23 ms·
I won’t buy ebooks anymore
- waynenilsen 6y agoThis is very shortsighted. People are motivated by wealth. Paper books cannot be copied for free but ebooks can, same thing with music. The creators must be compensated or the content that you enjoy would cease to exist.
- arch-ninja 6y agoI've had similar thoughts, and my conclusion is that most copy-able assets should be copy-able. The real value is in discovery and curation, which may be sold as a subscription. Many companies already realize this, and DRM requirements are set by 1 stockholder who pushes for it and nobody can give a good reason why it would hurt paying customers.
- kgwxd 6y agoThe subscription model seems generally good for the consumer but terrible for the creators. As a customer, I really like the Bandcamp model. I can't directly speak for the creator side of things but I feel like that would get them a far better cut.
- genghizkhan 6y agoThe issue is that if you have a model which is bad for consumers it doesn’t matter how awesome it is for creators. It won’t work out.
- arch-ninja 6y agoNever thought of it from the creators perspective. Thanks for giving me a new problem to solve during quarantine! I'm 100% certain there is an ideal system to manage every human problem, it's just a matter of investigation.
- Nasrudith 6y agoHow is it terrible for creators exactly? I don't quite know what you mean. Streamers often complain about the "always on" nature but that seems more related to having to handle building engagement as well. Patreon is a popular enough that there are several clones for whatever content they exclude to help their image ranging from taboo porn to extremists. The payment stream seems peripheral to the deal they get. Creators get screwed in publication models as well. The best deal I can see in a "Netflix" style package is a bit tracky in having a maintainer cut and a time weighted service by the consumers under the logic that if 1 work is why you are there it deserves the share more than anything you don't consume while among N works each matters a bit less. More content grows the pie but it is fixdd share. Heavy users pay the same as light but that is because metering and surprise bills are too stressing and loses customers combined with a marginal real cost.
- kgwxd 6y agoI ment subscription to service like Spotify or Netflix. Direct subscription to streamers is something I do often, but that doesn't work for music and movies.
- hvis 6y agoWhy is it bad for the creators? Currently, I hardly ever buy ebooks (maybe like 1-2 per year), mostly because I hate DRM and the hassle that comes with stripping it off. A monthly 4$ subscription to a store where all books of the world are available would make the industry see a lot more of my money. Surely that would be good for the creators.
- Noos 6y agoHow on earth would any author make money from you paying $4 a month? Why don't we pay all computer programmers $10 an hour, that's pretty much the price equivalent of paying what you ask.
- hvis 6y agoFrom economies of scale. The authors where I am the only reader won't make on writing alone either way.
- gjs278 6y agonope. just let the idiots pay for the books. we can steal them. same reason piracy didn’t kill netflix even though it’s trivial to get all the shows.
- jp555 6y agoMusic was being made LONG before there was a music industry. Creating value and collecting a portion of the value created are completely different skill sets. You can't put them together by just saying it MUST BE SO. That's the "central committee" approach and history has shown that while it appears attractive, it will more likely destroy it all.
- sneak 6y agoNone of what you wrote seems to me to be a justification for DRM.
- sn41 6y agoVery few content-creators get a fair royalty. DRM is mostly about publisher wealth, not creator wealth. I think selling books for 25 cents etc. can result in massive sales. There is a middle-ground between selling overpriced editions with small changes in between, and outright piracy. Digital formats allow large-scale distribution, so pricing copies for under a dollar makes piracy not that attractive, when following the law and your conscience comes so cheap. But somehow publishers want it all - the large scale distribution possibility of the digital medium, and the margins of the print medium.
- Zenbit_UX 6y agoYou need to consider perceived value, most of the books I buy are $9.99-14.99 and if I saw a new book come out for $0.25 my first reaction would be Wtf, then probably: did a child write this?
- justaguyhere 6y agoMaybe a middle ground, like what Louis C.K did. He was selling his videos for $5 at one point, if I remember correctly - directly from his website, cutting out the middlemen. Yes, one can buy it and send it to all their friends, but the price is low enough that many people would just buy it..
- crtasm 6y agoThen you spot other books at a similar price and maybe something that directly interests you, and your assumptions change.
- butdotheytho 6y agohonestly, having given it much thought, i don't think this is actually the case. all i can say in a short comment on my reasoning is: 1. works of art done for love or the need to share are peices of content probably worth spending very valuable time on 2. works of art created for money are inevitably optimising for wasting your life - films and books are dragged out to series that largely go no where, vacuous music and media is created in the hope of getting you to spend money, not expanding your mind and adding to the value of society 3. historically this doesn't really seem to have been an issue. if you are good you can make money out of commissions and guest appearances or signed copies etc. this is not perfect, but it certainly makes it more likely money will go to the creator rather than a distributor. - note also the current system is far from perfect and many creators suffer from its failures today 4. nothing is done in isolation: inevitably you created your thing based on what you learned from others and opportunities society gave you.. but most importantly the value comes from other people need, NOT your creation - ability to write code is not valuable, removing someones problem is. 5. controlling and restricting the ability for other to create as they are not creating how some right holder wants seems drastically counter productive and greatly slows progress and de-motivates people who could be adding to society. 6. if we got better about respecting what others had contributed to our ideas (as we felt less need to hoard them) then overall i think people would be worried less when its someone else take on their idea that "makes it big". if thre was less ot be gained financially, it would remove incentives for deceit. i suppose in summary, i think that you should create out of love and because you think that thing needs creating. if all "for profit" inventions and art were to vanish from existence, i don't actually think we would be missing much. there is no race we are trying to win with progress and there is no final state to get to.
- interestica 6y agoWhy don't you pay for recipes?
- waynenilsen 6y agoMany people do pay for the best ones. Recipe books are still very popular. Most people pay for their recipes by viewing ads.
- kayodelycaon 6y agoLet me get this straight, the author has a bad experience with one website selling ebooks, so they decide they’ll never buy ebooks ever again? In real life, this would be the equivalent of getting one bad meal at a restaurant chain in a city you’ve never been to before, so you stop eating at that chain anywhere else, despite positive experiences in the past.
