14 ms·
I feel like there is a decade of guillotines in the future that they are either not seeing or are looking way past. But then I've always been cynical about the
by JKCalhoun 7y ago
I feel like there is a decade of guillotines in the future that they are either not seeing or are looking way past.
But then I've always been cynical about the growing divide between the uber-wealthy and the other 99% of this country.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoGuillotines might have worked well in the past, but with modern weapons and technology, you can use a much smaller portion of the population to suppress a much larger portion of the population. You can pay 10% of the population well enough that they support the top 0.01%, and the top 10% can pay the next 20% to 30% well enough or provide a sufficient probability to move up (or illusion) that they are incentivized to help suppress the remaining 60%.
- hnarn 7y agoAlso known as the "Tyranny of the Majority". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority
- chrisco255 7y agoUh, you can't just pay massive numbers of the population without the wealth creation in the first place. We do not have some centralized salary authority that pays people based on loyalty to some arbitrary payment distribution scheme. This is completely contrived.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIt doesn't need to be centrally managed, the situation can emerge organically just based on how people are incentivized. Especially with the impact computers and scaling at low marginal costs has and how much more one person's labor can be worth compared to another person's labor.
- DSingularity 7y agoOh how splendid.
- sidlls 7y agoThat cuts both ways, so to speak. Drones and even more advanced technology can replace guillotines as easily as it can be used to have a smaller police force of the kind you mention. I think some people don't quite understand what people are capable of when they are truly desperate. Right now, in most of the western world, people aren't at that point. But when they get there, billionaires' ability to hide on islands or yachts or whatever won't stop the inevitable. Any violent revolution is going to be very bad, even for the very wealthy who think they're insulated/protected.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoSeems very difficult to evade location and transaction tracking, both which governments have very easy access to, but the rank and file do not.
- freehunter 7y agoThat’s assuming a French Revolution style uprising, which is probably unrealistic. What is very realistic, however, is an increase in “lone wolf” terrorist attacks targeted at rich and/or powerful people. You don’t need a thousand people rolling a guillotine down the street when one person with an off-the-shelf drone could inflict just as much damage. Sure the police would find them quick, but one thing the American military is really bad at is fighting an enemy that doesn’t dress in military gear and shoot back with military weapons in military formation. We’ve seen it recently, where a single man shut down CNN and I think some other news stations just mailing poorly-made bombs to the media and politicians. We’ve seen it decades ago with Oklahoma City. Could a Western population stand up against their government in a real fight? No. Could they inflect the same amount of damage without actually having to stand and fight? We’ve seen it before.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoNobody ever won a war of occupation without local support. I have no doubt the US population could stand up to it's government but with the current levels of polarization I don't think that's a realistic scenario.
- danieltillett 7y agoThis approach works well particularly well if the masses are decapitate by identifying anyone with high intelligence and “inviting” them into the 10% via education. Angry masses without a leader are not going to do anything.
- kulig 7y agoThey will only if they get desperate or frustrated enough. Leaders always emerge.
- tinco 7y agoI think you're overestimating the value of high intelligence. I don't believe we have any accurate means of identifying potent leaders, not even a 10% slice they might belong to.
- eanzenberg 7y agoStrip the wealthy if their wealth and most will probably become wealthy again. If you don’t call it intelligence what would you call it.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago> most will probably become wealthy again. Source?
- magicsmoke 7y agoThis sounds like something that a study of Chinese upper-class and their 1949 pre-revolution family history could shed some very interesting results on.
- arghnoname 7y agoThere's a book that attempts to look at this called, "The Son Also Rises." It tracks wealth by surnames and argues that the ability to gain (or regain) wealth is inheritable. This thesis is in contradiction to some of the ways I've experienced the world, but it is a source supporting the parent's claim. For my own political inclinations I'd be happy to hear many others that support the opposite claim.
- coliveira 7y agoMissiles are similar weapons may be useful against other countries (remember Vietnam, however), but they will not stop revolts inside the country itself. What would the US government do if 80% of the city of New York decided to turn against the government? Throw an atomic bomb in the city? Their time may be running out.
- ccffpphh 7y agoWhat would New York even do? People here don't believe in firearms, let alone violence. In reality the city would starve within a couple weeks due to siege/blockades if it really united and tried to revolt.
- wbazant 7y agoKropotkin's Bread Book is about exactly that! He claims any revolution will be as successful as its ability to feed everyone, and tries to outline a path to it.
