12 ms·
Embrace, Extend, and Extinguish
- enumjorge 7y agoAnyone have context as to why this is on the front page?
- philosopher1234 7y agoThis is about the directx for wsl post yesterday. Some people fear Microsoft is trying to do this to Linux, although others disagreed.
- whalesalad 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitions_by_Microsoft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitio... Microsoft is taking over the world. They now own Github, NPM, Citus data, LinkedIn and a ton of other companies. Not to mention they have a trojan horse on almost every new developers machine thanks to TS and VSCode, and all of the data and services that companies are trusting to them on Azure. They are poised to become a data king. TBH... if I had a bunch of liquid cash to fuck around with I would be buying a ton of MSFT becuase my gut is telling me they are going to really take a huge slice of the open source development pie here in the next few years. They know that is the market they need to capitalize on which is why all these acquisitions and investments are happening.
- Slackwise 7y agoThere are a lot of young developers that just have no context for what Microsoft did in the past. If you bring up their past, they say "that was so long ago" or "but they've changed!" But public companies are not people. Of course they change -- tactics -- and try to gain control again. Everything they do will in the end have to be justified to their shareholders and how it will either gain them profit either now or in the long run, and as soon as the fickle-minded shareholders change their tune, out goes Nadella, and we'll get another Balmer or worse.
- whalesalad 7y agoI’m on the fence. I resonate with your take on things, but I also have a bit of hope in me as well. At least outwardly their optics are looking much better and brighter, but I’m not sure what the real culture is like at present day.
- seph-reed 7y agoYour optimism is inherently misplaced. Power is corruptive. Even if the people in power now aren't corrupted, there is no fail-safe in place to pull the plug if they ever hand off that power to someone who can't control it. It will happen, it always does. There is historically no such thing as a trustworthy super-power unless it subsists overwhelmingly on the support of discerning people.
- prirun 7y agoYou may hop off the fence if they do something like, oh, I don't know, buy Canonical to counter IBM buying RedHat. I'm surprised they didn't do it immediately after that.
- bragh 7y agoAnd this is the saddest part of it all: the industry slowly started to drag itself out of the mire that is Microsoft monoculture, as servers were moving to Linux even in evil-corp style organizations; cloud services offering competition to Office hegemony (especially in education); IE6 dead and its descendants soon-to-be-forgotten; .NET being forced to improve itself and to become only 5 years behind the curve instead of 10 years (but some places still seek developers for the Lovecraftian horror that is Web Forms). And now all this, all over again? Goddamn this industry.
- Whil- 7y agoWhat are public companies if not people? It seems to me what you're complaining about is less about Microsoft and more about capitalism and greed in general.
- dsr_ 7y ago
- Shared404 7y agoI can say that not every new developer loves MS. I use vim, avoid JS, run Linux etc. As things currently stand, I'm considering migrating to BSD due to MS's new... love... for Linux.
- adamsvystun 7y agoThis probably connected to this post. 'DirectX is coming to the Windows Subsystem for Linux' https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23241040 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23241040 People think that EEE is what Microsoft might be doing in this case.
- somethoughts 7y agoPerhaps its from yesterday's discussion on Microsoft Lists which is similar to Airtable: Microsoft announces Lists, a new Airtable-like app https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23241084 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23241084 - Embrace, Extend, Extinguish is something different. It's about adopting standards in order to break them and gradually lock people into proprietary variants. This guy is talking about just copying existing products.
- mjburgess 7y agoEmbrace (the UI) Extend (integrate with office) Extinguish... Seems similar enough to me. Just thinking of UI as a feature.
- TechBro8615 7y agoIt's worth noting this is the 16th time [0] this article has been submitted to HN. [0] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=%22wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FEmbrace%2C_extend%2C_and_extinguish%22&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- dang 7y agoBut with no more than 1 comment on 2 occasions: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=comments%3E0%20%22wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FEmbrace%2C_extend%2C_and_extinguish%22&sort=byPopularity&type=story&storyText=none https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... 3 if you count https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15869249 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15869249.
- JKCalhoun 7y agoAssumed it was due to the article yesterday on Facebook "embracing" Shopify.
- acheron 7y agoI figured it was a Google thing. Still being worried about Microsoft sounds like that classic Guardian article about the unending Myspace monopoly. But the EEE philosophy is all over Google now.
- runawaybottle 7y agoWell in that case, Microsoft is really targeting developers. VSCode, Typescript, Github, WSL, the inevitable tie into Azure... I wonder how this all ends. We can short circuit some of the inevitability I guess, still holding out for this: https://panic.com/nova/ https://panic.com/nova/ Looks like Deno already adopted Typescript, but the world doesn’t have to revolve around Github. AWS and Azure will keep each other honest. Edit: I’ll add that I really really don’t think Microsoft wants to proselytize developers into it’s ecosystem just to make apps for Windows. I really think they are going to try mobile again.
