11 ms·
Uber is a net destructive play. Yes, taxi was a broken model but what uber did is suck social capital out of taxi, put driver against driver, rent seeking and i
by ggm 7y ago
Uber is a net destructive play. Yes, taxi was a broken model but what uber did is suck social capital out of taxi, put driver against driver, rent seeking and import money to America from the world.
A plague on uber and Airbnb. May they both rot.
Btw this is not just troll bait this is my honest opinion. I talk to taxi drivers and use taxi and these people got predated on for a thin profit outcome.
- ornornor 7y agoThe sharing economy overall is a rotten model. Offloading externalities. It did give a kick to the taxi business because they had become overly complacent though so that’s a positive. But I won’t be sad either to see Airbnb and Uber die.
- amelius 7y agoIt's not just sharing, but it's platforms. One gatekeeper regulating an entire market of poorly paid workers. Everything from food delivery services to App Stores.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoSo the encompassing term would be, I think, gig economy. I can't think of a single gig economy company that wasn't an ethical disaster.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoAt the risk of sounding argumentative, I will suggest Textbroker does a pretty good job. http://writepay.blogspot.com/2020/03/the-textbroker-solution.html http://writepay.blogspot.com/2020/03/the-textbroker-solution... I don't think the gig economy has to be an ethical disaster. I'm aware a lot of gig platforms are awful in that regard, but I don't think it simply can't be done well just because it mostly hasn't been done well. "Ninety percent of everything is crap."
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI wasn't saying gig economy couldn't be done ethically, just that I've never heard of a case where it was. I'll take a look at Textbroker. > "Ninety percent of everything is crap." I never seen that applied to ethics before. I so hope it's wrong...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI was thinking more in terms of "companies in a new economic model getting some parts of it very wrong." We try a thing, it goes horribly sideways, people freak out over "ethics," which often means large scale, social consequences that weren't necessarily readily apparent before you did the thing.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIf you're talking about journalists and bloggers buying into the hype and only noticing problems once things "go horribly sideways", then I agree; it's also fair to point out that second-order consequences are very often not obvious, and only apparent in hindsight. Hell, in my more naive days, I was also bullish on some of those companies, before I started reading about and contemplating the issues that were brought up later on. But the cynical me wants to point out that any particular company doing gig economy/"share" economy/locust economy[0] business has to design and understand their own business model. Many of the ethical issues are already apparent at this stage; when you look at Cost Structure and Revenue Streams segments of your Business Model Canvas, take a stock of regulatory requirements affecting you, you can already what corners you cut and who's going to get a short end of your value proposition stick. So e.g. I do not believe AirBnB was initially aware of the impact their business will have on the housing market, but I'm rather certain all the evil shenanigans Uber pulled were intentional. EDIT: also: I know that I'm being an armchair ethicist here, that it's easy to see the larger picture from a high horse, especially when one doesn't need to use said businesses. But to my defense: doing that is a valid market signal on its own; to the extent I don't deal with businesses I consider ethically challenged, and discourage others from dealing with them, this sends a (however small) signal to the free market that those issues are something that matters to some customers, and are worth competing on. -- [0] - I only now remembered this article, https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2013/04/03/the-locust-economy/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2013/04/03/the-locust-economy/. Worth pointing out that it was written in 2013, about when the "share economy" hype was at its peak, and everyone wanted to do a startup with this model.
- usrusr 7y agoI'm still hoping for those platforms to eventually get displaced by ones run by foundations or coops. Sure, those have a hard time initially competing against platforms powered by infinite greed, but in the end being trustable by the vendor side of platform users should be an unbeatable advantage.
- frobozz 7y agoCalling it "sharing economy" is doublespeak. Most AirBnB hosts and Uber drivers are not just occasionally letting spare space in their homes or picking up strangers who happen to be going the same direction. AirBnB hosts are short-let landlords, same as any other operator of holiday lets. Uber drivers are minicab drivers, same as any other minicab driver. They like to pretend otherwise in an attempt to bypass laws designed for consumer and worker protection.
- vinay427 7y ago> Most AirBnB hosts and Uber drivers are not just occasionally letting spare space in their homes I don't believe this is true for Airbnb, both anecdotally and from Airbnb's own statement about NYC: > "87 percent of Airbnb hosts in New York share only the home in which they live.” https://skift.com/2014/02/13/airbnb-in-nyc-the-real-numbers-behind-the-sharing-story/ https://skift.com/2014/02/13/airbnb-in-nyc-the-real-numbers-...
- dgoldstein0 7y agoAnd the other 13% make up what percent of new York Airbnb stays (for, say, 2019)?
- ric2b 7y agoThat's misdirection. 87% of hosts, sure, but what percentage of rentals? Does it matter if there are a lot of accounts that only list a few days a year? Notice that 2/3 of rentals are for entire apartments, the hosts that share their own home clearly can't do that very often.
