17 ms·
0xF Rules
- rspoerri 7y agoI dont like the vertical spacing of the font. While it makes the page shorter, it's bad for reading. Getting a lot of text on one page is good for programming (getting a overview, quick access of areas), but for reading it's generally worse (sequential action). Othervise i can follow most guidelines.
- irishsultan 7y agoBecause the images on that page don't have a size set on the img tag I do get visible reflow when visiting that page.
- timvdalen 7y agoI dislike sites that don't redirect HTTP to HTTPS.
- janpot 7y agoI also dislike sites that don't use semantic and accessible markup
- pfortuny 7y agoI do not like the “serves the ego”. Like: (1) Is there anything wrong in an ego? (2) If it were wrong, are you sure the intent is to serve the ego?
- boomlinde 7y agoThere is something wrong if you do it at my expense
- juped 7y agoWell, this is clearly inviting tons of subjective opinion threading, so here's the version tweaked for my preferences. 0x0. I like blazing-fast websites. 0x1. I like websites that are easy to read. 0x2. I like websites that are device-agnostic. 0x3. I like when the authorial voice is identifiable. 0x4. I like when the author leaves contact information. 0x5. I like when a full changelog is available. 0x6. I like justified text. 0x7. I like when quotes and citations are easy to find. 0x8. I like to minimize technology wherever possible. 0x9. I like RSS. 0xA. I dislike analytics which serve the author's ego and track me. 0xB. I dislike the blog format. 0xC. I dislike ads. 0xD. I dislike sites with wide main content. 0xE. I dislike visible reflow. 0xF. I dislike parasitism on main content.
- azatris 7y agoHow do you differentiate between analytics that serve the author's ego and analytics that serve other purposes?
- hk__2 7y ago> How do you differentiate between analytics that serve the author's ego and analytics that serve other purposes? What are those other purposes?
- Jyaif 7y agoIt allows optimizing many things such as the UX, the speed and size of your product, and your own time. Examples: * If you see that a button is used 10x than an other button, you can re-order buttons. * You can remove buttons that are never used (=faster load times, less bytes) * You can drop features that are never used, focus on features that are often used, saving your own time. The other approach is "I already know what is best, I don't care about how other thinks". This is also useful because it can allow you to break out of local optimum.
- mattlondon 7y agoI have in the past built websites where I assumed that Part A would be the most popular part and so put a lot of effort and work into Part A. Less effort was put into Parts B, C, D etc. When I launched it and let it run for a while, it turned out - thanks to analytics - that Part B was the run-away success that was getting lots of search-engine traffic and 90% of the visits to the site. Had I not had analytics then I'd not have known that and would not know which parts of the site people valued. As a result I put the larger part of my focus into Part B instead.
- tleb_ 7y agoThat can be solved through server-side log parsing assuming bots visit either all or nothing of your website (close to reality no?).
- jokoon 7y agoI have the same kind of website. I once showed it to an employer and he almost laughed. It's like the internet has been overtaken by an army of advertisers and wannabees photoshop artists. I'm curious about UX, because sometimes it's aimed to make consumers feel good, and sometimes it's to be productive. I'm wondering if UX is backed by science/engineering.
- doublerabbit 7y agoThere is a large amount of social engineering exploitation to UX and it comes down to how can I exploit the person viewing the content. The main question to UX design is how can I control the user to tap what I want? And it's all very simple. The main exploit you want is a reaction. Next time your commuting on public transport if you spot someone looking at social media on their phone watch their body language. As they scroll the endless pages of guff, you can start to learn their body language and how they react. With this you can start to psychoanalyze the user reactions and you can then use this to trigger a person to flip in to a emotional state; allowing you to socially engineer the person especially within a UX model. Media News does this all the time; you can easily cripple a person with just two sentences of text and a picture. It's why a good troll is so effective. If you spark a response, you've got their attention as exactly the downvote I received is. Another example of a human exploit in the world we live in. With that downvote it can flip the persons emotional state where the feeling is of "oh,no" because my "value of 69" is now "68". A pointless number, an pathos exploit which can be manipulated by bots.
