7 ms·
Don’t Be Fooled by America’s Flattening Curve
- coldcode 7y agoLiving in Florida I wouldn't trust any official numbers of cases or deaths. Also case numbers in general are dependent on the quantity of testing available which is highly variable across states and across the country. Even deaths can easily be uncounted due to people dying without a Covid-19 diagnoses before (or after) death.
- tehlike 7y agoYou can normalize by checking yoy overall death change, and attribute a good chunk to covid19.
- votepaunchy 7y agoExcept it will be impossible to sort out deaths from COVID and deaths due to lockdown measures.
- bluntfang 7y agoWhy do you think deaths directly from the virus is more important than virus deaths + collateral damage? Are you trying to make the claim that lockdown measures are more destructive than the extremely infectious disease?
- DuskStar 7y agoIt is quite possible for lockdown measures to be more destructive than the disease they seek to prevent. Taken to an extreme, forbidding all human contact to protect against the common cold would be an example of such. And it's definitely worth considering when trying to determine if a lockdown was "worth" it. If you locked down and 10k people died, the lockdown looks a lot worse when 9k of those deaths were due to suicides/"elective" procedures/missed cancer/etc. Especially if only 20k deaths were expected from the disease if there was no lockdown at all...
- HumblyTossed 7y ago> Living in Florida I wouldn't trust any official numbers of cases or deaths. Exactly. There has already been legal wranglings between DeSantis and the Miami Herald over this.
- dhimes 7y agoFlorida is especially problematic, but in general I'm using hospitalizations as a proxy where the hospital systems aren't overwhelmed.
- generalpass 7y agoAnother story with tunnel vision. I don't pay attention to the NY Times, but have they had any opinion pieces suggesting that maybe the destruction of the economy is also a bad thing? And, maybe, someone besides a reporter or "health expert" should make some kind of attempt to determine if it is even possible to sustain these policies? I really feel like I'm in a Tales from Dark Side episode.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoDemand is going to be decreased no matter if everything opens up or not.
- generalpass 7y ago> Demand is going to be decreased no matter if everything opens up or not. Sure, but is it possible to posit that, or to at least discuss, some nuance of at least some variance of some sort: A. Demand is going to be decreased, and a bunch of people are going to starve to death (or, more likely, take to the streets with their pitch forks and torches). B. Demand is going to be decreased, and recovery will be difficult.
- zaphar 7y agoThe New York Times reporters generally consult experts when they write stories like these. Just because their is a reporters name next to it doesn't imply the reporter fabricated all the data they are using and that no health experts were involved.
- scarface74 7y agoEven in areas where they are opening up, people aren’t in any hurry to travel unnecessarily, be in crowds, go to restaurants, etc. Covid’s effect on the economy is going to be devastating no matter what the official policy is.
- generalpass 7y ago> Even in areas where they are opening up, people aren’t in any hurry to travel unnecessarily, be in crowds, go to restaurants, etc. Covid’s effect on the economy is going to devastating no matter what the official policy is. Interesting that you have changed the topic. This is indicative of a broad problem that I am observing: nobody wants to discuss economic consequences and even mentioning this will result in either very heavy down-voting or outright deplatforming[1]. My question is rather specific to how long the economy can last while held in lockdown and whether the Times has ever reported such concerns. The economy does things like bring us food and pay for the health care that is supposed to save us from the virus. Without the economy, we don't have food and we don't have health care. If some percentage of the population is actively blocked from having jobs while having no income, no government subsidies, and no savings, then "civil unrest" becomes reality. This is historically true. [1] If you think that discussion of the economy is somehow a hidden message about 5G, anti-vaxx, NWO, etc., then you really need to take some time to learn economics, and I would also suggest some critical thinking, philosophy, and reading comprehension review.
- mkl 7y agoUm, what flattening curve? Flattening growth rates just mean linear growth instead of exponential. Flattening total or active case numbers is what flattening the curve usually means. Here are some clearer graphs: https://boogheta.github.io/coronavirus-countries/#currently_sick&ratio&places=Australia,Belgium,Brazil,Denmark,France,Germany,Italy,Japan,New%20Zealand,Norway,Russia,Singapore,Spain,Sweden,USA,United%20Kingdom&alignTo=confirmed https://boogheta.github.io/coronavirus-countries/#currently_... (active cases normalised by population) https://boogheta.github.io/coronavirus-countries/#deceased&places=Australia,Belgium,Brazil,Denmark,France,Germany,Italy,Japan,New%20Zealand,Norway,Russia,Singapore,Spain,Sweden,USA,United%20Kingdom&alignTo=confirmed https://boogheta.github.io/coronavirus-countries/#deceased&p... (deaths, absolute numbers)
- tomohawk 7y agoI wouldn't get too spun up by an opinion piece designed to spin you up. But, since you asked: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/daily-covid-deaths-per-million-7-day-average?country=USA https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/daily-covid-deaths-per-mi...
