7 ms·
Flu or not, it's possible to compare all-cause mortality this year against previous years. That's about as hard data as it gets. How does Covid compare to "seas
by HPsquared 7y ago
Flu or not, it's possible to compare all-cause mortality this year against previous years. That's about as hard data as it gets. How does Covid compare to "seasonal all-cause-winter-deaths"? That's what people are interested in - how unprecedented is the death rate?
- ceejayoz 7y agoIt's possible, and it's being done. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/27/upshot/coronavirus-deaths-new-york-city.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/27/upshot/corona... > The recent death count reached six times the normal number of deaths for the city at this time of year, a surge in deaths much larger than what could be attributed to normal seasonal variations from influenza, heart disease or other more common causes. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronavirus-missing-deaths.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronav... > These numbers undermine the notion that many people who have died from the virus may soon have died anyway. In Paris, more than twice the usual number of people have died each day, far more than the peak of a bad flu season. In New York City, the number has spiked to six times the normal amount.
- Fjolsvith 7y ago> These numbers undermine the notion that many people who have died from the virus may soon have died anyway. In Paris, more than twice the usual number of people have died each day, far more than the peak of a bad flu season. In New York City, the number has spiked to six times the normal amount. I'm betting that in the next few years the death rate will drastically fall because the only people left will be really healthy.
- smnrchrds 7y agoIf it is killing people a couple of years earlier than they otherwise would have died, it is fair to consider them excess deaths.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Fjolsvith 7y agoAre you counting more than one death per person?
- mcphage 7y ago> I'm betting that in the next few years the death rate will drastically fall because the only people left will be really healthy. If everybody died this year, then next year's death rate will be zero! That's not a good thing.
- simonh 7y agoExcept that people who survive severe illness with Covid-19 often seem to suffer severe organ damage as a result. Mortality among Covid survivors is therefore likely to be higher than normal in the coming years, so it’s unclear how the numbers will pan out.
- harryh 7y agoI will take that bet! I'd say that "drastically" means 20% or more. How much would you like to wager?
- ModernMech 7y agoIf you are old or infirm when you contract a bad case of corona, you die. If you are relatively young and completely healthy, you spend a month in the hospital; get onto a ventilator for weeks requiring heavy sedation; lose your ability to walk, talk, feed yourself and brush your teeth; have to relearn how to swallow; maybe suffer a collapsed lung and upon release if you're lucky are confined to a wheelchair and physical therapy unable to take care of yourself, your loved ones, and return to your job. Death is not the only negative outcome of this disease. "Recovery" from corona is sometimes the beginning of a long and slow struggle. I'm looking forward to any analysis on the economic cost of this.
- augustt 7y agoIf you are relatively young and completely healthy ... you overwhelmingly recover completely fine.
- malandrew 7y agoThe number of young people that are healthy (no pre-existing conditions like being overweight, diabetes or high blood pressure) that that experience what you describe is extremely rare.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> no pre-existing conditions like being overweight, diabetes or high blood pressure Well over half the country ticks one of those boxes. 70% of Americans are either obese or overweight.
- nradov 7y agoThe coronavirus is going to with us for a long time; we're unlikely to get a miracle cure or effective vaccine anytime soon. On average American adults are about 27lbs (12kg) above their healthy weight. That means if they start losing weight now at a safe, sustainable rate then most people can be down to a healthy weight in a year or so. Obviously there is a huge amount of individual variation but most people can take steps to improve their individual odds of survival.
- nradov 7y ago> These numbers undermine the notion that many people who have died from the virus may soon have died anyway. This is known as mortality displacement or the harvesting effect. We won't actually know whether this was a significant factor until we see future all-cause mortality statistics.
- cm2187 7y agoI think by "soon" I think he meant a few days but I don't know that anyone is making that claim.
- malandrew 7y agoOne question I have is how many of these excess deaths is due to coronavirus and how many are due to our response to coronavirus since people are not getting their regular health care. For example, my dad has congestive heart failure and sees his doctor once a month and gets an EKG every time. I've been in appointments and the majority of the discussion centers around changes in his EKGs from the previous months. Right now, he's not getting these regular checkups and appointments. He could have a change in prognosis go undetected and end up with a preventable heart attack. Is coronavirus the black swan event or is our reaction to coronavirus the black swan event. It's hard to say. Looking at all cause mortality excess deaths between Sweden and lockdown countries, it's hard to say: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronavirus-missing-deaths.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronav... One question I'm also curious about is if in the years following the coronavirus, will we see negative excess deaths relative to previous seasonal averages because of the excess deaths right now.