- minxomat 7y agoNot to forget LinkedIn, which is now being deeply integrated with O365, which has gained MyAnalytics (or whatever it's called) which is for all intents an automated "productivity" tracking software that aims to capture the time you're working, who you work with and how you spend your time. I wonder when that data will be exposed on LinkedIn (hey recruiters, this guy is working late hours a lot!). And then the eventual integration of that dystopian system with MS's developer monopoly. Now we have a truly "boring dystopia". The worst part is: MS now has all the tools for this and more.
- runawaybottle 7y agoMicrosoft wants nothing more than a world full of .NET developers.
- abakker 7y agoI've been waiting for the integration of active directory and linkedIn. It seems only a slight stretch to think of using corporate data and social data for cross-validation of true Identity.
- 52-6F-62 7y agoWorst case (MS moves to bad-acting), re: Deno—TypeScript can at least be forked for now https://github.com/Microsoft/TypeScript https://github.com/Microsoft/TypeScript I'd love to see Mozilla hop on board with it
- maallooc 7y agoMicrosoft does things well. If you don't want EEE to happen, just be better than Microsoft. As a consumer we just don't care whether Microsoft is the axis of evil or something. We don't give a f. We just want things to work and work well.
- parliament32 7y agoIf you're the "just work" type go buy Apple devices and be done with it. Not all of us want fisher-price-style products.
- maallooc 7y agoBut I did and am using, along with lots of people.
- treekogreen 7y ago"fisher-price-style". Some people just want to get to work on a machine they are comfortable with rather than worrying about the looks of their machine.
- immigrantsheep 7y agoso apple is ok but microsoft is not? because...?
- tmotwu 7y agoMicrosoft's recent involvement to open source is currently a bigger threat to OSX than it ever was to Linux. Users who use Linux distros are content with their overall desktop experience in the absence of closed-source libraries such as DirectX, etc. They were never the target audience Microsoft gains from embracing because not many would have felt the incentive to do so. Especially considering their efforts to port and upstream changes to the kernel, lessening the allure. Albeit not that Microsoft is doing this out of the goodness of their hearts, they benefit from doing so. Meanwhile, the Apple developer ecosystem has not made any significant strides. It has been a while since homebrew that OSX has gotten a useful developer tool, and ever since Lattner departed from both of his projects related to Swift (TF), it has slowly been losing traction. Many Mac users choose OSX for the neat desktop experience Linux struggled to offer, and the *nix-like interface Microsoft had been missing. WSL and Microsoft's recent contributions to Linux has changed the Windows developer experience significantly, giving many previously hesitant Mac shops the nod.
- aklemm 7y agoI’ll never forget muttering that to myself when Washington state passed a law banning smoking within 25 feet of doorways, but Microsoft made it 30 feet on the signage on campus.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danso 7y agoThis is brought up every time Microsoft and Github are discussed, and it seems like a very shallow thing to fixate on. Is it impossible that a company, with a new CEO and leadership team, would discard a strategy from 25 years ago (more like 50 years ago by non-tech industry timescales)? Especially now that its market dominance is fundamentally different and reduced (likely permanently) compared to the 90s? What evidence is there that Nadella is a Manchurian candidate for Ballmer forces? Note that my issue with EXX being brought up is that it is superficial, to the point of being deceptive to the kind of threats Microsoft+Github are most likely to pose if Nadella et al do have their own malicious plans. But I think Microsoft's support for a healthy OSS ecosystem, via Github and things like VS Code, is genuine. Not necessarily out of altruism, but because it's one of the few ways they can have an edge into the future and not fall into stagnation like IBM.
- nogabebop23 7y agoThey've always supported their developer ecosystem better than any other company as well. Nobody else has spent anything like the the time, effort and resources they have in helping devs thrive in their ecosystem. Not because "they're good people" but because it's effective.
- alex_young 7y agoAs with most interesting arguments, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle. I don't doubt that MS would take advantage of market dominance again if it was achieved somehow, and I am sure they are making these plays with increasing their ecosystem in mind. One interesting acquisition to look at is LinkedIn which they have really tightened the screws on to the point where everyone looking for employees or trying to find a job is made to pay. This is especially vile for the unemployed IMHO. On the other hand, the eager monopolist of the day is really Amazon, and MS taking them on is a good thing for the ecosystem. If there is competition MS seems to be playing a fair game. I hope it stays that way.
