43 ms·
SpaceX Starlink is now its own ASN and present at the Seattle Internet Exchange
- avmich 6y ago> Geographic scope: North America Is "global" not appropriate here?
- cryptoz 6y agoIIRC they are offering service only to northern parts of North America to begin. The network is sparse right now and I think the plan is to start with Canada.
- anoncareer0212 6y agoits increasingly feeling like we won't make it...cross-satellite link is out, so we're basically back to Iridium (read: DSL) speeds, meanwhile the company burns cash like crazy and needs to fundraise every 8 months. hearing it needs to be spun off to get funded separately but then again I've been hearing that for awhile. Push come to shove moment seemed to be when the FCC said to stop bs'ing about theoratical network speeds in applications for rural broadband grants, I still don't understand how that got submitted..lawyers... FCC smacking us (article is more than a little generous towards us, thank Ajit Pai's reputation I guess): https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/05/elon-musks-promise-of-low-latency-broadband-meets-skepticism-at-fcc/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/05/elon-musks-promi... Gwynne saying we might spin it off: https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/6/21126540/spacex-starlink-internet-space-mega-constellation-ipo-spinoff-gwynne-shotwell https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/6/21126540/spacex-starlink-i...
- avmich 6y ago> cross-satellite link is out Why?
- 6nf 6y agoLast I heard, the current generation of sats do not yet have inter-sat comms hardware but it's planned for the next generation which should come in 2021
- gpm 6y agoLack of cross satellite link means that - To serve as an internet backbone they need to bounce off of ground stations - In particularly busy areas where they might otherwise have routed traffic up, laterally, down they have to now go up, down resulting in 0.5x local available bandwidth. - The latency is a few ms higher on long routes when using starlink as a backbone None of this particularly effects their ability to serve as a consumer ISP. The advantages are still there. Also cross satellite laser links are still the plan as far as the public has been told, just somewhat delayed. > Gwynne saying we might spin it off: https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/6/21126540/spacex-starlink-i.. https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/6/21126540/spacex-starlink-i.... A day or two after that statement Elon said that the amount they were thinking of spinning it off right now is "0". PS. Your use of "us" makes me think you might be an insider, I'm definitely not, but as an outsider it looks like SpaceX has a pretty good chance of pulling this off.
- bhk 6y agoI would have thought that their backhaul ground station links would be many times faster than their user station bandwidth, since they can use large directional antennas.
- gpm 6y agoYes, the 0.5x multiplier is based on an over simplified model where everything is consuming the same resources... e.g. that might be onboard processing power. In reality it is probably much better than that, but considering what I was replying to I wanted to be conservative.
- Diederich 6y ago> cross-satellite link is out, so we're basically back to Iridium (read: DSL) How are those two related? Cross-link will somewhat improve latency, but will have very little if any impact on bandwidth.
- londons_explore 6y agoIt will have a substantial impact on bandwidth, because bandwidth to ground stations is much less than bandwidth to users.
- jandrese 6y agoThat seems backwards. They should have much more ground station bandwidth to those giant tracking dishes than to little personal phased array antennas. The problem with no sat-to-sat traffic is they'll need a crapton of downlink stations, which increases cost substantially. Also, they'll be geographically limited--no service out in the middle of the ocean.
- gpm 6y ago> Also, they'll be geographically limited--no service out in the middle of the ocean. There's a workaround for this, which is to stick a relay station out in the middle of the ocean on a ship that bounces the signal to a satellite closer to land. Expensive, but workable for the right price. If there's a high enough density of commercial ships, you might be able to piggyback on the user terminals for this purpose. At the same time the military is likely one of the most interested customers and probably wouldn't be thrilled at relying on the typical distribution of commercial ships.
