13 ms·
Authorities say Hobby Lobby's Gilgamesh tablet is stolen, must go back to Iraq
- vorpalhex 6y agoAuction houses have some very shady practices sometimes, and I imagine it's very difficult for buyers to navigate what is legal and what's not - but also in this case, it kind of seems like maybe they should have known.
- imglorp 6y agoThey knew. Their own expert lawyer warned them in 2010. It's also their MO apparently. A second case involves Egyptian papyri. They also mis-declare things to get them into the country (ie calling them "tiles" in customs declarations). So, lying and stealing. 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/05/nyregion/hobby-lobby-artifacts-smuggle-iraq.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/05/nyregion/hobby-lobby-arti... 2. https://www.thedailybeast.com/hobby-lobby-scandal-widens-as-museum-of-the-bible-admits-oxford-prof-sold-illicit-papyri-to-green-family https://www.thedailybeast.com/hobby-lobby-scandal-widens-as-... 3. https://www.theguardian.com/news/2020/jan/09/a-scandal-in-oxford-the-curious-case-of-the-stolen-gospel https://www.theguardian.com/news/2020/jan/09/a-scandal-in-ox...
- _bxg1 6y agoThe comical part is that their very interest in the items is based in a religion that's nominally very opposed to lying and stealing. Fetishizing artifacts is apparently more important to their faith than doing what's right.
- prutschman 6y agoOpposed to lying, stealing, and worshiping artifacts, no less.
- wl 6y agoIt's not very complicated to know what's legal and what's not. Was it exported from the country of origin prior to 1970? Legal. Exported with the permission of the government at the time? Legal. The problem here was fraudulent provenance documents. Ideally, every item that goes up for auction would have its provenance investigated. In practice, that's too expensive for the auction houses.
- dabernathy89 6y agoThis is a related and surprisingly fascinating article about the cast of characters involved in many of the missteps of the Green Collection (which became the Museum of the Bible): https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2020/06/museum-of-the-bible-obbink-gospel-of-mark/610576/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2020/06/museum-...
- hprotagonist 6y agotake that, L. Bob Rife. (the similarities between hobby lobby stealing tablets and religiously motivated tech magnates doing the same in a certain cyberpunk book of wide repute are, as usual, a bit eerie)
- throwaway17_17 6y agoMaybe the downvoted are for lack of on topic and substantive response, but I really appreciated the Snow Crash reference. I thought it was funny.
- slg 6y ago>"Whenever looted cultural property is found in this country, the United States government will do all it can to preserve heritage by returning such artifacts where they belong" So what is the definition of "looted" here? Museums are full of things that fit various definitions of that word.
- renewiltord 6y agoEssentially, if it happened in modern times we have to account to modern governments for it. It's just a property of current real life. If local people put pressure on their government over it, the government has to put pressure on America over it, and America may want to preserve relations by making a gesture that's ultimately strategically zero cost to preserve a strategic relationship. No one with any power seriously wants the Kohinoor back so it's not going to go back. But having an artifact taken from your country during a war of invasion is going to create lots of pressure on you. It's just realpolitik.
- hyperpape 6y agoIt's the subject of some discussion (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elgin_Marbles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elgin_Marbles). I think an extremely conservative rule is that if it was taken after the original playstation was released, that's looting.
- wl 6y agoThere are a few clear lines you can draw. Many institutions built their collections through a practice known as partage or division of finds. They would go to a government and offer their services as archeologists in exchange for a portion of their finds. While this practice is rare post-1970, there's not any serious debate about the legitimacy of cultural heritage exported under this regime. Purchases from the antiquities markets are also considered legitimate, assuming the export was originally done with the permission of the originating country. Where things really get questionable is when material culture was extracted by imperial power or as spoils of war. The Rosetta Stone is the most famous example. Also, you've got things like the Elgin Marbles that were taken through fraud and subterfuge a long time ago. These kinds of things are grandfathered in as a legal matter, but there's a moral argument for returning them anyway.
