22 ms·
Intel accused by workers of prioritizing chip output over safety
- vikramkr 7y agoHow has demand for chips looked over the past few months? Has it been enough to potentially necessitate from a business perspective keeping output high? I can imagine arguments for higher or lower demand that seem perfectly reasonable (low because consumer segment slowdown, high because surge in cloud service use increasing failures/expansion demand or business laptops for WFH) and I'm wondering what the dominant force is.
- ksidkrk9 7y agoPersonally demand for chips is not the measure I’d want them to use. Stabilizing employee mindset is the measure they should care about. Hard to ship chips if they feel the company doesn’t care about their demand to stay alive and they all quit. AMD wouldn’t mind a bunch of chip experts being suddenly available. Ogling market economics first and foremost is really not the priority for agency these days. If demand falls such that we’re just generating chips for science and industry, so be it. No one owes tech nerds tech to fetishize.
- vorpalhex 7y agoThey need to sell units, to make money, to continue to employ and pay employees. They may have contracts that require them to ship units or lose large contracts (and thus have to engage in mass layoffs).
- vikramkr 7y agoOh I completely agree that it's a bad measure. I'm not looking for a justification, I'm curious for an explanation of why management might be incentivized to act this way. If theres a business case for it it's fairly easy to rationalize as a manager why you have a moral responsibility to put employees at risk (the economy is running in WFH powered by our CPUs! They need us!). Especially if they're in for a nice bonus if sales spike in higher demand. I'm more curious if there's even a business case to be made which might explain (but not necessarily justify) reckless behavior.
- kube-system 7y agoI doubt many people are comfortable quitting their job in the current market. I also doubt AMD would hire any of these people, even in good economic times, since they divested their fabs 11 years ago.
- Jaygles 7y agoI can't imagine what higher ups in Intel are feeling about the current state of things especially since they are spending nearly 10x on R+D as AMD is($1.5b AMD[0] vs $13.1b Intel[1]). Of course AMD doesn't need to spend R+D money on the process they're using from TSMC although I'm sure some of the money they're handing over to them goes to R+D. I'd love to be a fly on the wall in the board meeting room. [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/267873/amds-expenditure-on-research-and-development-since-2001/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/267873/amds-expenditure-... [1] https://www.investopedia.com/news/amazons-23b-rd-budget-sets-record-recode/ https://www.investopedia.com/news/amazons-23b-rd-budget-sets...
- beardedscotsman 7y agoRealise that intel, has not been releasing chips with any major improvement either. They have delayed time and time again new chips and designs on purpose because they haven’t had the competition to be go up against. Intel performance will always be one step ahead of AMD, intel have faster tech in their pocket waiting to be released.
- kogepathic 7y ago> Intel performance will always be one step ahead of AMD, intel have faster tech in their pocket waiting to be released. Citation very much needed. Show me an Intel CPU with PCIe 4.0 or with the performance per watt of the latest AMD Ryzen mobile chips. You can't, because to date they don't exist. I think if they had anything in reserve it would have been released by now, because AMD is trouncing them in reviews.
- snazz 7y agoIf they were to have a revolutionary technology that they haven't released yet, they'd release it as soon as their OEM and enterprise sales actually started to take a nosedive. Even though PC enthusiasts are outspoken about it, Intel is still doing just fine in their much higher-volume areas.
- OrgNet 7y agomakes sense in this capitalist world... the proof is in the pudding. (keep your blinds on if you want but it is happening)
- Pfhreak 7y agoI'm just about as socialist as they come, but I'm dropping you downvote. Yes, this move is clearly precipitated by capitalism, yes, capitalism sucks. But I think we do everyone better by trying to put some effort into posting about why it sucks, and how it specifically seems to be impacting this situation. Low effort posts aren't going to change anything, and they clutter up HN. E.g. Intel's primary motivation is to increase their capital, they have relatively fixed material costs and somewhat flexible labor costs, and so they choose to expend their labor (in this case by putting them in a risky environment) to continue to increase their capital.
- OrgNet 7y agothanks for proving my point, most people just don't want to see it (also, downvotes don't matter as much as you think)
- lidHanteyk 7y agoOr, you could zoom out and look at a pattern: Intel's failure to care for the safety of their employees is analogous to their failure to care for the safety of their customers, in the sense of Meltdown and Spectre. In both cases, upper management prioritizes the bottom line and reinforcing the status quo, despite the fact that the world fundamentally changed and thus their practices should change too.
- solotronics 7y agoyes because socialist countries were so well known for their humanitarian treatment of their subjects /s
- zozbot234 7y agoAll in all, COVID19 is just about the one thing that's not a safety concern in a chip-fabbing cleanroom. Hydrofluoric acid is somewhat harder to deal with though, so I'm not at all sure that 'deprioritizing' workplace safety is the right approach.
- bob1029 7y agoThis is an excellent observation. A class 1000+ clean room is probably the last place you would catch something airborne from someone else.
- janekm 7y agoWe're not talking about the folks in bunny suits here, obviously.
