12 ms·
Solar’s Future is Insanely Cheap
- clairity 7y agonice application of the learning curve, a model taught in strategy and operations courses in business school. basically every model from around 2010 badly miscalculated the learning coefficient of the solar industry. apparently some forecasts are still badly calculating it.
- greglindahl 7y agoThe part that boggles the mind is that the forecasts are still terribly wrong, in the same direction, 10 years later.
- frede 7y agoThe forecasts from the IEA are my favourites, predicting a decline in PV expansion every year. https://www.pv-magazine.com/2018/11/20/iea-versus-solar-pv-reality/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2018/11/20/iea-versus-solar-pv-r...
- jmelloy 7y agoThe IEA forecast has been so wrong it suggests malice.
- ksec 7y agoI dont understand how you could continue apply learning curve , do we expect solar panel price to fall forever? And labour as well as land cost to fall ? Some of those are fixed. Even if Labour and Solar are free, you will still have to paid for land. In a way I think this is quit optimistic projection of solar.
- undershirt 7y agoIs solar just a stopgap tech? Like, do they still require fossil fuel energy to create, not to mention maintain and rebuild? And I know we’re now strip mining the ocean for battery metals. I don’t yet sense the sustainability in this amid all this economic hand-waving of “it’s getting cheaper”. (forgive my tone, i have a hard time of making sense of the big picture of renewables, hoping to eventually see how it actually fits into a utopic idea of a “closed-loop economy”) I’m reminded here a bit of Ted Chiang’s short story, Exhalation, where the people devise clever ways to try to put air back in the ground without using more than they’re sequestering. I hope our situation is better than that.
- Barrin92 7y agoI'm not sure about the resource costs of solar in particular but the question is a very salient one. Vaclav Smil has a great piece on this. "What I see when I see a wind turbine" "the quest for renewable electricity generation. And yet, although they exploit the wind, which is as free and as green as energy can be, the machines themselves are pure embodiments of fossil fuels. • Large trucks bring steel and other raw materials to the site, earth-moving equipment beats a path to otherwise inaccessible high ground, large cranes erect the structures, and all these machines burn diesel fuel. So do the freight trains and cargo ships that convey the materials needed for the production of cement, steel, and plastics. For a 5-megawatt turbine, the steel alone averages 150 metric tons for the reinforced concrete foundations, 250 metric tons for the rotor hubs and nacelles (which house the gearbox and generator), and 500 metric tons for the towers.[...] For a long time to come—until all energies used to produce wind turbines and photovoltaic cells come from renewable energy sources—modern civilization will remain fundamentally dependent on fossil fuels." http://vaclavsmil.com/wp-content/uploads/15.WINDTURBINE.pdf http://vaclavsmil.com/wp-content/uploads/15.WINDTURBINE.pdf
- lallysingh 7y agoSounds like a bullshit purity test.
- Barrin92 7y agoIt's not a bullshit purity test at all. It highlights the extremely neglected costs in raw material and non-electrifiable infrastructure that is required to produce materials that are nominally 'green'. In some cases it's questionable if some green technologies actually are a net positive at all. There is a strong 'abundance' bias implicit in articles by people like Ramez Naam, who push so strongly for green energy production because they don't want to consider the very obvious alternative, dematerialisation and reduction of energy consumption. People like Naam still categorically hang onto a growth narrative so they tend to neglect the downsides of the solutions they provide.
- 7y ago
- frede 7y agoEnergy is cheap, power is expensive - you can already get energy for free sometimes on the intraday market, but you still pay if you need delivery at a certain time and the grid fees for peak power consumption stay expensive. I am looking forward to Tesla's million-mile battery!
- Retric 7y agoAnother aspect of this is the cost of the physical solar cells have dropped low enough that other costs have become significant. This is pushing companies to increase efficiency which opens the door for other applications. A hypothetical cheap ~30% efficient solar panel could add something like 40 miles of range per day to a car in ideal conditions. That starts to look actually useful vs a simple gimmick.
- _-david-_ 7y ago>A hypothetical cheap ~30% efficient solar panel could add something like 40 miles of range per day to a car in ideal conditions. Does this take into consideration the increased weight of the solar panel and any additional equipment?
- andy_ppp 7y agoCould it not be built into the roof directly! This is a great idea as presumably people who don’t use their car a lot need not leave it charging permanently and if you run out of battery you can just wait (if it’s sunny enough).
- _-david-_ 7y agoI am not positive but I am guessing that solar panels as the roof would weight more than the regular car material? I am not really an expert on electricity but there could also be additional equipment involved as well (inverters, transformers, etc).
- Retric 7y agoThe light collecting portion of solar panels is extremely light weight. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B082FCZ4MD/ref=emc_b_5_t?th=1 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B082FCZ4MD/ref=emc_b_5_t?th=1 59.2 by 26.5 inches or ~1 square meter Weight: 6.2 lbs. If you looking at 12 square meters of space that’s 75 pounds though an integrated system would have plenty of options to save weight. Solar panels are DC as are batteries so you don’t need an inverter.