- zaroth 6y ago> FCC smacking us (article is more than a little generous towards us, thank Ajit Pai's reputation I guess) This is the FCC protecting incumbent service providers on the basis that Starlink isn't already widely deployed. They are not claiming that they have any kind of technical analysis that Starlink will not in fact be low-latency (the threshold is a full 100ms, so not incredibly strict). They are claiming that simply because they do not already offer the service they will get lumped in with the high latency geo-stationary sat link providers; "In the absence of a real world example of a non-geostationary orbit satellite network offering mass market fixed service to residential consumers that is able to meet our 100ms round trip latency requirements, Commission staff could not conclude that such an applicant is reasonably capable of meeting the Commission's low latency requirements, and so we foreclose such applications." Frankly it's very sad, because the $16 billion in rural broadband grants are the perfect application for Starlink. The funds are distributed by "multi-round, descending clock auction where bidders will indicate in each round whether they will bid to provide service to an area at a given performance tier and latency. The auction will end after the aggregate support amount of all bids is less than or equal to the total budget and there is no longer competition for support in any area." [1] I think if Starlink was allowed to bid as both a "low-latency" and "high performance" tiers, then at the pricing level they would likely have come in under, they would have wiped the floor with the competition and won a lion's share of that funding. So the FCC appears to be trying to keep them out of the most lucrative tiers to protect the incumbent approach of extremely expensive rural fiber deployments. IMO a much smarter approach would have been to require some sort of performance bond from every applicant that they will successfully achieve the service levels they are bidding on. It's not like Comcast or Verizon haven't won massive subsidies in the past and then failed to deliver. The approach the FCC is taking (not surprisingly) just limits innovation and wastes taxpayer dollars. Actually in this case the dollars come from customer service fees, but they are effectively taxes. [1] - https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-364457A1.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-364457A1.pdf
- reitzensteinm 6y agoI agree a performance bond would be best, with enough teeth that the worst case forces SpaceX to give every cent back or go bankrupt. Same with Comcast et al. But you're unnecessarily ascribing malice. SpaceX has made some big promises, and if it delivers it deserves to hoover up basically all of that money. But until the network is real, customers can sign up, and it's just a matter of scaling, a rational actor attempting to genuinely forward the interests of the country may well decide it poses too much risk.
- sq_ 6y agoI was under the impression that cross-satellite laser links would be coming with second-generation version of the satellites, as opposed to the first operational batches that've been launching. Has that changed?
- dicknuckle 6y agoAFAIK it has not changed.
- 0xffff2 6y agoAnecdata and all, but I'd gladly pay $200/month plus $1000 in setup costs to replace my current Hugesnet service with DSL speeds.
- dntbnmpls 6y agoTheir peering points are all in the US. So it's not global yet.
- jbuzbee 6y agoVery interesting Starlink analysis here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m05abdGSOxY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m05abdGSOxY
- ADent 6y agoI thought they only had U.S.A. licenses at this time.
- q3k 6y agoConnectivity (upstreams and peers) per bgp.tools: https://bgp.tools/as/14593#connectivity https://bgp.tools/as/14593#connectivity Nothing too fancy for now. Two tiny, I assume test, prefixes (one v4, one v6) that aren't even verified by IRR/RPKI. Happy to see, however, that they peer openly (at least for now).
- kitteh 6y agoOne IPv4 and one IPv6 prefix - no RPKI ROAs signed :(
- nerdbaggy 6y agoLooking at their RDNS it looks like they will be using CGNAT. But that makes sense, it seems like a tough time to get IPv4 in bulk required for an ISP
- derekp7 6y agoAren't most cellular networks CGNAT? I know my T-Mobile phone is (for IPv4), with native IPv6. I'd like to see more consumer internet be IPv6 first, with a weaker IPv4 to help speed along adoption of v6.
- nerdbaggy 6y agoYeah most cell carriers are, but from where I’m at most ISP aren’t yet
- est31 6y agoUsually the encumbent/older ISPs still have IPs from the age where they being handed more freely, so they have more than enough to give every customer their own public IP while the challengers have fewer IPs and have to resort to carrier grade NAT. Smartphone plans usually get carrier grade NAT even at the older ISPs.