- leephillips 6y agoI think it would be more like deciding never to eat in any restaurant anywhere. The headline says that he won’t ever buy ebooks, then lists good places to buy ebooks. I guess he is exaggerating for effect? But it’s true, nobody should accept DRM. Here is the statement of the publisher who sells my gnuplot book: “We believe that when you buy a book, it belongs to you. That’s why we use no ‘digital rights management’ or anything else that interferes with your rights. You can make as many personal backups as you want, and use the book on any number of your own devices. If you lose your files, you can just download them again, forever.”
- kayodelycaon 6y agoUnless I missed something, the author states they never had issues with other services but they don’t say they intend to keep buying ebooks despite one bad experience. One would hope the author is exaggerating but I have seen a number of people in my life be this irrational. I’m inclined to take the title as is given any lack of evidence to the contrary.
- tyingq 6y ago"the author states they never had issues with other service" True, but then the author also says "So I bought it. For the first time in my life, I bought an ebook". So I can't tell what is going on.
- salamanderman 6y agoI thought the other sites are giving away books that either had no DRM or the DRM has been broken, repositories of bootleg ebooks. I'm also confused.
- jonnypotty 6y agoI agree your experience has been shit, but work that an author spend months or years of their life on has to have some sort of protection. People need to get used to actually paying for digital services, but they won't when the experience is as bad as this. Companies can not make dealing with their drm more difficult than working around it.
- dudul 6y agoWas the author reluctant to buying the book? He bought it. He just doesn't want to have to use Windows and a whole suite of awful software because of the DRM.
- tgb 6y agoThe author is pretty clearly reluctant to buy the book, based off the first paragraph.
- dudul 6y agoReally? The 1st paragraph is just about his friend trying to borrow the book, and noboby having it, and the author eventually buying it. Is the problem that people are trying to borrow books from their friends? This has been going on for centuries.
- hengheng 6y agoUsed paper books have become cheap. "Affording the hassle of a bookshelf" is a thing nowadays, but I chose to indulge in that kind of luxury.
- falcolas 6y agoStoring them is less of an issue than moving them. You’ll get a good workout on the other hand.
- zozbot234 6y ago> The advertised format was epub, an open standard, useable on a large number of supports. But surprise-surprise, to get the file, I needed either a specific kind of tablet ... or to use Adobe [] spyware. How is this not bait-and-switch fraud? OP should file a complaint with their local business regulator.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kristianc 6y agoIs this communication style a function of being involved in FSF, or does FSF just naturally attract very angry people? It's not unreasonable that people should be compensated for work that they've spent months or years of their life working on.
- cmiles74 6y agoI am surprised by this comment; the article seemed clear that the author didn't mind paying for the book. Their issue was that the book was advertised as an EPUB file but then came wrapped in proprietary DRM.
- matt_heimer 6y agoTheir title is literally "I won't buy ebooks anymore". They've stated their intent to only pirate books. And they bought it with the intent of giving copies to their friends in the role as a "library". If they had stated a preference to only buy DRM-free books that would have been different but they literally link to a book pirating website in the article.
- Mr_Sweater 6y agoI struggle to see it as anything else and I find it difficult to read blog posts like this. Why are so many people so viscerally angry in oss?
- Tehchops 6y agoThere's definitely a demographic of that culture that comes across as having a very angsty, "hack the planet damn the man" attitude. A surefire way to stoke that anger is to involve them in any kind of process that results in profits being generated. Zealotry is great when you've got ample time on your hands, but some folks have work to get done and bills to pay, i.e. the authors who's books OP is stealing...
- smcphile 6y ago> Is this communication style a function of being involved in FSF, or does FSF just naturally attract very angry people? I agree that the article was poorly written. But you seem to be implying here that people involved with the FSF, as a whole, tend to be angry. I’m not at all sure that that’s true. > It's not unreasonable that people should be compensated for work that they've spent months or years of their life working on. Sure, agreed. And downloading unauthorized copies of ebooks from shady web sites, like the one mentioned in the article, isn’t a fair solution. But, for example, buying only ebooks without DRM from legitimate sources, and otherwise buying paper books, is one possible fair solution without DRM where writers and publishers do get paid.
- captn3m0 6y agoSometime last year, I was researching the OPDS spec and the upcoming release. I found that it’s all linked to DRM ultimately. Check the Readium specs if you’re interested. I was so disheartened to see DRM being pushed with an open standard. It’s the whole EME thing again.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MrGilbert 6y agoWe have downloadable music existing without DRM. Music industry tried before and failed. I pay an extra price for FLAC-quality downloadable content without DRM on it. And I hope that the movie industrie will take this road some day, too. BTT, there are a lot of books where you aren't forced into DRM. DRM creates real world issues for customers, as the shut down of DRM servers in the past showed. If you put DRM on your book, I won't buy it. It's as simple as that. Which doesn't mean I illegally download it from "somewhere on the interwebz". I simply won't read it at all.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- diego_moita 6y agoThe author has a very good point: buying ebooks is a crappy consumer experience. If that wasn't true, dead-tree books would be as rare as Compact Discs.
- MrPowers 6y agoBuying books from fnac.com sounds like a bad experience. I've bought books from https://leanpub.com/ https://leanpub.com/ without any problems.
- m4r35n357 6y agoYep, I have plenty of books dating back to the seventies (some even older). They are all still perfectly functional. Not heard of a 50 year old epub or pdf yet, wonder if it will ever happen ;)
- blackoil 6y agoI have over 100 books in my backpack that I carry where I go and get more books whenever I feel like, and I do not have Hermoine's magic handbag. So pros/cons of each method.
- fullstop 6y agoDon't need a bookmark either. Plus, built-in dictionary, and you can highlight passages without permanently marking up the book. It does need to be charged occasionally, though.
- falcolas 6y agoI used to collect physical books, but there are so many new and novel stories out there that I don’t reread most of them. So it’s a waste of space to keep 98% of them around anymore. Purging them was cathartic.
- gilbetron 6y agoClick on my kindle icon for "store", find book, click buy, have it seconds later. Alternatively, go to amazon.com and find book, click buy, shows up on my kindle seconds later.
- CogitoCogito 6y agoConsidering the author already strips the DRM from the purchased e-books and also apparently knows about Z library, a simple solution seems to be the buy the e-book, ignore it and then download the same e-book from Z library. I also feel the frustration though. I won't buy e-books unless it either has no DRM or if I know I can strip it easily afterwards.
