15 ms·
When I see about half my paycheck going to taxes it feels a bit rough. But then I think of stories like this, and how easily it could have been me with an illn
by magicalhippo 7y ago
When I see about half my paycheck going to taxes it feels a bit rough.
But then I think of stories like this, and how easily it could have been me with an illness requiring expensive medical treatment and possibly preventing me from working regular jobs.
And so I pay my tax with pleasure, knowing that if something were to happen to me or my fellow citizen, at least there wouldn't be millions of dollars in hospital bills to pay back and there would be aid for a home to avoid ending up on the streets.
- code_duck 7y agoAs someone else with serious medical problems which have been paid for by public health systems, the financial difficulties of which are compounded by losing your ability to pay once ill, thanks! I would note though, for the purposes of fairness, it's a small percentage of your taxes that go to paying for such programs versus things like the military and interest on debt.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoUS government healthcare spend is huge, it is not tiny compared to military. $1.1T according to this source in fiscal year 2018: https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/how-much-does-federal-government-spend-health-care https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/how-much-does-... This website states in 2018, the federal government spent $582B on Medicare, and $389B on Medicaid, plus all the tax exemption for employer sponsored health insurance and ACA subsidies to individual buyers, etc. https://www.thebalance.com/fy-2018-trump-federal-budget-request-4158794 https://www.thebalance.com/fy-2018-trump-federal-budget-requ... Defense and Homeland Security was only ~$630B or so.
- ccktlmazeltov 7y agoThat's because of private healthcare that prevent them from properly negotiating prices. If universal healthcare was a thing these costs would be much lower.
- AdrianB1 7y agoHow is that?
- QuixoticQuibit 7y agoNation-sized leverage. The same reason why equivalent pharmaceuticals are cheaper elsewhere in the world.
- barry-cotter 7y agoQuite. That’s why the US pays for more pharmaceutical and medical device R&D than anyone else. The US is where every pharmaceutical company makes the profits that incentivize further drug development.
- philjohn 7y agoOr, in the case of Valeant Pharmaceuticals they just jacked the prices up after buying smaller drug companies and getting rid of all the R&D teams ... that doesn't seem to have incentivized further drug development by them, did it?
- zaphar 7y agoYou are speaking of a specific anecdotal experience and he is talking about the industry in aggregate. Neither of you are invalidating the other's point. The actual facts are in support of the posters point: https://www.abpi.org.uk/facts-and-figures/science-and-innovation/worldwide-pharmaceutical-company-rd-expenditure-by-country/ https://www.abpi.org.uk/facts-and-figures/science-and-innova... But your example is a real occurrence of abuse under the US system.
- jfnixon 7y agoNation-sized leverage? Piffle. Pass a law that Big Pharma can't price higher in the US than the lowest price negotiated elsewhere. Boom, problem solved.
- shoo 7y agoTo add contrast, australia spends 32b on defence, 36b on education, 82b on health, 180b on social security & welfare, out of ~500b total government spend. https://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2019-04-03/federal-budget-2019-sliced-and-diced-interactive/10959808 https://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2019-04-03/federal-budget-201...
- treeman79 7y agoMy issues have been insanely expensive to figure out. But treatment has been very cheap now that I know the issues and what pills work. Main problem was being dismissed for 3 years and doctors not taking to each other. I can see what people start going to alternative medicine. One of the treatment options is a specialized diet. So all the crazy diet people are actually circling around valid treatment options. Health care can be done cheaper. But when a doctor has 5 minutes, there is only so much that can be done.
- Retric 7y agoThat 630B ish is figure is more spin than reality. Excluding say the coast guard is reasonable if you’re talking offensive military capacity but “Defense” should reasonably include CIA, NSA, border security, and anti terrorism expenditures etc. Further, related pensions and VA benefits are clearly part of the overall defense budget. Exact interest on past military spending is arguable, but those bills still need to be paid. PS: US healthcare expenditures is similarly a complex topic. Do you include the heath insurance costs of government contractors etc?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoNo matter how you cut, a very large portion of taxes paid goes towards healthcare. 30% for social security, 30% minimum for healthcare. Military and interest costs therefore are clearly not the bigger portions of spending. https://www.thebalance.com/u-s-federal-budget-breakdown-3305789 https://www.thebalance.com/u-s-federal-budget-breakdown-3305... > The government expects to spend $4.829 trillion in 2021.1 Almost 60% of that pays for mandated benefits such as Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. > Social Security will be the biggest expense, budgeted at $1.151 trillion. It's followed by Medicare at $722 billion and Medicaid at $448 billion.
