11 ms·
The due diligence is because the restaurants offer a terrible experience. Most still do not have an independent online ordering function. They want me to call.
by MattGaiser 6y ago
The due diligence is because the restaurants offer a terrible experience.
Most still do not have an independent online ordering function. They want me to call.
Most still haven't set up meaningful profiles on Yelp and other review sites. So I would need to root around to find contact information.
That is in addition to needing to give my credit card over the phone, not knowing how long the order will take, and needing to be concerned about the person hearing the order right.
The restaurants are barely trying to compete for customers.
- julianeon 6y agoI don't understand why this isn't treated like domain name hijacking, though. Suppose you want to go to McDonald's. I buy the McDonald's domain name. I put a credit card form on my site, and I "deliver" McDonald's to you. I charge a $40 surcharge for the privilege. There is no way in hell that McDonald's would have to go begging at realmcdonald's.com because of my shenanigans. They'd have no patience for this bullshit. In real life they'd sicc a DMCA notice and a ton of lawyers on this and I'd lose my webhost and the sheriff would come visit me and who knows what else. They'd get McDonald's.com fast enough to make your head spin, and I'd be pushed out of that business. Why is it different for restaurants? Same problem: instead of me it's a company, and instead of McDonald's it's a small restaurant. But the principle is the same. In domain name hijacking, it's presumed wrong because customers think they're reaching McDonald's when they're really calling me. In the GrubHub case it's exactly the same thing. I don't understand why it's wrong when I do it, but it's not a problem GrubHub does. After all, McDonald's doesn't deliver, and I may own a very fine delivery business, but I'm still not allowed to coast off their name for my own business.
- tick_tock_tick 6y agoI mean you can absolutely do your first businesses model as long as you don't claim to actually be McDonald's your fine. The issue here is they agreed to allow GrubHub to pretend to be them. You'd never get that deal with McDonald's since they'd just not agree to it since they know it's a horrible idea but tons of people running restaurants don't understand they are getting a raw deal.
- CharlesW 6y ago> The issue here is they agreed to allow GrubHub to pretend to be them. Sadly, that's false. GrubHub is a bad actor. https://www.eater.com/2019/10/30/20940107/grubhub-to-add-restaurants-without-permission-like-postmates https://www.eater.com/2019/10/30/20940107/grubhub-to-add-res...
- Dylan16807 6y agoThose aren't the restaurants paying a fee. Non-partner restaurants are going to get full menu price.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MattGaiser 6y agoThe Grubhubs and DoorDashes are not logistic services but also marketing services. Most companies sign a marketing agreement with them.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoI think I remember reading that they often set all of this up prior to speaking with the owner / without getting their approval and then basically go to them after the fact and say "look how much traffic we've been bringing in for you" Edit: Ah, yup - see link to eater.com post elsewhere in the thread
- MattGaiser 6y agoIn that case the owner is then getting the full price for the food though.
- Retric 6y agoIt’s still destroying their reputation by charging more than the food is ‘worth’. Aka the expectation is higher for an 8$ burger than a 5$ one.
- throwaway2048 6y agoExcept now grubhub et all basically controls their web presence through vastly superior SEO, and if they don't agree to grubhub's terms, they basically disappear off the internet.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ddalex 6y agoExcept it would cost grubhub money to run an uncooperative client, so why would they ?
- 6y ago
- chongli 6y agoThey'd get McDonald's.com fast enough to make your head spin, and I'd be pushed out of that business. If McDonald's were a mom & pop restaurant and you were a multi-billion dollar, VC-backed startup, then you can be sure McDonald's would not be able to do this so easily. That's the difference.
- izzydata 6y agoThat is specifically what he is alluding to.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> I don't understand why it's wrong when I do it, but it's not a problem GrubHub does. The same reason that you'd be arrested for running an illegal taxi, but when Uber does it, it's fine. And the same reason that you'd be arrested for running an illegal hotel, but when AirBnB does it, it's okay. Uber and AiBnb spend a lot of money lobbying governments at every level, and on marketing to make what they do seem acceptable.