- kotutku 6y agoThe author usually gets <5% share from the book price. I guess it's much better (although not legal) to just skip buying the book and send a donation directly to the author.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoNot all authors will accept such donations because it puts them in competition with their publisher. See Charles Stross: https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2009/03/reminder-why-theres-no-tipjar.html https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2009/03/reminde...
- panzagl 6y agoThey also acknowledge that many people work on a book besides the author.
- psychometry 6y agoMost of the "eBooks" from Z-lib and archive.org I've downloaded are nothing more than poor-quality scans of paper books converted to ePub via PDF+OCR. They're not even worth getting. The eBooks I rent via Overdrive or Kindle, though, were actually prepared specifically for that format.
- x775 6y agoThis is a distribution and not a format problem. A poor experience with what sounds like a poor distributor, and, perhaps by extension, a poor and limiting DRM, should not be considered representative for an otherwise neat format (.epub). If sales are done right, the experience is seamless, as the author himself finds to be the case with other distributors.
- fastball 6y agoHonestly I think the emphasis here is on "buy". Doesn't sound like the author is gonna stop reading ebooks, just that he's gonna pirate them (he mentions how easy it is to get a DRM-free book on Z Library).
- ojagodzinski 6y ago> Having DRM on books is a fucking dystopia nightmare that shouldn't even be a thing and I hope that the EU will pass laws to nuke them from orbit Learn polish ;)) there is no DRM on polish ebook sites. You just pay and get links to PDF/EPUB/MOBI formats of ebook. There is only watermark protection, example site: https://virtualo.pl/ebook/heban-i150038/ https://virtualo.pl/ebook/heban-i150038/ but it is similar in all publishing houses.
- chx 6y agoYes, I have been a Linux zealot once. I have been a "no DRM here" zealot once. I am now running Windows 10 + WSL and I begrudgingly accept if I want to support the authors while reading on an eReader I need to accept the DRM'd ebooks. I am getting too old to struggle with being a zealot. There are better things to spend my time on. You can download the DeDRM tools from https://apprenticealf.wordpress.com/ https://apprenticealf.wordpress.com/ linking to github, no crazy sites involved. Ps.: Funnily enough, my device is actually called a Not-eReader. It's lovely because it doubles as an emergency HDMI monitor.
- akho 6y agoDRM-using publishers tend to pay authors less than non-DRM ones do, and certainly less than you can donate to them (I assume the full price of the book). So if your intention is to support authors, pirating and finding a way to pay the author in a different way is more efficient. Nobody does that, of course.
- chx 6y agoI have yet to find a way to pay authors directly. One way I can support the authors is pirating the book, reading it once, deleting it and then purchasing a physical copy and donating it to the library. The end result is the exact same as if I had read the physical copy and donated it: I read the book, I paid for one copy and it doesn't take space which I do not have.
- tluyben2 6y agoI don't mind buying ebooks, movies, music but it has to be simple. With DRM is less good, but even DRM, as long as it's simple. I had the same experience as the author with a book I bought in Spain; they had ebooks so I bought this one. The process was so convoluted and annoying (and only worked on Windows which I don't have here) (also; I am a technical person/programmer; how is a 'normal' person supposed to do this?) that I definitely won't buy again from them. I think unlike the author though, I was not attempting to remove the DRM; the process of getting to read the book with DRM was many steps (downloading adobe crap, etc) and the endresult was something with DRM that could be opened in another Adobe program but no-where else. The most annoying part is books 'disappearing' or becoming unreadable like what happens on Amazon; like there are books that I bought which are limited to n devices (all mine and my account!) or they just suddenly cannot be read anymore (and cannot be downloaded again). What else can I do then just download illegally?
- bredren 6y agoI buy ebooks largely out of convenience. I’ll be laying in bed and want to continue the The Witcher. There are plenty of pirated copies of this but I’m not going to trouble myself so I just buy this thing I’ll spend weeks falling asleep in front of. Occasionally I’ll try to get something from the library but it has a seven week waiting time on it. Forget it. I buy that then also. Sometimes I want to remove the DRM from something, I buy a fair amount of ebooks I should be allowed to make this call. In the past I’ve used caliber to do this. Unfortunately the DeDRM plugin is broken on Catalina. As far as I can tell you have to boot macOS into safe mode and disable SIP to get it working. The eBook market kinda sucks. Not every book is available, for example a friend and I wanted to read Inca Gold as sort of a joke together. He bought the book used in hardcover, this particular novel is not available in the Kindle Store. I clicked the notify publisher they should publish this as an ebook link then I found a copy floating around on the web. The other thing is pricing. eBooks cost much more than regular books and I can not understand why except because it is convenient. Frankly the device is convenient. Not a lot about the systems that support ebooks feels convenient. Even supporting services like Goodreads feel clunky and stale at this point. I largely blame Amazon for half hearted support of kindle. Their flagship device has a micro usb on it.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoI was able to use deDRM with Catalina, that said my SIP is probably disabled (Hackintosh). Thankfully a lot of sellers are selling books without DRM. I just bought a number of political books from Haymarket and Verso and that was the case.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sneak 6y agoI've gone this route for books, music, tv, and movies. Either I buy it without DRM, or I don't buy it. Almost there with spyware, too. Creative Cloud is next on my list to replace.
- dudul 6y agoCan anyone recommend websites where one can buy epubs without DRM? I only know of technical ones like No Starch or Mannings. What about fictions?
- Synaesthesia 6y agoHumble Bundle, independent publishers like Counterpunch books, Haymarket or Verso.
- matt_heimer 6y agohttps://www.libreture.com/bookshops/ https://www.libreture.com/bookshops/
- homarp 6y agoyou don't need the chinese website, you can use github instead... https://github.com/apprenticeharper/DeDRM_tools https://github.com/apprenticeharper/DeDRM_tools
- macspoofing 6y agoYeah. DRM sucks if you want to lend your bought content, or if you're hoping to have it around for long periods of time (e.g. 10 years+). When I buy electronic copies of Xbox games, I'm under no illusion that I will be able to play them in 10-20 years. I see them as long-term rentals. I've made my peace with that because I have an entire library of games, movies and music on media like floppy disks, VHS, cassette tapes, CDs, DVDs, that I never felt the need to use again and are cluttering up my basement. If I get nostalgic about some content, there's always an electronic copy around somewhere on the internet, usually legal and available for a few bucks. Having said that, I do agree with the shitty ergonomics and usability of DRMed content. If someone went out of their way to pay for a book or a movie, they aren't the kind of people to go and pirate that - so don't punish them.
