37 ms·
Separated employees will receive 14 weeks of pay, and one more week for each year served at the company (rounding partial years up). The firm is also dropping i
by keiferski 7y ago
Separated employees will receive 14 weeks of pay, and one more week for each year served at the company (rounding partial years up). The firm is also dropping its one-year equity cliff so that employees who are laid off with under 12 months of tenure can buy their vested options; Airbnb will also provide 12 months of health insurance through COBRA in the United States, and health care coverage through 2020 in the rest of the world.
That strikes me as a pretty generous severance package.
- actuator 7y agoDropping the cliff period for new employees is pretty much useless. The equity/ESOPs new employees will be exercising will be of the last valuation price which would be already high, and after Covid-19, with the struggles of tourism industry as such the notional value would have fallen a lot. So if you exercise those significantly expensive options now, you would probably need to hold it for a long time and really believe that AirBnB can be where it was.
- lucasmullens 7y agoFrom some other comments it sounds like they're RSUs, not options.
- actuator 7y agoWhy do you need to buy the RSUs then? Don't you already get them once they vest.
- truthwhisperer 7y agodoes it matter? You want to make the world a better place right? Or is the world defined as a 50^2 place somewhere in a too expensive part of the world .. hmm
- hilbertseries 7y agoI think there was a 1 year vesting cliff, so if you get laid off before a year you get your rsus prorated instead of getting nothing.
- duxup 7y agoYeah that's generous by most standards.
- namdnay 7y agoBy most American standards
- speedgoose 7y ago~~Yes, because it's pretty shitty for Europe.~~ I didn't understand well, sorry.
- duxup 7y agoWhat's the average for Europe?
- disiplus 7y agoafaik in some countries its not required (switzerland?) and in others it depends on the number of years the person worked in company. i think it depends on the country.
- Schweigi 7y agoNo severance pay required in Switzerland but there will be a mandatory one month to three months notice period. A company can decide to send their workers home earlier but they would still be required to pay salary for that period. Though when laying of 25% there will be some additional government requirements as it would be classified as a mass-layoff and will need a social plan.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- KoftaBob 7y ago"In many countries, the severance pay is a lump sum that increases with the employee’s tenure in the company and their wage level. In the Czech Republic, Denmark, Hungary, Italy, Lithuania, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia and Spain, employees with service of up to one year are entitled to severance pay (in most cases one month’s pay), while in Luxembourg employees have to have a minimum of five years within the organisation before receiving severance pay. In France and Slovenia, employees with up to five years’ tenure are entitled to severance pay amounting to a maximum of one month’s pay; in Spain, the entitlement is 100 days’ pay for the same tenure." AirBnB is giving laid off workers around 3 months of severance pay. How is that less competitive than what's given in Europe?
- vkou 7y agoBack in the day, severance packages for white collar workers were close to one month per year served. My father received that from Kodak (Not once, but twice... He had the rare privilege of being laid off (From the same team, no less) in 2009, and then again in 2016. The severance package did not change much between each of his stints of employment.) With that schedule, anyone who worked at AirBnB for four years or less looks to be in a similar position.
- MattGaiser 7y ago4 years at Airbnb would be quite a long time.
- FireBeyond 7y agoMy brother (in Australia) got that this year. 14 months severance after 14 years.
- spats1990 7y ago>Back in the day, severance packages for white collar workers were close to one month per year served. in Korea this rule is in actual labour law. One month's salary for each year employed fulltime, for everybody.
- yojo 7y agoI’m surprised they were still handing out options - don’t most later stage startups switch to RSUs? I’d hate to have to decide whether to exercise today, cliff or no cliff.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoI haven't seen RSUs outside of publicly traded companies.
- kahnjw 7y agoI got an RSU offer from Pinterest a couple years back when they were private, though I turned it down.
- actuator 7y agoNon listed companies do give RSUs. For example: Stripe
- pb7 7y agoRSUs are common in late stage startups. The share price at the time of grant is calculated based on an estimated valuation. If I remember correctly, in the year or two leading up to IPO, Uber issued RSUs to employees at a valuation of $49/share so the IPO price of $45 was already below grant price for many that joined late.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hibikir 7y agoLate stage startups have to offer RSUs, as the equivalent option package becomes extremely unattractive if you depart before the company is public. Imagine, for example, an initial option grant of 180K shares at $2.00, which expire 90 days after you leave. Then fast forward two years: The valuations have doubled every year, and half are vested, so you have 90k options priced at $2, but that last valuation puts at $8 each. Sounds like you have a lot of potential money right? Maybe, but not if you leave. If the company isn't public, you either have to rely on some secondary market that might be really shady, or have to hold your shares until IPO. To do so, you need to spend $180K, and prepare for an AMT tax hit of, roughly, 28% of the gains. 90k shares, with $6 a a share paper gains, means $135k in taxes that year. So barring that secondary market for the shares, we are talking about spending $300k exercising the options. Few people can, or are willing, to put that much money in, even if on paper they are up hundreds of thousands of dollars. RSUs will demand action at IPO, as you can't delay the exercise forever, but it's far better than, in practice, letting a majority of options lapse, even when you are pretty sure they'll be deep in the money at IPO.