- gumby 7y ago> I'm wondering if UX is backed by science/engineering. Yes it is and has been for a long time. Time and motion studies were taken throughout the 20th century and even in the 19th. (There was a recent HN posting about such a study in aircraft cockpits of the 40s or 50s and the need for adjustable seating, relaying to air crashes). Don Norman published one of the first great such books (Design of everyday things) — check out the nuclear plant photo! There was a deep study of the efficacy of design in print media which fascinatingly to be settled on different design points in different countries, though the most scientific such studies waited until computers were readily available. Early GUIs were controversial and UX studies going back to the early 70s by people like Stu Card and by Fitts have been both surprising and influential. Xerox PARC where Card worked even hired anthropologists. UX researchers are pretty important today. All the “big guys” (FAANG etc) and less well funded companies as well. Engineering? Well companies spend a lot on their sites and devices. You can decide on that part.
- jfk13 7y agoGiven that they're numbered from 0x0 to 0xF, there are actually 0x10 rules listed.
- fla 7y ago"There are 2 hard problems in computer science: cache invalidation, naming things, and off-by-1 errors."
- Tade0 7y agoNobody ever gets this one when I say it.
- pwdisswordfish2 7y agoCan I ask a stupid question about this? I’ve always wondered what this quote really means. It seems obvious that the author deems “cache invalidation” to be badly or awkwardly named, but is that really the joke? Isn’t cache invalidation a pretty straightforward term? Maybe I don’t feel the awkwardness as much as a native English speaker? Or is it literally that cache invalidation is hard? Isn’t cache invalidation on a completely different level as naming things, both conceptually and in difficulty?
- mcherm 7y agoNo, it is not intended to be badly or awkwardly named. It really is the case that properly invalidating caches is surprisingly hard to do and is the root cause of many, many bugs. Of course, the term is intended to be taken broadly: "cache invalidation" includes everything from CPU level cash coherence issues with multi-processors to the maintenance of ACID compliance in a database, and probably even includes cases where a mutable variable is reused incorrectly.
- Someone 7y agoThrowing away cached data may not be hard, but knowing (actually, ‘guessing’ often better describes it) what to throw away is. “First in, first out” may seem fine at first sight, but if your access pattern is periodic, it may mean you just threw away the data you need, and kept around data you won’t need for 11, 10, 9, 8,… months. Also, why throw away data that’s needed, statistically, once a second, and keep the data that was read in for that one of a time query? Also, quality of service might affect caching choices. If you need room on a factory floor, you don’t move the fire extinguisher to the back room, even though you know you likely will not use it. Similarly, you might want to prefer caching data of web pages more likely to be visited, or even that of customers paying more.
- bloak 7y agoJustified text with a monospaced font is an unusual choice. (I can't work out whether my browser is stretching the space between letters as well as the space between words.)
- rejschaap 7y agoI also like monospaced fonts, but using them for articles is a bit unusual. Justifying monospaced fonts seems wrong on some levels, but who am I to judge. In my browser only the spaces between words get stretched, spaces between letters are not affected.
- hk__2 7y agoIf you care about your readers, justifying any font is wrong. Justification makes the text “look nice” but harder to read; it should be avoided as much as possible.
- garaetjjte 7y agoJustification generally isn't that bad, but browser implementation are much worse than real typesetting system, like TeX.
- throwaway744678 7y agoPrinted materials (books, newspaper) used to be justified manually. Is it still the case?
- gerikson 7y agoNo, it’s all automated. The open source world knows of TeX but there’s a plethora of proprietary justification algorithms used in commercial typesetting.
- hk__2 7y agoJustification doesn’t make any sense. Why would you want to have spaces of variable size, making the text harder to read?
- gumby 7y agoI still prefer rss because going to the web site Just to see what’s new is annoying.
- satish-setty 7y ago> 0x6. I like monospaced fonts. Author doesn't follow his own advice? http://fabiensanglard.net/git_code_review/index.php http://fabiensanglard.net/git_code_review/index.php May be he forgot to update his php pages, which are all in proportional fonts.
- davidcollantes 7y agoHe changed layout and theme in 2018. See related post[0]. [0] http://fabiensanglard.net/bloated/index.html http://fabiensanglard.net/bloated/index.html
- throwaway_pdp09 7y agoA thing about these fast, static and minimalist websites (which I love) is that they use a monospaced font (which I don't love) instead of proportional, which I find easier to read. See http://antirez.com/ http://antirez.com/ as another ecxample It's not a criticism but an observation that giving up on so much modern junk seems to mean discarding something I consider good; better fonts. Not intended to be provocative, just a note.