- vinay427 7y agoI agree. I'm curious why you chose to reply to my comment with this complaint when I was directly responding to the claim, which you quite reasonably view to be "misdirection," in the parent comment.
- 7y ago
- Lammy 7y ago> import money to America from the world. While I wish this were true, Uber is yet another tax dodging corporation like so many others: https://fortune.com/2015/10/22/uber-tax-shell/ https://fortune.com/2015/10/22/uber-tax-shell/
- oblio 7y agoThat's the funny thing: all these tech companies are basically bleeding the rest of the world dry (Facebook is basically killing local newspapers across the world) and then they're hoarding money. But it's disingenuous to pretend there aren't any benefits for the US as the hundreds of thousands if not millions of people working in tech companies in the US for very high salaries can attest. Very high salaries both for the US and definitely for the rest of the world.
- andrepd 7y agohundreds of thousands if not millions of people working in tech companies in the US for very high salaries can attest I think you are off by one or two orders of magnitude.
- oblio 7y agoNope, not really. According to various sources the number of software developers in the US is around 3.3 million (https://dqydj.com/number-of-developers-in-america-and-per-state/ https://dqydj.com/number-of-developers-in-america-and-per-st...). Even by a pessimistic estimate, let's say that 25% of these have very high salaries compared to the average or median wage in the US. Either because their seniority or because they work for big companies. So that would mean something like 0.8 million. Now, on top of that, add associated engineers working for tech companies, add middle managers (which are generally paid more than individual contributors), etc., and it's easily 1 million highly paid individuals. Just think about it: Amazon, Microsoft, Google, Apple, Facebook, Cisco, Netflix, Oracle, IBM, Adobe, Uber, HP, Verizon, AT&T, Intuit, ServiceNow, VMWare, Salesforce, Workday, Dell, Intel, Qualcomm, Ebay, Paypal, Activision, and probably another 1000 companies with at least 1000 employees in the US, that I don't know. Plus non-tech companies that have huge tech departments, such as Walmart, and that pay salaries that are competitive with the ones paid by purely tech companies. On top of that, American software devs have no idea how good they have it. In Europe getting 100k as a fresh grad is impossible even in Switzerland (Switzerland having much higher salaries than the rest of Europe), unless you work for... a US giant (FAANG). And those spots are a minuscule part of the tech world in Europe. And now imagine that Europe is better off than 95% of the rest of the world. The idea of a regular Joe Developer having a decent shot of having made (made, not saved!) a million by the time they're 35 is frankly ludicrous for most of the rest of the world.
- snemvalts 7y agoone could argue with Uber having almost never made money it's redistributing VC money to ordinary people. just about the only upside
- mav3rick 7y agoIf these drivers are unhappy they can choose not be drivers ? Both these companies eroded existing shitty models. I'm a happy consumer.
- joe_fishfish 7y ago> If these drivers are unhappy they can choose not be drivers This is oversimplified to a painful degree.
- hjawdev 7y agoHow so? Coming from the service industry, I have noticed many including myself work hard to escape and progress. If people want more they need to earn it.
- murukesh_s 7y ago>A plague on uber and Airbnb. May they both rot. Don't agree with that. It is a new model which have advantages and disadvantages. You would know if you are a foreigner in a remote town and want to get a Taxi. If the model is bad the market will correct it eventually. I think what's bad is the VC's funding or persuading founders to continue to run with loss making business models for cornering the market. These companies then pump huge marketing money without a profitability in near future. That destroys the local competition if any and skew the market towards them for a while. Sometimes it will work out but many times it would fail. Again time will correct the practice if it's not sustainable, we have to wait. Also Airbnb and Uber have enabled lot of people earn livelihood without having to wait for trade union approvals for sharing taxi stands or getting hotel licences. If the model is sustainable it will go back to old models, but i feel it's gonna stay whether through Uber or other service(s). >import money to America from the world What about CocaCola, Pepsi, Amazon (and AWS) Google, Microsoft, Facebook, Nike and hundreds of other brands ?
- sarakayakomzin 7y ago>Don't agree with that. It is a new model which have advantages and disadvantages. You would know if you are a foreigner in a remote town and want to get a Taxi. If the model is bad the market will correct it eventually. "I don't care how much damage this does because it'll work out" >What about CocaCola, Pepsi, Amazon (and AWS) Google, Microsoft, Facebook, Nike and hundreds of other brands ? Sick whataboutism. Let's not talk about problems because other problems exist.
- zwaps 7y agoWell it is a two-sided platform market that may very well be sustainable. However it is set up to extract rents from both consumers and drivers, which is a problem for the latter. In effect, it captures profits from transportation markets and sends them to a company in the US. And that may be both sustainable, since its a platform market, and it may create suffering and poverty for many drivers. Handily, the existence and further political support for traditional taxis implies that a regulatory approach on competitive misconduct is unlikely. So these companies may not only be economically stable, but even in terms of competition policy. In any case, I hope you see the difference between companies selling a product, and those selling a platform, for a local economy.