- triceratops 6y ago> Hobby Lobby bought the tablet in a private sale, after a Hobby Lobby representative viewed the tablet in London. The auction house shipped the tablet to its New York office and, from there, hand-carried it to Hobby Lobby's headquarters in Oklahoma City, "so that Hobby Lobby could avoid incurring a New York sales tax," according to prosecutors. Oy vey. I don't know how serious this is but it's not a great look. Is this kind of thing common in the art world? I find old clay tablets, and ancient writings in general, absolutely fascinating - particularly the randomness of the information that we can get from them. The oldest person whose name we know is from a signature on a receipt for some oil or some other merchandise.[1] It's slightly incredible when you realize that you have no idea who the ruler at the time was, or what he (or she did) but you can pinpoint precisely which goods exchanged hands on a specific date. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kushim_(individual) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kushim_(individual)
- AdmiralAsshat 6y ago> Oy vey. I don't know how serious this is but it's not a great look. Is this kind of thing common in the art world? Sure. The British museum used to be fairly brazen about the fact that they'd loot less-developed countries for cultural artifacts. Who do you think used to sponsor archaeology expeditions? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Museum#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Museum#Controversies
- triceratops 6y agoErr... my comment was referring to the sales tax evasion. I'm aware that the looting of cultural artifacts is an age-old practice, that's only recently been legislated against.
- dmurray 6y agoIf your New York business sells something to someone in Oklahoma, you don't have to charge NY sales tax. That's not controversial or a grey area (edit: until 2018). I don't know exactly how they structured this transaction, but if it ended up in Oklahoma it seems to be within the spirit of the law.
- legerdemain 6y agoOne of the outcomes of the US-Iraq war was Iraq's national heritage of antiquities getting plundered and sold illegally.[1] The burning of the Library of Alexandria is a potent symbol in Western culture, but the world has repeatedly suffered massive losses of cultural and historical artifacts in the last few decades. The public quickly develops historical amnesia for recent events. Compare, for example, the loss of Brazil's National Museum to a fire two years ago.[2] [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2018/03/iraq-war-archeology-invasion/555200/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2018/03/ir... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/sep/03/fire-engulfs-brazil-national-museum-rio https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/sep/03/fire-engulfs-b... edited: clarity and link formatting
- keiferski 6y agoThe destruction of Baghdad itself, including the House of Wisdom (large library), by the Mongols in 1258 is probably a more apt comparison. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Wisdom https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Wisdom https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Baghdad_(1258) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Baghdad_(1258)
- deathgrips 6y agoWhat a tragedy. Most westerners don't realize that when Europeans were living in mud huts and emptying their chamber pots into the streets, the Muslim world had plumbing, water filtration, surgery, advanced mathematics, and many more amazing scientific advances which quickly spread throughout Muslim countries due to the cultural exchange at Mecca. I wonder what the world could have been like if the Mongols had never destroyed so much civilization and progress.
- laingc 6y agoWait until you read about the Roman Republic thousands of years before this time - you’re gonna love it.
- 6y ago
- MikeKusold 6y ago> "Whenever looted cultural property is found in this country, the United States government will do all it can to preserve heritage by returning such artifacts where they belong," How does this tablet differ from any other artifact in a museum? Couldn't it be argued that any ancient artifact from another culture is stolen?
- triceratops 6y agoI think it's basically a function of when the artifact was taken. Older generations (I'm thinking pre 1900s) of historians, archeologists and explorers didn't think anything of it. And often in the colonial era, there wasn't a native government or state that could take possession of those artifacts. From reading history books, I think there was more of a finders-keepers mentality back then. EDIT: from reading another comment, it seems like 1970 is the cut-off. The same actions today would be considered deeply uncool (which they are IMO), and also illegal in many jurisdictions. It's not right for a country's cultural treasures to be put on display permanently (loans are OK, I guess) in a museum thousands of miles away where most of the people of that country have no chance of admiring them.
- ABeeSea 6y agoIt also breaks apart a potential comprehensive collection. The Mayan collection from the Guatemalan government is currently in a traveling tour. Saw it in Vancouver as a special exhibit and it was a truly great exhibit that would be impossible if all those pieces were in different collections around the world.
- ChainOfFools 6y agothe problem is that local (to the archaeological context) museums lose a lot of potential support when the most salient artifacts connected to the history of the community they serve are held in (or more likely, outright belong to) a much more comprehensive collection in a far away city that many of their patrons will never visit. It's a thorny problem. That local and often very impoverished communities will value their history enough to pay the costs of protecting it from being (legally or illegally) sold off in bits to the international market, is not a given. Local museums are often a cornerstone of establishing that value.
- renewiltord 6y agoI wonder how many soldier millionaires have been made by the War in Iraq. A small shot at wealth, a low risk of death, maybe going to war there as an individual isn't too bad.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoMy son was scarred for life by what he saw, and what he had to do. No, not a walk in the park.
- renewiltord 6y agoSorry to hear about that. Naturally I didn't mean to imply that everyone had it easy. Some even died, tragically.
