32 ms·
PC games are fighting a new surge of cheaters and hackers
- Jonnax 7y agoCheating in online gaming is prevalent. I think there's a lot of people that find the enjoyment of it so there's a captive market for people to sell cheats. But I also wonder about competitiveness when it comes to people playing with others with better than average hardware. Like someone who has a 240hz monitor and the performance to back it up versus someone with a low power slim laptop. Then consoles could be considered a level playing field. Except for Pro variants of the console. And also there seems to be fancier controllers with extra buttons on the rear side. Of course adding cheating to the mix. Personally I have no interest in playing online multiplayer games. But that's just me.
- kroltan 7y agoNot really, just like a beginner painter using the finest unicorn-hair brushes or whatever would not be able to paint the Mona Lisa, "gaming" hardware gives a very marginal benefit, that is better taken advantage of when you actually have the game skill. For all but the highest ranks, it does not make much of an actual difference. Most games have some sort of skill ceiling, or at least narrow bands of clustered players. Hardware will put you slightly above competitors of the same cluster, but will not by itself enable you to climb to the next cluster. This is evident in cross-platform games, where in casual or non-professional competitive play, a good console player can still beat a slightly less good fully-geared PC player, despite the 30fps and controller "handicaps".
- spery 7y agoPeople playing with better than average HW is not such a big issue. It could mean a bit for the absolute top tier competitors, but that's under 0.01% player-base and for certain genres (FPS primarily). Cheating however affects anyone and is much more frustrating to play against than vs really good players. Being outplayed have its merits (you can learn something), but being killed by cheaters feels, well, cheated. It's just waste of time and energy.
- rasz 7y agoNew surge of bad programmers is a more apt title, or "We gave game clients absolute control and you wont believe what happened next!!1". Pretty much all the games listed have ZERO server side validation. As I commented under previous Valorant anti cheat backdoor story: 'what is actually crazy are modern game servers lacking even the most basic server side assertion logic(1) letting players FLY around the map, teleport, summon items, kill other players on the server at the press of a button, etc. Seen in all massive FPS games, for example Apex Legends, PUBG, Escape from Tarkov.'
- alpaca128 7y agoAnd Crysis 2. I wanted to get into the multiplayer of that game but it was hopeless. Every single server was filled with either cheaters or players that were so damn good they could almost match the cheaters.
- dijit 7y ago> New surge of bad programmers is a more apt title, or "We gave game clients absolute control and you wont believe what happened next!!1". Pretty much all the games listed have ZERO server side validation. I feel like I should share an inside opinion, but you will not like it. So please take it as an opinion and don't crucify me. The Industry itself is mired in complexity, year on year we have to build bigger games, better and more complex games and we have diminishing amounts of budget (both in time and money) to do so. Failing to make something truly great will cause the next iteration to have even less budget and then you're dead. When it comes to gameservers, which is actually something I understand very well[0] there are additional budgetary constraints. The cost of a player, playing the game is an eternal one. If you keep playing we only get the upfront game sale from you, so there's an incentive to keep the costs as low as possible. NDA prohibits me from saying an exact number, but lets assume (and it's mostly true) that if you play a game for 3 months then we've lost money on you from server time alone, and we well optimise our servers. The more you put in for verification and detection, the more cost there is. This is why when we originally talked about releasing the game we were intending to forego a PC release entirely, as consoles are barely affected by this, and when they are it's quite easy to detect comparatively. [0]: you can see me talking about it here: https://youtu.be/d29tHMRJIU8?t=2060 https://youtu.be/d29tHMRJIU8?t=2060
- iforgotpassword 7y agoFor a long time, this was sold as a plus for gaming consoles, but afaik even there a bunch of cheating tools are available now. So right now game streaming is being sold as the next savior of online gaming since everything runs in the cloud. But being the pessimist I usually am, and reading about how the cheating business is apparently a multi million dollar market, I expect this to also not hold up forever. There's already AIs that can play doom and starcraft just by scraping the screen, so if people are willing to pay for cheating tools, they'd probably also be willing to attach stuff to their Google Stadia that captures the screen and simulates input.
