10 ms·
Cryo-electron microscopy breaks a key barrier
- controlweather 6y agoNot a single real image in that laMe fluff piece.
- erik_landerholm 6y agoDumb question, but if electrons are basically point particles, why is hard to get below 1 angstrom resolution?
- Areading314 6y agoAt these scales, electrons behave more like waves than particles. Also the way that they are scattered by the subject and manipulated via em lenses causes information loss.
- auvi 6y agoNow I would like to see a Corona virus with it.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoAnother commenter linked to a study that did just that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23415625 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23415625
- 1-KB-OK 6y agoMakes me think of that one Simpsons scene where Mr Burns finds atoms in his factory https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DqgvHUg_vxY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DqgvHUg_vxY
- The_rationalist 6y agoWhat would be the "realistic" potential use cases?
- pritovido 6y agoWe don't know yet. That is the idea about research. When the microscope was invented, people made the same question: What is the use of it? Just watching things we already know bigger? That is a recurring question. So much that Aristotle created the book MetaPhysics(meta meaning different from the Physics book) with the idea that this particular book did not need to be useful to be created. It was a compilation of non useful things. This non useful compilation helped create science as we know it.
- TomJansen 6y agoOh please, this philosophical stuff is unnecessary. Cyro-EM is about a decade old and is just an alternative to X-Ray Crystallography for elucidating the structures of proteins. This article describes a way to improve the resolution of Cyro-EM, matching it to X-Ray Crystallography. The biggest bottleneck of X-Ray Crystallography is the production of protein crystals which is not necessary with Cyro-EM.
- twic 6y agoIt's unbelievable how cryo-EM has come on. When i was a student, it was an also-ran behind crystallography and NMR, something that a few weird groups used to study a few special cases. Now you have to wonder if there's any point doing crystallography at all! I still like NMR, because you're looking at proteins in solution. But if the freezing is good in cryo-EM, maybe even that becomes moot.
- natechols 6y agoIt's especially shocking how many crystallographers have switched over - when I started, the ribosome crystal structures were the latest heroic achievement, but now nobody would waste time trying to crystallize ribosomes.
- thereisnospork 6y agoI'm not sure if it applies to proteins, but for smaller molecules there seemed to be some really interesting results a few years ago about using MOF's to adsorb analytes in a spatially repeating manner so x-ray diffraction techniques could be used without crystallization. Haven't followed closely enough to know if anything is panning out though.
- anfractuosity 6y agoI'm curious could you use AFM/STM to image molecules? I'm curious how that would compare with this approach.
- fabian2k 6y agoYou can, and it has been done. But that was with very small, flat molecules. Cryo EM can be used with very large molecules or complexes with many tens of thousands of atoms.
- jcims 6y agoFeels like this might be useful for exploring the surface of cancer cells to identify receptors and other features that might be useful for developing targeted therapies.
- presiozo 6y agoI thought an individual atom has been imaged before, at least roughly. Anyway, this is fantastic science. I'm excited to see how imaging atoms affects our understanding of quantum mechanics and atomic structure in general.
- dmitrybrant 6y agoI think they mean that this is the first time individual atoms have been imaged using this specific type of electron microscope. Individual atoms have of course been imaged as early as the 1980s using scanning tunneling microscopy. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scanning_tunneling_microscope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scanning_tunneling_microscope
- wumms 6y ago> has been imaged before Last year, Aricescu’s team used cryo-EM to map the protein to 2.5 ångströms. But with the new kit, the researchers attained a 1.7-ångström resolution, with even better resolution in some key parts of the protein. “It was like peeling off a blur over your eyes,” Aricescu says. “At this resolution, every half ångström opens up a whole universe.”
- iagovar 6y agoSo, pardon my ignorance, but can we finally say that atoms are particles with concrete dimensions? Last time I checked the whole field seemed measuring everything into probabilistic and statistical terms.
- nabla9 6y agoWe can meaningfully talk about concrete dimensions just like before. Atomic radius is mean distance from the nucleus to the boundary of the surrounding shells of electrons. Because the outer shell of electrons is fuzzy, there are multiple ways to define radius: covalent radius, Van der Waals radius and ionic radius. In molecules atoms overlap in different ways because they share electrons and electrons interact. There still exists fundamental uncertainty about the location of atoms and molecules. Electrons, atoms and molecules have de Broglie wavelength. For molecules with tens of atoms the wavelength is in the order of picometers.