- Retric 7y agoOverall I agree, but I am pointing out how numbers are framed is really important. For example this puts Defense spending at 1T and heathcare at 1.7T, while leaving out several categories of both. https://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year_spending_2020USbn_21bs2n#usgs302 https://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year_spending_2020USbn_... I am not saying any specific number is correct, but that 1T figure excludes military pensions and heath care excludes related research spending. Neither includes any debt payments from past spending or projections of future obligations. In the end it is actually possible to construct a number for each where federal defense spending is greater than federal healthcare spending, but again I don’t agree with such categorizations. PS: This gets back to the oldest trick in “cutting“ spending, define a portion as something else. Similarly, define a category of taxes as “income taxes“ so you can exclude payroll taxes when talking about them.
- john-radio 7y agoYou're assuming they're talking about America, but you're probably not talking to Americans, because: > if something were to happen to me or my fellow citizen, at least there wouldn't be millions of dollars in hospital bills to pay back and there would be aid for a home to avoid ending up on the streets Not trying to be an asshole, but that's not a description of the American system.
- code_duck 7y agoIt depends on your financial situation and what state you live in. Most of the places I’ve lived, such as Minnesota or Oregon, do have systems for emergency medical assistance. They also currently have great insurance for people who truly can’t afford it. People in middle income ranges are the worst off, though. Personally, I was just hospitalized with a bout of diabetic ketoacidosis, probably just a day away from going into a coma. I haven’t even had to see a bill. It was 100% paid by the state and federal programs. If I hadn’t set up insurance before going to the doctor, though, I’d have received ridiculously high bills, probably been provided less service, and it would be up to me to get it paid back. I had a situation before where I went to the ER while an insurance application was pending, and then after it was approved and I provided my info, the private hospital dilly dallied and sent it to collections anyway.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I would note though, for the purposes of fairness, it's a small percentage of your taxes that go to paying for such programs versus things like the military and interest on debt. No, its not. US public healthcare spending (which in most states is the lion’s share of public welfare spending, and is also on the US is more than defense spending and is, in fact, pretty typical as a share of GDP, high as a share of taxes (because of the light US tax burden), and enormous per capita compared to other industrialized nations. Its small as a share of total national healthcare spending compared to other countries, because we have to even more private spending on top of it, and the whole healthcare system (or, rather, the literally hundreds of mutually-interfering public and private healthcare systems) is the single most inefficient healthcare delivery system in the world, but we spend plenty of money on it, just not well.
- kulig 7y agoI live in a country with plenty of socialized services, and when I see stories like this it seems to me like it's everyone for themselves in the USA. Seems kinda bleak.
- apta 7y agoIt's good and important to have a proper function healthcare system. However, we shouldn't fall into the false dichotomy fallacy. We don't have to pay 50% of our pay checks in taxes in order to provide good healthcare for all. It's just that some greedy people at the top will have to give up some of what they're making now.
- ccktlmazeltov 7y agoIf half your paycheck is going to taxes you must have a bunch of $$$, I personally make around 300k/year and I feel like I'm not paying that much taxes. I could be paying much more and still live pretty comfortable, it's pretty outrageous.
- ciupicri 7y agoYou can donate money to the US Government if you feel that you're not giving it enough. See https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.html https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.h...
- nloladze 7y agoyeah we already have that, it's called "lobbying"
- ccktlmazeltov 7y agoI'd be happy if everyone gave more, I don't believe in donation. I believe the government should be funded to work for the public. Refusing to fund the government is why we're in this.
- malwarebytess 7y agoAh yes, the obligate vacant comment about donating to the Federal Government when there's talk of taxes being too low on the wealthy. Get a new line. The problems in this country, including the mess that is the tax system, cannot be solved by snarky comments like "donate your money if you think taxes are too low." They require a longitudinal and deep response.
