15 ms·
California affordable housing is more expensive than luxury housing
- client4 6y agohttp://archive.is/J8tpy http://archive.is/J8tpy
- standardUser 6y ago"...and rules that compel developers to meet labor and environmental standards that often exceed what’s required for luxury condominiums." It's not just rules. Funding is competitive, and if you want a competitive bid you need to promise the world. Parking, green technologies, accessibility, community space, lots of amenities for residents, landscaping, not to mention the cost of ongoing compliance. "Another is California’s labyrinthine financing process, which forces developers to navigate a dozen different funding programs controlled by five separate departments with authority divided between the governor and state treasurer." Having worked in the industry for 10 years, I'd say this is an understatement. There's also federal, local and county regulations in addition to the multi-tentacled state system.
- downerending 6y agoOuch. Maybe CA should just give up on housing and have everyone commute in daily from a different state.
- mgolawala 6y agoThis is so depressing to see. These are the symptoms of a system slowly grinding to a halt under its own weight. Compare the tax code in 1970 (or earlier) vs today (1). Regulations and laws keep getting more and more complex. It keeps getting slower and costlier to get anything done. Then throw in the aging infrastructure, the greater wealth inequality along with significantly decreased social mobility. Un-affordable healthcare and education costs that cripple you before you can even begin to walk. Completely un-affordable housing after that, or a ridiculous commute without decent public transport. No wonder our political system looks as bad as it does.. people are getting increasingly angrier, more polarized, more frustrated, more desperate. There is such inertia to these 'systems' that it takes overwhelming effort and sacrifice to change its course. These problems don't seem to be getting solved, they seem to be getting worse. How do you realistically reverse something like this? Are there examples of a successful reversal having been made without hitting the dreaded 'reboot' button on society? We will probably muddle along during our lifetimes, but I fear for my children's generation. (1) https://taxfoundation.org/how-many-words-are-tax-code/ https://taxfoundation.org/how-many-words-are-tax-code/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ageitgey 6y agoI sold a piece of software to the state of California once. Among the 100+ page contract was a page where we had to agree that if, during the installation of this web app, a baby was to be abandoned, that we promise that we would abandon said baby at an approved fire station within 3 days of birth. That was probably 10+ years ago, but it was a real eye opening moment in seeing the mindless wheels of bureaucracy turn. Obviously everyone at every stage of the procurement process knew this page of the contract was insane in the context of installing a simple web app, but no one had the power remove unneeded rules in situations in which they don't apply and no one is going out on an anti-baby-safety ledge. So everyone for the rest of time has to agree on how to properly abandon babies in every contract.
- gizmo686 6y agoThrough my employer, I do work on an open source application. At one point a 3 letter agency contracted us to add some functionality that they needed. Of the developers at the company who work on said application, I happened to be the one picked to work on these features. Eventually, someone actually read the contract and noticed that it required anyone working on it to have a security clearance. I ended up working on other parts of the same open source application that were being funded by a contract without such a clause, so we could have someone with a clearance charge the contract.
- milesvp 6y agoI read an article last year talking about reboot cities/regions. They mentioned places like hong kong, shenzhen, silicon valley, dubai and similar places throughout history where they are given a status that allows for more freedom than surrounding areas usually with less regulation. The thesis was that these areas are essential for making big progress in science or engineering or business , and that they were sort of a double shot in that not only do they have fewer restrictions, but they also attract people who want to accomplish things. These regions never last forever, but really spark kind of a punctuated equilibrium sort of environment for a generation or two. I’d love to see each state support a city like this. But it can be tricky to balance, especially if it sounds unfair to the rest of the populace. Also, it would require separate governmental systems that could lead to all kinds of problems. As it is the US was set up initially to allow for easier variation among the states to get some of these benefits. But it can be nearly impossible not to end up with similar regulations over time. You even see it within corporations too with similar corporate policies as scar tissue from similar problems they all experience.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 6y agoI'm still sbuurprised at how many people think we don't have buildings because of NIMBY residents, or because of lack of space. Our building issue is entirely self-inflicted. Do most people even know what it takes to remove an ordinance tree on your property? There's red tape EVERYWHERE, and special interest has made sure that their pet issues have considerations along each step of the way.
- ab_testing 6y agoThe bullshit and nimbyism in California is truly breathtaking. That happened in the wealthy San Diego County enclave of Solana Beach, where the Pearl was cut from 18 apartments to 10 and its approval required an underground garage with 53 parking spots.