- taf2 6y agoIn my area Comcast is ipv6 but not very good and fios is ipv4 and very good
- dicknuckle 6y agoSprin isn't. yet. who knows what's going to happen with the merger. AT&T is though. I'm using OpenMPTCP router to my VPS to both get around CGNAT and aggregate the speed of both connections.
- kitteh 6y agoA number of them are. Especially when you get out of first world countries. The problem is that folks who deploy them really hate scaling them up. They believed in IPv6 and the transition isn't going fast enough (sup hosters and cloud providers - stop treating IPv6 as a "customers aren't asking for it" problem and realize this is infrastructure you have to do on their behalf). So now they are stuck paying for v6 CGNAT upgrades or in some cases: running them congested.
- gpm 6y ago> Registered on 5 Sep 2018 (21 months old) From this: https://bgp.tools/as/14593#asinfo https://bgp.tools/as/14593#asinfo Is the new part here that they are advertising prefixes?
- throw0101a 6y agoPerhaps. Some interesting peers as well: * https://bgpview.io/asn/14593#peers-v4 https://bgpview.io/asn/14593#peers-v4 Singapore? Any netengs here that can interpret the chicken entrails?
- nerdbaggy 6y agoThey have an open peering policy so anybody can peer with them https://www.peeringdb.com/net/18747 https://www.peeringdb.com/net/18747
- joenathanone 6y agoAlso says it was last updated >2019-02-21
- kitteh 6y agoLooking at their prefix right now I see them behind Hurricane Electric prepended 3 times. They ought to filter/sever that out give HEs "we treat peers as customers" offensive routing policy. Unless that's what they want :/
- Jonnax 6y agoWhat do you mean by "we treat peers as customers"?
- est31 6y agoThat they don't offer peering for free but charge for it. The idea of peering is that both sides gain from it as they reduce the traffic routed through middlemen like level3. So you both go to internet exchanges like DE-CIX, and pay a basic fee that you may participate in the exchange but you get all the connectivity to other ISPs from that exchange. But some ISPs don't do that and require you to peer in one of their own datacenters, requiring you to pay them money. You are now their customer instead of a partner. A big German partially government owned ISP did this for a while until they finally gave up a few years ago.
- welterde 6y agoHE doesn't charge for peering though. The complaint was that HE was leaking peer routes to other peers per default, which is normally only done if you are a customer (which can be nice if you want this, but can lead to sub-optimal routing if you don't want this).
- sprayk 6y agowhere can I find more information on HE's "we treat peers as customers" routing policy?
- kitteh 6y agoSo this is something they're not very open about, but you'll learn the hard way. Years ago Hurricane Electric would setup settlement free peers to be downstream customers in order to inflate their IPv6 footprint. Years ago HE was trying really hard to be the largest IPv6 transit provider in terms of prefixes and ASNs behind them in order to get some of the larger networks to peer with them ("we have X percent of the IPv6 internet"). To their credit it actually worked with a few. As for the goofy routing: if you were an IPv6 peer they'd announce you to their a large amount of their other peers (normally you don't announce peers to transit or peers - just to customers). This led to lots of sub-optimal routing scenarios and you'd have to ask them to knock it off and treat you like a real peer. So yeah cool you get free transit kinda, but the goofy routing isn't worth it for a lot of folks. This plus their long history of lack of filtering their transit customers and enabling lots of route hijacks really gave them a bad reputation. Their recent news about deploying RPKI is a bit of fake news: it's not real RPKI and doesn't address the issues with their customers.
- shockinglytrue 6y agoThis isn't the first route leading straight to satellites. I forget the name of the provider, but there is at least one big allocation where whatever you're sending to it is basically coming straight back down as radio.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- walrus01 6y agoAll of the major geostationary telecom satellite owners (intelsat, eutelsat, SES, etc) operate their own ASes and IP networks. Nothing quite leads "straight" to a satellite, but you can definitely look at the prefixes announced by a company like Intelsat and try to make intelligent guesses as to which earth station it correlates with. for instance: https://bgp.he.net/AS12684 https://bgp.he.net/AS12684
- l00sed 6y agoI've reached some geostationary and orbiting weather satellites with Software-Defined Radio (SDR) in the past. I'd love to try and snag some signals from these... Anyone know of a more formal scientific write-up on these to find the frequency/modulation?