- sudosysgen 7y agoTo name it, "The Conquest of Bread". Very good read, kept me from snoozing off in my CS classes :p
- Supermancho 7y ago> People here don't believe in firearms, I don't know what that means. Guns are highly correlated with leathality and people believe in them completely. Generally, a population may not want to have possession of guns. That quickly changes for a large percentage in survival mode. Effectively, many criminals are perpetually in survival mode.
- scarface74 7y agoIt’s not like police haven’t resorted to bombing its own citizens before. https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/8/8/20747198/philadelphia-bombing-1985-move https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/8/8/20747198/philadel... The entire Civil Rights movement is littered with examples of a police state and civilian mobs shooting, lynching, using dogs, water hoses, etc against its own citizens. It doesn’t take much to rile people up against “them” and get people to look the other way or even participate.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoThis is almost a kind of income equalizing. The top fraction of a % will pay a bit more to the people they are bribing not to kill them and so forth. The smart thing is the people at the top pay it all, so they control it.
- sudosysgen 7y agoThere is a much simpler alternative. The general strike.
- rcpt 7y agoMarket could still go up. The Fed just has to agree to print money until the strike ends.
- sudosysgen 7y agoWhich will be very useful when the utility workers of the stock exchange strike and the lights turn off.
- kart23 7y agoNot when half the country is living paycheck to paycheck.
- droptablemain 7y agoMutual-aid networks could be set up to subsist strikers
- Glyptodon 7y agoYeah, people always say "Why should I pay more in taxes? It's not fair, they should be flat and the same for everybody!" and I'm always like "Do you have just as much to lose in a French Revolution scenario? You should be happy to pay more if it leads to more social stability."
- eanzenberg 7y agoThe top 1% pay something like half our taxes. What share do you think is fairer?
- justicezyx 7y agoHow about equally to their share of national income?
- kalleboo 7y agoIt should be in proportion to how many % of the wealth they own. So more like 90%
- eanzenberg 7y agoThe 1% earn 36% of the income[1] as of 2016, and pay 37% of the taxes[2]. Everyone happy now? [1] https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-inequality/a-guide-to-statistics-on-historical-trends-in-income-inequality https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-inequality/a-guide... [2] https://taxfoundation.org/summary-latest-federal-income-tax-data-2018-update/ https://taxfoundation.org/summary-latest-federal-income-tax-...
- eanzenberg 7y agoGet rid of the wealthy and enjoy becoming another Venezuela!
- malandrew 7y agoWhile you're not really wrong in your assessment, please take the time to post a more substantive, less flamebaity comment.
- eanzenberg 7y agoGet rid of the wealthy and enjoy becoming the USSR?
- Redoubts 7y agoYou mean go from a peasant nation to first (object,man,woman,space station) in space?
- itsuart 7y agoYeah, the one that begun with bloodbath of the Civil War, purges, forced collectivization, continued through disastrous wars and GULAGs only to die 80 years later with social degeneration of unprecedented levels. That one USSR, yes.
- mcv 7y agoThis is something a lot of people forget: Russia before the revolution was not a modern, industrialised nation, it was a country still half stuck in the middle ages. I don't want to defend the atrocities and oppression of the Soviet system, but it has been very effective at industrialising a backwards peasant country. (In fact, Marx considered Russia the least likely candidate for a communist revolution; it would start in England or Germany.)
- mirimir 7y agoSocial chaos, perhaps. But the 1% aren't much at risk, because they have enough resources and can isolate themselves well enough. It's the upper middle class that may get seriously injured.
- alpineidyll3 7y agoNot disagreeing. But the proximal reason for this is political. Inequality is not intrinsic to capital markets. Capital markets are merely not a solution for inequality, and require some modicum of intelligent regulation to function properly. Instead the Us is rife with regulatory capture, unenforced antitrust laws, etc. If the democracy were representative, and the public informed, things would be better.
- RickJWagner 7y agoAt least in the US, today's poor have smart phones, air conditioning, refrigerators, and better health than any other time in history. Comfort-wise, things are at historic 'best' levels. Why would anyone in their right mind give up their life for a revolution under these conditions?
- jotm 7y agoPresumably that would be after they lose all that because they can't pay for it anymore. Then again, judging by the downvote happy people here, there may not be enough braincells left for a successful revolution.
- tsimionescu 7y agoToday in the US the working poor have cheap entertainment and no money to take vacations, no way of paying for even a 400USD unexpected payment, often rely on the state to eat (food stamps),and can't afford any Healthcare. There may be reasons some of you will want a revolution.