- Lammy 6y agoIt makes a lot more sense when you realize the entire "environmental movement" arose as the justifiable/defensible workaround for the Fair Housing Act in 1968: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=environmentalist%2Cenvironmentalism%2C%22civil+rights%22%2C%22local+control%22&year_start=1800&year_end=2008&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t1%3B%2Cenvironmentalist%3B%2Cc0%3B.t1%3B%2Cenvironmentalism%3B%2Cc0%3B.t1%3B%2C%22%20civil%20rights%20%22%3B%2Cc0%3B.t1%3B%2C%22%20local%20control%20%22%3B%2Cc0 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=environmentali... e: I can't get the direct link to work properly, but press the blue "Search lots of books" button and it will work.
- riazrizvi 6y agoIn 1968 the number of books on 'environment movement' here rockets up. It will be more compelling if there is a link between events related to housing regulations and the other massive upswing in 1985, and then the downswing in 1997.
- chucksmash 6y agoLinking to a ngrams graph that shows "environmentalism" graphed against "civil rights" as evidence that environmentalism is just a fig leaf for segregation is beyond flimsy. Surely this must be the arch example of correlation ≠ causation.
- Lammy 6y agoOf course there's so much more to it, but there isn't really a single source I can link you that makes this argument. One example I can easily show is the history of planned freeways in the Bay Area that were canceled due to environmental concerns. Take a look at what areas the canceled freeways would have connected, then take a look at the demographics of those areas. Notice in particular how no freeway (or rail!) connection to the Golden Gate was ever allowed, since that would have connected Marin to the Bay Area megalopolis. https://www.kurumi.com/roads/3di/sanfran.html https://www.kurumi.com/roads/3di/sanfran.html http://www.radicalcartography.net/index.html?bayarea http://www.radicalcartography.net/index.html?bayarea
- virgilp 6y ago> Pearl was cut from 18 apartments to 10 and its approval required an underground garage with 53 parking spots. How did it ever get here? Requiring more than 2 parking spots per apartment is insane.... especially for "affordable housing".
- kevingadd 6y agoLow-income families often pack many people into a small apartment, so it's not unrealistic for one apartment to need 3 parking spots for two working parents and a working child, just as an example. I lived in a household like that growing up
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoOR decent mass transit. But forget that in California.
- xvedejas 6y agoNow, I'll grant it's only very specific corridors, but the densest parts of California do have passable mass transit. The majority of Californians don't have access to this, but the most crowded parts do.
- twblalock 6y agoMass transit exists but it's really bad -- e.g. Muni and BART and Caltrain in the San Francisco area. Constant delays, mechanical failures, and overcrowding. Now that Coronavirus and social distancing are the new normal, I expect some of those transit systems to lose funding and perhaps even shut down. I'm a huge fan of public transit and I'd love to see good transit systems exist in California, but I have no hope that it will happen.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoBART! I used it once just to see how it went. A cross between a cattle car and a shipping container. Unbearably noisy and dirty. Reminded me of the public transit in Gotham when Bruce Wayne returned.
- kwillets 6y agoAmongst the various human rights, the right to build a house should be fundamental, but somehow it was lost to political forces.
- bbeekley 6y agoHousing seems to me to be one of the most government-planned markets due to the strict zoning laws, but I've only seen fairly lefty orgs advocating for relaxed regulation. I'm surprised there isn't more movement from libertarians along the lines that property owners should have more rights for what they can build on their land.
- dugmartin 6y agoI think the libertarians are worried that their next door neighbor will drag in a trailer. Ideals are one thing, property values are another. Around here we have a lot of open space advocates that don't want any development (even though we are losing population and in a generation won't be able to fund our schools). I've often wanted to ask one of those folks (normally older with a nice older home) if they are so invested in open space why don't they knock down their house?
- CameronNemo 6y ago>why don't they knock down their house? You kid, but redevelopment of less productive buildings is a pretty important part of preserving open space.
- sokoloff 6y agoSome libertarians are presumably also in support of "you spent money buying land and a house in an area with full awareness of a specific framework of zoning laws and those laws should not be changed without good cause and due process". (Libertarians are not necessarily and are often not anarchists.)