- lettergram 7y agoDo we really need a “2020” by the title?
- ascorbic 7y agoIt's in the title of the original post, to distinguish from similar posts in 2011 and 2015
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoI'm actually quite shocked at how much energy is produced by solar, especially when compared to residential wind turbines. Panels are efficient, and when it's sunny, you're juicing. The real challenge is of course bringing down cost of storage, which is the key to make solar systems efficient (not just cheap).
- Scoundreller 7y ago> residential wind turbines Wind has a scalability problem. Residentially, it's only a good sell as a backup supply for when solar isn't cutting it to hopefully prevent generator use. And even that's a tough economic argument. Towers have huge economies of scale, both in total size and height. So the turbines just keep getting bigger and bigger because it's more and more cost effective.
- somewhereoutth 7y agoIf my understanding is correct there is curious difference in perceived scale with kinetic vs thermal energy. Based on a a rowing machine's advertised metrics, I calculated you could row across the English channel on half a packet of chocolate biscuits.
- ryanwaggoner 7y agoPut another way: I’ll have to spend an hour on the treadmill to work off the calories in this burger.
- burlesona 7y agoThis sounds interesting but I don't really understand, could you elaborate?
- somewhereoutth 7y ago1 biscuit = 85 cal 1000m rowing = 60 cal [1] English Channel = 35km (narrowest point) 35 * 60 / 85 = 24.7 biscuits! [1] https://darkhorserowing.com/how-to-translate-calories-to-meters https://darkhorserowing.com/how-to-translate-calories-to-met...
- maheart 7y agoI recently watched the documentary "Planet of the Humans". For context, the writer of the documentary is an environmentalist. One of the stated points was that solar and wind cannot be relied upon 24/7 -- to account for the lack of reliability, you need to have a backup power generator (e.g. coal power plant) running. The thing about coal plants (does it apply to natural gas plants too?) is that if you "idle" them, then have to ramp them up to feed demand, then later ramp them down -- it's a very inefficient way of running them. Now based on my understanding, it might be more efficient to just run the coal plant (or natural gas planet?) 24x7, in which case you've just added waste with the use of solar/wind. How much truth is there to this?
- qaq 7y ago0? You can have utility scale storage and Nuclear as backup
- ktal 7y agoDamn shame we haven't been investing in nuclear over the past few decades. Now when we need it most, it's too late.
- epistasis 7y agoNuclear is one of the few technologies that has a negative learning curve. As we improve designs, it seems to get more expensive rather than less. There was a brief window in the 1970s where US nuclear construction projects were finishing on time. But the utility industry had planned for waaaaay too much new capacity. So when all the construction projects with poor execution, that struggled to complete and therefore came in way over budget, finally came online in the early 80s, they were financial disasters in a scale that nearly bankrupted several utilities. Since then, utilities lost their appetite. And there's basically no way for us to replace the 400 or so reactors in the world that eMate nearing end of life. However, I'm not sure we will need nuclear. With how cheap wind and solar are getting, far faster than anybody anticipated, we have finally found the technologies that may some day provide energy "too cheap to meter." However, like nuclear they are not dispatchable (except for some designs in France), so if we want to power a grid we either need to overbuild capacity by quite a bit, or use energy storage. There's a cost trade off for the two that depends on how cheap storage gets, and how cheap extra capacity is, and how cheap transmission is from an area with different weather that day. (For example, one can imagine building 2x of panel capacity over the amount of inverter capacity on a solar install, so that even on cloudy days you can chug along at near full energy output... it all depends on the cost trade offs.) And as fast an solar is getting cheap, far beyond expectations, so is lithium ion storage. And there are many chemistries with high specific energies (and thus unsuitable for vehicles), that we are just now dipping our toes into. Nuclear would be a nice tool to have, if it was competitive with other technologies, but it's going to be decades before it can prove itself and establish a positive track record for deployment. Utilities have been burned too many times by financial dumpster fires.
- Animats 7y agoIt's now reached the point that "energy producer" lobbyists are lobbying Trump to keep banks from refusing to finance fossil fuel projects.[1][2] They're now a bad long-term investment. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/reuters/2020/05/08/us/08reuters-health-coronavirus-energy.html https://www.nytimes.com/reuters/2020/05/08/us/08reuters-heal... [2] http://archive.is/QSPle http://archive.is/QSPle
- sephamorr 7y agoPower markets are more complicated than most people realize. One thing to note is that solar power can be cheaper than gas, but still not be economic. The fact of the matter is that an intermittent kWh is not as valuable as an on-demand reliable kWh to a utility who's number 1 priority is reliability. Even as solar is acquired at lower and lower prices, if evening power is generated by expensive and inefficient gas turbines, the customer might not see costs go down (and emissions might not go down either!). Solar is clearly economic in many markets, but we'll never get grid emissions in a place like California down much more without storage.
- CapitalistCartr 7y agoSolar all day, NG all night would be a major improvement over our current system. Especially as batteries get better.
