9 ms·
Wtf? That’s insane. I can just randomly DDOS projects by submitting DMCA notices? Edit: Just realized there’s nothing distributed about it.
by Aeolun 7y ago
Wtf? That’s insane. I can just randomly DDOS projects by submitting DMCA notices?
Edit: Just realized there’s nothing distributed about it.
- CKN23-ARIN 7y agoFalse DMCA notices are, in theory, perjury, but in practice, yes.
- redwall_hp 7y agoHave we ever seen a media company prosecuted for perjury, despite copious evidence that they constantly misuse DMCA takedowns to do exactly that?
- monocasa 7y agoNope.
- sneak 7y agoNot once, no.
- downerending 7y agoNot sure anyone ever gets prosecuted for perjury. It's the norm in divorce cases, for example.
- saagarjha 7y agoWell there was the contempt of court and all with Bill Clinton…
- monocasa 7y agoAnd the amount of times I've seen a cop perjure themselves is unreal. We know that our former Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper perjured himself before congress with impunity as well. https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2018/01/19/james-clappers-perjury-dc-made-men-dont-get-charged-lying-congress-jonathan-turley-column/1045991001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2018/01/19/james-clap...
- downerending 7y agoProbably shouldn't drip gasoline on this smoldering dumpster fire, but pretty much anyone at a high political level that testifies "I can't remember" is probably committing perjury, yes. Oh well. https://www.newsweek.com/ken-starr-says-he-almost-charged-hillary-clinton-perjury-1117125 https://www.newsweek.com/ken-starr-says-he-almost-charged-hi...
- nullc 7y agoI received bogus DMCA complaints (over Big Buck Bunny, lol, multiple times), and Google stonewalled me when I tried to find out the identity of the complainant so that I could litigate against them. I expect situations like that contribute to the lack of response, along with the fact that providers often ignore DMCA complaints or put things back up without following the statutory takedown period.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Google stonewalled me when I tried to find out the identity of the complainant so that I could litigate against them Playing devil's advocate, that information may have been protected by NDA. In that case, you'd have to sue Google to divulge the complainant.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoDMCA or Google's/YouTube's internal copyright dispute resolution process?
- nullc 7y agoGoogle's form letter claimed it was a DMCA complaint, but it might have been confused.
- colejohnson66 7y agoWhy do people say never? It has happened, albeit extremely rarely: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act#Automattic,_Inc._and_Oliver_Hotham_v._Nick_Steiner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_A...
- sneak 7y agoYou seem to be conflating a civil countersuit and a criminal prosecution for the crime of perjury.
- Dylan16807 7y agoNegligence is not against the DMCA rules, and they can always claim they were being negligent, so no.
- lostcolony 7y agoOut of touch politicians coming up with tech policy in the 90s. Tada!
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoPresumably, you'd have to succeed in that notice leading to a takedown. The 10 day waiting period only presumably kicked in when GitHub decided the DMCA was valid and actionable.
- URSpider94 7y agoNo, Github has no discretion in this process. Their only job is to follow the policy to the letter: provide the notice to the presumed offender and disable content, then forward the counter-notice to the original complainant and re-enable the content in 10 days.
- KenoFischer 7y agoGitHub can decide a takedown notice is facially invalid. Of course if it's later found that they're wrong by a court of competent jurisdiction, they'd be in trouble, so they're likely to be extremely conservative in making this determination.
- URSpider94 7y agoI'm curious to know whether platforms ever even bother to evaluate takedowns, beyond the most basic fact-checking (e.g. the item to be taken down is spelled properly). It seems like one of those cases where the risk of getting it wrong outweighs the benefit of trying to discriminate between good and bad requests.
- colejohnson66 7y agoDoesn’t Google deny DMCA requests sometimes?
- duskwuff 7y agoSometimes. Not as often as they should, but they will at least reject keyword-based delisting requests for obviously innocent web properties like Wikipedia or IMDB (typically because they have an page about the movie that some overzealous "copyright defense" outfit is trying to protect).
- khun533 7y agoThis is why you should never host your open source project on a US server. You're one DMCA notice away from being destroyed, needing a lawyer to counter claim properly, etc. This is insanity. Git hosted in Europe: https://codeberg.org/ https://codeberg.org/ Anyone know other git hosts outside the US? pls reply
- lazyjones 7y agoPerhaps you're right, but perhaps DMCA takedowns are a preferred alternative to what the MPAA does in other situations, like the Kim Dotcom raid in NZ.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoOther areas that could be used would be like Tor and IPFS. Tor is anti-censorship but can be a SPOF. IPFS provides full identity of machine to the network (internal and external IPs), but is highly redundant and resistant to single attacks. And IPFS refuses to mainline work for Tor/I2P... So it still spits out every adapter to the world. Yes, even your internal non-routable addresses.
- i_d_rather_read 7y ago> This is why you should never host your open source project on a US server. You're one DMCA notice away from being destroyed, needing a lawyer to counter claim properly, etc. This is an excellent takeaway that should be upvoted.
- kevingadd 7y agoYes, you can, and there's nothing the victim can do about it. Many service providers won't even give you the details of the person who submitted the notice so you can sue them (Google, for example).