- kwillets 6y ago
- subsubzero 6y agoWhat can't be discounted besides the usual suspects of bad zoning, high cost of land etc. is construction costs. Basically an area gets so expensive that it prices out construction workers and their families. This is being seen in the bay area now as a typical single family home goes for over 1M in the pennisula/SF/South Bay area. Go farther out to the east bay, far south bay(gilroy etc) and prices are still 700/800k+. The need for housing is so great but also it is a vicious feedback loop of ever increasing construction costs to build this housing. For LA/San Diego area it is rather large so more affordable housing can be found but overall it is still extremely expensive compared to the rest of America.
- JamesBarney 6y agoThis seems reasonable but I don't think it's a significant contributor to the price of construction. None of the developers seem to mention it as an issue, and there are plenty of employees that exist in San Francisco that are paid wages that are similar to construction workers.
- pchristensen 6y agoBut there are marginal projects that don't get built because of the higher cost of construction labor. With shortages like the Bay Area, every bit lost, for any reason, hurts.
- JamesBarney 6y agoIs it true that if the labor rates in San Francisco were lower you would have more buildings 100% agreed. But its like your business is setting money on fire to keep the building warm. Could you use a regular unleaded instead of premium gasoline? Sure. Would it be better for the business? Yes at the margin. Should you spend any time deciding what is the cheapest gasoline to use to set money on fire? Not until you decide to use something besides $10 bills as fuel.
- Gibbon1 6y agoI can ask my friend again who worked on public housing projects ten years ago. But one thing I remember her saying is California is really leery of shoddy construction and the resulting blight. And blighted low income housing is a big big political problem. So low income housing has to be built to take a lot of abuse. Which of course $$$.
- sambull 6y agoNo new house around me was sub 1500 sq ft... guess bigger is better. But all the other houses in the area built between 1950-1990 were all under that.
- Ididntdothis 6y agoI would be perfectly fine with 800-1000 sqft and little yard but nobody builds this anymore. And if you have a basement for storage you need less garage too. Why do US houses rarely have usable basements?
- three_seagrass 6y agoNot saying this applies to everything, but the houses I lived in without usable basements were close to the water line, which would have made a full-sized basement a liability for the house.
- CameronNemo 6y agoBasements do not react well to earthquakes either.
- nitrogen 6y agoI'd also imagine that excavation is more expensive than just pouring a concrete slab.
- xur17 6y agoI think it depends on the area - pretty much every house in my local market has a basement.
- mullingitover 6y agoIt depends on where you live. If you live in a place where the ground freezes in the winter, you must build your foundation deep enough below ground or your foundation will go to hell the first winter after you build it. So in large areas of the midwest, for example, pretty much every house has a basement. In places where the ground doesn't freeze, most people skip the expense of excavating a basement.
- vmception 6y agoOne thing I've found is that it isn't worth it to "win" and be able to afford living in these places, because nobody else can. In expensive neighborhoods there are good connections from neighbors, but right now - and I have no way to quantify this - it seems like that doesn't apply to places that now become expensive. People with connections are just part of a different generation and live in already wealthy neighborhoods. The up and coming trendy neighborhood don't have the connected's trust fund children nor a bunch of VCs. Only airbnb speculators, transient corporate housing and some TikTok influencers chasing status. Everyone has been resigned to imagining their dreams of certain zip codes, and just doing something else that happens to be way more practical. If you actually get into those zip codes, nobody else is there. So doing extra things for the goal of keeping up against all odds seems to be a fools errand, for housing location at least. Other fun things you can do with your net worth.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Medicalidiot 6y agoHow do y'all think this nationwide housing crisis will precipitate?
- qppo 6y agoI'm doing my part to extract as much wealth as I can from my Bay Area salary to buy a home somewhere else. Anyone else doing the same? It would be financially irresponsible to buy property here even if I could afford it.
- Antecedent 6y agoWhy don’t we just make the poor people move? Once they leave to more rural areas, wages will rise from there being fewer laborers balancing everything out.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.md/J8tpy https://archive.md/J8tpy
- nerfhammer 6y agoyou can also confuse the paywall by putting an extra dot after the .com
- r0m4n0 6y agoHonestly I ran into partially related situation in NYC. I found a 1-bed apartment I liked at a nicer building, I decided to proceed and next thing you know I'm signing the lease. I read the lease and says a few very peculiar things: 1) the rent is 50% higher than what I saw being advertised/communicated 2) there is a massive discount that brings the rent down to what we agreed to on a separate page 3) this turned out to be a rent stabilized building so my rent is protected under rent control and I was informed I have more rights about increased rent After some more thought I realize building management has been increasing the rent at the government regulated percentage every year behind the scenes and sometimes the market was relatively flat, they continued to raise the actual rent providing discounts, 10 years later they are giving a massive discount so that it actually meets the market demand. Later on they have full control on raising rent as often as to basically whatever price they want. Something about the whole thing seems like this isn't what rent stabilization was for...