- rayiner 7y agoThe problems in this country also cannot be solved by empty rhetoric about “taxes being too low on the wealthy.” Taxes on the wealthy in the US aren’t dramatically lower than in Europe. The top tax bracket in Germany is 45%, versus 37% + state. So if you live in any of the 9 states with a top state bracket of 8% or higher, including New York and California, the top income tax bracket is actually lower in Germany. Capital gains taxes in Germany are also similar accounting for state capital gains taxes. So how does Germany pay for its expansive welfare state? It has a 42% bracket that kicks in at 57,000 euro. In California, the marginal dollar income tax at that level is just 26% (federal plus state). It also has a 20% VAT. In both Germany and the US, the vast majority of income is earned by the bottom 99%. In the US, we don’t tax those people enough. (Or we tax them what they want to be taxed. I can’t help but notice that while half the country wants European-style social services, nobody is proposing European-style taxes on people making under six figures, or a VAT. Even Sanders promised not to raise taxes on people making below $250,000. The math just doesn’t work. Americans—the bottom 99% that makes 80% of all income—have chosen to be taxed less than Europe in return for less social services than Europe.)
- klenwell 7y agoI think the actual quote is a little different, but I like this version: I like to pay taxes. With them, I buy civilization. https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/17105-i-like-to-pay-taxes-with-them-i-buy-civilization https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/17105-i-like-to-pay-taxes-w...
- xondono 7y agoI pay 50% of my shitty income in taxes and then have to pay for health insurance on top of that because public health here is useless. Public health is not a panacea, although I’m happy for the people who get a good deal out of it.
- amelius 7y agoThe fact that you are making that much money is without doubt also something you have to thank society for. Would you be able to make the same amount of money in every other country, and without the sacrifices made by other people over the course of history? This is also something to keep in mind.
- rexpop 7y ago"making that much money" is not a beneficial end unto itself, and is really only valuable in a particular socioeconomic context. You can't eat money.
- jerome-jh 7y agoFrom this side of the Altantic, it looks like the US economy is organized so that the lower working class only earns just enough to live. No wonder they are homeless when illness, disability or bad luck strikes. I am not implying this applies to OP.
- PragmaticPulp 7y agoI worked at an international company where we frequently had employees from other countries visit the US for a while. Some even chose to relocate to the US. These were almost all technical people, raised on the Internet, social media, and discussions in comment sections. It was fascinating to see how bad they expected America to be according to Internet comments and news articles. Many of them were shocked to realize that we do have social safety nets, disability programs, heavily subsidized or government healthcare for lower incomes, and so on. I’ll be the first to admit that our systems require improvement and are far from perfect, but at the same time it’s not the dystopian society as portrayed on Reddit’s front page or in certain media outlets day in and day out. I can’t speak to the OP’s situation because obviously we don’t know the particular details, but given the mention of nearly $10 million of medical treatment it’s possible they were referring to a new or experimental treatment that wasn’t yet covered by traditional healthcare options. We have a lot of cutting-edge and experimental treatments in the United States, but insurance usually refuses to cover expensive experimental treatments until the evidence is sufficient to support their use. For rare disorders, it can take an extremely long time to collect enough evidence to reach that tipping point. It should be noted that many nationalized healthcare programs won’t cover or offer these treatments for the same evidentiary reasons, so I wouldn’t assume this was a uniquely American problem without further details.
- ido 7y agoI don't buy it, due to first-hand & second-hand experiences of friends and relatives I have in the US. Let me give you one example: my friend(and at the time business partner)'s wife got cancer in the US. It was fairly "mundane"/common cancer that got treated and everything was alright at the end. He was working as a software developer (normal employee, not self-employed - our venture was a side project) with the aforementioned "good health insurance" well paid professional middle-class Americans get. At the end of the ordeal he was stuck with a $65k bill (presumably that's just the tip of iceberg and insurance paid more). Years later I had a malignant tumor here in Germany. Again everything is fine at the end, but it was in many ways a worse case than my friend's wife (due to where the tumor was) & I spent several weeks in a (very nice) hospital in Berlin. I also get an MRI every 6 months to keep track of the situation. I paid a grand total of ~€500 despite being self-employed at the time (so I only had standard public insurance everyone in Germany gets). My twice-yearly MRIs are free. When I was diagnosed with the tumor they offered me an appointment for surgery for 3 days later (I ended up taking it a week later than that as I wanted to get a 2nd opinion). Neither mine nor my friend's experiences are exceptions.
- quotz 7y agoOr perhaps you could just donate that much money to a non-profit that takes care of people in unfortunate circumstances like this
- duckMuppet 7y agohttps://www.econtalk.org/vanessa-williamson-on-taxes-and-read-my-lips https://www.econtalk.org/vanessa-williamson-on-taxes-and-rea...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nojvek 7y agoShould have specified what country. In US, that pay check is more likely going to help the military complex build more weapons than hospitals provide for the needy. In US, poor people are seen as worker bees who just get enough to live and have an illusion of freedom.