- gpm 6y agoThe FCC filings are probably your best bet, 95% of the technical details we know are from them (92% of statistics are made up). I'm not sure if they contain enough information for you though. There are links here: https://old.reddit.com/r/Starlink/wiki/index#wiki_-_what_frequency_bands_does_it_use.3F https://old.reddit.com/r/Starlink/wiki/index#wiki_-_what_fre...
- londons_explore 6y agoThe frequency bands and modulation types are available from the FCC. The data will probably be encrypted, but I think theres a good chance you might be able to get some metadata.
- wmf 6y agohttps://fcc.report/IBFS/SAT-LOA-20161115-00118/1158350 https://fcc.report/IBFS/SAT-LOA-20161115-00118/1158350
- nullpage 6y agoFrom what sparse info I can find, it appears ground > sat > ground comms will be encrypted in some fashion so listening with an SDR and doing anything meaningful with the data might be hard, but I'm curious if there will be opportunities for it to be abused for anonymous downlink connections like the Turla spyware group used to do (https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/09/how-highly-advanced-hackers-abused-satellites-to-stay-under-the-radar/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/09/how-h...)
- mrspeaker 6y agoI have an SDR module and have played around listening to things (and having a blast doing it) but nothing like that! That sounds really cool. Do you have any resources you could point?
- ghostpepper 6y agoFor those of us unfamiliar with BGP and/or peering protocols, does this mean there are routable starlink networks? Are these routes being advertised?
- dsr_ 6y agoIt means that they are interconnected with the Internet. Whether that's six laptops and a server closet or a ground-to-space link is up to them.
- miohtama 6y agoIs this Interplanetary File System (IPFS)? /Sarcasm 50%
- wmf 6y agoNo, you're thinking of Marslink. Starlink is just for Earth.
- Invictus0 6y agoIt's a shame EarthLink was already taken.
- theossuary 6y agoBetter to pick a name with room for growth. Especially if Elon actually achieves the goals he's set out.
- marktangotango 6y agoGalaxyclusterlink - even more room for growth!
- netsec_burn 6y agoOr something short and sweet, like Synapse. Fully uniting the global village.
- iso1631 6y agoWhich globe?
- LeoPanthera 6y agoI'm pretty sure they could afford the name, if they really wanted it that much.
- skissane 6y ago
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoASN has one /24 (IPv4) https://bgp.he.net/AS14593#_prefixes https://bgp.he.net/AS14593#_prefixes
- gpm 6y ago/24 has 7 addresses that return pings from nmap -sn, all have about the same ping as the previous hop on the traceroute so my ping probably isn't reaching space.
- CameronNemo 6y agoThey probably only publicly route the ground stations.
- numpad0 6y ago> 192.31.243.0/24 how anticlimactic
- MintelIE 6y agoReally hope Elon charges by the GB, I don’t want to subsidize all the Netflix watchers.
- LeoPanthera 6y agoThe "cells" (which move) are relatively small, so you won't be sharing with many people at any point in time.
- topspin 6y ago> you won't be sharing with many people at any point in time. That depends of the density of subscribers. Starlink is only feasible (at least with stable, high performance...) for low density areas. The stated market for Starlink is "the 3% to 4% of the hardest to reach customers for telcos." Almost no one reading this is part of that market.
- blizzarac 6y agoHow about China or North Korean will they be able to operate there and sidestep the firewalls?