- fsloth 6y agoOur understanding on the nature of atoms is not something someone suddenly "discovered". Rather, we've gathered evidence of various phenomena over the century. There are lots of models to explain the findings. This is a bit of a long winded list of discoveries. There is no simple sophism you can utilize and say "atoms are this or that" unless you actually understand something of the background. This Khan academy lecture is as good resource as any: https://www.khanacademy.org/science/chemistry/electronic-structure-of-atoms/history-of-atomic-structure/v/chem37-history-of-atomic-chemistry https://www.khanacademy.org/science/chemistry/electronic-str...
- marcosdumay 6y agoYou can resolve atoms despite all the uncertainty just like you can resolve a tree at distance despite it not having a clear surface. The electron distribution falls with an exponential function on large distances, what is much cleaner than a tree surface anyway.
- AtHeartEngineer 6y agoThis is a good analogy
- TomJansen 6y agoThe real breakthrough here is that with this technique you don't have to crystallize the proteins anymore, which is the biggest bottleneck in X-Ray Crystallography. Relevant; they used Cyro-EM to elucidate the structure of the SARS-CoV-2 Spike protein [1], which is a big step towards the development of a vaccine. This is a resolution of 3.5 ångström, but still a very nice feat. [1]: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/367/6483/1260 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/367/6483/1260
- claar 6y agoVery interesting! They link the full labelled 3D model in the article's footer: https://www.rcsb.org/structure/6vsb https://www.rcsb.org/structure/6vsb - very cool.
- l33tman 6y ago3.5Å cryo-EM structures have existed for some time. The important thing coming down under 2Å or so, is that it drastically improves the quality of the molecular dynamics simulations you build of these structures.
- natechols 6y agoI'm skeptical of molecular dynamics and docking studies... but the ability to clearly resolve bound drug molecules, or host-pathogen interactions, is very valuable indeed.
- fabian2k 6y agoThe headline is potentially confusing, it doesn't mean that this is the first time individual atoms were measured, but the first time this particular method has been pushed to such a high resolution that individual atoms could be distinguished. Cryo EM is a very hot method right now to determine the three-dimensional structure of large molecules like e.g. proteins or protein complexes. Something like 10-15 years ago the best you could get was maybe 1.5 - 2 nm (these are rough numbers from memory), the results described in the article are 0.17 nm.
- jjoonathan 6y agoFurther, atomic resolution is routine in electron microscopy, it's specifically Cryo EM (a sub-technique aimed at imaging proteins, which are extremely fragile compared to, say, chunks of metal or computer chips) where the advance has happened. This is phenomenal! The title still feels a bit sensationalized, but don't they all?
- m4rtink 6y agoCryo EM is really cool (not just in temperature! ;-) ) technology! :) Recently I had a chance to go on a tour in the two-part CEITEC research center in Brno, a city with long history of electron microscopy manufacturing and research. One part of the CEITEC research center does "dry" tech - chemistry, robotics, motor and machine control and chips. Of course, they have quite a lot of cutting edge electron microscopes to image various nano structures. All looking super high tech as you watch their shiny metal over the clean room window. All the machines stand on concrete slabs embedded into the hill below the building to avoid vibrations and have ultra high vacuum inside. The other part of CEITEC does "wet" research - proteins, cells, bacteria, microorganisms. Of course also they have cutting edge, cry electron microscopes. These looked quite different to the other ones - it was a huge black cube, reaching almost the high ceiling of the room. You could not see all the glistening internal components like in the previous case. In this case they even let us to the room itself - apparently given all the volatiles in the samples, the cleanliness requirements in the room containing the machine are not as strict & it likely (my guess) needs to keep quite a bit part of the machine at very low temperatures, explaining all the covers. IIRC the software controlling the camera runs on Linux & engineers from Brno working for one of the big EM manufacturers were involved in building this enormous cryo EM machine, which was a pretty nice touch. :)
- Gatsky 6y agoLooks like atomic rez is only possible with certain very stable proteins. Hopefully the tech will improve to allow broader application.
- diegoperini 6y agoWhere can I find the pictures?
- COGlory 6y agoThere aren't any. The way cryo-EM works is it images hundreds of thousands of copies of the molecule and uses those to construct a 3D model, in this case, with atomic resolution. However, a single micrograph doesn't necessarily contain atomic resolution.
- diegoperini 6y agoThanks for the explanation.