- chrisbennet 6y agoI only "buy" (1) ebooks to read on the plane. You can't practically (2) loan ebooks and I like to share them with my friends. (1) You don't actually buy them, you lease them. (2) For example; Kindle books can only be loaned for 14 days. I guess if you vacationing on the beach, you could probably read it that quickly. Most people only have some weekend or evening time.
- ubermonkey 6y agoI dunno about you, but both my wife and I read books is much less than two weeks most of the time, and we both work full time and have other hobbies.
- fullstop 6y agoNot OP, but my children seem to have a "Kindle Activity Detector" and suddenly want to play whenever I sit down to read. They're only children once, the books can wait. But, hey, I finished Worm and that's about a million words!
- johnchristopher 6y agoI don't understand why someone with such a pedigree feels the need to fake he just learned of DRM ebooks. This is disingenuous and doesn't bring much food for thoughts at the table. Is the outrage porn card being played to garner attention for something else ?
- josephernest 6y agoAre you me? I could have written the exact same blog article! I have the same experience this month, I ended spending hours to be able to use an e-book I bought, and I also finally needed to convert it multiple times, install shady software, etc. I didn't find an online shop meeting these criteria: * really big catalogue (of the size of Fnac.com, etc.) * EPUB with no DRM I also sent an email to the (French) publisher/editor of the book to narrate the awful user-experience. Maybe you can do the same ;) If enough readers contact the publishers to say they won't buy ebook anymore with such a poor user experience, it might help.
- altacc 6y agoYes, pirating media is often easier than buying media that compensates the author and distributor. Didn't we all know that? DRM and other protection instruments are widespread in digital media and I don't think a good answer to this problem has been found yet, which addresses ease of access & use and also adequate compensation to creators. We still want an equivalent to physical ownership of media but that's applying old thinking to a modern technology, so frustration is understandable. Truly owning digital media is increasingly rare concept. Being able to sharing individual media items more so. Typically we merely rent temporary access through a defined ecosystem. I don't know what the answer is, beyond acknowledging the limitations of both physical and digital media and not expecting the best of both worlds to be possible.
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt is essentially a proverbial greed trap the same as the music industry encountered already. They can in fact get more but they need to let go of the impossible first. DRM asks for the product to be viewable to the end user while not being copyable when fundamentally being viewable is being copyable. It is a hint of a fundamentally insane world view.
- clarry 6y ago> Yes, pirating media is often easier than buying media that compensates the author and distributor. Didn't we all know that? We all know that it doesn't have to be that way. > DRM and other protection instruments are widespread in digital media and I don't think a good answer to this problem has been found yet DRM is the easiest of problems to solve: just remove it.
- ImprobableTruth 6y agoAlright, I'm interested: what's your business model that can compete with Z-lib?
- clarry 6y agoTake a look at digital distribution stores for games that give people a fuss-free experience. Access a well organized catalog & help pages, discussion forums, wikis, etc. Keep track of your library, always get latest version, download anytime anywhere in the world from fast servers any number of times. That really made a huge impact on game piracy. Now contrast the experience with something like Zlib.. oh hey: https://i.imgur.com/494nZjd.png https://i.imgur.com/494nZjd.png What a typical "illegal download site" that tries to bombard you with ads, puts a bunch of silly restrictions on you and then starts to nag for money to lift those restrictions.. what a pain.
- tgb 6y agoI bought a ebook from Kobo, having never heard of them before and thinking they'd be the small competitor to Kindle that offers a better experience. (Oops, they're owned by a big conglomerate.) I stupidly bought the ebook using my google account to sign-on. Then to read the book, I had to enter my google account username and password into their app! Their desktop app is clearly an electron-type web-based thing but they don't have an in-browser reader so there's no secure way of letting them do single-sign on. Here's hoping this app I know nothing about didn't steal my password - the only solace being that a desktop app can screw you over regardless if it wants to.
- fredsir 6y agoIf you buy from the kobo store, you can just go to your "library" on the website and download the DRM free files and then use whatever app you want to read the books.
- Crespyl 6y agoIt may have changed, but last time I looked, only some Kobo books are actually DRM free. For the others, if you have a Kobo device, you can download them onto your device and then use a Calibre plugin to extract them as a regular epub. I presume there's a way to do the same with the desktop client, but haven't used it myself. On the whole I've been far more satisfied with Kobo than Amazon, though if the DRM situation ever becomes more onerous I'll stop buying from them. The devices themselves are excellent and pretty easy to tinker with.
- tgb 6y agoSo that's round-about but going to "My Books" (which seems to be their new "library") downloading it gave me a .acsm file which can be opened with Adobe Digital Editions software which will then download the epub. So it works, but surely there's a saner way!! Also note that you can't download the book from the book's page (which only points you toward their app), but only by clicking the dropdown menu on the My Books page. Thanks for pointing me to it!
- 6y ago
- wilwade 6y agoI refused to buy Amazon ebooks when I learned that I didn't own them. I only owned a right to read them (dependent on many legal things). The price of an ebook has so far been the same as the price of a physical book. Considering the resale value of a book is on average about 50% of the original price, the real price of an ebook for the user with this limitation should be ~50% less than the cost of the paper book. (Not taking into account shipping costs, etc...) This became real to me when my aunt died. She had purchased thousands of dollars worth of ebooks. Had she purchased physical books, those books would have been donated or resold. At a loss to the publisher, but a gain to the original purchaser and secondary purchaser. (or estate in this case). Unless I as the purchaser am at least partially compensated for this loss of value by a price decrease, I cannot buy ebooks with a resale limitation.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe resale value of most books is nowhere near 50% of the original price. The more popular the title and the bigger the print run the less it's worth - until you get to remainder mountain title like 50 Shades of Grey, which are literally worthless, except perhaps as fuel for a wood stove. I had a library with thousands (and thousands) of books. When I moved I decided to get rid of many of them, because decluttering. Long story short - by the time you've allowed for post/carriage, listing time, packaging, and so on, you're more likely to be left with 5-10% of the nominal cover price - and that only after endless hours of work. I donated most of mine, and I still got complaints from the local recycling facility that they were worthless because they were "too obscure" (i.e. pop science, math, stats, and such.)
