5 ms·
The entire product is a copy of the AirPods. But you know what? I'm fine with that. That's how competition works, and competition is what brings down prices.
by crazygringo 7y ago
The entire product is a copy of the AirPods.
But you know what? I'm fine with that. That's how competition works, and competition is what brings down prices.
And I personally find the scrolling page design (both Apple's and Google's) pretty cool. It would drive me nuts if a site I used daily implemented something like that, like if it became a trend for news sites. But to show off a new product where I'll scroll through once in my life? It's pretty slick as far as I'm concerned. (Provided you've got the CPU to handle it.)
- cat199 7y ago> The entire product is a copy of the AirPods. as if airpods were the 1st rechargable wireless earbuds anyway
- kelw22 7y agoGenuine question: has anyone ever made the claim that being rechargeable is what makes AirPods unique?
- hackmiester 7y agoTo me, the biggest thing that makes AirPods unique is that they look pretty weird. The Google ones don't, so I see them as clearly differentiated from AirPods.
- kadoban 7y agoWhat _is_ unique about AirPods? All I can come up with is the look. These ones from Google look way different. Are they really clones in some way?
- Kalium 7y agoWhen you're selling a luxury good, one of the important aspects is it being recognizable. Other people in the target demo need to be able to see and understand that your customer owns and uses a status symbol without it being tastelessly obviously flashy. Think the Birkin bag.
- Octoth0rpe 7y agoThe easy pairing / switching between devices. There are cheaper wireless headphones out there, ones with longer batter life, ones with better sound (haven't tried the pros yet myself), but none pair as easily. Supposedly the next version of bluetooth will enable all devices to do that, but we're not there yet.
- ayoisaiah 7y agoWhat is the source for this claim? They only work perfectly with Apple devices. For other devices, they're function just as generic Bluetooth earbuds
- Octoth0rpe 7y agoThis is a well-known feature. From the cnet review (https://www.cnet.com/reviews/apple-airpods-review/ https://www.cnet.com/reviews/apple-airpods-review/): "W1 chip makes for seamless pairing: Apple's custom Bluetooth chip, the W1, is designed to allow for automatic pairing with Apple devices running iOS 10 or later, WatchOS 3 or later or MacOS Sierra or later. And it totally delivers: Just place the headphones near your compatible device and they'll automatically be detected and ask for pairing, no diving into settings menu needed. You can also transition easily between Apple devices, toggling between the sound of your computer to that of your iPhone or iPad. For Apple Watch owners, that seamless transition between Watch and iPhone is critical, and it's one reason that AirPods are something of an appealing accessory for Watch owners. " > They only work perfectly with Apple devices You're correct that the seamless pairing feature only works on apple devices. On non-apple devices, they work equivalently - no worse or better really - than competing headphones. That doesn't mean that the pairing feature isn't very valuable for those of us willing to own more than one apple device.
- fxleach 7y agoHow are they a copy of the AirPods? The AirPods, to me, look hideous. You take the original Apple headphones and cut off the wire. But putting that aside I'm finding it hard to see how these headphones resemble anything like AirPods. I mean, they're wireless headphones...? Is that the issue?
- delecti 7y agoThat's an interesting thought I hadn't considered. The AirPods do indeed seem like Apple accidentally invented (or at least popularized) a new product category while trying to reference the old headphones, which were pretty iconic in their advertising. All of the "copycats" are taking that same product category and designing around the formfactor. I agree that most of the copycats are more aesthetically pleasing, including the Pixel Buds.
- 333c 7y agoThe (rounded, white, shiny) charging/carrying case is definitely heavily inspired by the AirPods. While the headphones, visually, don't look a lot like the AirPods, in terms of functionality they're very similar, as they're wireless earbuds that don't have a wire even between the earbuds, and they feature noise cancellation that adapts to the environment.
- legolas2412 7y agoIf your criteria is that loose, then iPhones were a copy. And I think airpods were certainly a copy too.
- mattacular 7y agoSeems like a really inefficient system. Bringing down the price of a finished good requires another entity's ability in making a separate clone of it?
- tenacious_tuna 7y agoI'm not sure how that's inefficient, it's pretty normal market dynamics. If the demand for a thing is high enough and the supply is low (or artificially controlled), then the provider can just freely set the price wherever they want. Enter a competitor, and now the competitor has incentive to undercut the original producer to capture their market segment, and then it's a battle between the two between the cost to produce, market price, and value of the good to consumers. I suppose there's 'inefficiency' in that both producers are now providing identical goods, but very rarely are the goods actually identical. In this case there's also the surrounding product ecosystem of Apple and Google, which is a significant difference at the very least.
- mattacular 7y agoI guess I will eagerly await the price drop from these highly competitive products that aren't designed to be used in the others ecosystem.
- somerandomness 7y agoTo be fair it looks quite different in shape.
- ayoisaiah 7y agoAirpods were not the first true wireless earbuds. Samsung released the Gear IconX in 2016. You could say Apple took an idea and made it better, and that's exactly how it should work. Google is simply trying to do the same thing here
- reaperducer 7y agoThat's how competition works No. Competition is you inventing a better mousetrap, not copying someone else's mousetrap.
- arbitrage 7y agonot in applied capitalism, no. ever wonder why there are three gas stations at a four-way intersection? Because someone saw two gas stations there, and said to themselves, "I want a piece of that action." There isn't a strict motive to make something better than someone else .... there's only a motive to make something that someone will buy instead of something else. Big difference.
- EvanAnderson 7y agoIf your mousetrap's very easy to copy maybe your mousetrap isn't good to begin with. Patents, design patents, trademarks, and trade dress are all completely reasonable ways to protect your product. Failing the ability of any of those methods to product your product, I'd argue copying is fair game.
- jngreenlee 7y agoSometimes better is defined as [more colors|more available|lower price|supports my phone]. So it is competition, for sure!
- mbrameld 7y agoA mousetrap is still a mousetrap, though. They didn't copy the Air Pods, you should be able to see the differences for yourself if you just look at the product pages. Can you honestly not?
- bobthepanda 7y agoScroll-jacking is notoriously bad for accessibility. Can't tab through the sequences and maintain proper focus, using the down arrow key moves the screen 1px per tap it feels like. From my abled point of view, it's a terrible implementation; if I scroll using mouse wheel it should not be so slow. I would rather see each flick of mousewheel anchor the next or previous slide in place rather than having to do all the scrolling to get there. And that's really what this is, a vertical PowerPoint.