- xupybd 6y agoNot to mention Spotify or the early days of YouTube. Money is power, with enough of it you can bend the law.
- rightbyte 6y agoSpotify didn't have any fuckoff money in the start and the streamed stuff they got from the Piratebay. The authorities in Sweden didn't notice since they Spotify also tried at the same time to get proper contracts I guess and the music industry seemed to look through their fingers. Youtube is more strange since they illegally hosted IP for a long while.
- catalogia 6y ago> Youtube is more strange since they illegally hosted IP for a long while. They still do, their ContentID system has a lot of holes.
- Abdulozovehe 6y agoYes
- Can_Not 6y agoI dont find this convincing, taxis are mad because it's competition, the restaurants are mad because its impersonation. The restaurants should be entitled to civil suits to reclaim damages while in the Uber/AirBnB situation its more about regulations that the government failed to enforce.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mrighele 6y agoWhy do they ask the credit card number? I would expect to pay on delivery on a portable POS with card or phone. Safer for both.
- ponker 6y agoSo they can charge you if you never pick your food and they have to throw it out.
- MattGaiser 6y agoSo that they can charge you if the order is a prank. Maybe this is less true on smaller orders.
- tomc1985 6y agoI beg to differ. None of the places I've placed orders with (and I've been doing it a lot what with quarantine) have ever asked for CC over-the-phone. Most just want my name, some a phone number. Ordering usually takes less time than it would to fiddle about with a bunch of dropdowns, even if it had my customer information already saved.
- a_e_k 6y agoSpeaking of information already saved, one of my favorite pizza places has my order history keyed to my phone number. Ordering ahead usually comes down to dialing them up, giving my name and phone number and telling them I'd like the same as last time. They read it off to me to confirm, quote me a waiting time, and that's that. Start to finish, the call is probably less than thirty seconds.
- tomc1985 6y agoExactly. For most of my usual spots, someone picks up on the first ring, I place my order, they ask my name, and that's it
- cortesoft 6y agoOne of the coolest parts of GH and DD, though, is being able to try a new restaurant without having to enter any new information. Also, calling on the phone is not always easy; I often place orders on my phone while simultaneously on a work call, or putting my kid down for a nap, or doing something else where speaking is not easy.
- rahimnathwani 6y agoIt's strange that they have to ask for those details. I wonder what software they use and why it doesn't look up the customer record based on caller ID, as soon as the phone starts ringing.
- wruza 6y agoBecause it’s a phone and a software, and these are two separate tools?
- Causality1 6y agoIndeed. I can't count the number of times I was trying to pick a restaurant and bypassed because they either didn't have an online menu at all or wanted me to start an online order before showing it to me.
- bentcorner 6y ago> The restaurants are barely trying to compete for customers. That's a pretty broad brush you're using. All the restaurants in my area that I frequent don't need any help. I've ordered from them all over the phone or online through their website and haven't run into a problem that some SV 3rd party would have or could have solved. Any "improvements in experience" by yelp/grubhub is pure grift.
- acchow 6y agoThey also make no attempts to keep their operating hours on Google Maps or Yelp up-to-date. Especially for holidays. Is keeping this stuff up to date actually difficult. I don't run a business, so I have no idea.
- projektfu 6y agoRunning a small business is having lots of loose ends to manage by only one person. The restaurateur spends all day doing kitchen and front of house, closes the restaurant, and then looks forward to bookkeeping. They’re responsible for HR, payroll, scheduling, and marketing. They have to supervise repairs to the physical plant. Often, they forget which service you need to update to change the hours, they don’t realize that Yelp has changed their phone number to a GrubHub number until they’ve been receiving advertising bills, and even then maybe aren’t sure why it’s so expensive, etc. There are hundreds of companies trying to take advantage of you depending on the limited time you have to dedicate to everything. Why do I get so many “ads” that look like invoices? It must be an effective technique.