- mr_gibbins 6y agoI went through a phase where I was buying and selling job lots of books in the hope of striking gold (spoiler: you have to go through a LOT of books, and you'll make less than minimum wage). I ended up selling pallets of excess books for pulp - the paper of the books were worth more than the content.
- megameter 6y ago
- judge2020 6y agoI wish ebooks would follow the movie industry with Movies Everywhere and start offering an ebook copy of the physical books you buy. I love the convenience of having things electronic, but having the physical medium is a great backup if/when these services decide to shut down.
- neya 6y agoThis article resonates with me so much. I recently purchased an e-Book on Wiley too. Atleast, the author got an EPUB with DRM in it, which is pretty easy to remove using de-DRM tools (open source). However, what I got from my purchase from Wiley was some stupid proprietary format that requires me to install some crapware called Vitalsource. There is nothing out there that will de-DRM for you and you are forced to install this crapware wherever you intend to read this - be it on your mobile or desktop. I thought ok, no biggie, let me seek a refund ASAP, but Wiley explicitly disallows refunds, probably this is the reason. In their entire website, they refer to these things as "E-Books", but it is anything but. It's a proprietary viewer. There is a small "i" icon next to them in the listings, which I presume they must have added recently that now states these things aren't actually E-Books (in fine print). Clever huh? Either way, I don't understand the point of DRM. People can still make copies if they're determined to, and studies have shown that giving away ebooks actually increases sales. If these sort of publishers go bankrupt, no one will shed a tear. Because, you know, don't fuck your customer maybe?
- andyzweb 6y agoI had a script to de-DRM books from VitalSource. It “printed” each page one at a time to a PDF and then concatenated the individual PDFs into a single file.
- takecarefnd 6y agoYour link has trojan in it!!! ebook-converter-program
- AdmiralAsshat 6y agoI've done every step the author has done, in multiple flavors. I have the Kindle for PC app running under Wine on my Linux laptop, so that I can get ebooks I buy off Amazon decrypted and converted to EPUBs. I have the requisite suite of DeDRM tools and Calibre plugins so that I can strip the DRM off books I buy on my Kobo. At one time I had an Android VM so that I could pull the decryption key out of my Nook app and decrypt those books as well. It's a massive pain in the ass on every front, and I despise having to do it. There is hope on this front, however. People need to understand this. The e-book manufacturers implement DRM at the behest of the publishers. Publishers can also request that the books they sell not be DRM-encumbered. You'll see that listed on the product page. See below: https://www.kobo.com/us/en/ebook/lightspeed-magazine-issue-73-june-2016-people-of-colo-u-r-destroy-science-fiction-special-issue https://www.kobo.com/us/en/ebook/lightspeed-magazine-issue-7... > Download options: EPUB 2 (DRM-Free) Or you may see a note like this on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00ME0TBFE/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_hsch_vapi_tkin_p1_i0 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00ME0TBFE/ref=dbs_a_def_r... > At the Publisher's request, this title is being sold without Digital Rights Management Software (DRM) applied. It's not easy to find books that are DRM-free, but this does show that pressuring the publisher works. I think this is the route to go if we want to make DRM-free books the norm. Pressure the publisher, not the platform.
- justaguyhere 6y agostripping DRM - is this legal? surely there must be some fine print in 2px font size somewhere in the long user agreements that nobody reads?
- AdmiralAsshat 6y agoProbably. So sue me. I'm paying for the books. I simply wish to be allowed to choose what device I use to read the books that I paid for.
- criddell 6y agoAs far as I know, there's no crack for Amazon's KFX format. There is a workaround to download the book in an older format that can be cracked, but when you do so you don't get the newer features that are present only in KFX files. If cracking DRM sounds like a fun project, check out the thread here: https://github.com/apprenticeharper/DeDRM_tools/issues/38 https://github.com/apprenticeharper/DeDRM_tools/issues/38
- gnu 6y agoRelevant: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html
- jccalhoun 6y agoI only buy ebooks that I know I can break the drm on. The first thing I do when I buy a book from amazon is to run it through calibre with dedrm plugin so I know I will always have a drm-free copy.
- zigzaggy 6y agoI buy ebooks because I have intermittent low vision. Large print books worked ok, but the lighting is never right. The ereader has freed me up to read when and where I want to instead of under very specific conditions. I am also think I am sensitive to the "renters economy" issue. I think I preferred owning them, but I'm not sure why. I've had to dispose of books in various ways in the past for running out of space etc. And I have had books lost or stolen, or borrowed and never returned, so many time. Now I can actually read the books I buy regardless of the quality of my vision. I don't have to worry about running out of space or carrying huge heavy boxes. So I don't know if I really don't like the new way or if I'm just resistant to change.
- anotherevan 6y agoVery title of the article has an error. If it has DRM, you're not buying it, you are leasing it. Agree or not with the use of DRM, I object to buttons that say "Buy Now" instead of "Lease Now" on web-sites.
- Turukawa 6y agoI've written two novels, formally published in the UK, self-published in the US. Books available on Amazon, and DRM-free on my website https://gavinchait.com https://gavinchait.com. Both novels were stolen and uploaded to ZLib within the first week of release: https://b-ok.cc/s/gavin%20chait https://b-ok.cc/s/gavin%20chait Here's how I - as author - experienced it: - Within the first week someone buys the book via Amazon using a stolen credit card; - Book is uploaded to ZLib; - I complained to Amazon, raising both the issue of the stolen work and the stolen credit card; - No response from Amazon, although they were quick to reverse the charge (I'm assuming as soon as the card is reported stolen); - I complained to ZLib using their DMCA reporting tool; - ZLib care about as much as Amazon, and my novels are still up. I made it as easy as possible to read my work on my website and pay me direct. I released it as a DRM-free epub for use on any device or platform. You can even buy anonymously. Still doesn't matter. Folks like the OP won't support writers. And, while this won't stop me writing, it makes it impossible to afford to write as often as I'd like. Two years after my second, I'm still trying to save up enough to afford to write my third. Thanks OP.