- dijit 7y ago> For a long time, this was sold as a plus for gaming consoles And it will be again when the next generation comes out this year. This happens every console generation, in the last year cheating tools finally catch up.
- sidibe 7y agoScraping the screen fast enough to do the right thing would be pretty impressive, at that point there is nothing you can do.
- namelosw 7y agoCheating is so common nowadays simply due to game companies are not willing to pay to make dedicated online games. A lot of so called online game are just basically client side modified version, how they are doing it would simply shock web devs.
- midnightclubbed 7y agoBS. There are thousands of games developed as dedicated online games without any intention of having a client only version. The difficulty is balancing how much of the game runs on the client, how much on the server and how state is synchronized between clients and server. Oh and it needs to render a photorealistic world with 2km Draw distances at a constant 144Hz with no more than 50ms latency between a button press and the other players seeing the result of that press. The servers will be receiving hundreds of packets per second for each game instance, will potentially be hosting thousands of game instances and must cost at most a few cents per player hour. Web devs shocked, really?
- namelosw 7y agoI understand how difficult it is to build an online game, especially real-time MMOs with seamless maps. > The difficulty is balancing how much of the game runs on the client However, it's important to have the mentality to build on the server by default. And try other optimization before give up to the client. The reason that games are fighting this cheating surge is mostly due to the mindset is more "security bolt-on" in the game industry, instead of "security built-in" which you could see more in Web development.
- nyxxie 7y agoI built my initial programming/security skills by making PC game cheats, and now that I'm actually working in the software industry on other stuff I decided at the beginning of quarantine to see if I could still do it. Specifically, I targeted PUBG. They've added obfuscation, that's about it. Even one of the guys the author interviews admits it: > “Last year, we spent time working on various measures to block cheat programs,” explains Taeseok Jang, executive producer of PUBG PC. “Most of these actions focused on blocking cheat program developers to make it more difficult for them to create these highly lucrative cheats.” That obfuscation was probably a huge problem when PUBG initially started adding it, but so long as some bored high school kid has a pirated copy of IDA and a desire to prove themselves, that info is going to end up online. Each new obfuscation feature or anticheat detection becomes a challenge, and the results of that challenge being inevitably solved are inevitably posted in a public and high-visibility place for others to learn from and use. All of this public information meant that creating a cheat for the game probably added around a month or two of work to adapt to the cheat prevention efforts, on top of the month or so that I spent looking for the actual in-game structures necessary to implement the radar I was going for. I already expected every hindrance I encountered when reversing the game and writing the tooling to interact with the game's process. It was still daunting, especially since I had never touched the windows kernel until this project, but ultimately when I ended up getting everything working it felt like I was just using the same techniques I used to use back in the day only with extra steps. My takeaways for anyone interested in preventing videogames from being cheated in: - Cheaters will eventually find a way, but you can always reduce the quantity and quality of them. - All information on how to write a cheat for your game eventually ends up in public forums. Keep an eye on those and learn how most people are writing cheats and target those methods specifically. - Obfuscation (new detentions, new anti-reversing measures, new countermeasures to cheating methods) buys you time in the immediate term and invalidates existing online information in the long term. They're like antibiotics--they increases the barrier to entry and pain factor of cheating only if you continue adding/changing it. - Obfuscation will never be adequate to prevent cheating entirely. Human monitoring, ML, skill-based pairing, and full visibility & control over hardware the game is executing on are probably the next generation in terms of cheat prevention.
- som33 7y ago
- cwhiz 7y agoIt just seems trivially easy to me to just look at game stats and catch 80% of cheaters. I assume they are gathering all sorts of information to balance the game... so just use that data to catch cheaters and ban them after the game. When you watch these cheaters play it is obvious. They laser everyone in the head. Number of kills, type of guns used, distance of kills, hit rate, head shot rate, distance traveled, etc, etc. Just look for consistent extreme outliers.