- i6ruce 7y agoI live not in USA, and before Uber taxi services were a total mess.
- pal_9000 7y agoI would bet Uber has created wealth, a lot of it. Uber didn't just sway rides from Medallions, i would imagine it increased rides by manifold. Note: Not considering environmental impact. (E) I'm not saying it's a flawless model, but you can't discount how it led to more people taking ride shares in contrast to car ownership. I think this is obvious in urban areas. Genuinely curious about this cycle of opinion on Hacker news. It's trendy to shit on these companies until it's not.
- akoncius 7y agocould you explain more about "created wealth" especially related to your point about "it led to more people taking ride shares in contrast to car ownership" . rides are cheap because Uber is doing actual dumping of taxi industry by operating on a loss. Uber drivers are earning very little + spending money on car maintenance etc. so basically only one benefit is cheap rides but even this is damaging overall system and is not sustainable. so again.. where is that wealth creation (apart uber itself maybe)?
- rubber_duck 7y agoLooking at it from my consumer perspective Uber is net positive - even if it ends up being unsustainable and goes bust eventually. The prices in the local taxi market didn't go down a few % it got fractionally cheaper - it went from being barely affordable and only used in exceptional cases to a substitute for car ownership and not having to think about using it (depending on your daily commute). The market expanded incredibly around here. Also traveling around with Uber is a great experience (in countries that didn't ban it) - the service has been consistent across Europe and it's another thing I don't have to worry about when travelling - not having to navigate public transport or roads in a foreign country while also being relatively sure you're not getting ripped off by the local taxi service is amazing.
- chefkoch 7y ago> The prices in the local taxi market didn't go down a few % it got fractionally cheaper - it went from being barely affordable and only used in exceptional cases to a substitute for car ownership and not having to think about using it (depending on your daily commute). That's because they loose money with every ride? I mean it really can't be cheap to have your have your personal driver for your daily commute.
- rubber_duck 7y agoThe thing is there are other taxi services locally that are competing with Uber at similar prices. Even if prices went up 30% it would still be in the "I don't have to think about it" territory.
- chefkoch 7y agoI'm not sure how this is possible as afaik taxi fares are heavy regulated. Just because Uber subsedises rides no city council will change the taxi fares. https://www1.nyc.gov/site/tlc/passengers/taxi-fare.page https://www1.nyc.gov/site/tlc/passengers/taxi-fare.page
- 7y ago
- collyw 7y agoI mainly agree, but quality of taxi services varies from location to location.
- zabil 7y agoAgree the business model is questionable, but it's a great example of using technology for an essential service.
- puranjay 7y agoUber pulled off a massive bait-and-switch in India. Offered drivers incredible bonuses, baited them with "rumors" that the bonuses were permanent, encouraged them to apply for loans to buy cars and even has a financing program of its own. And then they pulled out the bonuses, practically forcing drivers to work 12+ hours/day (some even sleep in their cars) just to make minimum loan payments. No driver I've ever spoken to has been happy driving for Uber, but they do it because they have a car to pay off
- alexpetralia 7y agoTo be fair, they sound like any new car dealer here (get the sale and often the auto-loan sale as well).
- puranjay 7y agoExcept these people would never get loans without Uber's backing. Indian lenders are notoriously risk averse and make it very hard for self-employed people to get loans. Moreover, without Uber's (formerly) juicy carrot, they would never be in the market for a car in the first place
- chriskanan 7y agoAs a consumer, Uber and similar businesses are an enormous net positive. It is a much better experience than taxis. It enabled me and my family to get around. Even if taxis had a consistent app across cities, the quality of the vehicle tends to be much lower and the drivers are not as kind. That may be just because Uber drivers can be reported much more easily than a taxi driver. For smaller cities with a low taxi density, many Uber drivers treat it as an additional source of income to a primary job and I've had a lot of "stay-at-home" moms pick me up in Rochester NY. In NYC, I've noticed the opposite, with most Uber drivers treating it as a full-time job. Lastly, without Uber, my wife and I would have had to purchase another vehicle. Thanks to Uber, sharing a single vehicle works great when we can't sync up start/end times for work (pre-quarantine).
- ashtonkem 7y agoIn most larger cities the Uber drivers are either now taxi drivers using personal cars, or are beginning to behave exactly like taxi drivers do.
- hlmencken 7y agoI agree 100% on airbnb. I disagree completely on uber. Uber is safer, better and fairer than taxis. The strategy of growing it quickly is aggressive and clearly short term but the value of having uber in a community where driving is the only option makes drinking out so much safer. Girls getting rides alone are protected by verifying drivers, having so much more data for the entire trip and transaction. They clearly were able to gain market share with vc backing, but I will 100% take an uber over a taxi every day.