- klyrs 7y agoIdle concern -- what about the inside of those bunny suits? Are they sanitized between uses? As I understand it, folks wear 'em to keep the cleanroom clean, not so much to keep them safe from eachother's germs
- elihu 7y agoIt might not be a concern in some cleanrooms, but it definitely is when entering and exiting a cleanroom. And no matter how good the equipment and protocols are in manufacturing areas you could also still get it by grabbing the doorhandle of the main building entrance or a bathroom.
- klenwell 7y agoSince reading about Paul O'Neill's turnaround of ALCOA, I've been convinced that worker safety (or well-being for less life-and-death office environments) should be the one OKR/KPR/whatever-you-want-to-call-it every company is focused on. Especially for manufacturing companies. As Charles Duhigg notes in writing about O'Neill's leadership, it's a focus that can improve communication and performance all around: http://txti.es/duhigg-keystone-habits http://txti.es/duhigg-keystone-habits Instead, it feels like most corporations are managed by the people who run Royco in Succession: https://youtu.be/UcTmBfA7Qik?t=48 https://youtu.be/UcTmBfA7Qik?t=48
- hpoe 7y agoI heard about that story, albeit through "The Power of Habit" by Duhigg, which is probably what your referencing. My reservation about just saying "safety is the top priority" is that it can quickly turn into management cargo culting if someone doesn't actually understand what changes it made at ALCOA and why it worked. Its the same as a manager who hears that being interested in the well being of his employees can get them to work harder so he starts pretending to be interested in his employees, not because he cares but because he wants performance improvements. It ends up being insincere, creepy and off putting instead. If the brass of a company try and emphasize safety to try and get the benefits ALCOA got, they won't pull it off, not because safety isn't important but because they didn't really care about safety in the first place.
- sascovid19tw 7y agoI have firsthand experience with this, albeit not at Intel. Several known positive cases have appeared Samsung's fab in Austin. Samsung mandates they not return and quarantine at home. Before any of that, I'd already decided back in early March—when it became clear that things were more serious than people had been taking everything—that I'd stick around until we either temporarily shut down or when the reported cases start getting too close for comfort. A few weeks ago I sat down in the morning to find another company-wide email sent out at 9:00PM the night before (don't know why they hadn't also forwarded a copy of this one to my personal inbox that I could access from home, as with the ones before). In this case, symptoms were reported 4 days before, and now with confirmation having tested positive. This time it was on my floor, not far from where I sit in our open office. I sent an email that I was leaving and would not be returning for at least two weeks and pending further info about any spread. That was a Friday. I got fired over email (although not in those terms) at the end of the day the following Monday: Although you did not resign failure to report to your scheduled shift(s) has been taken as a voluntary resignation. We have gone ahead and ended your assignment for you. Please do not report back to the SAS site as your assingment here is done. This was all within the last two weeks. At the time, our group had been doing a piss poor job of observing both company and local rules about distancing. It had been less than a week since people around me had finally gotten moved to different workstations. It wasn't an availability problem, because (a) half the office was already a ghost town due to select folks ordered to work from home, and (b) the rest of the company had been been working spread out for something like a month already—but not our group. At the beginning of April, we were supposed to get a scheduled payout for earned PTO, but we received an email that due to COVID they were actually going to delay the payout. I had to jump through a lot of hoops alternately taking on extra days that I wasn't ordinarily scheduled and taking off other days to burn the PTO to give the effect of getting the payout for the hours I'd accrued.
- stainforth 7y agoWere you a contractor? If not, sounds like you have cause for unlawful termination. Bring it to them.
- 7y ago
- smaddox 7y agoI worked at Intel in a fab for 2 years. The culture is extremely safety conscious, if not safety obsessed. The moto is Safety, Quality, Output, in that order. In my experience, Intel strives to create an environment in which workers are safer at work than at home.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- blitmap 7y agoSpeaking as someone who knows nothing about fab: What are the most dangerous aspects of the job? What's the most likely injuries to happen doing x?
- ISL 7y agoI've done lithography in research settings. To me, the chemistry is the scariest. High voltages, high-power optics, vacuum systems, etc, all exist, too, but the risks associated with chemistry/process-gas accidents are perhaps the greatest. As a teaser, HF is used throughout the industry -- it is spooky stuff (and awesome at getting things done).
- tedsanders 7y agoSeconded. TMAH is particularly scary, though less common than HF. If enough splashes on your skin, you die. Highly toxic stuff.
- hectormalot 7y agoOff topic, but that reminded me of some horror stories from my chemistry days: Dimethylmercury able to kill through 2 drops absorbed through a latex glove: https://www.acsh.org/news/2016/06/06/two-drops-of-death-dimethylmercury https://www.acsh.org/news/2016/06/06/two-drops-of-death-dime... And of course the amazing series of ‘things I won’t work with’. E.g.: https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2014/10/10/things_i_wont_work_with_peroxide_peroxides https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2014/10/10/th...
- acd 7y agoThis posting made I am buying AMD CPU the next time.