- hef19898 7y agoDeleted
- vkou 7y agoIn parts of countries like Canada, the last part isn't particularly important, but it's not nothing. Typically, white collar employers cover, in part, or in full, medical insurance premiums that every resident is expected to pay. In BC, prior to the recent phase-out, it was ~$900/year. (That money now comes out of income taxes.) Employers paying for that kind of benefit is either tax-advantaged, or just consistency of policy between their US, and Canadian offices. Not sure which.
- hef19898 7y agoDamn, deleted the comment to soon it seems... Agree, for the US it isn't to bad a package, especially considering the circumstances and the health care system. All the best for the affected people!
- schkkd 7y agoThat's why when a yet another aspiring startup wants to hire me, I ask for a high sign on bonus as an insurance, monthly vesting cycle, at least 200k in base pay and high severance upon termination. Never been given that, but I don't regret: looking back, all those "just 1 year till IPO" companies are underwater.
- colordrops 7y agoMost startups are an unintentional scam by unwitting founders.
- rob_austin 7y agovery astutely stated. I think many of us make fundamental attribution mistake - what can be attributed to ignorance/stupidity should not be attributed to malice.
- ithkuil 7y agoAnybody accepted those terms?
- Southland 7y agoHe literally wrote "Never been given that"
- ithkuil 7y agothere are other people here who might have made similar attempts
- schkkd 7y agoNope, no one. And I could negotiate terms with directors, VPs and CEOs (of small firms) over lunches: meaning that they deemed it valuable enough to spend a few hours of their time on me, make a sales pitch and listen. Some admitted that while my terms were reasonable, it would just too expensive for their company to hire me.
- 7y ago
- dominotw 7y agoI found COBRA to be extremely expensive. I instead enrolled in obamacare via job loss exception.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoIt sounds like it's saying that Airbnb will pay for COBRA for that duration.
- alfalfasprout 7y agoAirbnb employee here-- this is the consensus.
- fbourque 7y agoIf it is the case it seems out of context to refer to this severance benefit as COBRA as it is my understanding this program has been specifically designed by Congress to force employers to offer the "opportunity" for the separated employees to get health insurance at full cost (without the employer subsidy). Since the Affordable Care Act, it seems to be cheaper to forego COBRA benefit and enroll in one of the offered options. Lost of job let you do so outside of the official enrolment period.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoNobody is stopping aribnb from paying the full cost of Cobra, after the option is provided as is legally obligated. It is certainly not cheaper to forgo free COBRA and buy insurance on the exchange.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoMy read of that is that AirBnB is paying the premiums for the next 12 months, as regardless of what the company does all employees are eligible to stay on their employee plan and pay their own premiums for 18 months.
- julesqs 7y agoit's generous by startup standards, but laid off kickstarter employees are getting an even better deal because they unionized: four months full pay for everyone, up to six months of paid (not COBRA healthcare), recall rights if the jobs open back up, release from non competes https://twitter.com/ksr_united/status/1256382357311012871 https://twitter.com/ksr_united/status/1256382357311012871
- tpmoney 7y agoSince COBRA is always available to terminated employees, this announcement reads that AirBnb is paying for 12 months of health care.
- julesqs 7y agoah you might be right. wording confused me.
- johnnyb9 7y agoHow is this an even better deal? About the same amount of pay, half the healthcare paid (COBRA healthcare is same plan). As for recall rights and release from non-competes, these are slightly better than nothing I suppose.
- elhudy 7y agoGlad to see the money they are stealing from those of us who can't cancel our summer airBNBs is going to a good cause.
- pwned1 7y agoIs it just a certain time period? I've cancelled two stays and have received full refunds, but both were in April and May of this year.
- elhudy 7y agoMine is late June / Early July in Italy of all places, and is not covered. They keep extending the coverage period though so I'm crossing my fingers.
- ramimac 7y agoThey're gradually pushing the time period back, as of a couple days ago I believe it was end of May. As of right now it's for "stays and Airbnb Experiences made on or before March 14, 2020, with a check-in date between March 14, 2020 and June 15, 2020" Of course, events as far out as late July are cancelled due to COVID-19 https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/2701/extenuating-circumstances-policy-and-the-coronavirus-covid19 https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/2701/extenuating-circums...