- jrockway 7y agoI spent a lot of time thinking about this when I redesigned my own website. I really like the narrowness of Iosevka, and couldn't find a good proportional font to match its look and feel. So I just used Iosevka for the body text too. (I am currently experimenting with a quasi-proportional variant, Iosevka Aile, but I am not quite sure how I feel about it.) It looks weird, especially with justification, but I think I'll probably keep it.
- freshhawk 7y agoYou are definitely right. It's almost like those typographers have figured some things out in the time since 1440AD when they started working on it.
- mattlondon 7y agoI really enjoy Fabien's articles - really great fascinating stuff. I have to wonder about the choice of custom PHP to generate the pages, especially if you are going to start from scratch when the intention is drastic simplicity? I can understand the rationale of picking PHP many years ago to hand-roll something, but these days there are a lot of excellent static site generators which might be a better choice? E.g. Jekyll is very simple and flexible in my experience, and you can hand-roll some HTML + CSS and get something looking and behaving (e.g. URL structure) how you like very easily. I have had less success with Hugo (in terms of URL structure etc), but I know a lot of people prefer it to Jekyll for its golang-based compile performance. Am I missing something for the rationale for PHP here? It would seem that most of the rules here are editorial/design decisions rather than technical restrictions really. I guess perhaps there is the legacy issue of loads of old articles that are written in PHP that would need to be migrated, but that sounds like something that can be trivially automated and would only need to be done once.
- as1mov 7y agoNot sure about the OP, but I have a small devlog which is basically just a Bash script which I run whenever I need to write a new post. The script takes a bunch of markdown files in a folder and spits out HTML files (common index.html + files of each individual post) with a header/footer. This HTML is then served using a web server. I just tried visiting the Jekyll website to see how to get started, the documentation page has the following under the Getting Started section -- 1) Install Ruby, Ruby Gems. 2) Understand what Gem, Gemfiles, Bundler(?) are. 3) Tells me about it's community for some reason. 4) Finally there's a page which tells me how to make a 'Hello World' blog. 5) 10 more pages explaining what Liquid, layouts, includes, datafiles, assets, deployment are. 6) I still don't know how to make a new post. Most static site generators have too much of cognitive load. I just want a bunch of plain HTML files generated (ideally in <1s + no JS) from a bunch of markdown files, I don't really care for 99% of the features these things have. I would rather spend a few hours a write a simple script to do it myself instead of wading through the documentation looking for the relevant parts.
- discreditable 7y ago
- thosakwe 7y agoWhat if I told you that you can have all of these things, while also having a website that looks good?
- simplicio 7y agoI liked Fabien's old site. With the images that faded in when you moused over them, to give you some idea of what a given article was about before you clicked on it. I don't remember it as being particularly slow to load, though I wasn't timing it or anything. Not a big deal, I doubt I'm conscious of the design of a blog for more than a second or two after I load it, but not sure the change is an unalloyed good.
- shdon 7y agoI actually rather miss the commenting on Fabien's site. IIRC, he initially kept the comments underneath the older articles, but now those are gone too. On his site at least, the comments were frequently quite insightful or at least asking interesting questions. Yes, there's also spam and trolling in comments, but eliminating them entirely feels like a waste and cuts off an important way of interacting with the readers. At least personally, I'm far more likely to ask a question or to point out a mistake in a comment than I am to send off an e-mail.
- dysoco 7y agoAs much as I'm an advocate for simple websites; I still prefer his old design. It was simple and wasn't bloated, and it was much more readable imho.
- nyanpasu64 7y ago>I like when the author's name is clearly stated. Legal name, or online identity? I don't feel comfortable revealing my legal name online.
- ebg13 7y ago> Legal name, or online identity? I don't feel comfortable revealing my legal name online. Name that a reader can recognize as something that identifies you to the collective. There's a 0% chance that he cares what your parents wrote on a paper at the hospital.
- eddieoz 7y agoThe next step is having the same but decentralised, uncensorable and with the domain absolutely under your control. I think it is the best way to have your complete freedom.
- lostmsu 7y agoHis contrast is too low even for my normal eyes. Did not notice that initially though, until I turned off Dark Reader extension to view website colors as designed.
- p4bl0 7y agoMy website [0] exists by the same rules. Only differences are that I use a Makefile and Bash scripts relying on the GNU coreutils and xml2/2xml [1] to generate static pages from my template, and I use git to synchronize it with my server. Oh, and I write these in Emacs :). 0. https://pablo.rauzy.name/ https://pablo.rauzy.name/ 1. https://packages.debian.org/buster/xml2 https://packages.debian.org/buster/xml2