- natechols 6y agoHaven't checked the article, but it's certainly possible the individual particle micrographs are archived somewhere. (But you're right, each will just look like a fuzzy gray blob.)
- rezna 6y agoNo longer need for hundreds of thousands. The aim is for just few thousands in few hours to reach acceptable resolution. The development goes real fast with both SW and HW.
- COGlory 6y agoDepends greatly on whether or not what you're imaging has symmetry.
- rezna 6y agoYou can see that the record tests are being done with apoferitin or gaba. It all depends on the improved qualiry of direct detection cameras, filters, things like afis, fringe free imaging, ... The innovation goes insanely fast.
- 6y ago
- COGlory 6y agoI'm a structural biologist that uses CryoEM to study archeal viruses. I'd be happy to answer any questions about CryoEM. I did want to point out though that this title is misleading. The researchers didn't get an image of an atom. Instead, they reconstructed hundreds of thousands of images of the protein to determine where the atoms are almost exactly. So there's no actual image that shows an atom, as cool as that would be.
- mynegation 6y agoWhat are the limitations of this technique in determining spatial structure of the proteins? Do they get denaturated when cooled?
- gewa 6y agoNo, the proteins are vitrified very rapidly in liquid ethane at approx. -200°C, so that the structure ist conserved.
- candiodari 6y ago"Vitrification" is a way to freeze water so that it forms a glassy solid instead of ice crystals, locking the proteins in place and so that the "ice" reflects electrons randomly like water does, and so the only large structure redirecting electrons is the protein particles.
- tynpeddler 6y agoProtein "structure" is a slippery concept. In situ measurements, molecular dynamics simulations and basic common sense pretty conclusively show that most proteins actually have a number of conformations they access during normal biological processes. In many cases, these conformations are required for the proteins normal functions. I used to work in the de novo protein field and it was a constant source of irritation to me that what we mainly designed were crystal structures, not dynamic functional proteins.
- 6y ago
- benjaminva 6y agoI had the privilege to ocasionally work with Holger Stark on similar structure determination challanges and can confirm that they really pushed the limits here thanks to very smart statistical methods. The resolution heavily depends on correctly sorting/classifying the large amount (> 10k for sure) images of these small particles. There exists a race in the structural biology community about the next big method that allows to determine structures of proteins that were hard to crystalize and it seems that CryoEM is becoming the winner in this race. As an alternative approach, people are building large X-ray lasers that have extremly high intensity and short pulse lengths which they plan to shoot at single particles and resolve individual scattering images. This method can very likely also achieve atomic resolution of non-crystaline particles, even without the need to freeze them down. It will be exciting times for the whole bio-chemical physics community. Congrats to Holger and the team for another great publication in Nature.
- natechols 6y agoHaving worked in X-ray crystallography on synchrotrons and XFELs, I can't take the single-particle XFEL concept seriously any more. Ten years ago it seemed impressive, but the EM technology has advanced so much faster - and it's a fraction of the cost. There are some neat applications of nanocrystallography, but that too seems like a niche application now, not a magic bullet for accelerating protein structure determination.
- yters 6y agohow do we know atoms exist?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mysterypie 6y agoCould someone confirm what we’re looking at in that picture please? In that spider web of blue points joined by blue line segments: Those tiny blue points are atoms? The blue line segments are covalent bonds? And what’s the difference between the blue and purple areas? If those line segments are probability distributions of shared electrons, that means our high school mental model of a covalent bond (drawing a line between two atoms) is not too bad.
- natechols 6y agoThe line segments define surfaces around the regions of highest electron density. This is how X-ray crystallographers traditionally viewed electron density, probably because that simple mesh was the best that early computer graphics systems could handle. In this particular image they've shown nested surfaces - my guess would be at 1 (purple), 2, and 3 standard deviations above the mean, or something like that. Again, not atoms, just electron clouds, but obviously the regions around the atoms have the most electrons.
- mysterypie 6y agoSo it’s not like what I thought at all. If I understand you correctly, then each one of those bright blue balls is a cloud of electrons at the center of which is a nucleus (but we don’t see the nucleus itself). The tiny blue lines and vertices are just computer generated imagery to define the “surface” of an atom. Those hexagons with six blue balls joined by purple mesh are benzene rings? So each purple area defines a cloud of shared electrons in a benzene ring?