- ver_ture 6y agoSo this is saying that you are "agreeing" to the full price, allowing them to one day charge you that full price? (While hooking you in with the 50% discount?)
- currymj 6y agothey can't just arbitrarily jack up the rent during the term of the lease. but they might when you try to renew the lease, or when you move out. the effect is as if there is no rent stabilization (unless market rents go up above $4000 a month or whatever the "official" number is.)
- gotoeleven 6y agoThe answer is clearly one more regulation to fix the loopholes in this regulation.
- wan23 6y agoThis was sort of fixed last year. https://streeteasy.com/blog/preferential-rent-nyc-new-laws-nix/ https://streeteasy.com/blog/preferential-rent-nyc-new-laws-n...
- pascalxus 6y agoI know this will be downvoted because people aren't really interested in solving the real problem. We could fix the whole SF homeless population problem in the space of one parking lot. Just build micro apartments of 10'x10' feet. Make it 150' wide at the base: 15x15 = 225 x 40 stories = 9000 inhabitants. 100' feet might not be much, but it's a hella of a lot more space to live in than hong kong, where people barely get one bed. And, with SF's enormous homeless budget of over 300 million, combined almost over 500m? there'd be more then enough funds to build as many of these buildings as we need. The thing that stops these types of solution is rules, rules and more rules. We choose not to solve the homeless situation: it's a political choice.
- jayd16 6y agoI'm not sure building a ghetto is the right answer. Whats stopping anyone from claiming a 10x10? Can I claim one? You're grossly oversimplifying the issue.
- pascalxus 6y agoThe first 10K or so units would be for the homeless. But, after that you can rent them out for some small amount to anyone that needs it. Just imagine, if you're homeless and it's raining. What would you prefer? live in the streets or live in a small micro apartment? Sure, not everyone wants one, but why not give people more choices? Right now, your only choices are this: 2 million dollar condo or 20$ tent under a bridge. Let's give people more options?
- jayd16 6y agoYou're hand waiving a lot here. Means testing is complex and a 10x10 in SF is valuable enough to bring a lot of bad actors. I'm pointing out that its not as simple as building a 10k occupant building.
- asdff 6y agoHow is this a ghetto? This is housing that is more spacious than my dorm room. The current situation is accepting a ghetto to exist on the sidewalks where there is no plumbing or services or shelter or a lock or any semblance of safety.
- pavlov 6y agoAfter moving to America a while ago, one thing that struck me is how a lot of things are designed as effectively regressive taxes: the poor pay more than the rich. I opened a basic bank account with a giant American bank. The account has an exorbitant monthly fee, something like $15, but it’s waived if you keep a sufficient balance or have a steady salary. So the only people who pay the crazy fee are the broke people with irregular income. This is one example out of many such seemingly structural biases in everyday services.
- stevehawk 6y agoYea, don't do business with that bank. Not all banks do that.
- HighlandSpring 6y agoNo single bank should do that.
- idoh 6y agoBanks are businesses, why can't they charge what they want for services?
- beambot 6y agoAnd the dark patterns of opening accounts without your permission, burying fee information in the fine print, etc etc...? It's not just business; it's predatory.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoUnless every bank is opening up accounts with permission, I don't see how your comment is relevant.
- refurb 6y agoNow you're onto a different topic - we're talking about charging fees on accounts.
- renewiltord 6y agoHaha, most government money projects in California are a mechanism to funnel tax money into chosen pockets. The interests in play encourage that because: * Most Californians don't like other people living near them. They want to live like in the suburbs and it annoys them if that changes. * They can fig leaf in 'environmentalism' or 'traffic' or whatever in order to do that. Sometimes they'll fig leaf in 'gentrification' and 'affordability'. * They want to be able to complain about government spending but not really do anything about it. The best part is that this allows you almost all the real benefits of actually having government spending change: you still get the funneling, and you get all the social value of being against overspending. * The last thing is that Americans as a whole hate being told they've been defrauded. It's like the worst thing in the world to be a sucker here. So the right response is always to pretend like you aren't being suckered. That's crucial. You can always choose to say things like "San Francisco is built upon 150 years of shipwrecks" or "America is a big country" or "California is diverse". My hope is one day to embed myself in enterprise sales to government. It's the good life.