- Natsu 7y agoI don't see how they would help. There's a common refrain among Reddit socialists and whatnot about the rich sitting on some mythical "pile of resources" that needs to be redistributed, but even if you suppose that we guillotine the rich I don't think the poor can eat stock certificates. What are they going to do if they dismantle, say, Wal-Mart? Now all the people who worked there have no jobs and the people who shopped there have one less source of goods. Sure, we might be fine without it due to the alternatives, but once you go down that road, you find out that you've ripped up a complex system of logistics that moved goods to places that people wanted them and that you don't have any sort of replacement planned. But that's usually what happens in these revolutions, they rip everything apart and then try to replace it with something better and fail. But next time will always be better, right?
- tsimionescu 7y agoHow about ripping Wal-Mart apart and replacing it with what existed before - many different shops, each owned by a local person, and many different logsitics networks, each also owned by someone in the area? People on the right often claim to be for the free market and for small, decentralized government, but then turn around and love big, centrally planned conglomerates,just as long as they are owned by share-holders and are ruled with an authoritarian hand.
- chii 7y agoeach small store will have little bargaining power when it comes to their suppliers. therefore, each little store will end up paying "market price". Eventually, the small stores join up together to bargain for a wholesale price lower than market price to their suppliers, and thus earn a higher margin. ala, what you see at walmart today.
- KozmoNau7 7y agoWhat you see with Walmart is singular entity, owned by an obscenely rich family, who can strong-arm any supplier into accepting their terms. They have the massive capital to build a megamart anywhere they want, and have it run at a loss for however long it takes to drive everyone out of business. This absolutely kills local businesses and funnels money out of the area, leaving only the low wages paid to the local Walmart staff. And because it's Walmart job or no job, people have no bargaining power. When small businesses form cooperatives for collective bargaining, they keep ownership local, they keep jobs local, and they keep the stores in the city centres running, which is better for pedestrian and public transit access, not to mention cafe life and local bars/eateries. Compare this to a megamart outside the city where you have no choice but to drive there. You get everything there and have no real reason to go into the city. As a consequence, city life dies out. Coops and associations work with the local shop owners and communities, whereas megacorps trample and replace them with cookie cutter faceless megamarts.
- partiallypro 7y agoI want to know why this "guillotine" thing has become so big recently? It has largely been Bernie/DSA people. I find it a bit disturbing. I've seen even very innocent things like simply being a landlord as "guillotine" worthy on social media. This is pre-COVID. While most landlords are actually middle class people trying to make a side income. I don't think people actually know what they are asking for, they want revenge on a perceived (false) notion, not reform to make it better; it's a very dangerous path. I would bet if the far right were making this type of threat, it wouldn't be brushed under the rug.
- taneq 7y agoIt seems popular among certain sociopolitical groups to see other people getting nice things and feel entitled to getting those same nice things yourself, without regard for any effort expended or risks taken by the first group. It's pure "you have, I see, I want, I should be able to take".
- gitrog 7y agoI honestly believe your thinking here is one of the biggest misunderstandings of our time. Is it really so hard for you to believe that the majority of constituents in these groups want equality rather than them being envious of others' wealth?
- truculent 7y agoI suggest you try a little harder to understand things before you comment on them lest you be mistaken for a fool
- mcv 7y agoI've always assumed it's meant firmly tongue-in-cheek, but it's very morbid humour. But it's also a reminder of how powerless people in the past still managed to take action to rectify injustices, even if it happened in an overly brutal manner. In free, democratic societies, people should have more power to create the change society needs, but it doesn't seem to be working. But it's also a reminder that if the powerful people in society offer too much resistance to the change the people need, at some point the only way to get that change is by extreme overreaction. Personally I'd rather see the revolution happening by the soap box or the ballot box rather than the ammo box, but when media and voting systems get gamed and corrupted while people's rights and needs keep getting trampled upon, at some point a more violent solution may become unavoidable. But that's going to be very hard to steer and have many harmful side effects.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI loathe the guillotine rhetoric - did they all sleep through the rest of history class and that it ends with massacres of innocent people not even tenuously connected and getting a fucking emperor? Really it is an all too common attitude - they don't want to fix anything or even think; they just want to feel good about hurting people.
- bosswipe 7y agoThe Anciene Regime ceased to exist and that was a good thing. Many revolutions require violence but that doesn't mean they're never worth it. Nobody could have predicted Napoleon but he was still much better than the monarchy.