6 ms·
I really want to see the Starship full stack launch but can't Falcon Heavy get to the moon now? I mentioned in a thread a couple months ago that they could prob
by chasd00 6y ago
I really want to see the Starship full stack launch but can't Falcon Heavy get to the moon now? I mentioned in a thread a couple months ago that they could probably strap the Blue Origin lander to the top of FH and call it done.
EDIT: oh yeah, and what is it with all the exploding starships? Are the interns in charge of testing or something?
/ to the interns on HN, only kidding. you could probably do it better than us old folks anyway hah
- Robotbeat 6y agoThe Blue Origin lander is pretty big and would need to be launched in pieces. The Dynetics lander, on the other hand, is much smaller and could definitely fit in Falcon Heavy with the extended fairing (that SpaceX is already developing for Air Force payloads). I'm a big fan of the Dynetics lander. It's small for its capability and just a single stage (plus drop tanks) so should have low development and build costs. Video of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFBeVQ3STZ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFBeVQ3STZ0
- twic 6y agoYou want to get all the exploding done before you launch the rocket with crew aboard. Saturn V could lift 140 tonnes to low earth orbit. Falcon Heavy can lift 54 tonnes to low earth orbit. I think that means it could get a mission to the moon as long as it weighed 38% of what Apollo did. That doesn't sound like a fun trip. Unless you assemble the moon ship in earth orbit first. Falcon Heavy can launch Orion on its own, or the European Service Module that it requires. I imagine it could launch a lunar lander too. You would also need a booster to send the combination to the moon - the Saturn final stage that did that weighed 100 tonnes, twice what Falcon Heavy can launch. So, maybe you launch an empty booster, and send up a couple of tankers to fuel it on orbit? It's a lot of launches, and a lot of work to do in orbit. That's not impossible (and is cool as hell), but there would be a lot of work to do to make it possible.
- inetknght 6y ago> Saturn V could lift 140 tonnes to low earth orbit. Falcon Heavy can lift 54 tonnes to low earth orbit. I think that means it could get a mission to the moon as long as it weighed 38% of what Apollo did. That doesn't sound like a fun trip. While I haven't yet seen anything concrete, SpaceX's definitely wants to have orbital refueling. If I recall, that's actually one of SpaceX's requirements for Starship. Orbital refueling would mean that lift capacity to LEO doesn't translate directly the range beyond LEO.
- chasd00 6y agoorbital refueling makes a lot of sense, do you know if there are plans to manufacture the fuel in orbit? That would be somewhat good practice for producing fuel on Mars. At lease they would know not to forget anything, no making a quick trip to Home Depot while in orbit.
- chrisjc 6y agoI've heard about approaches for manufacturing fuel on the Moon, but I can't imagine how you might manufacture it in earth's orbit. What are the leading ideas around this approach? edit: i know we can launch more fuel into orbit, and I really emphasize the "manufacturing" in orbit part.
- twic 6y agoCollect a water-ice asteroid or cometary nucleus or some such, park it in orbit, and electrolyse it. I'm not aware of a less outlandish plan! Now, if you want oxidiser, you could skim air off the top of the earth's atmosphere. I have no idea if that has been considered outside of science fiction [1], though. [1] okay, here they're skimming nitrogen, but: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallen_Angels_(science_fiction_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallen_Angels_(science_fiction...
- Turing_Machine 6y agoIf you were electrolyzing water ice, wouldn't you get both hydrogen (fuel) and oxygen (oxidizer), by definition?
- avmich 6y ago> Saturn V could lift 140 tonnes to low earth orbit. Just to be pedantic, remember, that the only thing Saturn-V brought to LEO and left there was Skylab, with mass 77 tons. Other than that you counting parts of Saturn-V itself as part of payload, which is inconsistent - you don't count mass of Falcon-9 second stage as part of payload, for example, even though it gets to orbit. Saturn-V is better characterized by the mass it leaves on translunar orbit, which is 48,6 tons. For LEO it's awkwardly lopsided with mass of 3rd stage and remaining fuel. In other words, if you have a 140 tons satellite, you couldn't get it to LEO with Saturn-V. So the comparison is wrong.