- topspin 6y agoSpaceX has good reasons to be compliant with the policies of sovereign nations; Starlink relies on shared spectrum and orbits a shared planet. I expect SpaceX will diligently observe the disparate policies of all nations. Note that the purpose of Starlink is to fund major SpaceX initiatives, particularly the Mars mission. It isn't an egalitarian exercise and squabbles with China or its client states are not a source of revenue. There is no opportunity for clandestine use either; the ground station is a transceiver. Transceivers are relatively easy to detect when they transmit.
- Skunkleton 6y agoProbably not. I doubt these countries will allocate spectrum to starlink, and I doubt that they will allow the import of the ground stations.
- modeless 6y agoThey just launched the next batch of Starlink satellites minutes ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y4xBFHjkUvw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y4xBFHjkUvw. The 60-satellite train should be visible in the sky over the SF bay area around 9:35 tomorrow night: https://james.darpinian.com/satellites/?special=starlink https://james.darpinian.com/satellites/?special=starlink Random FAQ about Starlink below: The combination of low latency (20-40ms) and high bandwidth (100+Mbps) has never been available in satellite internet before. A public beta may start later this year for some users in the northern US, around the 14th launch. Today is the 7th launch of v1 satellites. SpaceX is hoping to do more than two launches per month but haven't reached that pace yet. The ground stations look like this: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/gkkm9c/starlink_base_station_photos_from_the_location_of/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/gkkm9c/starli... The user antennas can be seen in that picture; they are the smaller circular things on black sticks. They are flat phased array antennas, and don't need to be precisely pointed like satellite dishes do. They are about the size of an extra-large pizza, so you won't be able to get a Starlink phone. The user antennas are likely to be quite expensive at first (several thousand dollars). Cost reduction of the user antennas is the biggest hurdle Starlink currently faces. Nobody knows yet how much SpaceX will charge for the antenna or service. Starlink can't support a high density of users, so it will not be an alternative to ISPs in cities. Rural and mobile use are the important applications. The US military is doing trials with it. Cell tower backhaul may also be a possibility. Starlink V1 doesn't have cross-satellite links, so the satellites can only provide service while over a ground station. There will be hundreds of ground stations in North America; no information about other regions yet. Starlink V2 is planned to have laser links between satellites, which will enable 100% global coverage 24/7, though local regulations are likely to prevent SpaceX from providing service in many places. Because the speed of light in a vacuum is 30% faster than in optical fiber, the latency of Starlink over long distances has the potential to be lower than any other option once laser links are available. Each launch of 60 Starlink satellites has nearly as much solar panel area as the International Space Station. Once SpaceX's Starship is operational they should be able to launch several hundred satellites at once instead of just 60. Starlink's only current competitor, OneWeb, just filed for bankruptcy after only launching a handful of satellites, and is fishing for acquisition offers. Amazon is also planning something called Project Kuiper but not much is known about it. Starlink V2 will have 30,000 satellites, requiring hundreds of launches. Even once the initial fleet is launched, SpaceX will still need to maintain the constellation with many launches per year indefinitely. SpaceX's FCC application has many interesting details: https://licensing.fcc.gov/myibfs/download.do?attachment_key=2378669 https://licensing.fcc.gov/myibfs/download.do?attachment_key=...
- nerdbaggy 6y agoSpaceX also has a /20 announced by Google. Looking at the RDNS it’s for SEA, LAX, SJC, ORD, LGA https://bgp.he.net/search?search%5Bsearch%5D=spacex&commit=Search https://bgp.he.net/search?search%5Bsearch%5D=spacex&commit=S...