- zests 7y agoYeah, its quite amazing how poor our data is. Combine that with how politicized the issue is and I don't think we will ever have reliable numbers.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> One question I have is how many of these excess deaths is due to coronavirus and how many are due to our response to coronavirus since people are not getting their regular health care. I wouldn't personally know where to start on getting the data, but you can likely tease this out by evaluating populations with already limited access to healthcare - uninsured, low-income folks with $13k deductibles, etc. Have you considered getting your dad an Apple Watch, so he can do his EKGs at home and send to a doc? Not as effective as a twelve-lead, but maybe it'd help at least somewhat?
- malandrew 7y agoI've been looking at the KardiaMobile but the reviews on Amazon look pretty bad. How well does the Apple Watch perform since it's just on a wrist?
- thu2111 7y agoYou've selected anecdotes from two very specific places. But that cuts both ways. There are plenty of places where so far they have been equally or less affected than a flu season. For instance the UK is doing worse than most other countries in Europe but currently there are quite a few years within my life with similar death numbers by this point in the year: http://inproportion2.talkigy.com/ http://inproportion2.talkigy.com/ Or look at the graphs for Europe: https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps/ https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps/ There are some countries where it's higher than the flu seasons in the past 4 years. But there are other countries where it's equal or lower. Overall weekly mortality in the EuroMOMO reporting countries peaked at approx 2x that of 2016, approx 20k deaths per week more. Given the large populations of these countries this is a tiny change. To put that in perspective 20k people is 0.03% of the British population alone, but you'd also need to include all the other countries to get the real percentage.
- r721 7y ago>Mortality statistics show 122,000 deaths in excess of normal levels across 14 countries analysed by the FT https://www.ft.com/content/6bd88b7d-3386-4543-b2e9-0d5c6fac846c https://www.ft.com/content/6bd88b7d-3386-4543-b2e9-0d5c6fac8...
- addicted 7y agoIf you count excess deaths, globally where we have data, official Coronavirus deaths are always about half or 2/3rds the excess death. In other words, it’s likely we are undercounting deaths caused by COVID by a factor of 1.5 to 2 in places which are actually properly tracking COVID deaths.
- makomk 7y agoMaybe, but the article is doing the exact same thing with the flu, except probably even worse because we're not systematically testing people for the flu in the same way that we are Covid-19.
- DanBC 7y agoYou don't need to systematically test people in order to assign their death as a flu death. We have many different ways of counting deaths. We either count the people who had a test; or we count death certificates; or we do surveillance to see what respiratory illnesses are circulating and how many people are searching google for flu-like symptoms and how many people are attending primary care and ED for flu-like symptoms. (and which ever method we pick, if we pick the same method for covid-19 we see many more deaths)
- makomk 7y agoThe whole point of the article is to argue that those flu deaths are "wildly inflated statistical estimates" and not real flu deaths in the same way that Covid-19 deaths - where we are systematically testing increasingly wide-ranging groups of people who are hospitalized or even just in care homes - are real Covid-19 deaths. That the only apples-to-apples comparison is not to statistically compensate for the lack of flu testing at all and only compare tested, confirmed cases. It's obvious just from comparing the numbers in the article to the ones in the comment I'm replying to that lack of testing has a much, much bigger effect on confirmed flu numbers than confirmed Covid-19 ones - confirmed Covid-19 deaths are at 2/3 to 1/2 of excess deaths, whereas confirmed flu is at 1/4 to 1/8th of estimated flu deaths, and the flu estimate does more work to exclude unrelated deaths than just counting raw excess deaths would. The supposedly apples-to-apples comparisons in the article looks to be even less directly comparable than the apples-to-oranges one it's rejecting.
- gpderetta 7y agoin the most affected countries in Europe, it is significantly higher (2, 3 times) than the worst flu seasons in recent times.
- pacala 7y agoThat being said, we have developed a combination of vaccines and ICU treatments to drastically reduce the mortality of the flu. This is not your '70 flu anymore.