- rekabis 6y agoSounds like you are employing a reactive, defensive and antagonistic approach to eBook “piracy”. Which puts you into the very position you described - at a loss, angry, and frustrated; instead of fuelling your sales and playing a direct hand in your success. Unfortunately I don’t have the article on hand, but about a year ago I ran across a description of how an author _dramatically enhanced_ his sales by leveraging eBook “piracy” in order to drive people to official channels. Yes, he actually released his eBooks for free onto the piracy sites - with a twist: he included the entire first portion (quarter or third, cannot remember) of the book, gave info on where to buy the full copies (with zero recriminations - just the facts!), and then repeated those same early chapters to plump out a fully-sized eBook. He then flooded all the file sharing networks with this copy so as to make it difficult to find legitimately complete copies. The entire first quarter or third was used to get readers heavily enough invested into his novel to _want_ to run out and buy the official copy -- he _justified_ the effort and expenditure to his readers, and they responded (mostly) positively by actually doing so! Granted, there was a lot more to it than that, but this was the basics, and it pushed a lot of people towards not just his eBooks but also his physical sales. And there are probably many other strategies out there as well that utilizes the “piracy” platforms to your benefit instead of leaving you tilting impotently at windmills.
- nils-m-holm 6y agoDRM is ridiculous. I have/had some 20 books on the market, all of them also as ebooks (PDF) and not a single one of them is DRM'ed. I refuse to sell ebooks on Amazon, because their ebook format is not open. This year I will publish my first EPUB book. Also without DRM. However, most authors just don't know and/or don't care. Either because they do not know anything about DRM or because they only care about sales, and with some publishers DRM is not an opt-in. Unfortunately! So, yes, I understand the frustration expressed in the article! Look closely before you buy any ebooks!
- betimsl 6y agoInstead, buy a printer. It's cheap and you can print anything you want, including books. It's much easier to read on paper and with a highlighter, you will annotate and remember much more. This works -- especially -- in a country where you have to wait ages for a book to arrive by post, not to mention silly countries like mine, where you have to pay tax on books.
- framebit 6y agoFWIW, I'm not "buying" ebooks or audiobooks anymore because I found out about the magic of digital access via a library card. This is certainly not a new thing, but since it'd been years since I engaged with the public library it was new to me! I've been tearing through material lately, all through the library app (Libby, which I think is a rebrand of Overdrive), and it's still magic to me that I'm getting all of it for free. Sure, it comes with the normal library restrictions (popular stuff has long hold waits, sometimes tough to find a specific book vs. any book, etc.) but the sheer amount of books available that spark my interest is really cool. I fell out of the habit of reading actual books for awhile, and diving back in has been like reconnecting with a long lost friend.
- octygen 6y agoI'm in the same boat. I do wonder how much author X makes when I borrow his/her ebook or audiobook on Overdrive. Any thoughts from anyone?
- therealdrag0 6y agoMy impression is it's similar to physical books. Libraries buy/rent them per copy and loan them out at an equal rate. So authors should get paid similarly to if a citizen bought it from the store. Except if the library already acquired the book, then them leasing it to you does not give the author any money.
- jiveturkey 6y ago> for free it's not free. You've funded the library (who has to volume license the book) with your taxes. There's a wide gap between "free" and "you've already paid for it, may as well consume it". I have to mention this because people in non-USA countries always talk about "free" healthcare, which isn't.
- mierz00 6y agoThis is something that gets repeated again and again. Yes. People in other countries get that healthcare isn’t actually free. Just that they don’t have to fork out any money at the moment they need it. I promise you, we’re aware that we pay a lot of taxes and those taxes fund things we go on to call free.
- umvi 6y agoWhat a baby. There are only 2 steps: 1. install DeDRM in Calibre[0] 2. Strip DRM from epub [0] https://github.com/apprenticeharper/DeDRM_tools/releases https://github.com/apprenticeharper/DeDRM_tools/releases
- glxxyz 6y agoI don't buy physical books anymore. It's just stuff to get dusty and clutter up the place. Reading on a tablet is great- carry it anywhere, also has search, highlighting, bookmarks etc. I prefer no DRM but I don't complain about the hassle of removing it- I'm too busy reading.
- fortran77 6y agoI stay on the "happy path." I have a Kindle e-paper reader. I buy a book, I can read it. It's probably DRMd. But it doesn't get in my way. I agreed to the price and I know I may or may not be able to read the book 5 or 10 years from now. I accept that. I realize this may not be the experience or purchase model for everyone, but for a large segment of the reading public, it "just works."
- NaOH 6y agoAnyone here who gives away some of their books, consider also the Little Free Library if it’s in your area. https://littlefreelibrary.org/ https://littlefreelibrary.org/ Previous HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8237696 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8237696
- theagilecoder 6y agoI am building an app that enables book exchange based on geographical proximity, think tinder for books. Do you think there is place in the world for such an app ?
- gizzlon 6y agoTL;DR: He doesn't like DRM. Neither do I. Don't support it by buying anything with DRM. There's lot's of ebooks without drm though[1].. so.. you know.. buy those. [1] Especially within technical fields. Also Norwegian ebooks :D
- djsumdog 6y agoI have a lot of Google/Nook/Amazon ebooks that I still need to get around to removing the DRM from. Over the past year I've honestly just started pirating books. I'll try to buy merch off the author's website or support their projects (podcasts, patreon, etc.) so I can contribute something to them if they have such avenues. Kobe has some DRM free books, but not a lot of authors publish there. I'd really like to buy DRM free books. I'd even pay twice as much for them. I started going down the eBook route when I was moving and travelling very minimally, and now I rarely read paper books. I prefer the ebook format, but wish there was a Bandcamp for eBooks.
- rocky1138 6y agoThis is the same experience I get when dealing with companies who have mobile apps but are actually just websites, like Instagram.