- Taek 7y ago> If there is competition MS seems to be playing a fair game. I hope it stays that way. The structure of US corporations is such that they are fundamentally misaligned with playing a fair game. Corporations have two types of cycles: growth, and profit taking. Regardless of who is in charge of Microsoft today, when Microsoft reaches a position of dominance, the leadership will be shifted by the board and shareholders to focus on exploiting that dominance, rather than continuing to play fair. We are only seeing fair play because Microsoft's position in the open source world is not yet entrenched.
- neogodless 7y agoWith meaningful competition, the game is elevated for everyone. Those competing must win on merit, and those watching and consuming get the best output. When Microsoft was the dominant software Goliath, they were winning in business and personal computing. The internet was new and they wanted to win that - not necessarily by being the best, but by using their leverage. In the current environment, Microsoft is still winning in a lot of areas of business - competitive if not dominant. They have meaningful positions (but also competitors) in cloud hosting, operating systems and productivity software. In my opinion, we're in a good place for a lot of these vectors. Cloud has Azure, AWS and GCP (though I don't know how well GCP is competing.) Operating systems have the classic gorilla in Windows, the polished closed system macOS and the persistent open source varieties of Linux. They are all meaningfully competitive. Mobile is probably the weakest area, in my opinion. I wish Microsoft was still competing with Windows Phone here, because I don't love my Android and iOS options. They are good and they do what I need. I'm not confident I could switch between them easily (the way I am mostly confident I can switch between Windows, macOS and Linux). (Online advertising is clearly the realm of Facebook and Google.) I'm not sure how to summarize, but I don't think Microsoft is the same 800-pound gorilla that stuck us with Internet Explorer 6 for way too long. They'll (as long as they can) always be ambitiously seeking dominance in profitable software-related markets. They'll never be 100% charitable or philanthropic. And neither will their competitors. Is there a useful rubric or framework to think about all this? What are personal decisions you can make that aren't too painful, but matter on the grand scale of these massive companies?
- Doches 7y ago+1, and I wish more folks thought about Microsoft/Google/Amazon/etc this way. What we're seeing with Github, LinkedIn, Azure -- all the modernish MS moves -- feels more like the sleeping giant is waking up and _competing_, not like an 800-pound goliath throwing its weight around to extinguish competition. Github vs Gitlab is a _healthy_ competition, to the benefit of everyone (including MS and Gitlab!), same with Azure vs AWS vs GCP. This is a _good_ state we're in, not a bad one.
- factorialboy 7y agoVS Code. GitHub. NPM. VS Code Online. GitHub CodeSpaces. Integrated Azure. A ten year old today learning programming will be locked in. As will JS yuppies and the extremely articulate product manager types. I like it. Gives me an opportunity to become a "thought leader" by promoting the UNIX approach to enterprises in 5-10 years.
- Doches 7y agoJetbrains. Gitlab. Deno. Aws. We're in a world where there's healthy competition in _all_ of these domains, excepting possibly VS online/GH codespaces which both feel like products too young to have yet found a market. In what world is a 10-year-old locked in to the MS ecosystem any more than they were in the days of win32 and IE6? If anything, I'd look askance at Apple for Safari's hiding of `view source` by default...
- pmontra 7y agoThere is a difference. Amazon doesn't have an OS. Google does but it's not for developers, yet. Apple's is but they care only about their own walled garden, the entrance fee is expensive and they don't have the online ecosystem that Microsoft has built and acquired in the last years. Microsoft is in a good position to control the new developers' experience from the OS to the tools to the deployment cloud (Azure).
- krzyk 7y agoBut there is alternative OS - Linux. Lately I know only devs that work either on macos or on Linux. I haven't seen Windows anywhere since few years (except when I do cloud gaming).
- pmontra 7y agoI know. I've been developing on Ubuntu since January 2009. Before that I was using colinux on Windows XP, a Linux kernel in a Windows process, somewhat similar to WSL. http://colinux.org/ http://colinux.org/
- badrabbit 7y agoCisco has entered the chat
- mncharity 7y agoEEE is, among other things, a pattern of incentives. Embrace: We care about our customers. If someone other than us creates something that would be valuable to them, of course we're going to embrace it. To do otherwise, would be a Not Invented Here failure, would be to let down our customers. Extend: We care about our customers. We are a major center of innovation, working constantly to improve things for them. We're not going to hold back on helping them just because some standards committee is moving like cold molasses, riven by politics, technically tasteless, or has conflict interests optimizing for things other than the best interests of our customers. And we're certainly not going to later break things for our customers merely because some committee eventually decides it wants things done differently. They're just committees. More people are benefiting from our work than theirs. We're not going to hurt our customers just because some committees have a disproportionate sense of entitlement and importantance. Extinguish: We care about our customers. And those who are potentially our customers. We want to make it as easy as possible for people to gain the benefits of being our customers. The health of our competitors, and even of people unfortunate to not yet be our customers, are not our motivating responsibility. We're focused on our customers, and what happens to that portion of the industry that isn't, can't be what we optimize for. And we're just a normal commercial company, so of course we're not going to fail to compete with our competitors. If nothing else, we owe it to their customers who may soon be ours. And of course to our stockholders. Much evil in the world is arguably an emergent property of regrettable incentives. I mention this only because this post is for whatever reason trending today, and past discussions have repeatedly been of unusually disappointing quality for tech topic on HN. Perhaps this comment will help prune some of the inevitable "but they're good people now, not evil, so there's no problem" comments.