- tedivm 6y agoAccording to the most recent study data (2017), an average of 16 veterans commits suicide every day here in the US. Claiming that it "isn't so bad" is remarkably callous.
- tzs 6y agoPerhaps unexpectedly, among veterans who served during the Iraq or Afghanistan wars, those who were deployed have a lower suicide risk than those who were not deployed [1]. Anyone have any explanation for this? [1] https://www.publichealth.va.gov/epidemiology/studies/suicide-risk-death-risk-recent-veterans.asp https://www.publichealth.va.gov/epidemiology/studies/suicide...
- throwawaygh 6y agoMost people who deploy never see combat, but "undeployed" is likely to correlate with some personal problems (lack of discipline/skills/intelligence/etc.) that will make post-military life difficult. From your question, I guess maybe you have the impression that "deployment" means "regular combat', or even "any combat". Maybe things will make more sense if you think about this as a comparison between "people who mostly stayed on base overseas/at sea" vs. "people who mostly stayed on base state-side". Most of the military is non-combat, and only a small percentage of even combat arms every see combat. (Also, the military is not exactly safe even when you don't deploy. Even with two active wars on, there have been years since 2001 when more troops died from non-combat accidents than from combat). It's true that "war is 10% bullets and 90% logistics", but it's also true that the US runs its military as a sort of rural jobs program of last resort. So you're drawing from a highly vulnerable population to begin with, and then probably not deploying the bottom parts of that distribution. Guess which part of the distribution is also most likely to struggle finding work or getting through school post-deployment. The mundane everyday reality of living in poverty in America is far more deadly than the battle fields.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoKind of sad all around. The table was essentially rescued from ignominy. But of course it belongs to Iraq. Then it'll probably just disappear again. Sigh.
- crazygringo 6y ago> Then it'll probably just disappear again. Sigh. What are you basing that on?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoOh is Iraq's government stable again? Are the people not at risk of hunger? Will the sanctity of museums be observed now and in the future, uninterrupted? The Elgin marbles are safe in the British Museum. Would they have been safe, left where they were found, for 100 years? Being PC about antiquities is intellectually interesting. But practically, it means many antiquities will be broken up, lost or hidden.
- officemonkey 6y agoConsidering they were looted from the Parthenon in Athens, which is still standing, I would say "yes."
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThrough a world wars I and II, the various rebellions and coups, a civil war? No, very likely someone would have 'harvested' them to sell for food. Come on! The Nazis systematically plundered art treasures across Europe. After the war much of that was lost. There is not really much doubt on this.
- officemonkey 6y agoHalf of the marbles from the Parthenon survive in the Acropolis Museum. In other words, the Greeks know what they're doing. The Elgin Marbles were taken when the country was owned by the Ottoman Empire. I really wish you would do some research before spouting off with ill-informed opinions. The Nazis and Italians conquered Greece during WW2, they didn't take Acropolis marbles.
- chadlavi 6y agowhat a bizarre timeline we live in (edit: to be clear what I mean is that it's extremely bizarre that a discount tchochke store in the US would own an extremely precious Mesopotamian artifact in the first place, not bizarre that justice is actually being done about it)
- aaronbrethorst 6y agoIt's not that weird. The founder of Hobby Lobby is an evangelical Christian, among other things. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Green_(entrepreneur) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Green_(entrepreneur)
- chadlavi 6y agotbh that guy's whole deal only makes it weirder
- aaronbrethorst 6y agoI think that Green's whole deal is really bizarre and disturbing. This tablet sub-plot feels really on brand for him.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoI have to think it's because the Epic of Gilgamesh has a flood in it.
- ctdonath 6y agoNot weird. Chain owner has a HUGE collection of extremely precious religious/historical artifacts. I've seen it, staggering - a museum unto itself.
- selimthegrim 6y agoThis sounds like the beginning of a horror movie you'd find on Lifetime or Hallmark, but where the ancient Mesopotamian evil accepts Christ and sits down for tea and cakes with the children like in Narnia.
- davidw 6y ago"Ned Flanders comes into possession of an ancient evil stone tablet and makes Homer do his bidding"
- aaronbrethorst 6y agoSeems more likely that Ned Flanders would come into possession of an ancient, cursed monkey's paw...
- selimthegrim 6y agoClearly someone didn't see the episode with the re-neducation camps...