- elhudy 7y agoAdditionally, this policy has been modified since COVID arose to only apply to 1.5 months out. In the past, and in fact when I booked my airbnb (late last year), extenuating circumstances would have easily covered an epidemic 2 months out.
- saiya-jin 7y agoHow come you can't cancel? Did you book at place with strict cancellation policy or is there something else?
- 7y ago
- markdown 7y ago> Separated employees Separated? Is this American english?
- keiferski 7y agoSounds like a weird new euphemism for laid off, designed to make it seem less negative.
- bogomipz 7y agoIt's actually an HR(human resources) term. There's a standard document employees sign called a "separation agreement." See: https://gusto.com/blog/people-management/employee-separation-agreement https://gusto.com/blog/people-management/employee-separation...
- HumblyTossed 7y agoCompanies go out of their way to use words that they hope will soften what is actually happening. Separated almost sounds as if this was consensual. That being said, Airbnb gets some credit for a decent severance.
- spacefearing 7y agoI'm not a fan of Airbnb's business but this is highly commendable. The severance package is the core metric to judge a company that is doing layoffs. In this case, it sounds like Airbnb did the right thing. Airbnb fired people well in advance of when they were actually forced to. This enabled them to provide an ethical severance. Some companies wait until the last minute and then provide two weeks or similar. These companies should be publicly shamed for all time.
- texasbigdata 7y agoAgree with you but.... 4x12 = 48 weeks of compensation disbursed by the entity. Restated compared to some nightmare no severance scenario meant they effectively terminated 4 FTEs to achieve slightly less than 3 FTEs of cost savings (adjusted for healthcare costs). I'm not arguing against AirBNBs approach btw. Their CEO had a wonderful podcast on the Masters of Scale pod roughly two weeks ago. However the Rawlsian philosophy on that marginal employee that got terminated effectively to fund the severance for herself and her colleagues is a tricky ethical consideration.
- danenania 7y agoIt doesn't seem all that tricky to me. While losing any job is rough, losing a job with enough severance and benefits to cover the ensuing period of uncertainty and a job search likely isn't going to be that bad for people who were able to get hired by Airbnb to begin with. But losing a job without a safety net could be a disaster. Imo it's far better to put more people in the 'bad, but not that bad' situation than to put anyone in the 'disaster' situation.
- mgiampapa 7y agoI wouldn't judge them too softly, they did after all promote having an internal services food team for years and virtue signaled all over the place that they wanted them to be team members and not contractors like every other tech company (they got stock, sick days, vacation, benefits etc), then fired them all over Christmas break one year and replaced them with contractors.
- ulfw 7y agoTotally agreed. Those are very generous terms, no matter where in the world. Well done AirBnB.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- three_seagrass 7y agoDo employees have to waive filing unemployment to accept the severance package? In California those can last up to six months.
- kirubakaran 7y agoNo, California considers severance to be compensation for past work.
- pb7 7y agoI don't think they're legally allowed to waive your unemployment insurance payout.
- chadlavi 7y agoAt first I misread this as 14 days and was wondering why everyone is calling this such a "lavish" severance. Now I get it.
- keiferski 7y agoSomehow 14 weeks also seems less than 3 1/3 months, even though they’re the same.
- andy_ppp 7y agoAnd slight more that a quarter of a year seems more to me again...
- ryantgtg 7y agoBut those all seem pale next to 98 days.
- dan-robertson 7y agoI get paid monthly and have a yearly salary so three and a half months or slightly over a quarter of a year are durations I can more easily convert to an idea of money (or time), which I think is the point. If I hear 14 weeks or 98 days I can’t easily (ie naturally) convert it into terms I can think about.
- Bang2Bay 7y agoif numbers sway one like this, pre-ipo company is not the place one want to be
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 7y agoThey aren't the same. 1 month is not 4 weeks. 1 month, on average is 4.348 weeks, so 14 weeks is actually 3.22 months.
- darkerside 7y agoAllowing former new employees to buy shares in a private company essentially at cost doesn't seem terribly generous to me.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- senderista 7y ago“We had to let you go to pay for your severance package.”
- polote 7y agoThat's roughly equivalent to what anyone in France would get if they get fired
- Joky 7y agoAccording to https://shieldgeo.com/terminating-an-employee-in-france-a-guide-for-overseas-employers/ https://shieldgeo.com/terminating-an-employee-in-france-a-gu... it would rather be roughly 1 week pay per year of seniority. However it is hardly comparable as unemployment benefits would kick in (on average 72% of your previous salary after taxes, maximum duration 24 months with decreasing amount). For instance if you worked 3 years and your annual salary was 80k, you could get a benefit of 57k over 12 months.