- ansible 6y agoI used to really worry about this sort of thing, and would only buy ebooks from vendors like O'Reilly or Baen because they were DRM-free, and I could read them forever. These days, I can't be arsed to worry about any of that. I just buy what I want from where-ever (Google, Amazon, etc.). Why? Convenience of course. Really, how many of these books am I ever going to read again? Tech books in the old days (1990's) would last you a few years at least (my copy of TCP/IP networking from O'Reilly was well-used) but these days? Everything is changing so fast. So I just buy them, enjoy them, and don't worry about having access to them in the future. A few true classics I have purchased multiple hard copies of over the years anyway. If I end up purchasing electronic something for a 2nd time, I might make more effort to ensure continued access.
- chooseaname 6y agoThis was a rabbit hole they needn't traveled into. Buy the DRM version (if that's all they could find), then download a deDRM'd version from the internet. There are plenty of places to do this, Google being one (intitle:index.of blah blah and such).
- Havoc 6y agoAlso one of the reasons I’m gonna take back my old kindle from a family member. You need an old one to break the latest generation of DRM they deployed. The new ones - paper white etc pull the new format off the cloud which is currently unbroken. I definitely want a backup of all that stuff
- namelosw 6y agoI subscribed to O'Reilly Safari and Packt. They provide web pages and mobile apps. Because I don't own the books so it seems I cannot download them, but the apps are not very nice. I would avoid them when I can, so I just use those books as manuals to refer to when I have to read them. On the contrary, I spend quite some money on Manning Publications and Pragprog to buy some PDFs and read through my PDF viewer and I'm pretty happy about it. I know it's not a fair comparison at all, since I didn't buy books from O'Reilly and Packt. But the point is just to illustrate DRM + apps really destroy the experience.
- CtrlShiftI 6y agorelevant XKCD https://xkcd.com/488/ https://xkcd.com/488/
- acomjean 6y agoOReilly had DRM free books to buy. I bought a bunch. But Piracy killed it, so now its subscription service, or available on kindle (I don't use). Some authors seem to have deals to give away their books and sell them at the same time: e.g.: https://www.tidyverse.org/learn/ https://www.tidyverse.org/learn/ I buy some DRM free books from Manning. They put a footer on each page, saying, licensed to: xxxxxxx@yyyyy.com to discourage me from sharing. It doesn't bother me. Manning also seems to be going a sort of subscription route too. They have "live book" where you buy access to parts of books you want with tokens. Its kinda interesting how they're trying to do micropayments. https://www.manning.com/livebook-program https://www.manning.com/livebook-program
- kyleee 6y agoDid piracy really kill OReilly's previous business model? I was sad when they morphed into a weird subscription service
- acomjean 6y agoI can find a specific reference, but it they made a bid deal of being DRM free a decade ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2368560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2368560 If ebook sales where working well, I suspect they wouldn't have gotten rid of them.
- aplusbi 6y agoThey still sell DRM free books, just through other stores like Google Play. The reason they switched to subscriptions was because of the cost of running an ebook store and the low ROI.
- zajio1am 6y agoOr just buy ebooks without DRM. Last time when i bought ebooks, the eshop just offered epub/mobi/pdf for download, directly from browser, with only 'social DRM' (info about buyer on separate page in ebook).
- ashtonkem 6y agoMy opinion on ebooks is entirely driven by weight. I move often, and am usually stuck with the heavier lifting tasks in my household. Books in dead tree format are heavy, and I'd prefer not to move them.
- coliveira 6y agoEbooks are a gimmick. I only buy them if they are deeply discounted (symbolic value). The only books that I pay full price are real paper books that I can read without a computer and keep in my library.
- hi_im_miles 6y agoEbooks are words arranged in a digital document. If that's a "gimmick", then everything is a gimmick.
- yarrel 6y agoI buy them if they are DRM-free. ebooks.com, kobo.com and shashwords.com are good for this, as are Verso.
- srg0 6y agoI bought a book with Adobe DRM once. It was a relatively obscure book, and I wanted to support the author. Downloaded the file. Installed Adobe ebook software. Then something went wrong. I had to uninstall and reinstall Adobe software, and after that I couldn't open my new book anymore. Had to break the DRM. I never bought any other e-book with Adobe DRM again. It was obvious that the user experience was the last thing Adobe cared about. I also avoid Google Play Books. E-books are just one of too many things Google does. IMO Google won't think twice before switching off the service. I do buy some Kindle titles though. At least it works, books are linked to my Amazon account, and Kindle is core business for Amazon. I bet it will stay around longer.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- the_jeremy 6y agoMy preferred way is to pirate everything, and support after the fact, usually by buying copies to give to friends (though more than once it was just "buy the DRM version and never touch it because nothing else was easily available"). I like this because I make sure to support things I enjoy, rather than buying something and finding out it was not as good as the reviews made it out to be. It is a product of my entitlement, sure, but with the wealth of free content available, I can't justify spending money up front anymore.
- nihil75 6y agoI realized when I bought "The Catcher In The Rye" in digital form that I can only buy it once. But I want to buy more copies of "The Catcher In The Rye", Every time I visit Amazon.com I try to buy "The Catcher In The Rye" but it won't let me because I already own "The Catcher In The Rye" and that's a real shame because I really like "The Catcher In The Rye" and want to buy more copies of "The Catcher In The Rye" whenever I see a copy of "The Catcher In The Rye" which I cannot do in digital form.
- giarc 6y agoI've run into the situation where I want to buy an e-reader. I like the Amazon paperwhite product but my public library doesn't support it (they support Kobo). So if I want to get books from the library I need to buy a Kobo.
- pfranz 6y agoMine situation is arguably worse, it varies depending on the book. Some are Kindle compatible, others require Adobe's software, and I believe yet others only support Libby. What's nice is that I'm able to get access to libraries that are a pretty far drive. I can borrow those books without having to drive to one of their libraries.
- projektfu 6y agoThe place where e-books leave me lacking when they have DRM is the ability to loan them or transfer them. It is a lot easier to get a friend to read an important book than to get them to buy it. But I can’t lend the kindle copy, which is the format I can read best.
- pfranz 6y agoIt depends on if it's "allowed" for that specific book, but Amazon has had a system for lending ebooks to friends and family for years. https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=GJUXNRAHSH6LX6FA https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=...
