6 ms·
And when upstream service providers cut him off, he can start his own one of those. When payment processors close all his accounts, he can start one of those.
by bitwize 7y ago
And when upstream service providers cut him off, he can start his own one of those.
When payment processors close all his accounts, he can start one of those.
Remember, kids, censorship refers to the government and only the government. Stray far enough onto the wrong side of history, and society may voluntarily decide you're an asshole and show you the door. And that'll be on you.
- gadders 7y agoHe could end up like Laura Loomer and get banned from Uber, Uber Eats etc as well.
- koheripbal 7y agoI hate Alex Jones, but I have to agree. There's a difference between being kicked out of a restaurant for being an ass, vs being kicked out of EVERY restaurant on Earth for the rest of your life - without due process. These online services aren't small mom/pop shops that you can just replace and patronize another. They are global near-monopolies that you cannot function without. Google isn't just my search provider - they run my email, my internet connection, my cell service, my company's cloud repository, etc... They could destroy me at the drop of a hat.
- a10c 7y ago> Google isn't just my search provider - they run my email, my internet connection, my cell service, my company's cloud repository, You have no alternative to any of those services?
- tim333 7y agoI'm skeptical of "kicked out of EVERY restaurant on Earth" The Daily Stormer is fairly bad as sites go "Jews Howl as Portuguese Move to Shut Down Their Citizenship Scam" typical story - and after various attempts to get rid of them all you have to do to go to the site is google them and click on the link in the wikipedia page. About the only sites that are really kicked out of all restaurants are paedophila ones and they deserve that and more IMO.
- bitwize 6y agoTwitter has actually vowed to support pedos, as long as they don't talk about plans to hurt actual, particular children. But the community of "MAPs" is protected by social media these days. Repeat the 13-50 statistic, though, and you're out (though the likes of "kill all white people" appears to be ok).
- perilunar 7y ago> Google isn't just my search provider - they run my email, my internet connection, my cell service, my company's cloud repository, etc... They could destroy me at the drop of a hat. More fool you. Maybe you should diversify a bit.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoAye, a bit part of my push this year has been de-googling my life. Along with de-facebooking and de-microsofting.
- orf 7y agoA more apt comparison is being banned from every bar/pub in town for causing issues, without due process and without having set foot in some of them. Which is perfectly fine and acceptable
- koheripbal 7y agoBeing banned from every bar and restaurant in the world for something he said? Have you ever heard of such a thing? It would be ludicrous.
- cycomanic 7y agoSo where were you when the Isis videos were taken off YouTube and ISIS twitter accounts were deleted? The thing is the outcry always only comes when companies don't want to be associated with some right-wing nutjobs hate speech, while I never hear the same people shouting that ISIS promo videos should not be taken down because of censorship. If all censorship is always bad, why not complain about those cases? Call me sceptical, but to me this sounds very much like, "hey they remove content that I sympathise with, instead of content that I don't like" and almost always aimed at propagating the myth of right-wing victimhood.
- beefbroccoli 7y agoIf I advocate for criminal activity and my advocacy is likely to produce said criminal activity, that speech is not protected.
- koheripbal 7y agoYou really cannot differentiate between content that should criminal murder in progress versus Alex Jones's conspiracy theories? That's a pretty soft shell you have.
- kelnos 7y ago> I hate Alex Jones, but I have to agree. There's a difference between being kicked out of a restaurant for being an ass, vs being kicked out of EVERY restaurant on Earth for the rest of your life - without due process. That's a bit of a straw man, no? Jones still has plenty of perfectly-functioning restaurants to visit, with quite extensive menus. If one of the biggest assholes on the internet still has a platform to spew his hate, I don't think we're in any danger of this dystopian society existing where people can be completely silenced based on the will of a few corporations. > Google isn't just my search provider - they run my email, my internet connection, my cell service, my company's cloud repository, etc... They could destroy me at the drop of a hat. That's a choice you've made, not a required state of being. There are plenty of other companies that provide search, email, internet service, cell service, cloud repos, etc. that are just as (if not more) functional and featureful.
- koheripbal 7y agoI don't see how this is a straw man. He's been banned from all major social media platforms, for life, without due process. > That's a choice you've made... No, not really. Because my argument (perhaps wrongly) focused on Google, but it's still true that I have to choose a major near-monopoly corporation to do email, mobile, social media, telephone service, cloud, etc... There are no alternatives. Have you ever tried to stand up your own email server? You can't. Google won't even relay the emails.
- unethical_ban 7y agoI think you missed the parent's point. I read it as, "if you get kicked out of every restaurant on the planet, it might be your fault." Of course there are protections for certain classes of people based on their attributes or fundamentals, but society can call your bullshit out.
- koheripbal 7y agoThis is hollow logic. If I say someone is punished unfairly, it's probably because they deserved it? Maybe you should tell that to a rape victim some time.