- jayd16 6y agoIt might be an unpopular opinion but considering the current pandemic I'm glad California is not as dense as it could be.
- supernova87a 6y agoOne thing I would really like a clear explanation of: When public officials in CA cities talk about "affordable housing", there is actually some definition of this, isn't there? And it doesn't usually match what people in casual conversation mean by affordable housing, right? "Affordable housing" doesn't just mean a normal house or apartment at an affordable price, does it? Does it mean public housing units built and managed by the city? Or it means housing built by private developers, that's only available for renting or ownership by people meeting certain criteria? If "affordable housing" means public housing complexes, then I think people voting or advocating for it don't really understand what they're getting into. Because those don't really have a great track record of success.
- z3ncyberpunk 6y agoSure, it means the cheapest option... Like "genuine leather".
- pchristensen 6y ago"Affordable" can mean a lot of things. Usually the official definition is housing that costs less than 30% of the income of someone at some multiple of the local poverty income level. Housing can meet that bar in a number of ways: rising incomes, smaller/less equipped units, no parking, public subsidy for rent, public subsidy for land or development fees, etc. Due to the terrible experience with public housing across the USA in the 1950s-1980s, most governments avoid owning the units if they can avoid it.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIt's a means-tested govt program for below-market rate apartments, with tons of red tape. Which in true government fashion exacerbates the problem it is meant to solve.
- kwillets 6y agoRight now there's the colloquial meaning, and a proper noun which means taking 10-30% of housing output and selling it at a government-set price to government-approved people.
- tru3_power 6y agoMan this hits deep. I moved out to Southern California a few years ago from the south east. It’s crazy, I can barely afford to buy a house here with a 300k/yr income. Even then it’s gonna be some non remodeled, in need of upgrades 700k home. To get anything decent (new kitchen, windows, working hvac) it’s at-least 900k+. I don’t get how people are buying these homes.
- xnyan 6y agoHelp me understand. An average mortgage is 200k, at the average household income of 63k and a 30 year at 4.1%, thats 18.5% of your pretax income going into a mortgage. The same numbers for a 300k income and a 700k house works out to 13.5%. Seems like you are doing significant better than most? Happy to be corrected.
- missedthecue 6y agoYeah I'm not sure what he's talking about either. $900k home on $300k income is entirely reasonable and a better ratio than what the average person does
- mistrial9 6y agono employee making $300k per year in California gets to keep that amount.. tax rate is 40% + overall last I heard, differing slightly by county and tax details
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI’m not sure what part about a a 900k house inflated due to NIMBYism and stupid policy choices is reasonable. If OP feels the main entering the bottom of the market with their exorbitant salary, imagine how the the average person feels.
- ak217 6y agoThey might be able to afford a house, but the community around them will not (the average household income in San Diego is around 100K, not 300K). By pricing out young people and stunting their communities, California NIMBYs reduce opportunity and social mobility. The ultimate result of the totality of California housing policies is that California senior homeowners transfer resources from the rest of society to themselves while reducing quality of life for everyone else.
- aSplash0fDerp 6y agoUnless you have a stake in the "exotic investment schemes", you missed the boat on selling out a generation. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=HzSAmOQuyjU https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=HzSAmOQuyjU We can replace New Zealand with the US, Canada, UK and Austrailia and the story is almost exactly the same (even the bad actors are consistent). Take the money and run (now that WFH/WFA has gained ground). Running in place financially does not build character, contrary to popular belief.