- polote 7y agothere is a mandatory 3 months notice period
- fcantournet 7y agoYou get 3 month of mandatory notice period (if you had a "CDI" which is permanent employment) You get 1w/y on top of that.
- arcticbull 7y agoSounds amazing, I wish someone would lay me off like that, damn. Four months PTO with healthcare?!
- scarface74 7y ago"Airbnb will also provide 12 months of health insurance through COBRA" That just means that it is available to you -- not that they are going to subsidize it.
- mlinsey 7y agoAnyone who loses health insurance due to losing their employment (even if they voluntarily resign) is legally allowed to buy COBRA for 18 months. I think they are paying for it, otherwise this would be a fairly meaningless statement since the employer isn't involved with COBRA at all and that's less eligibility than any employee would have.
- nicesave 7y agoMany times employers will make statements like this for better PR (always leaving out that they were required to)
- arcticbull 7y agoI mean, if they're paying 4 months salary, and healthcare optional, they'd probably just pay 3.5 months salary and offer healthcare.
- paulcole 7y agoCan you name a single time this has happened?
- RussianCow 7y agoAlmost literally every company that had to make changes in compliance with COVID-19 health and safety guidelines.
- rb808 7y agoAs a European, that isn't great. (options excepted). Usually I thought you get 14 weeks plus a month for every year of service, not a week.
- conanbatt 7y agoAnd typically much higher unemployment numbers
- r00fus 7y agoNot these days. Europe is doing much better than the US in terms of unemployment - wonder why?
- rubber_duck 7y agoAs a European I wouldn't be too fast to gloat - the EU is trying to keep jobs on hold but it's not clear to me what will come out of this - it seems like the restrictions are going to be here for a long time and keeping businesses afloat artificially could end up blocking restructuring. My biggest concern right now is that migration restrictions are going to kill seasonal manual labor migration and government unemployment subsidies will prevent local population from taking up that work - we could end up with major issues in things like crop harvesting.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 7y agoWhere is that? Many countries are already taking seasonal workers with 14 day quarantine.
- shuckles 7y agoThe USA's unemployment rate in March 2020 (4.4%) was lower than the EU's unemployment rate in January 2020 (6.2%) according to a very casual Google search. I'm curious how you're drawing this. Are you saying the EU has lower unemployment today than it did in January?
- freepor 7y agoI have never seen a more generous one.
- cm2187 7y agoThat also means they have no expectation for the market to come back for at least 2 years.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- screye 7y agoThis makes me think, they value their reputation a lot more than the greedy 'minimize losses' option. This way, they still save money over 2020, while hopefully hitting the ground running when the whole thing clears up.
- perlpimp 7y agoI moved to Canada for a job and month later disbanded,told my job went to India and not paid my outstanding wages. So yeah pretty generous.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- xivzgrev 7y agoWow! 14 weeks of pay is freaking amazing. Add the other stuff on and...takes the sting out quite a bit. Bravo Airbnb.
- Pfhreak 7y agoIt's generous, but I also wish it was normal.
- sytelus 7y agoIsn't there much better way? Many big cities are projected to start opening up in June. I would expect life coming back to normal around August end. So that's basically 4 months. Why not just keep paying instead of doing severance and lose all these well-trained talent? If you are doubtful if 4 months will be enough, you can still offer option of continued employment at 50% or 75% pay? I feel move like this tarnishes stability aspect of companies. Does anyone now want to sell their houses and move to where AirBnB is so they have their job in future?
- coopsmgoops 7y agoI guess they expect a recession even afterwards, so that means reduced travel for potentially years.
- KorematsuFred 7y ago14 weeks is pretty good generous package IMO. Typically 6 weeks is standard so h1b employees could find another job.
- wdb 7y ago14 weeks pay, don't they just mean that you are on garden leave while given notice? That's quite common in Europe, have to admit the one year health insurance is a nice extra which is the first time I hear about it.
- londons_explore 7y agoWhat incentive does an employer have to give a generous severence? Sure, there is a slight PR benefit, and you have slightly more chance of rehiring those employees later maybe, but as a shareholder it really seems to be throwing money away unless the severance package was agreed upfront when the employee was first hired (ie. as an incentive to join the company).
- vishnugupta 7y agoFree Apple laptop to boot. This must be an industry first.
- gigatexal 7y agoYeah that’s what I thought as well. The health insurance part is even more profound than the weeks of pay imo