- Retric 7y agoDead people don’t require medical attention. Flattening the curve is about hospitals getting overwhelmed even if similar numbers of people get sick and die either way. The difference between hypothetically 1 million deaths vs 1.2 million deaths makes a huge difference for 200,000 people.
- tomohawk 7y agoI have a family member working in a major metropolitan hospital. They are not overwhelmed. By all accounts, our state is at or past the peak, and we are not even close to being overwhelmed. Many doctors and nurses are actually out of work as "elective" procedures are on hold. Measuring the number of cases as the testing is being massively bumped out does not measure overload - actual death rate does.
- austincheney 7y agoI like how they made an example of Texas where I live. My observation is that people in urban areas aren’t take this seriously from their frequent visits to stores for shopping, lack of face masks, eagerness for normalcy and so forth. The risk of exposure is multiplicative of population density. Counter-intuitively the lower risk rural areas appear to be taking this far more seriously. It seems impatience will get the best of us. The only way to beat this is with very strict exercising of social distancing for not less than three months, healthy habits, and extreme sanitation. It seems urban areas are not willing to wait 3 months until there is an uncontrolled outbreak.
- paypalcust83 7y agoI got the heck out the SF Bay Area to semi-rural NorCal, and have a good 12 months of food that would normally get eaten anyhow. Curiously, I frequently see drivers speeding down the street here with their vehicle windows down, no masks, and acting like there's no such thing as a virus. One of the adjacent properties is constructing a house and multiple neighbors have been chainsawing pines and oaks nonstop for the past month. In 3 months, I've only been off-property once for an emergency dental visit. I don't think there is, or ever will be, sufficient testing evidence to justify similar-to-past public interaction until if or when there is a safe and effective vaccine deployed that covers all strains. The prevalence is basically unknown and will only be worse when there is no longer mindshare or patience to keep up the fight... I think nearly all of this socioeconomic pain will be for naught because of the endgame.
- draw_down 7y agoYou think people are getting this from driving their cars with the window down? What?
- graeme 7y agoFlu hits rural areas hardest, but hits them later than it hits cities. I wouldn’t make quick assumptions this early on. This may be different, as people don’t take flu as seriously. But America is already loosening up. You also can’t see stuff as clearly in rural areas. The big risks are indoor gatherings at private homes, church, work, and school. If you aren’t doing those things, you won’t see them happening. Whereas it’s easy to see people walking on an urban street as you drive by, or to watch the news going to a central urban location. You see this with crime rates. People assume it’s a big city issue due to visibility, but crime rates tend to be higher in rural areas. Coronavirus may well require urban density, but don’t be too quick to assume it as an axiom. https://www.ajc.com/news/state--regional/flu-hits-rural-georgia-hard-data-shows-will-covid-the-same/dzStNJhbzIVTQJ7MG0PfJP/ https://www.ajc.com/news/state--regional/flu-hits-rural-geor...
- amelius 7y agoWhat's that strangle blip in the last days of Sweden's data?
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoI'm not sure, but typically when that happens there's a change either in how deaths are counted or how tests are administered.
- amelius 7y agoCould the historical data be adjusted for this blip? Because now it looks like Sweden's curve is flattening.
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoRetconning the data? That's highly unpopular among a vocal minority. Typically these sorts of things show the raw data and allow people to extrapolate 'real' infection rates etc for themselves. Changing all data from before there was a change in the measurement standard would be putting extrapolation right into the data feed. I think the responsible thing to do might be to show error bars, then it would be more intuitive what happened.
- watwut 7y agoIt takes them till they counted all deaths, the bureaucracy is just slow. So last days data for Sweden (but also other coutries) are odd.
- llarsson 7y agoWhich graph are you looking at?
- amelius 7y agohttps://boogheta.github.io/coronavirus-countries/#currently_sick&ratio&places=Australia,Belgium,Brazil,Denmark,France,Germany,Italy,Japan,New%20Zealand,Norway,Russia,Singapore,Spain,Sweden,USA,United%20Kingdom&alignTo=confirmed https://boogheta.github.io/coronavirus-countries/#currently_...
- chasd00 7y agothere's enough metrics and ways to manipulate them to support any agenda. we'll probably never get any real insight until after the US election.
