outside the US that needs to come home a be burned.
- opportune 6y agoDepreciation (writing off a loss on the fed balance sheet) might cause a lot less problems than you think. Recessions like this are already deflationary. Plus global economic slowdowns increase demand for dollars
- masnaox 6y agoyou forgot where the fed gets their money. yes, it all goes to the fed, then to the tax payers. and all that bounce back to where it began, and the 1% uses it to either buy realstate or save the money in a way its immune to the incomming inflation, making things worse in the long run
- jawns 6y agoIt feels like a huge wave just crashed, and many people standing waist-deep in the water think things are on the upswing now -- when really they're about to get sucked into a powerful undertow. Judging by the state of the stock market, many investors seem oblivious to the magnitude of the effects of the pandemic. The S&P 500 lost more than a third of its value in the pandemic crash. Yet the index is now two-thirds of the way back to its high point: https://www.npr.org/2020/06/04/865117170/the-economy-is-in-trouble-try-telling-the-stock-market https://www.npr.org/2020/06/04/865117170/the-economy-is-in-t... But look at the levels of initial jobless claims still coming in at multiples above where they should be. Look at how many businesses are still shuttered, with an uncertain H2 ahead. Given the harsh economic reality, I'm very bearish right now. I think we're going to see another significant drop as the full effects sink in, which is what has happened in other crashes. Investors call it a dead-cat bounce. But in this case, I'm picturing a bigger animal. Hippo maybe.
- serf 6y ago>Given the harsh economic reality, I'm very bearish right now. as am I. I've more-or-less frozen my trading until a) a recovery plan is clear and being executed or b) until it is more clear we've hit a real bottom. All these hopeful spikes that do not correlate to the economic reality are probably going to throw a lot of people through hoops until any real roof or floor is hit. It sucks because I keep having these "buy the dip" moments, but then I have to hand-wave the opportunity away knowing that whatever dip i'm looking at is likely one of many upcoming movements.
- satvikpendem 6y agoTime in the market beats timing the market. If you continue to invest regularly even in a down market you will eventually make more than those who target peaks and dips.
- mycall 6y agoDollar-cost averaging is theoretically sub-optimal to lump sum investing in terms of expected return. This was shown to be the case in a mean-variance framework in 1979 by George Constantinides [0] [0] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=148754 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=148754
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoWhen the next pandemic hits, I doubt any government will dare to attempt a closure. The costs for these closures have been high in terms of economic pain. In addition, the protests, though they are justified due to the oppression the community has experienced, are likely undoing a lot of the effects of social distancing by putting a lot of people together in close proximity for hours. So in the end, we will have experienced a lot of economic pain for not that much benefit.
- fooey 6y agoUtah is very clearly having a significant infection surge, and the state just recommended to itself that we pretty much drop the rest of the few restrictions we ever had in the first place. https://coronavirus-dashboard.utah.gov/#incidence-epicurve https://coronavirus-dashboard.utah.gov/#incidence-epicurve https://senate.utah.gov/majority-newsroom/2020/6/2/public-health-and-economic-emergency-commission-recommends-most-of-utah-transitions-to-a-smart-green-risk-levelnbsp https://senate.utah.gov/majority-newsroom/2020/6/2/public-he...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoMy guess is that in two weeks, we will be seeing an infection surge everywhere. So, Utah is not really losing much by opening up now.
- devalgo 6y agoMine as well. I do hope the reports saying outdoor spread is unlikely are correct becaust the protests seem to be ideal superspreader events. Hot sweaty people packed into enormous crowds coughing because of tear gas and smoke? Thankfully some people are wearing masks but it's almost a worst case scenario.
- munificent 6y ago> undoing a lot of the effects of social distancing We've had several months of social distancing, which bought us a lot of time to ramp up healthcare and medical supply manufacturing capacity.
- Simulacra 6y agoIs there an economist here that might know if this would lead to stores decreasing prices on products in order to move merchandise, keep the same, or increase?
- eightysixfour 6y agoWay back in the day I worked for CompUSA while they were going out of business and helped shut down a number of their stores in my area. The process was to mark everything back to normal retail prices, announce a going out of business sale and on a set time frame start to lower prices (depending on how fast we needed to clear the store). Most of the high value things were bought at their normal “on sale” prices with the few things that snuck by to the lower price points getting picked up by employees and friends of employees. Everything else was junk and would get sold off for 40%-80% off of retail. Then we would sell things like shelving and display cases. Obviously this isn’t an equivalent scenario, but if we start seeing retail stores going out of business, I imagine it will follow a similar pattern.