- jessriedel 6y agoCould someone explain the technical notability beyond what can be inferred from the Wikipedia page? > An autonomous system (AS) is a collection of connected Internet Protocol (IP) routing prefixes under the control of one or more network operators on behalf of a single administrative entity or domain that presents a common, clearly defined routing policy to the internet. > Originally the definition required control by a single entity, typically an Internet service provider (ISP) or a very large organization with independent connections to multiple networks.... The newer definition ...came into use because multiple organizations can run Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) using private AS numbers to an ISP that connects all those organizations to the internet. Even though there may be multiple autonomous systems supported by the ISP, the internet only sees the routing policy of the ISP. That ISP must have an officially registered autonomous system number (ASN). > A unique ASN is allocated to each AS for use in BGP routing. ASNs are important because the ASN uniquely identifies each network on the Internet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_system_(Internet) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_system_(Internet)
- walrus01 6y agoISP senior neteng here: It means they're starting to get serious about becoming their own facilities-based ISP at the most fundamental "core" level of the Internet. In this case the facilities will be their earth stations for trunk links to the starlink satellites, the satellites themselves, and their routers at major carrier-neutral interconnections points such as where the SIX is physically located. A number of the earth station filing geographic coordinates, in public FCC documents, correlate with the known location of regen huts for north america's largest dark fiber/DWDM/transport carriers on intercity fiber paths. Such as Centurylink and Zayo. The typical thing to do in this case is that they'll be buying 'lit' circuits from carrier-of-carrier ISPs to reach those IX points.
- inopinatus 6y agoIt’s the ISP equivalent of setting up stall at a wholesale market. To exchange traffic, providers advertise the IP ranges they can route. The starter pack for this consists of an AS number (which is fundamentally just a nominal integer identifier for your organisation), an interconnect (either to an internet exchange or a transit provider), and some address space to call your own. The notability is commercial: StarLink is ready, or at least preparing, to negotiate peering with other providers. That’s a whole other ball game, c.f http://drpeering.net/white-papers/Art-Of-Peering-The-Peering-Playbook.html http://drpeering.net/white-papers/Art-Of-Peering-The-Peering.... There’s also a social angle. I’ve seen folks wearing their ASN like an agency windcheater. Network engineers are tribal.
- ggmartins 6y agoWe didn't fix the pollution of the ocean now we have to worry about the pollution of the space.
- modeless 6y agoSpaceX moved the satellite orbits much lower to mitigate this concern. In their current low orbit, any broken satellites or debris will fall out of the sky within a few years due to atmospheric drag. The real concern is in higher orbits where debris would persist for millennia.
- exikyut 6y agoSo now the cloud isn't just going to rain users' data, it's going to rain satellites too. Great.
- modeless 6y agoThe satellites are designed to completely burn up as they reenter the atmosphere. So it won't rain anything on the ground. And the mass of the satellites is minuscule compared to the mass of dust and meteors that fall into the Earth's atmosphere from space every day.
- Skunkleton 6y agoIf we're not careful here we will give the anti-vax 5g conspiracy crowd another thing to ferment.
- aherz 6y agoThese satellites have de-orbit plans after they've served their lifetime use.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoYes, low orbit and disposable and planned obsolescence. Which I believe they have already live-tested the EOL burnup.
- siavosh 6y agoDoes anyone know the next most prolific/frequent commercial launcher after SpaceX and what their annual average is? The frequency of their launches seem completely nuts.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoIts one if those things where you could probably game the metrics to justify half a dozen different answers. For example ISRO doesn't have many launches, but they do a lot of rideshares so I wouldn't be surprised if they're #1 or #2 in terms of individual satellites launched last year. It also depends a lot on what you consider a commercial launcher. In recent history, the Chinese Long March rockets have been dominating the numbers game (around 25 launches last year, vs around 20 Soyuz and 15 Falcon 9s). But the Long March family is a lot more diverse than most rocket families, so they're probably not #1 if you're comparing specific configurations. You also probably don't want to count rockets that missed space and ended up in the middle of a village, which hurts China's totals.
- __m 6y agoOr we admit that they have more launches
- Denvercoder9 6y agoWikipedia has statistics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_in_spaceflight#Orbital_launch_statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_in_spaceflight#Orbital_la... Note though that 2019 was a pretty slow year for SpaceX, they launched almost twice as much in 2018.
- breitling 6y agoOk I have a naive question I think someone here can answer: how long do these satellites stay in orbit? Don't they need a boost every now and then to maintain the momentum? Is that boost built in?