- sephamorr 7y agoDepending on where you are, that's pretty close to what's happened. Right now (4pm), the California ISO is generating 73% from renewables+hydro, 7% nuclear, and the balance gas. Naturally, the night replaces solar with gas. This is largely how California has reduced electricity emissions to their current levels.
- bananabreakfast 7y agoAnd that nuclear power is just from a single plant!
- Gibbon1 7y agoAlways gets me that the above is a no brainer. But people married to the argument that we can't have renewables until we solve the storage problem just refuse to even consider it. Disconcerting.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoNG is still extraordinarily high carbon. "A little better than coal (if you ignore the pipeline and wellhead losses)" is not something we can settle for given the seriousness of climate change. We need 24/7 low-carbon power. Fracked natural gas for entire nights (recall in winter nights are quite long) is not an option.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ph0rque 7y agoThis tells me that until fossil plants are mostly shut down (and perhaps afterward), we will continue to have negative electricity prices at times. It might be a profitable idea to buy extra energy storage capacity to get paid for storing energy at certain times, then sell it when it is high demand.
- rootusrootus 7y agoProfitable for the first guy. Not profitable for anyone after enough people try to get a piece of that action. And maybe not profitable for anyone ever if the power company themselves installs enough storage capacity.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI just wish the negative electricity prices reached the non-industrial consumer. If it reached me, I'll have an Arduino controlled hot water heater, furnace and fridge/freezer dynamically turning on/off to take the most advantage of prices pronto.
- tialaramex 7y agoIn some areas you can buy electricity this way, but the other end of the deal bites you, so beware of that. When it seems like you might die from the heat but the price charged is $8.50 per kWh how much longer do you want to wait before switching on the AC? (If you live somewhere it never gets hot, figure on the same but for a midwinter freeze and deciding when to pay for your resistive circuit heat pump boost)
- Scoundreller 7y agoI figure it all averages out. But when I pay an average price, I have no incentive to lower demand when prices are high or raise demand when prices are low, contributing to even higher average prices.
- discordance 7y agoThere’s an Australian startup that sells electricity at wholesale prices to consumers https://www.amberelectric.com.au/ https://www.amberelectric.com.au/
- maallooc 7y agoCheap for the economy, not so cheap for the environment. These kind of articles rarely calculate the price to dispose old solar panels. Our country recently found that current methods for disposing solar panels pose a grave danger to the environment and imposed strict regulations for it. As a result the price for disposal quadrupled. Because consumers of the solar panel, which are mostly individuals, can't afford those prices, the government is preparing for a law that charges manufactures up front for the price of disposal. It is assumed that solar will be more expensive than natural gas after the changes.
- pfdietz 7y ago"Grave danger" from what?
- maallooc 7y agoThat just dumping old solar panels into the landfill will cause Cu, Pb, As, Cr to spread into the ground effectively contaminating it. The government is trying to ban dumping it and trying to impose a responsibility to manufacturers to properly recycle and decontaminate it, which will cost about 4~5 times more than dumping.
- pfdietz 7y agoOh no, copper! Chromium! Next you're going to tell me of the fiendish plot to incorporate these into pots and pans to poison us all. There is no reason to include As in PV. There are anti-renewable propaganda screeds that pretend otherwise ("look! GaAs PV cells are a thing, therefore all PV uses As!") That leaves lead. Lead has been used for connections, but it is being phased out, not least because of EU environmental regulations. The PV cells themselves do not need lead. I suspect you are just repeating anti-renewable lies here.
- maallooc 7y agoActually it does matter if it's not properly processed. Government research found those metals were contaminating landfills, and imposed restrictions. If you are interested in the facts, here are one. I believe in research done by my pro-PV government and scientists, not environmental shills and anti-science PV aficionados like you and this article. http://knrec.or.kr/file/2018%EC%8B%A0%EC%9E%AC%EC%83%9D%EC%97%90%EB%84%88%EC%A7%80%EB%B0%B1%EC%84%9C.pdf http://knrec.or.kr/file/2018%EC%8B%A0%EC%9E%AC%EC%83%9D%EC%9...
- deepnotderp 7y agoWith launch costs set to drop aggressively I wonder if space based solar becomes viable sooner than expected. Iirc the NASA estimate was something like $200-500/kg launch costs. I wonder if concentrated solar in the form of thin mirrors can change that.
- lachlan-sneff 7y agoMusk's most recent estimate of the eventual cost per kg on starship was 10 usd/kg. He may be considered an unreliable source at this point, however.
- swayvil 7y agoSolar's future may be cheap but capitalism's future is always going to be pricey.
- gyogyo 7y agoMaking solar panels require massive amount of energy. If built in China, these panels are made with electricity from coal. They don't have a great C02 budget.
- timbit42 7y agoToday's solar panels are efficient enough that even if they are produced using electricity from coal, by the end of their life, they've reduced CO2 emissions by more than what the coal produced to manufacture them.
- dave333 7y agoI thought the old lie with statistics trick of starting the Y axis above zero was debunked in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s etc. The blog name above the X axis and gray shading make it look like the costs are approaching zero.