- crispyporkbites 6y agoThere’s plenty of economists that know the answer to that, not so many that will be right.
- munificent 6y agoGiven a sufficient number of astrologers, you are guaranteed to have one with a correct prediction for your future. The hard problems is picking which one to listen to.
- seph-reed 6y agoI'm kind of glad things are falling apart. It's like walking in the slightly wrong direction, every day you don't change course you add a bit of debt. At this point we're hitting something of a dead end, and it may finally be time to fix things. It's going to be painful, ofc. But it always was.
- devalgo 6y agoThe burn it down and rebuild approach is terrifying. There's absolutely no reason to think there will be anything left to rebuild. Do you really think a Country like the US with thousands of nuclear weapons will allow itself to be torn down? You really think strongmen won't appear and enforce totalitarianism on any country sufficiently destabilized? There's a million ways for that sequence to go horribly wrong and like 5 where it works out. It's not a real solution.
- seph-reed 6y agoYou walk down the wrong nature path until it reaches a cliff. Do you jump off, or start walking through the brush? Ofc we should just turn back, but humankind is far too head-strong for that.
- russellbeattie 6y agoBoth of the movies The Big Short and Too Big To Fail have a moment where they're watching people come out of a subway or walk down the street, and say something like, "They don't have any idea what's about to hit them." It sort of feels like that now. Lots of normality still. There is definitely something not right about the stock market not feeling the impact of millions of unemployed and more than half of retail stores missing rent payments. Maybe there's macroeconomic explanations involving credit and the Fed. Maybe the stock market is in fact disconnected from the general economy as a whole, and is really just a plaything for giant corporations and the 1%. Maybe it's not as bad as it seems. Maybe everyone's betting on a V shaped recovery after the virus fades. But as we saw during the financial crisis, everything seems fine until it isn't - then things go pear shaped in a hurry.
- devalgo 6y ago>It sort of feels like that now. Lots of normality still. There is definitely something not right about the stock market not feeling the impact of millions of unemployed and more than half of retail stores missing rent payments. Not saying their right but Wall St. types will tell you the market has already priced the pandemic and current unemployment numbers in and is forward looking.
- IAmGraydon 6y agoThe difference here is that in the financial crisis, The market was in a bubble. Almost anyone you would talk to at the time would tell you the Stock market has never been stronger. A very, very few number of people knew what was coming. Now, every armchair trader is believing they’re reliving The Big Short and they’re the main character. They fail to realize that this is literally the opposite situation- a crash that has already happened and now the subsequent recovery we’re in. How many crashes did you know about before they happened? I’m guessing zero. You still believe this time is different.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoYou're asserting that the crash happened (came to an end) and we're in recovery now. A lot of people, myself included, are less than convinced that's the case: believe it or not, there's still a lot of room for this to get much worse. The pandemic is barely getting started in places like India and South America, and the US is not out of the woods yet.
- thrown2020 6y agoThe liberals are doing their best to kill everyone - between the fake covid virus and burning cities down. The democrat party should just hang up their spurs - they are done.
- perfunctory 6y ago> Many retailers have asked for assistance from their landlords to no avail. For some businesses, even pinpointing who to ask can be difficult as the majority of commercial properties are owned by real estate investment trusts and investors in commercial mortgage-backed securities. even pinpointing who to ask can be difficult - can it get any more comical?
- fortran77 6y agoThey really should have offered dollar-for-dollar grants to landlords who forgave rents. (Or dollar-for-dollar property tax discounts.) I own commercial property in 94089. We didn't charge our tenants rent in April and May. They received $44,000 in stimulus and grant money--each. We received zero. Weren't eligible for anything. Fortunately, we have no mortgage to cover. But we do have a $50,000 property tax bill coming due. There's no relief for property tax.
- dzonga 6y agoUS is on the brink of two major things. 1. a civil war: lots of guns lying around n a demagogue in the white house. n trump like a rat, he's been biting n blowing air on the wound. come nov, he can easily say the elections were rigged, if in the small chance event he loses to sleepy Joe i.e Biden. he's supporters will buy it, as they already bought about mail in voter fraud. n his repeated calls for violence against minorities etc. people frustrated by the economy n elites etc 2. a major depression: this is already in play, as unemployment numbers had been propped up. n the fragility of the US economy i.e dependent on excessive credit n consumption. so it's catch 22: which one is gonna happen first.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoProbably neither.