- twic 6y agoGood points. I think the reason this is complicated is that the Apollo missions included one stage, the S-IVB, which was used twice, for getting into low earth orbit, and for departing for the moon. You have to count some fraction of that as mass lifted to orbit, but i don't know how much.
- rbanffy 6y ago> Falcon Heavy can lift 54 tonnes to low earth orbit. I think that means it could get a mission to the moon as long as it weighed 38% of what Apollo did You can launch the lander first, park it in lunar orbit, then launch the crew on a second Falcon Heavy, each having 38% of an Apollo worth of mass. With a little more creativity, you can launch the ascent vehicle on another Falcon Heavy and land it before the other two so that astronauts can rest assured that, unless they kill themselves during the landing, there is a ride back up waiting for them. With that you can have 3 separate chronograms and each mission is simplified in relation to a single Apollo. If you are unhappy with the mass budget, you can launch yet another series of missions with supplies and equipment to be landed before the ascent vehicles are landed. And, since in this case whatever lands doesn't even need to be pressurized, or delicate, landing it should be much easier too. Now we are at 1.52 Apollo masses per mission. It took 4 launches to get there but, still, it's a lot of stuff for our astronauts to work with. Also, if any one launch fails, you can always try again.
- m4rtink 6y agoOne think to note is that if you use cryogenic proplants for your lander or lunar tug, you might face issues with fuel and oxidizer boiling off over time (unless you go for very good isolation or use active cooling, both rather heavy), reducing your time window to have everything launched & used. You can opt for hypergolic propellants that won't boil off, but you sacrifice performance and make ground handling more expensive and dangerous due to these being highly toxic.
- rbanffy 6y agoYou can use cryogenics for the landers and depots that don't stay parked in lunar orbit for long, but any assets with long shelf life should use hypergolics. And now my mission profile has two different landing modules, one using cryogenics, one using hypergolics. Oh well... We can always go hypergolic if the mass budget is not a big issue.
- nradov 6y agoRequiring the astronauts to execute a cross country EVA from the lander to the ascent vehicle seems like a huge risk. What if they land just slightly too far away?
- inamberclad 6y agoYou can get an F9 to the moon if your payload is only a few hundred kg...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jccooper 6y agoTwo things: (1) no one's used methane on a rocket before, so there's not a lot of experience in ground handling it, and its properties are rather different than other fuels. (2) Making large lightweight steel pressure vessels is also rather novel. Those two account for most of the destruction; the rest are the sorts of errors usual to a rocket test program. It's an industry famous for blowing things up due to low margins and lots of potential energy.
- bronco21016 6y agoGiven those two statements, how much testing ($$$$) are agencies like NASA going to require before attaching self-loading cargo to the ship? A large part of SpaceX’s success in winning commercial crew approval is because the stack is actually very traditional. The primary innovation is first stage recovery which arguably doesn’t add any risk to the crew. Fully new materials and propellants completely change the game when it comes to risk. I hope the succeed and I think they can succeed. It’s just that this round is going to take a little more money than the Falcon/Dragon program and I hope they’re able to find enough of it.
- fastball 6y agoAs the other commenter pointed out, the Falcons have some innovation in there. But Starship's has even mroe. It uses SpaceX's new Raptor engines, which are full-flow CH4/LOX engines. No full-flow staged combustion cycle (FFSCC) rocket engine has ever been used to deliver a payload to LEO (or even used in an actual rocket at all, AFAIK). This is somewhat surprising (and indicative of the difficulty of manifesting the design), given that the design has been around since at least the 1960s and has a lot of benefits over other rocket engine designs. In that regard, FFSCC rocket engines actually remind me of LFTR-type MSRs: 1. been around for decades 2. clear benefits to the design 3. hasn't managed to be used viably So I would say Starship + Super Heavy is definitely a riskier investment than NASA has made with Falcon.
- jccooper 6y agoQuite a lot, I imagine, but given they're (supposed to be) fully reusable, the idea is that testing will be $$ instead of $$$$.
- tdy721 6y agoNew Glenn has deep cryo hydrolox upper stage, same as proposed lander? Like they were made for each other.