5 ms·
The cold war is back, the fashion is back and out of all the things that are back I am glad that the USA is back in space flights. Wish you the best luck and h
by mrtksn 6y ago
The cold war is back, the fashion is back and out of all the things that are back I am glad that the USA is back in space flights.
Wish you the best luck and hope that this will lead to some serious competition. Soyuz is great but we need to do more as species.
- dmos62 6y ago> do more as species Space exploration and exploitation is awesome, but shouldn't the first items on the "do more as species" todo list be about taking care of earth?
- gpm 6y agoFirst, yes (or similar terrestrial activities). Only, definitely not.
- mrtksn 6y agoThese things don't have to be mutually exclusive. Unless you create an AI to build paperclips, of course.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoIn fact, if they are mutually exclusive it’d be indicative of incredible mismanagement. There are enough people for us to be able to do both, and nobody benefits from reallocating rocket scientists to things that aren’t rocket science.
- gowld 6y agoWhy not? Rocket scientists can work on fuel efficient cars and airplanes. And rocket science is only one small part of the overal industrial effort of launching rockets.
- Koshkin 6y ago> Rocket scientists can work on fuel efficient cars In all honesty, that's like saying that Jack the Ripper could work as a surgeon.
- avmich 6y agoWe raise the question if the space deserves exploration fairly frequently here. For some reason, neither commercial advantages - certain things, like global communications, navigation, imaging can be conveniently done with satellites - not traditional expansion of species habitat reasons - though I'm sure for each Columbus crew there were some loudly wondering why sail at all - serve as a good enough explanation.
- lmilcin 6y agoOf course it is worth to explore space. It does not "deserve" to be explored, it just pays off. There is huge amount of knowledge and resources to be had. Of course robotic missions are better for exploration than manned mission. Manned missions costs so much we could do so many more robotic missions for the same cost. People are absolutely not required in space. We send people into space because we can and we want. Because we keep separate track of record of things achieved by actual human beings. That's why we list who beat 100m or marathon record even though we have machines to move as around much faster. Because standing a human on a mountain, sea bed, or a piece of rock in space is an important step for us to prove we can command nature around us.
- avmich 6y ago> Of course robotic missions are better for exploration than manned mission. Manned missions costs so much we could do so many more robotic missions for the same cost. People are absolutely not required in space. Can you imagine being wrong on that? That people can and are cheaper than robots for certain important aspects? That accomplished space robot makers would disagree that robots are at least universally cheaper - or better in other aspects? > We send people into space because we can and we want. Because we keep separate track of record of things achieved by actual human beings. That's why we list who beat 100m or marathon record even though we have machines to move as around much faster. Because standing a human on a mountain, sea bed, or a piece of rock in space is an important step for us to prove we can command nature around us. I suspect you're mixing several significantly different things into one here. Token achievements, like current champion in sport X, are one thing. Genuinely advancing, say, science - like on ISS - is another.
- galacticaactual 6y agoWhy is this question never raised whenever the latest web company raises X million dollars that could’ve funded green tech?
- jayd16 6y agoIt never factors in to the conversation. No one brings up a species wide imperatives so its not countered with a question of priority.
- deegles 6y agoIt's clear that the people writing the checks thought they would make more money with the web company. Either they're looking at the green projects and thinking "meh" or they're not seeing them at all.
- bcrosby95 6y agoOr they're investing in both web and green tech.
- simonh 6y agoI think as a species, it should be possible for us to do more than one thing at a time.
- KoftaBob 6y agoSure, that should be a higher priority. Is there a sentiment somewhere that space exploration is a higher or more urgent priority than green energy?
- DannyB2 6y agoElon seems to be in favor of both space exploration and green energy and other ways to generally improve the planet and human life. Comcast vs Starlink, hmmm, I wonder which?
- Symmetry 6y agoAll efforts have diminishing returns. If the tiny amount of resources our species spends on space exploration were re-directed towards taking care of Earth you wouldn't see any difference there. And also, efforts in space benefit the Earth a lot through things like comms and weather satellites and by learning more about our come by comparing it with other planets. Comparing the atmosphere of Earth with that of Venus and Mars, for instance, told us a lot about the importance of the ozone layer and we might have only just stopped the production of CFCs if it hadn't been for space exploration.
- kempbellt 6y agoThere are over 7 billion people on the planet. We can do a few things at once.
- LoSboccacc 6y agohttps://launiusr.wordpress.com/2012/02/08/why-explore-space-a-1970-letter-to-a-nun-in-africa/ https://launiusr.wordpress.com/2012/02/08/why-explore-space-... in general, there's a lot of items on the urgent list, there's so much money to go around and you don't want to invest everything in endeavour X only for Y to be worse and catch you by surprise. so you allocate some budget to secondary research as well. NASA doesn't even burn that much in the grand scheme of things.