- natechols 6y agoMostly correct, except it's only indirectly the surface of the "atom" - because of the way covalent bonding works, there's continuous electron density between atoms too. It's just that the region around the nucleus is the most electron-dense. And yes, those look like phenylalanine or tyrosine (amino acid) sidechains to me, both of which have a benzene ring at the core. (For the record, there is also something called neutron crystallography, which works like X-ray crystallography except it's the nuclei that diffract, not the electron clouds - which allows you to visualize hydrogen atoms more directly, and even resolve the difference between hydrogen and deuterium. But it's another speciality technique, in part because neutron sources are so much weaker.) EDIT: since I actually did some work on visualizing electron density maps on the web, here's an interactive view of an older X-ray structure (from 2003, at only 3Å resolution) that shows how a protein molecule fits into the density: http://natechols.github.io/xtal.js/map_viewer.html http://natechols.github.io/xtal.js/map_viewer.html (click and hold the middle mouse button to pan through the molecule)
- jgehrcke 6y agoWhile this is a breakthrough within the field of cryo-electron microscopy it is important to appreciate that for many questions in structural biology we also need to understand how protein structure changes over time. With the presented method the structure sampling time seems to be O(10 s) which easily is about 10 orders of magnitudes slower than the dynamics we're interested in seeing. A direct consequence of this is that for achieving atomic spatial resolution they needed to use a "rock-solid" protein -- one that has an exceptionally stiff structure (one that does not wiggle a lot). The presented method is great and cool, but this is a pretty severe limitation. Most proteins wiggle a lot :-). Background: protein structure-function relationship can often be well understood only when considering the structural dynamics of the protein (key words: conformational changes, the entropic contribution to free energy). That is, in the ideal case we would be able to measure molecular structure not only at high spatial resolution, but also at high temporal resolution. How can one make such a measurement much faster, by ~10 orders of magnitude? By irradiating a lot of light. Via X-ray free electron lasers (XFEL). XFEL-based techniques are expected to revolutionize structural biology (as always, also still a long way to go): > XFEL protein crystallography not only determines high resolution structures of proteins, but also reveals the time-stamped conformational changes of proteins. - https://www.nature.com/articles/nmeth.3070.pdf?origin=ppub https://www.nature.com/articles/nmeth.3070.pdf?origin=ppub - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6678726/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6678726/ (PhD in structural biology/bioinformatics, investigated dynamics of proteins with molecular dynamics simulations)
- djaque 6y agoTo add on, another promising technique is ultrafast electron diffraction (UED). You can get atomic space and time resolution (sub-angstrom and 100 fs) already. It's just a matter of scaling up beam quality to the point we can study complex macromolecules. UED will also fit in a single room while the worlds only XFEL is miles long. (I work on instrumentation improvements for XFELs and UED.)
- Ultimatt 6y agoYou're glossing over the advantages specific to cryo-EM though, which is it can give you a good picture of large ensembles of small things at this accuracy, with a lot less computational/interpretation hardship than X-ray crystallography or NMR. So for seeing structures of large protein complexes and how the super structure varies with heteromeric variation this is a really big deal. If you wanted to see what viral capsids in-situ looked like down to the atoms this is what you'd use. There are a lot of places this is going to be useful, there is no one method to rule them all in structural proteomics simply because nothing can offer all of the spatial and temporal scales one might need. Plus cryo would only give you the surface hull of these complexes, you'd still need a different method to fill in all the exact structures inside. Writing up these methods as if there is some competition for "best" is an entirely false impression to a lay person reading. The best is all methods improve and researchers collaborate to provide every possible scoped view. Even mass spectrometry is doing crazy things for investigating the structure of disordered proteins. You'd never use that for something you would use cryo-EM for.
- samovar_booth 6y agoFor the record, individual atoms were imaged for the first time back in 1955: http://pubsapp.acs.org/cen/coverstory/83/8348atoms.html http://pubsapp.acs.org/cen/coverstory/83/8348atoms.html? > On Oct. 11, 1955, Pennsylvania State University physics professor Erwin W. Müller and Kanwar Bahadur, who at the time was a Ph.D. student working with Müller, made history by being the first people to image individual atoms. The scientists were using a relatively simple and inexpensive instrument, and with it they directly observed individual tungsten atoms at the tip of a sharply pointed tungsten specimen.
- jxramos 6y agoI had heard once that new imaging modalities that advance a lot of new research invariably translate to Nobel prizes. Would that be expected of cryo EM techniques?