7 ms·
The lawsuits around this are going to be amazing. African American developer has kids and moves to Georgia to be near family; receives steep pay cut compared to
by rayiner 6y ago
The lawsuits around this are going to be amazing. African American developer has kids and moves to Georgia to be near family; receives steep pay cut compared to white developers who move to Connecticut to do the same.
And how does Facebook decide what the cost of living in your area is, anyway? The more data-driven Facebook makes that calculation, the more delicious the law suit gets. For example, DC is a fairly high cost of living Metro area, but there are some nice suburbs in PG County 30-45 minutes east of the city that are quite affordable. They’re also predominantly African American. Does Facebook set your salary based on living in the DC metro area, or do they drill down further and cut your pay for living in PG County? I can’t wait to see what happens.
- enitihas 6y agoAnd how exactly is that different than the current low salaries in Georgia compared to Connecticut?
- wtfno009887466 6y agoSince we pretend there's no class divide in America we've got to use the tools we have to combat economic injustice.
- lykr0n 6y ago> The lawsuits around this are going to be amazing. No. They won't. This isn't anything new. GitLab as a company does this. My company does this. US Federal Government does this. It's not controversial. HN is the one making it controversial. YOU are making it controversial by bringing race into it. If you have clear salary bands ("SWE III makes base 100k to 150k") and clear location bands ("NYC is 35%, Westchester County is 29%, Monroe County is 8%) then it's completely fair. > And how does Facebook decide what the cost of living in your area is, anyway? You could use the same scales the US Federal Government releases. You could base it on the average cost of living. Lots of data-points. Every state and local government collects this data for various reasons. Hell, Walmart and other large Grocery Stores most likely do this as well to localize prices properly.
- Craighead 6y agoRace is always in it and always has been in it. YOU have decided to use that as a counter argument with zero evidence.
- Joof 6y agoWhat does your company do if the employee is entirely Nomadic? Officially I live somewhere, but I never go there.
- lykr0n 6y agoLegal Address? It's a good question. Who knows, with modern technology it could be updated daily. ... I shuttered at that thought.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoYour place of domicile (a tax and legal concept) cannot be updated daily.
- IggleSniggle 6y agoHow frequently can it be updated?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI moved from PA to NM last year. From PA's perspective, PA remains your domicile until you take steps to permanently establish a new residence somewhere else. Other states may or may not take the same position. Those steps include, but are not limited to: buying/renting property as a primary residence, registering a car, registering to vote.
- wiseleo 6y agoShould it be updated? South Dakota lets you establish tax domicile with no state income tax instantly. You need to show a receipt from a hotel or campground that you spent a night in the state. You also get a new driver's license and open a bank account. That's it. What stops me from setting up a remote workstation in SD, logging into work through VPN from there, and living wherever I want? :) Once the pandemic lessens, I am switching my domicile from California to SD and semi-retiring away from Bay Area. I will have a legal presence and a computer in that area, but I will not live there. There could be a business opportunity in setting up remote workstations in high rent areas to comply with these requirements.
- selimthegrim 6y agoSo is this the salary and redlining counterpart of the BoJack episode where they finally decide how to fix the gun and drug problem in America?
- cortesoft 6y agoIt's not actually based on CoL... it is based on comparable salaries in the area (which of course is highly correlated with cost of living). The distinction is important, though; they pay the salary that gets a worker to stay and not go to another company that will hire them.
- gamblor956 6y agoCompanies, and many agencies in the federal government, already do this.. As long as the same policy would equally apply to all races, there is nothing wrong with making COL or salary adjustments based on where an employee moves.
- 25mph 6y agoIt's not like these companies are dumb. They'll factor the diversity coordinate into their equation.
- tzs 6y agoThe rational way to do this would be for Facebook to take into account COL when setting salary for non-remote work, and to not take it into account when setting salary for remote work. Why? Because if they are specifically trying to fill a spot in Menlo Park they are going to have to pay enough to attract people who live within commuting distance of Menlo Park. If they are trying to fill a Seattle spot they need to pay enough to attract Seattle workers. And so on. If they are trying to fill a remote spot then they should be largely indifferent to where that person lives. For remote work they only need to set pay high enough to get the number of people they want from the entire country. If they set remote pay at a level that makes them attractive to people in Georgia but not to people in Connecticut, and at that level they can find all the remote workers they want, why should they care that Connecticut engineers aren't applying for remote Facebook jobs?
- rayiner 6y agoYes this makes total sense to me. The pay bump in SF is to get sufficient good people in SF, which the company cares about because it has an office there and needs local people. That rationale evaporates for remote work.
- hedora 6y agoIt would be interesting if they also figured in the cost of providing office space, food, etc when recomputing remote workers’ pay. The rule of thumb I’ve heard is that workers cost about 2x their salaries, with the additional money going to HR, taxes, IT, morale budgets and facilities. Facilities is the biggest of those costs. (This completely ignores stock based compensation.)
- esoterica 6y ago> If they set remote pay at a level that makes them attractive to people in Georgia but not to people in Connecticut, and at that level they can find all the remote workers they want, why should they care that Connecticut engineers aren't applying for remote Facebook jobs? Presumably because there are not enough people in Georgia alone who meet their hiring bar to fulfill their staffing needs. So they also need to hire people in HCOL areas with better competing offers and more leverage to demand more money from them.
- im3w1l 6y agoHonestly my whole life I have basically been rolling my eyes whenever people complain of discrimination. "Why would a company pay more for less? They'd be eaten alive by competitors that don't". But here we have the whole industry saying they are gonna pay people less based on nothing more than living in black neighbourhoods. And gloating about how people don't have negotiating leverage. It's making me rethink a lot of things.
- air7 6y agoI do the same type of eye roll and I think it still applies here. Unless "the whole industry" create a salary cartel, the free market will adjust for this salary imbalance quickly. If there's a guy living in a black neighborhood that does the same job as a guy from a white neighborhood but for less, who would you hire? So will everyone, and the salaries will eventually match. This is even more true in a world of mostly-remote workers where social interactions are reduced.
- throwaway4715 6y agoNah. Pay is, and will continue to be, based on market rate. If they offer you 150k in Georgia and that's near top of market for your skill level, even though if you were in SV you'd make 250k, then you're still being paid well. No discrimination. If they offered a black person 150k and a white person 250k for the same job in the same place, that's discrimination.