- derekp7 6y agoThis is like parents telling their children "If you have time to goof off and play games, you should have time to study harder / do the dishes / mow the lawn". This isn't an either /or, also even if you stopped doing X completely, and did only Y, you still won't be done with Y. Because there is always more Y to do. So as long as Y isn't fully achievable, might as do some X also.
- aquajet 6y agoWhom exactly is this Cold War against?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Rerarom 6y agoShanghaiskaya Cooperation Organization
- snazz 6y agoIndia and Pakistan have now joined that pact as well. As I understand it, the US has the biggest beef with China and Russia.
- koheripbal 6y agoAnyone with large stockpiles of nuclear weapons that isn't vested in the success of the global financial system.
- Koshkin 6y agoWell, the human species first and foremost should be seen as consisting of individuals, and while being deeply excited about and appreciative of all the high-tech endeavors, I keep asking myself, how much they are - and for how long they will continue to be - dependent on a near-slave labor of millions of said individuals around the world. (It's still there, on a massive scale, in spite of automation, machines, robots, the AI and what not we take as a given these days.)
- mrtksn 6y agoThat's not going away until we robotize everything. We no longer hunt, all the genetic material for hunting left in us is now just an artefact, we no longer ride horses for transportation, we no longer loose contact from our friends and families for prolonged periods, we no longer do many many things. I think we no longer eat meat too - I mean sure we eat meat but for most of us meat is this thing in the supermarket and we don't have an intuitive understanding from where it is coming from. Something like that needs to hapen with robotics before we no longer have people who do the undesirable jobs. There's this movie "Downsizing" about people getting miniaturized and live lavish lives as their material needs get smaller. It's not a very good movie but what stike me in the move was that even in that kind of society they needed to have miniaturized people for the labour that no one wants to do and they had to have slums and so on so that the society works. I find this very realistic because even though we have rich countries and poor countries, we still have to have income gradient everywhere so that some people will do the jobs that others don't want to do. I don't think that this will go away without eliminating the need for near slave labour.
- billfruit 6y agoYes, but is manned missions really going to achieve much. I thought there was much differing opinion about the value/lack of value of manned missions among the space community itself.
- nradov 6y agoThe US kind of has to preserve at least a minimal manned spaceflight capability in case we really need it for something in the future. If we completely lose the infrastructure, supply chains, and institutional knowledge it will become impossible to restart from scratch in a reasonable time frame. Think about it like paying for an insurance policy. It's worth doing even if it eats into the budget for unmanned satellites and probes.
- Koshkin 6y agoI don't think the US as a nation (or anyone in particular, for that matter) "has to" do anything. As usual, there are simply various diverse interests - military, commercial, scientific - and it's up to these interested parties to do what and when they think benefits them.
- enchiridion 6y agoYes. GP said "kind of has to" and then went on to explain the incentives.
- kens 6y agoBy the way, NASA style is to avoid using "manned" and use a term like "crewed" or "piloted" instead. The Manned Spaceflight Center is an exception. See https://history.nasa.gov/styleguide.html https://history.nasa.gov/styleguide.html
- gowld 6y agoThose appositive Oxford commas, though: > The exception to the rule is when referring to the Manned Spaceflight Center (also known as the Manned Spacecraft Center), the predecessor of Johnson Space Center in Houston, or to any other historical program name or official title that included “manned”
- billfruit 6y agoAs much as many US "hawks" seems to want it, I think another cold war is one of the least desirable thing to start now.
- koheripbal 6y agoAs long as other nuclear powers exist - there will be cold wars. There are two alternatives... 1. Non-nuclear hot wars. 2. A single global authority.
- unnouinceput 6y agoSticks and stones.
- Koshkin 6y agoDisarmament on the global scale, sure. Won't go that far, for practical reasons - we'll still need knives and fusils de chasse.
- billfruit 6y agoWe didn't have a cold war last 20 years, except some in the US still maintaining a cold war mentality.
- andresgottlieb 6y agoAs long as the meaning of "Cold War" stays poorly defined, there will be no point to this conversation
- trynumber9 6y agoNotably, there was a single global hegemon that bombed and invaded countries at-will during that time period. Now another pole rises in China and so a return to a "cold war" like system is possible. Personally, I hope we can come to an arms control limitation with China. In 20-30 years, even force parity will be charity on their part.
- 6y ago
- badrabbit 6y agoWhat fashion?