- kragen 6y agoUS $414,000 per apartment was the original bid? Something has gone terribly wrong with your civilization. — ⁂ — I think about the Isla Maciel slums where I used to volunteer. They're on the outskirts of Buenos Aires, and although I'm not familiar with any official statistics, I think the average daily income is under a dollar per person per day, with significant variation above and below that level. Some of the roads are dirt while others are paved, and the buildings are mostly somewhat ramshackle houses made of hollow brick with corrugated iron roofs. It's sort of similar to some of the neighborhoods I lived in as a kid in the US before I moved into a trailer park. Despite this astonishing level of income, there is no homelessness (though there is elsewhere in Buenos Aires), and almost nobody rents. This is because people build their own houses. The most common material is hollow ceramic brick, the kind that's a latticework of thin red-clay walls; you have to scavenge or buy these https://articulo.mercadolibre.com.ar/MLA-821163523-ladrillo-hueco-12x18x33-9-tubos-pallet-144-unidades-zona-sur-_JM?quantity=1#position=13&type=item&tracking_id=9848aa63-e0a0-4f35-a558-f9709cb9ac9e https://articulo.mercadolibre.com.ar/MLA-821163523-ladrillo-... at a cost of about AR$6000 (US$50) per pallet of 144 bricks, which works out to about 35¢ per brick. The poorest people instead build with wood, like people in the US. (We haven't had an earthquake here during human habitation.) If you do the figures, you can see that a generous 7 m × 3 m wall contains about US$130 worth of bricks, plus a smaller and cheaper amount of sand and cement. You can build a 49 m² house from four of these walls (US$520) plus 49 m² of corrugated steel, which if you have to buy it https://articulo.mercadolibre.com.ar/MLA-799438818-chapa-acanalada-galvanizada-c30-por-6-metros-_JM?variation=40260420703#position=10&type=item&tracking_id=df5f6081-993b-4eff-a37e-abbf02e1f477 https://articulo.mercadolibre.com.ar/MLA-799438818-chapa-aca... is about AR$24000 (US$200). Putting these parts together into an actual building envelope typically takes a semi-skilled laborer a week or two, and most people either do it themselves or have their sons, boyfriends, or husbands do it, since they don't have any money to hire someone else. Adding a toilet, a sink, a bidet (we are not barbarians, after all), some PVC pipes for water and sewer, and a kind of shitty electrical installation (hopefully with at least a circuit breaker) might bring the total out-of-pocket cost close to US$1000. You might note that US$1000 is significantly less than US$414000. Now, Isla Maciel is a dangerous place. Everyone has lost family members either to gang violence or to police violence. I wouldn't advise visiting without knowing anybody there any more than I'd advise trying to visit the US without a visa; people there laugh about the stories of the tourists who mistakenly wandered into their neighborhood and got robbed. I'm not holding it up as an ideal of human civilization. But I'd much rather have a house in Isla Maciel than a park bench in Los Angeles or a rat-infested motel room in Solana Beach. And I don't think the violence there is a result of a lack of enforcement of building codes, as someone will no doubt attempt to argue in response to this comment. Rather, both the insecurity and the freedom to build your own house result from the lawlessness of the neighborhood, which in turn proceeds from a general feeling that the law establishes oppression rather than justice — a proposition with ample empirical support within the confines of Isla Maciel, in my view, as well as other similar slums in Buenos Aires. This in turn undermines officially recognized systems of land tenure, with the consequence that residents of Isla Maciel can often claim land by building on it, if that doesn't piss off the neighbors too badly. — ⁂ — How much would building such a house in the US cost, if it were somehow allowed? Let's suppose the cost of labor is some US$30 per hour (https://www.ziprecruiter.com/Salaries/How-Much-Does-a-Construction-Worker-Make-an-Hour https://www.ziprecruiter.com/Salaries/How-Much-Does-a-Constr... gives an average of US$16/hour with a range of US$9–23, but this doesn't include overhead, worker's comp, unemployment insurance, etc.) which works out to US$2400 for two person-weeks. So maybe the total cost is US$3400, including materials and labor. So the cost of labor isn't the problem. Something has gone terribly wrong with your civilization. — ⁂ — I reread Laura Ingalls Wilder's Little House on the Prairie last month, and I was struck by the description of the building process. If we take the description in the book as factual (not everything in the book is, but I assume in this case Ingalls Wilder was doing her best) it took a couple of weeks for a skilled carpenter and an unskilled assistant to build the single-room log cabin which afterwards housed a family of five for a year, plus another few days for the fireplace. But this was using raw materials from nature — trees chopped down and hauled from the creek by horse-drawn wagon, mud mortar to hold the fireplace stones together, mud for the chimney. (The chimney later caught fire due to shoddy construction and nearly burned down the house, and a dropped-log accident nearly broke Ma's foot. Building codes and safety rules are important!) Presumably