- BeetleB 6y ago> Is keeping this stuff up to date actually difficult. They usually have a zillion things to do, and this has a very low ROI. The impact to their bottom line is negligible whether they update or not. Not many people will refuse to use their business because they can't bother to update Google/Yelp/etc. They usually do it if there's a permanent change in hours, though.
- arn 6y agoI don't know about that. Not that it's easy to measure. But I feel that if I go to a restaurant and it's closed outside their normal hours inexplicably... I am definitely less likely to come back.
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoI think the issue is restaurants need a 3rd party platform. They aren't in the tech industry and they aren't going to hire a developer to build their own system unless its a global franchise. What we really need is for someone to build an open source / one time cost / subscription platform that gives restaurants the ease of using a premade system without the expense of having a per transaction fee.
- cortesoft 6y agoWhat makes Grubhub/doordash/etc so valuable to consumers, though, wouldn't be replicated by a premade system like that, though, no matter how good it was. The killer feature is that it is a single market place. I go on the app, I can search through dozens of local restaurants, all with a consistent interface. I can place an order in a couple of clicks at a brand new restaurant I have never tried, and I dont have to enter any new information. I can scroll through all my previous orders at all the previous restaurants, and re-order in one click. This service can ONLY be provided by a unified platform. It doesn't matter how good a restaurants website is, I want ALL the restaurants in one place. Now, could it be cheaper for restaurants? Does GH take too much of a cut? Maybe, but I don't know.... GH and DD both lose a ton of money, and have spent a ridiculous amount of money to get to where they are. Could anyone provide the service for a lot cheaper? If they could, they sure haven't yet.
- milesskorpen 6y agoI think the challenge here is that all the competitors are exceptionally well funded venture backed companies that are fighting to be the winner who takes it all. We don't know what this market would look like without the flood of exceptionally venture money to finance the engineers and discounts and all. Sustainable delivery would probably more bifurcated. I could imagine a range of food types that are delivery-centric (think pizza & Chinese) in areas with cheaper rents & smaller (or non-non-existant) dining rooms, and more delivery-optimized (high margin, easy to transport) food, with their own delivery drivers - and that a lot of other venues wouldn't do delivery, or would partner w/ a service like Lyft or Postmates when necessary, and it'd be expensive. I think this would be a healthier place to be.
- noelsusman 6y agoI've had a pretty great experience calling restaurants to place orders. I talk to a human, tell them my order, they repeat it back to me, and tell me it will be X dollars and ready at Y o'clock. I show up at the specified time and the order is ready to go. A couple times I had to wait 5 minutes because they were inundated and couldn't keep up. No stupid app to download. No account to create. No bullshit fees. No marketing emails. I just tell them what I want and then go get it. It's refreshing.
- mikysco 6y agoYes! I don’t know why there’s so much apprehension about calling the restaurant. So often I learn more about the dish I’m ordering - does it come with X ingredient yes/no, should I order Y add-on, is rice extra. Simple questions usually omitted from online menus. Makes the experience just a tiny bit more human and that’s honestly enough for me
- astura 6y agoI have very minor issues with phone orders that make me prefer online ordering. Restaurants are loud, add in shitty phone signals and heavy accents - the result is communication barriers are common and you have to do a lot of back-and-forth. Another issue is the person taking the order usually has more job duties than just taking phone orders, so they can be distracted if it's busy and forget to write something down and/or sometimes you have to call back several times until someone has a free hand to answer the phone.
- gambiting 6y agoYep, same. Every time I order over the phone I'm just hoping the other person understood what I said correctly, because I sure as hell haven't understood anything they said. It's a combination of accents, very loud backgrounds, and English not being my first language.
- ikornaselur 6y ago
- lapnitnelav 6y agoYelp tends to be yet another scam in the same vein. It's fair to leave them out. And even though your points are right, I am not sure those providers should charge as much. It's killing the golden goose in the long term, especially now.
- ehnto 6y agoWhy should they be required to set uo anything on Yelp or other aggregators? Yelp strong armed it's way into importance, they aren't a public service. I wish fewer restaurants would cave to their bullying.