- LUmBULtERA 7y agoCertainly more subtle cheats exist, but blatant cheating was one of the reasons I had to stop playing Battlefield series games on PC. It was relatively common for there to be some 80-100:1 KDR player on a team who would admit to cheating in game chat. If they'd get banned, they'd buy another hacked account and just do the same thing again.
- shahbaby 7y agoI had the same experience with battlefield.
- a1369209993 7y agoPretty much this; if someone's cheating so subtly that you can't tell they're cheating, so? Just bump them up to the next skill rank; if they make it to e-sports level they'll get found out soon enough, and if they don't, how is that different from someone with unfair amounts of natural talent? For that matter, would you insist that your players submit a urine sample to prove they aren't on amphetamines? If the opposing team can distinguish between cheating and non-cheating, so can the admins; if they can't, what's the point?
- lucb1e 7y ago> It just seems trivially easy to me Makes you wonder why the problem exists, then, doesn't it?
- midnightclubbed 7y agoThere is a push towards this and some companies offering 3rd party systems to do ML based detection of cheaters. The basic checks trivially are easy to put in to place (kills past weapon range, warping, impossible movements etc) although someone has to do the grunt work (and make sure the checks are not invalidated by certain gameplay features). Once you get in to things like head-shot rates it gets trickier to differentiate players with amazing hand-eye co-ordination and cheaters. The line is really really thin. Add in internet latency spikes and it gets even harder. Some cheaters will use things like aim-bots to nudge their mouse inputs and give an advantage that is difficult to see even when watching them live on stream. Others will blatantly cheat, get detected and kicked within a few minutes (after ruining some people's experience), create a new account and repeat, multiple times an hour.
- elorant 7y agoSame story two days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23102375 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23102375 How is it possible the same link can be submitted twice?
- jsnell 7y agoSubmitting duplicates is not impossible indefinitely, just for something like 12 hours. (And yes, it's quite random whether even a good submission ends up on the front page or not. But there's no point in complaining about it in the comments. Linking to earlier submissions mostly makes sense if there's interesting discussion there.)
- elorant 7y agoI'm not complaining, just asking an honest question.
- slightwinder 7y agoI wonder whether some day the industry will discover cloud-gaming as a "solution" for cheating. After all, if the gamer has no access to the system, many ways for cheating are impossible. And if you design a game around the additional lag, it might work well enough to feed it to the masses.
- SeanBoocock 7y agoI doubt anyone will pursue game streaming purely as a solution for cheating, but it is a nice second order effect. Hosted servers are already an expensive ongoing cost to supporting a live game and cloud streaming would magnify that cost several times.
- slightwinder 7y agoWhat costs? Im talking about Google Stadia or Nvidia Now(?), which is paid by the users, not the gaming-company. If anything, the gaming-Company might even get paid from the cloud-provider for enforcing usage of the cloud.
- jameslk 7y agoWhy not offer a bounty program for reporting "game vulnerabilities" that lead to hacks? Or report hacks in the wild? Or is this already done?
- throwaway2048 7y agoBecause some hacks, like aimbots are always going to be possible no matter what, even if all the client does is displays a video stream.
- whatever1 7y agoWould distributing PC games in their own Virtual Machine mitigate any of the cheating risks? Now we do have enough RAM, CPU cores and the capability of passing through the GPU to a VM.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 7y agoHow does that help? The host can see inside the VM. There have been a few games whose obfuscation was effectively a different instruction set being run in a VM, and it does slow down hacking by a few months while people reverse engineer and retool. Can't remember names though.
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt’s probably an artifact of aging, but one of the more beneficial things I’ve done in the past half decade is switch from online games to single player or coop. The peaks of online games are very high; when you get a team that’s cooperative and communicative it can be great. But the expected outcome is much much lower, especially when trolls and cheaters show up. Single player games let me enjoy the experience without it being ruined by anything other than my relatively low skill level at the game in question. Also, I can buy games that are older and play them on weaker hardware to significantly reduce my cost of ownership, since there’s no penalty for playing single player games later.