- SllX 7y agoYou know what's not being reported on? I'm going through the charts on https://www.worldometers.info https://www.worldometers.info and I notice something. There's different tabs for "cases" and "active cases", and you can drill down into some individual countries (like the USA), and you can drill down into some individual States (like California). So I'm going through it today, and one of the columns is total deaths. So for the purposes of this thread, Closed Cases = Deaths + Recoveries, and while there isn't a column for recoveries specifically, you can infer a couple of things from the data that is there. First, the data sucks. Each State and in some cases, each county health department is responsible for reporting their own cases and deaths, but it seems not every place is making good efforts to track recoveries. If you drill into California and check San Francisco, and it's not limited to just San Francisco, you can see the "Active Cases" over in about the sixth column is only Cases - Deaths instead of Cases - (Deaths + Recoveries). Not all 58 Counties are like this, but you also have outliers like Humboldt where apparently 52 of 54 total cases are recoveries because there aren't any reported deaths and there's only 2 reported active cases. It isn't limited to just individual counties in California. If you go back up a level to the USA and look at various States, you can see that New York is making some effort to track recoveries because at a glance, Active Cases does not equal Cases - Deaths, it's actually quite a bit lower than Cases - Deaths, which is good. But if you look below New York at New Jersey which has had the second highest number of cases, it would seem like every closed case has been a death, because Active Cases = Cases - Deaths, same probably with San Francisco County in California. So when I last looked a few hours ago, the United States had about 964K Active Cases. This is probably both an overcount and an undercount. It's certainly an undercount because we obviously have no idea how many people are actively carrying it right now. But it's also an overcount because of the verified cases, recoveries are being underreported. This bloody chart in the NYTimes is annoying. It is seemingly trying to apply some corrective measures to people's expectations about how much the curve is actually flattening in the country, that it is not equally flattened, and that reporting is fine. It's leaving out half the bloody story which is: recoveries. If the goal is to lead and not mislead with this piece, then by not attempting to address the discrepancy in reported cases and active cases, and how many closed cases are closed because of recoveries and not because of deaths, it will leave people with a sense that maybe the country is in worse straits than we think, or at least different pockets. To be blunt, nobody knows. They don't know, the Administration doesn't know, apparently half the bloody Governors don't have a clue about a big part of the situation in their own States in addition to almost every other part of the situation, and if you assume that in terms of closed verified cases, recoveries outnumber deaths 4:1, then New Jersey should probably be subtracting somewhere around 30K Active Cases (assuming there have been 4x as many recoveries as their reported 8K deaths). A lot of people are dying or dead, but what about the other side of this coin? How many are recovering, and why don't we know? Is it really the case that in New Jersey, not a single person has reportedly recovered and all the closed cases are actually deaths? The number that's getting trotted out by the media in terms of cases is 1.2M (implicitly, verified cases rather than actual cases). But we don't currently have 1M verified active cases, we may not even have 900K (yet) but the best available data I can find doesn't even reflect that.
- spodek 7y agoMy science background leads me to look at the situation as the NY Times does. I find this article compelling in motivating me to support sticking with protocols from science experts on social distancing, etc. Last week I appeared on a very pro-Trump podcast. The starting point for the very pro-Trump person was freedom and the economy. Numbers like in this article seemed irrelevant to him, or even signs of people trying to seize more power. If we want to lower the spread of this pandemic, our biggest challenge is influencing people's behavior. If telling people more numbers doesn't influence people how we intend, they may be verifiable and right, but if we want to save lives, including our own, we have to figure out what works. Elsewhere in this thread somebody wrote > Another story with tunnel vision. > I don't pay attention to the NY Times, but have they had any opinion pieces suggesting that maybe the destruction of the economy is also a bad thing? And, maybe, someone besides a reporter or "health expert" should make some kind of attempt to determine if it is even possible to sustain these policies? > I really feel like I'm in a Tales from Dark Side episode. Currently the comment is downvoted to near invisibility. But that perspective is motivating tens of millions of people. If we want to motivate them, we have to figure out how to respond. Spewing facts, however right, if it motivates people to stop listening, or downvoting instead of addressing is a matter of life and death. How do we respond effectively to people with such views?
- dhimes 7y agoChanging people's minds to something they don't want to hear is really difficult. I have a personal hypothesis that some people are just really bad at abstract reasoning- they don't really get patterns, and they can't see the same pattern in a different context. Even something like, "If we're wrong and come out of this too early we may have to do this all over again next fall."
- DuskStar 7y agoWell, here's something you're going to love to hear, then: "If we do this right and come out of it this summer, we're still going to have to do it again this fall"
- 7y ago
- foolzcrow 7y agoWe flattened the curve and now we know this is global government attack. 0.1 deathrate is comparable to flu. We've been had.