- savrajsingh 6y agoYes. They have built-in thrusters to maintain their orbit. If they stop working or get retired their orbit decays and they burn up in the atmosphere. See the 'ion propulsion systems' graphics at starlink.com.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoThese particular ones won't stay in orbit long. If left to decay naturally, maybe 5-10 years (tending towards the lower side of that range, but there's unpredictable factors that can have an impact e.g. space weather). However orbital decay times increase exponentially(ish) with your height. At the higher orbits they've gotten permission to use, it can take more like 200-1000 years to decay naturally
- kgersen 6y ago"Last Updated: 2019-02-21" what's new ?
- coderholic 6y agoThey're only announcing a single /24 currently: https://ipinfo.io/AS14593 https://ipinfo.io/AS14593
- ConnorLeet 6y agoLittle bit off topic question Is there a public API or a database ASN ownership? Contact information would be nice also...
- mike_d 6y agoPlease don't. Yes there is a database of contacts, but the people on the other end only want to hear from you if you also run an ASN.
- abinaya_rl 6y agoExcellent report. I'm wondering the tech used in Google’s Loon balloon internet service and this Starlink is different? Does both are using a similar tech?
- shaklee3 6y agoNo, different frequencies and antennas.
- Softcadbury 6y agoSomething bothers me for a long time, how can Starlink be allowed be China or other countries with high internet censorship ?
- AnssiH 6y agoI don't think they are currently planning to provide services in such countries.
- chaos_a 6y agoWouldn't it be possible for someone to fake their location and sign up anyways? Or does starlink require the knowledge of your exact location to operate?
- fastball 6y agoIn order to access Starlink you'll need a phased-array antenna, so yes, they will know exactly where you are.
- nickik 6y agoIf they look for them
- 8bitsrule 6y agoA flat box decorated to blend with the shingles it's resting on might be invisible for a long time.
- fastball 6y agoI meant that you are directly communicating with moving satellites, so they can fairly trivially triangulate anyone using the service. But yes, they will also have your shipping address, as they are producing the ground antennas in-house.
- Denvercoder9 6y ago
- aledthemathguy 6y agoif a human from just 300 years ago would see this post - he would def think we are aliens.
- Skunkleton 6y agoYou could probably convince humans from 100 years ago.
- caogecym 6y agoKudos to SpaceX for potential lower latency internet service. But I'm concerned about the light pollution caused by Starlink satellites at night: https://www.unilad.co.uk/science/spacex-to-test-starlink-sun-visor-to-reduce-brightness-of-satellite/ https://www.unilad.co.uk/science/spacex-to-test-starlink-sun.... If they don't fix it, it would look awful for people who prefer a clean sky. And an average people wouldn't have a mean to mitigate that - it's not like a drone flying on top of your roof and you can shoot it down, it's a set of satellites thousands miles away. And if the parts of those satellites broke down, I wonder how much SpaceX itself could do to fix them. If the broken satellites end up a space garbage, that reminds me of the film scene in Gravity. This is a problem we already have today, contributed by all aerospace institutions. I guess people are treating it just like any other garbage around us: if it doesn't show in my eye, it's not my problem. But it's a harder problem than things like metal garbage on the ground, the latter you could recycle, but I don't know if people really recycle a satellite.
- sacred_numbers 6y agoRegarding light pollution: It's not as bad as it seems, since the satellites really only show up while they are raising their orbits, and usually only during dusk and dawn. Once they're in their final orbit you can't really see them. Also, SpaceX are working on the problem. They are testing a sun screen that will block light from reflecting towards Earth while being far enough away from the satellite to prevent overheating. Regarding space junk: These satellites are in low orbits, so if the satellite breaks it will just re-enter the atmosphere and get burned up within a few months or so. I believe they also have a deployable drag device to intentionally de-orbit the satellites at their end of life, or if there's a problem with the satellite.
- laurensr 6y agoWe have a GeoIP challenge up ahead :-) https://xkcd.com/713/ https://xkcd.com/713/