- projektfu 6y agoThat functionality is enabled for about 1 in 20 titles in my collection, and sufficiently well hidden that I can't imagine most people know it exists. E-book publishers don't see the value in lending. Look at how they are clamping down on the number of copies available to libraries. To them, every loaned book is a lost sale.
- pfranz 6y agoI agree it's not widely used and not known about. What surprised me is that I know older family members, who are otherwise fairly technically illiterate, who actively share ebooks using their Kindles. Another older family member, where their local library is very hands on with helping them. They both know way more than I know about what's possible and how to do it. Another, I believe separate program, is family sharing (it's not a loan you can both read it simultaneously). I'm not sure if that's a separate privilege the publishers must opt-into, but I have used it the one time I tried.
- moonbug 6y agoentitled jerk.
- lytefm 6y agoI've had my "no more DRM" experience when my ebook reader crashed on a vacation, required a reset and wouldn't let me read the DRM protected books afterwards. I'm still buying eBooks without DRM. At least in Germany, it's common to only have a watermark instead. DRM on eboos is utter trash, it just makes everyone's life harder but can easily be removed by anyone who puts some effort into installing the required tools.
- pnathan 6y agoI use Calibre to back up my Kindle library periodically. I prefer not contributing to deforestation & pollution via paper. This leaves me with specific niche or historical books to buy in paper form.
- rciorba 6y agoThe Pragmatic Bookshelf https://www.pragprog.com/ https://www.pragprog.com/ deserves a mention, as they're DMR free.
- bitwize 6y agoSorry, but content protections including DRM are the "death and taxes" of the online world. You will have to deal with them one way or another, because without them, authors and creators -- especially small-time ones -- will not be able to make a living doing what they love and so they will stop producing output. Learn to accept DRM, or go without. Anything else is snatching food from the mouths of the children of authors, artists, and musicians.
- hi_im_miles 6y agoI reject that the only way forward is to simply accept rent-seeking behavior and move on. It's unreasonable to expect people to pay for a freely reproducible good, and "doing something" about that implies state surveillance and ultimately violence, which leaves me uncomfortable. Based on my understanding of history, I actually believe it's the perpetuation of this violence that created an underclass who can't afford anything in the first place.
- josteink 6y agoNot buying ebooks at all is a bit drastic. I’d rather just research which sites sells DRM-free (or with easily removed DRM, like Amazon) and stick to those.
- northisup 6y agoHow is the zlibrary not just piracy?
- MintelIE 6y agoEver since Amazon deleted its first books remotely from people's Kindles, I haven't bought any ebooks, digital music downloads, movies aside from on physical media, or software which is downloaded and delivered digitally. I do have numerous shelves in my home devoted to Laserdiscs, vinyl, CD's, tapes, and of course many many books. But I don't have any room for media which I don't physically own, nor media which can be taken away as easily as I can download it.
- poletopole 6y agoThis is why I bought a SV600. Very few platforms or publishers except for example No Starch Press allow you to buy a PDF anymore.
- theonlybutlet 6y agoI had this exact same discovery/dilemma 3/4 months ago. My windows partition stopped working now so don't think I'm going down that road to buy a book again. The Adobe digital editions hassle just really isn't worth it.
- tamaharbor 6y agoYou work for twenty-some years writing your perfect novel and then some scumbag pirates it, cracks it, and makes it available to everyone for free? That sounds reasonable.
- jonahbenton 6y agoEveryone writing about what they think and what they did about it. I think authors should get paid, and I should have free use over the artifact. So I wired together some machinery to take a downloaded Kindle file, turn it into a PDF (using the underlying Calibre tooling), and send that to my Remarkable tablet. I should make it available, think it would be useful to others (under terms that the PDFs are for personal use only- authors need to get paid).
- samclearman 6y agohttps://medium.com/@samclearman/stop-paying-for-e-books-and-start-stealing-them-efb293e9a64c https://medium.com/@samclearman/stop-paying-for-e-books-and-...
- Pxtl 6y agoFor the record: HumbleBundle frequently does eBook bundles. Obviously that's niche - generally comics, programming books, stuff like that, and you're just buying a bundle and not getting to peruse a library. However, all their ebooks are DRM-free. I've bought into a few ebook kickstarters, and the books came in open files visibly watermarked with my KS email address. That seems a reasonable approach. For KS, from the author's perspective this is ultra-high-risk. Their book isn't even on store shelves yet, and yet they're selling DRM-unencumbered copies. Meanwhile if I want to buy a 60-year-old book that's obviously available on every pirate site, the seller will still foist DRM onto me. So I think we're getting there. There are new businesses working with DRM-free ebooks, since the encumbered ones are basically pirated instantly anyways.
- pjettter 6y agoGet burned once... When you pet a snake and get bitten, you don't pet snakes anymore. But since you already were afraid of snakes (who isn't), you don't have to test petting it to find out it bites. So the author doesn't have the eBook instinct. e-book. In other words: "electrified book", "less of a book", "not a real book". Then, he's not using standard tested consumer channels like Amazon Kindle etc, so then he's on his own. He doesn't need to brag about having to set up a VM and going to darknet to hire a Korean hacker gang and buying a DM cracking botnet to crack DRM. He was just being cheap.
- mark_l_watson 6y agoI understand the sentiment. When I buy a book now I first decide if I will ever want to loan it to someone, and if yes, then I buy a physical book. For the books I write I now only sell eBooks but under a Creative Commons Share and Share Alike license and I encourage people to share with friends. Writing books is a lot of work and I want them to be widely available. Then, you may ask, why not just put PDFs in the public domain? The answer is that I do enjoy getting some revenue from writing, so it is a compromise.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoSwitched to Spotify and Netflix when they became available in my country as pirating the content I wanted just took too much effort.
- wilt 6y agoI have a heap of ebooks i got from amazon and find I need to break the drm and convert them to pdf just to read them on my kindle. Really hate the situation on one hand I want to support the author but I don't want to support amazon for the bs that doesn't work.
- lstodd 6y agoIt's 2020 and we're for some reason discussing DRM. It was repeatedly shown for the last 20+ years that DRM can not work, is detrimental for sales, author popularity and income. Late Jim Baen of baen.com realized that in 1999 and since then sold DRM-free multiformat books with usually first 1/3 to 1/2 of the text available free. And it works just fine since then.