- nogbit 6y agoIs it so hard to call? You still use Yelp after all we know about them? A simple search on just about any maps app gives a direct contact info, have you tried that? Give the card over the phone is arguably more or as secure as online. They read the order back to you don't they? They are trying to compete, call them directly and cut out all these middle men.
- chrisseaton 6y agoMost people these days just don’t like having to make a phone call.
- vladvasiliu 6y agoI think there are two different things here. I do notice in my area (Paris, France) that many small restaurants hardly have an online presence. I understand some people don't like calling up restaurants to order (I sometimes am one of those people). Indeed, in such cases, having some sort of external service aggregating information and maybe even exposing some sort of common ordering platform would be great. However, I think that people have an issue with GrubHub (and/or others) impersonating the restaurants. They don't come out and say "Hello, this is GH, we'll connect you to XYZ". They make you think you're doing business directly with the restaurant when, in fact, they're covertly routing the order through their platform and extracting fees. For me the actual issue is their not being open about it. I don't often go to restaurants and I don't know people working there either, but I would think that offering such a service in an open manner would be welcomed by both businesses and clients.
- Doctor_Fegg 6y ago> I do notice in my area (Paris, France) that many small restaurants hardly have an online presence. I understand some people don't like calling up restaurants to order and some restaurants are quite happy with their current customer base, and don't see the need to market themselves.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> ...offer a terrible experience. Most still do not have an independent online ordering function. They want me to call. Curious reversion to what I want for everything. I don't want to do it online, I want to call for anything. Less online presence = good, in my books. Less to build profiles with. (posted in public on HN by accident of course)
- La1n 6y ago> The due diligence is because the restaurants offer a terrible experience. If this was true Grubhub would gladly put there name on everything, say it in the automated phone call, so people would actively seek them out for a better experience.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoI mean I don't blame restaurants for only accepting orders over the phone, given that the alternative is a money-grabbing monopolist trying to take away all of their customers. Yelp is another matter full of fake reviews and spam - I can also see why restaurants don't want to have a "social media manager" doing that for them. I mean, you're using smart vocabulary "due dilligence", "Yelp" - but how much of that is literally spammy articles that have nothing to do with the real quality of the food in the restaurant?
- tzs 6y agoI too don’t like to call to order things...which I don’t understand because if I went in person I’d have no problem voice ordering. I wonder if ordering by video call would make it feel more like in person ordering?
- PascLeRasc 6y agoWow, did the restaurant owners not show up to UX class when they were at Stanford? How are they going to scale their MVP into an IPO at this rate??
- toss1 6y agoRight Restaurants are typically swamped in the massive overhead of running an actual restaurant, and are not fully up to date with every latest bit of marketing toolkit. Because they are not fully up to date on the latest digital marketing, you think it is justified that they be subject to what is effectively hoards of VC-backed extortionists - nice restaruant you got there... be a shame if some bad reviews got highlighted ... or here, we'll just hijack your phone listings and take care of delivery for you... At least the mafiosi would occasionally eat at the restaurants on whom they were running protection rackets... The Due diligence is required because of these new hordes of extortionists, not the restaurants (and no, it isn't all about your trivial convenience, OMG, they want you to call and don't have the latest web technology up for every function... nevermind the quality of the food, ambiance, or service, it's all about whether you can order it through an app, isn't it?) sheesh
- wlll 6y ago> Most still do not have an independent online ordering function. They want me to call. There's the significant chance that most of the restaurants you have to call are running at such thin profit margins that they don't have the money to spare to hire web devs or pay hosting providers, and even if they did, do you want to hand over your credit card details to some budget build order page? It's also likely that the profit margins are low enough that the fees for something like Grubhub cut deep. On the flip side, having to call somewhere really isn't that hard, and to describe it as "a terrible experience" is a bit mystifying. > needing to give my credit card over the phone Pay in cash? > not knowing how long the order will take You don't need a computer to tell you this, just say "How long will the order take?" to the person on the phone and they will tell you. > needing to be concerned about the person hearing the order right Ask for a read-back.