- derision 7y agoAMD's superior CPUs is why you should be buying them
- jl2718 7y agoThe fab is probably the safest public place on earth right now.
- simlevesque 7y agoAre workers rights a thing in the USA? Seems like it's not.
- antonzabirko 7y agoOf course not, don't be so naive as to expect rights in us.
- jethro_tell 7y agoRights are a commodity in the US, you just buy them like orange futures or oil tankers.
- antonzabirko 7y agoI think more aptly: life is a luxury here.
- snewrekcah 7y agoWe traded it for guns, religion & tax relief.
- lliamander 7y agoAssuming you are correct, why would the US be in a situation need to trade worker protections for civil liberties? If those politicians offering worker protections were threatening civil liberties, I wouldn't take that deal either.
- stagger87 7y agoGenuine question. Are there other countries in which you can not show up for a scheduled shift, without making prior arrangements with management, and not get reprimanded? On top of this telling your boss that you won't be in for two weeks without their approval...
- random9763 7y ago
- luckydata 7y agoOh wow, who would have thought weak labor protection laws and no unions would end up reproducing exactly the same conditions that lead to labor protection laws and unions? I'm shocked. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jungle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jungle
- luckydata 7y ago"your boos mean nothing to me, I've seen what makes you cheer"
- ben509 7y agoThe whole notion of priorities in safety vs. revenue never works for me. (And you can s/safety/security/ or s/safety/privacy/.) In a very limited scope, it could work. If a team has a sprint or something, they can work on the safety tasks first. But that's not really how a company operates. You have a whole mess of tradeoffs and often the costs and benefits can't be clearly quantified. What they do is work out an operational model, some people work exclusively on examining safety, and they put out guidelines to management and employees who then have to practice safety themselves. Generally, you only know if it works after the fact by examining the results, maybe even tally up the costs of lawsuits or bad PR. But it's meaningless to say "safety is job #1" because you're doing all the jobs 2 and on or you're going out of business. And that means all of them; no one says "taking out the trash is job #1" or "sending out W2s is job #1" but a company grinds to a halt pretty quickly if they aren't done.
- AlgorithmicTime 7y agoDuh. Safety is not priority number one. It shouldn't be. Safety third.
- supernova87a 7y agoAt first, I thought the headline meant chip designers were pressured to create chips that had huge performance at the risk of catching fire.
- the-dude 7y agoThey have an opcode for this : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halt_and_Catch_Fire_(computing) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halt_and_Catch_Fire_(computing...
- eBombzor 7y agoNot the location in the article but my roommate is a technician for one the fab plants in Hillsboro and he is still required to go to in-person classes alongside his main role despite the non-essential lockdown order in Oregon.
- csours 7y agoEven safety conscious employers have a hard time reacting to new and different safety related areas. For instance, see the USCSB's video on the BP Texas City refinery explosion. The refinery operator had a great record for safety, but it was measuring individual worker safety, ie PPE and recordable injuries. It was not measuring Process safety. https://www.csb.gov/bp-america-refinery-explosion/ https://www.csb.gov/bp-america-refinery-explosion/ --- Edit: I should probably make clear that I don't think BP actually had a great safety record. I think they measured and cared about a certain class of safety, but not another class of safety, and that's the point I was trying to make.
- say_it_as_it_is 7y agoLet's be specific: managers prioritized chip output over safety. The call came from the top -- the board of directors.
- oliwarner 7y agoThis seems redundant. Who else would be?
- nickff 7y agoYou might be surprised to see how many times manufacturing/warehouse employees ignore safety protocols for reasons of aesthetic/fashion, comfort, or convenience. Many managers have to discipline employees for disregarding precautions.
- boyadjian 7y ago"Safety" : European people are obsessed with safety. At the same time, migrants take huge risks in order to conquer he world.
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/8cE95 https://archive.md/8cE95
- tpmx 7y agoIntel should have placed that fab here in Sweden. What this accusation is saying is the norm here.
- Top5a 7y agoChip fabs and cleanrooms are designed to protect the wafers from contamination by workers, not the converse. For instance, look up the repeated deaths and cover-ups in Samsung's plants in ROK.
- magwa101 7y agoSo this is how it's going to be right? Endless lawsuits based on what really??
- Doc-Saintly 7y agoAs for the original topic, it's patently wrong. It sounds like an individual case being blown out of proportion or a disgruntled employee trying to leave a mark. I can speak from experience that their safety standards are above and beyond regulation, and sometimes reason.
- IlyaMoroshkin 7y agoIf you are a healthy adult, COVID-19 is barely more lethal than the Flu, so what is the concern here?
- ivoras 7y agoMany healthy adults have parents and non-healthy friends. That's the pretty much entire reason for pandemic-mitigating measures.
- jodrellblank 7y agoHaving both your legs amputated is less lethal than the flu, is that your only measure of whether you want something to happen to you or not? Even healthy people with no need for hospitalisation can be taken down for a couple of months of fatigue and symptoms from it.