- marcosdumay 7y agoIt is different when you go out of your way to extend the product in a way that is incompatible for no gain for your clients (and often in detriment of them). And when you make sure not to support the standard and use your market dominance to push your competitors out. Nothing on the Halloween Documents resembles good faith. Those cases where companies just want to improve their products are much more benign and fail to have the same extinguishing power.
- 7y ago
- SllX 7y agoWas thinking about this earlier, saw some article about how Microsoft is trying to get Windows 10 to run Linux GUI apps. But also Spotify! There's a strain of thought out there that the podcast ecosystem is resistant to centralization, but Spotify is making a serious go at proving this wrong.
- parliament32 7y ago>saw some article about how Microsoft is trying to get Windows 10 to run Linux GUI apps I thought that exact same thing when I saw that article yesterday. Interestingly Linux has its own corporate champion: Redhat/Poettering. Currently they're the villain in most Linux circles, but it'll be interesting to see them and MS square off, as they inevitably will.
- treekogreen 7y agoWindows 10 can already run GUI apps using WSL and an X server. Microsoft is planning to build a native X server so it's frustration free. Personally, I cannot wait.
- ekr 7y agoI'd love to hear Torvalds' opinion on this DirectX PR. In any case, as someone who hates complexity and loves simple software (in the suckless sense), whenever I see these monstrosities get merged into the kernel, it makes me search for alternatives. There was a time when the kernel codebase was small and easily understandable by 1 person, apart from the drivers. Apparently simplicity and keeping complexity at bay is no longer a goal for Linux. BSDs do a bit better here, but they are still behind on several metrics. Maybe this will be the main motivation for the next successful kernel? The fact the Linux simply got too big and complex?
- mjevans 7y agoAs some of the replies on the LKML suggest ( https://lkml.org/lkml/2020/5/19/742 https://lkml.org/lkml/2020/5/19/742 ) having this as a simple accelerator pipe, but simple in the Linux perspective of re-using as many conventions and existing infrastructure as possible, and living _not_ as a display adapter (which will surely become far more complex later) would probably work for everyone; right now. The question is strongly dependent on future developments. With this being contributed as a GPU driver and the likely hope of this being used to run Linux applications within another OS, the question might be re-framed: How is this addition to the Linux Kernel API going to benefit _all_ users of Linux, not just users of WSL? Were Microsoft trying to provide a thin abstraction layer, so that drawing to a vGPU shard from windows on the application facing side of the Linux Kernel API looked like any other standard GPU under Linux, I feel it very likely everyone would feel positively about the changes. If this were about contributing Microsoft's vGPU driver for Linux, and in so doing also implementing only Freely Implementable Industry Standards (like Vulcan, OpenGL, or maybe others that Microsoft made/makes similarly free), while also not neglecting the expected core standards for other GPU drivers, then that also seems logically acceptable for everyone. Though my above suppositions are purely my opinion and guesses about the opinions of the maintainers for the software, while trying to think about how they approach their inherent responsibility for the long term maintenance and stability of a project they are clearly passionate about.
- fithisux 7y agoIt is strictly my personal opinion. From the WSL + Direct X announcement of today, I see the same old M$ that I knew 20 years ago. They simply learnt new tricks.
- type0 7y agoEclipse is making open-source registry for VS Code extensions https://open-vsx.org https://open-vsx.org support it if you are afraid that MS could pull the plug on their Marketplace in a few years
- foobar_ 7y agoExtinguish only works if it is a monopoly. Back in the day Microsoft had a monopoly on the PC operating system market and microsoft tried to extinguish the web. Microsoft still has lots of monopolistic practices built into the bootloader. Not sure if driver makers are forced to work only with windows these days but thats definitely the case with hololens. It would be more interesting for microsoft to take a stance on privacy like apple.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Shared404 7y agoSaw this while scrolling Reddit, and thought it is relevant here as well. https://medium.com/@probonopd/microsoft-loves-linux-a-little-too-much-cff91023e4b8 https://medium.com/@probonopd/microsoft-loves-linux-a-little...