- erodommoc 7y agoHere's the charts for a number of states in the US. It's pretty dramatic. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-death-toll-total.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/28/us/coronaviru...
- ModernMech 7y agoDear god those charts are useless. Different scales all lined up next to each other, no clue as to the value of the bottom of the y axis, no clue as to what the baseline or the peak numbers are, no ability to actually inspect the data... Who are they hiring to do this nonsense at NYT?
- pacala 7y agoGoing to be charitable and hope the bottom of y axis is zero.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThey're not intended for comparing chart to chart, there's a table with key numbers below, and links at the bottom to country-by-country, state-by-state, and "look up your city" options. It's a "look at the spikes" illustration in the spot in an article a big photo would typically go.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIt's pretty dramatic because they excluded all of the states where it is not dramatic.
- rsynnott 7y agoDiffers on a country by country basis, but generally it's pretty bad in Western Europe anyway. See https://euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps/ https://euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps/ for excess mortality data. By the way, most countries' local COVID peak is either in April or still to come; it's not really winter deaths. One caveat; in many countries, death reporting is pretty slow and data from the last couple of weeks shouldn't be considered particularly reliable.
- ballenf 7y agoHere's the 2 numbers that matter: - Covid w/o a shutdown - Overall deaths from lockdown w/o Covid Neither number can ever do more than guess at and fight at which statistical model lies less.
- Pxtl 7y agoOne problem with comparing excess deaths is that automotive traffic deaths are down, and automotive traffic deaths are a very large slice of the pie in many countries (including the USA).
- Diederich 7y agoThere were about 2.8 million total deaths in the United States in 2019 compared to about 40 thousand motor vehicle deaths.
- williamstein 7y agoGoing further, in 2017 all accidents combined were 6% of deaths in the US (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm). Nearly half (1,246,565) of the 2,813,503 deaths in the US in 2017 were from heart disease and cancer. Deaths from heart disease per day are almost as bad as covid-19 right now, so since there is a lot one can do proactively to reduce the chances of heart disease, I'm taking it way more seriously than I did before: don't smoke, hour+ of exercise every day, heart-healthy diet, sleep enough, and less stress.
- derriz 7y agoThis was posted here recently: https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps It only covers Europe but effects of Covid-19 are easy to see. For example during the peak, about 85,000 Europeans were dying per week as opposed to the normal range of 50-55K. I don't know of a source for non-European countries unfortunately. Until there is an international cooperation to standardize how Covid19 deaths are counted, these type of numbers are all we have for international and historic comparison.
- bjornsing 7y ago“That's what people are interested in”. I very much disagree. 9/11 didn’t exactly register in all cause mortality. There’s a lot more people are interested in, for good reasons.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- malandrew 7y agoThe question I have yet to see posed is "How would society be experiencing the common flu if it had never existed before and this is the first time it jumps to humans?" The first year you see an airborne transmissible disease is likely to be the worst regardless of the disease. The big problem I see is that we're comparing the common flu in its herd immunity steady state to the coronavirus in its first year. Once coronavirus settles into its steady state, we will be able to compare it to the flu, apples to apples. That being said, assuming the flu and coronavirus at steady state is approximately comparable, would it justified to react to the flu in its first year the same way we're reacting to the coronavirus in its first year? If we know there will be a modest spike in the first year that mostly claims the infirm and becoming endemic is unavoidable, is it worth doing the damage we're doing to the economy. That this is going to become endemic and likely reach steady state in a year or two (possibly longer depending on how long we retard reaching that point with lockdowns varying from geography to geography) is at this point a foregone conclusion because not every country has the natural borders of New Zealand and can completely kill this off. It will bounce back and forth between the northern and southern hemisphere indefinitely at this point until herd immunity.
- gpderetta 7y agoA case of deadly flu with little population resistance would like the Spanish flu pandemic. Yes, I would say that the an extraordinary reaction would be entirely appropriate.
- malandrew 7y agoAt this point, the disease becoming endemic is all but guaranteed, so we're just delaying the inevitable at great economic cost. The best case scenario is to ride the healthcare system capacity threshold while getting the economy moving again so there aren't excess deaths beyond those that would have been claimed sooner or later. The people arguing for waiting for a vaccine simply don't understand how long that likely to take. It's an unreasonable expectation to keep the world shut down until a vaccine is available as it will cause far more damage than the virus is liable to cause.