the family had an outhouse for defecation, although the book shrinks from even mentioning such matters. She doesn't give dimensions for the house, but it seems to have been around 4 m × 5 m, some 20 m², less than half the size I described above. My own apartment is 40 m²; fortunately I'm spending the quarantine at my girlfriend's apartment, which is some 50 m². (The roof leaks, the pipes burst, the curtains billow from the wind even when the window is closed, and whoever installed the electricals was either an idiot or a homicidal maniac, but she had my refrigerator, you see…) — ⁂ — How did we get from a situation where an average person could build a five-person house with four person-weeks of labor — 0.08 years' of per-capita GDP — without even the support of a manufacturing base to provide them with boards, bricks, and toilets, to a situation where an "affordable housing" unit costs 6 years' worth of the US per-capita GDP, and 7 years of the US median household income? That is, a median household in the US now needs to work for seven years to pay the cost of building a house, rather than two weeks. Half the population earns less even than that. When it comes to housing buying power, people in the US are three orders of magnitude poorer than 150 years ago, or than in the worst slums of Buenos Aires today. Something has gone terribly wrong with your civilization. Some people might cite the cost of land (both the Isla Maciel residents and Ingalls Wilder's family simply took their land without paying for it), but consider https://www.landsofamerica.com/property/0.2-acres-in-Los-Angeles-County-California/7848448/ https://www.landsofamerica.com/property/0.2-acres-in-Los-Ang..., 0.2 undeveloped acres for US$175000, about 20 km from downtown LA. In non-medieval units, that's 800 m², enough for 15 of the 49 m² single-story houses I described above, which works out to US$12000 per house; if you dig a basement, you could cut that to US$6000 per house, at some penalty to the construction cost. Moreover, if you could build a 15-story apartment building on half of that land (you can't, it's zoned industrial), it would hold some 100 apartments of 49 m² each, at a land cost of US$1750 per apartment. In a skyscraper you have to pour reinforced concrete slabs for floors, which isn't free, but at ground level it typically costs on the order of US$50 per square meter, which is only US$2500 for 50 m². $1750 + $2500 + $3400 = $7650 ≪ $414000! Something has gone terribly wrong with your civilization. Some people might cite Baumol's cost disease: when productivity goes up, wages go up, and so goods that have fixed labor requirements become more expensive; Baumol's example is an hour of chamber quartet music, which continues to require four musicians for an hour, just as in 1787. (The article itself blames "union-level wages" for construction workers.) But that explanation would suggest that construction workers like Miguel Zamora could easily buy housing, and we know that's not true. Even if the whole workforce was earning the US$51 per hour cited for plumbers in the article, that would only add another US$2500 or so per dwelling to the numbers I calculated above. — ⁂ — What if, instead of using ten-thousand-year-old technologies like log cabins and bricks cemented together with mortar, we used modern technology to build housing? You might get something like the Hexayurt, which costs under US$500, can be built by one unskilled person in less than a day, and shows up by the thousands every Burning Man: http://hexayurt.com/ http://hexayurt.com/ — although there are some fire safety concerns with the material, so stuccoing it might be advisable. That might double the cost. High-cube 40-foot shipping containers cost about US$7000 (or much less, used) and can be stacked into buildings many stories high; they are watertight, laugh at earthquakes, and have 28 m² of floor area. For $414000 you could buy dozens of them, maybe hundreds. Or you might get something like modern trailer houses; I don't know how much these cost to make, but you can get them used for US$20k–US$40k, full of amenities like gas stoves, showers, cabinets, glass windows all around, multiple bathrooms, electrical outlets in all the walls, and central heating, unheard of in both Ingalls Wilder's time and in Isla Maciel. But could we maybe sacrifice some of the outlets, and the heavy welded steel frame that allows you to move your house to a different trailer park, in exchange for ending homelessness? Something has gone terribly, terribly wrong with your civilization.
- TA_askhn_iplaw 6y agoI live in Solana Beach, a few blocks from the Pearl site. AMA.
- greedo 6y agoI grew up in SB, moved away in 95. Went back last summer for a wedding in La Jolla. Town sure has changed. House prices are crazy as ever, and even the poorer parts of town had crazy prices for housing. But it has the best Mex restaurant in SoCal (Tony's Jacal).
- foogazi 6y agoin 2009 when this project was being planned housing was soooo cheap in San Diego Existing apartments for 100k in nice areas, why even try to build for 400k on prime beach areas? Think about it: Miguel Zamora has been living on government housing vouchers since 1992 waiting for an apartment whose cost rose from 400k to 1MM. If he had received as settlement enough money for a downpayment (20-50k) he would own his own place and would have participated in the equity growth