- selimthegrim 6y agoOr maybe JHU, given their financial exigency of late? http://washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/heavily-in-debt-newseum-considered-risky-strategy-to-improve-finances/2015/07/01/b5e94286-19e7-11e5-bd7f-4611a60dd8e5_story.html%3FoutputType%3Dcomment%26commentID%3Dwashingtonpost.com/ECHO/item/8a001840-11a1-4ecd-9d6c-f7797ebd39b6 http://washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/heavily-in-debt-ne...
- Apocryphon 6y agoIt's literally the beginning of The Exorcist
- grillvogel 6y agoweren't a lot of the remaining artifacts just getting destroyed recently anyway?
- iamleppert 6y agoIt's just going to go back there and be stolen again, so what's the point? At least where it is now it is protected and on display to the public.
- desireco42 6y agoThis NPR, source we should trust. It carefully avoids to say that tablet was stollen from Iraq during US invasion. Whole museums and collections were stollen during that time by advancing US soldiers and "contractors". I highly doubt HobbyLobby owners didn't know origin of this tablet.
- doktrin 6y agoSince the article claims the tablet was in London "in or before 2001" it couldn't have been looted during the 2003 invasion of Iraq.
- sandworm101 6y agoThe tablet is real? A bunch of the Hobby Lobby / Museum of the Bible scrolls turned out to be fake. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/dead-sea-scrolls-face-museum-of-the-bible-washington-artefacts-a8596636.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/dead-sea-s... "Hobby Lobby said that it was new to the world of antiquities when it began acquiring historical items for its Museum of the Bible in 2009 and made mistakes in relying on dealers and shippers who “did not understand the correct way to document and ship” them."
- dependenttypes 6y agoHere are some more similar cases: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archimedes_Palimpsest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archimedes_Palimpsest and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elgin_Marbles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elgin_Marbles
- ctdonath 6y agoNYTimes: "In a lawsuit filed on Tuesday, Hobby Lobby accused the auction house Christie’s of “deceitful and fraudulent conduct” in connection with an ancient tablet bearing a fragment of Gilgamesh. The suit claims “fraud and breach of express and implied warrant” in connection with the tablet, and seeks the return of what it paid for the tablet. In a statement on Tuesday, Christie’s said the lawsuit was related to an unidentified dealer’s admission of illegal activity “predating Christie’s involvement” with the tablet." Interesting how few are interested in the defense that Hobby Lobby was a victim.
- micmil 6y agoHas to do with Hobby Lobby's history of victimizing its workers and ALSO their history of doing illegal shit. https://www.npr.org/2018/06/28/623537440/hobby-lobbys-illegal-antiquities-shed-light-on-a-lost-looted-ancient-city-in-ira https://www.npr.org/2018/06/28/623537440/hobby-lobbys-illega... This is a two year old article about a different set of artifacts. They're hoarding shit that was stolen during wartime. Hobby Lobby are scumfuck pieces of shit and every last asshole involved in this needs to metaphorically burn.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>Interesting how few are interested in the defense that Hobby Lobby was a victim. They weren't. With this tablet, maybe they never had any solid reason to suspect it had been looted. This wasn't the only artifact they bought, other items had no documentation detailing their history and they made purchases after being warned that items were likely illegal. It's doubtful they tried very hard to verify this tablets history given their record. There are other criminals involved, but Hobby Lobby was not a victim.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 6y agoKinda like when you buy a used car at auction, but it turns out it was stolen.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago
- abiogenesis 6y agoI'm amazed that "[...] fragment of the oldest known creation tale" is only worth $1.6 million. What is even more amazing is its (recent) history: > The U.S. dealer bought several pieces, including the Gilgamesh tablet, for $50,350.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoEvery time that the fragment was sold their were at least concerns that it was stolen, which likely drove down the price.
- crazy_monkey 6y agoThe UK should learn something from this.
- johnmarinelli 6y agoHopefully Germany will do the same with the Bust of Nefertiti.
- AndyMcConachie 6y agoHow is this any different than basically everything in the British Museum?
- yters 6y agoAren't most museum pieces in the west pilfered? I say we send it all back.
- MH15 6y ago"The United States of America v. Approximately Four Hundred Fifty (450) Ancient Cuneiform Tablets" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hobby_Lobby_smuggling_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hobby_Lobby_smuggling_scandal
- Andrex 6y agoOne of my favorite random Wikipedia finds: "United States v. Approximately 64,695 Pounds of Shark Fins" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Approximately_64,695_Pounds_of_Shark_Fins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Approximately... In rem cases have fun titles in general. :D
- sschueller 6y agoWhile we are at it. The United Kingdom should return all the artifacts it stole from Egypt.