- unethical_ban 7y ago"dang", is it okay if I call this a stupid argument? Someone is comparing social shaming for hate speech and lies and defamation - to someone getting physically raped. So someone who willfully, repeatedly, taunts murder victims' families, spreads lies and conspiracy theories, and feeds off the attention of the mentally ill - getting taken off private platforms that not only host his content for free, but earn him money: Is the same as telling a woman she somehow deserves getting raped. Grow the fuck up.
- cambalache 7y agoMaybe smarter people (Zizek?) have already talked about this, but for me the current global political compass is very weird. I consider myself a hard-leftist and yet somehow I sometimes feel ideologically closer, or at least not so estranged from your salt-of-the-earth Trump/Brexit voter than to the current modern western progressives, or what people in the 60s used to call a somewhat similar group: Champagne socialists. For me, at least, using my conspiracy hat this is a big big victory for the dominant class, because the existent cries for stricter corporate oversee, dismantling of the lobbying system , unjust labor conditions are totally drowned in a sea of political correctness, in which many of the issues are less important. Many people counter-argue saying that all injustices are worth to be talking about, and I of course agree, but not to the expense of the most important ones, and even less to the expense of basic issues like freedom of speech and equality before the law. The same people who cheer and request the banning of all platforms for their political enemies are scandalized if the workers demographics of any "chic" industry or company does not match exactly their perceived ideal.
- samastur 7y agoThis feeling of closeness is not new (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory)
- cambalache 7y agoNice try, but no. I would say it is more an orthogonal thing. Most of the worries of the common folk(left and right leaning) are not shared by the vocal pieces of the progressive movement.
- samastur 7y agoNice try? Look, mate, I intentionally only provided a reference to show that the idea of commonality between hard-left and hard-right is not a new one without going into the correctness of it or if it is the same as what you feel. My point is that it is not new and not weird. It is not even only an idea, as one can already observe both sides cooperating on some issues in Europe. Apparently my bland non-committal comment was already provocative enough to get down-voted. I don't have an inclination to debate it further as both of your comments are peppered with descriptions (salt-of-the-earth Trump/Brexit voter, common folk...) that suggest this would unlikely be fruitful.
- Angostura 7y ago> Stray far enough onto the wrong side of history, and society may voluntarily decide you're an asshole and show you the door. And that'll be on you. Remember kids, there's no such thing as being an actual arsehole, harassing people and endangering people. It's just that they are people who strayed on "the wrong side of history". My neighbour who's kicking his cat? Not an arsehole.
- Aeolun 7y agoI mean, at some point in history your asshole who’s kicking his cat was probably not seen as an asshole. If only because domesticated cats haven’t always been a thing.
- Traster 7y agoYou're arguing this as if the censorship you're talking about has actually happened to anyone ever. We're literally talking about Alex Jones because he's the most extreme example, but actually the opposite is true. We have Alex Jones as a great demonstration of the most objectionable person on the internet. Is he censored? I don't know, I suggest you ask him here: www.infowars.com or listen to one of his 6 podcasts a week, or subscribe to his newsletter, or buy his Tubo Force tablets in his shop, or download his app, or his soundcloud, or his reddit account, or his Gab account, or his Telegram account, or on liveleak. The fact of the matter is that Alex Jones has more ability to braodcast his speech to people around the world than any single individual who was living before 1980.
- leereeves 7y ago> You're arguing this as if the censorship you're talking about has actually happened to anyone ever. It has happened. When Gab tried to compete with Twitter, Apple and Google banned their app. Payment processors have banned controversial sites like Wikileaks too.
- Traster 7y agoYou can download the Gab android app here: https://apps.gab.com/application/5d3f982c9dd49a5b1d9fc881 https://apps.gab.com/application/5d3f982c9dd49a5b1d9fc881 Or visit gab.ai on your Chrome browser. Wikileaks explains the 5 different ways you can donate to them here: https://shop.wikileaks.org/donate https://shop.wikileaks.org/donate Including about 75 different cryptocurrencies
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- leereeves 7y agoIt's still censorship if a school library bans a book even if you can still buy it from Amazon. The existence of alternatives doesn't mean censorship hasn't happened.
- 7y ago
- _petronius 7y ago> society may voluntarily decide you're an asshole and show you the door For all people who support the "marketplace of ideas" argument (which I don't, not least because there is fairly compelling research that documents why a marketplace is a bad metaphor for how ideas spread and damaging ideology takes hold) – wouldn't this be evidence that your idea is failing in said marketplace? Your comment seems to confuse a laissez-faire approach with supporting and subsidising anyone who comes along no matter how problematic their speech is. Being anti-censorship is not the same being pro-megaphone: freedom of speech doesn't require giving everyone the widest possible audience with no restrictions. (obligatory XKCD https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/)