4 ms·
Wow, I’m a bit surprised that the one with the ability to say yes or no in this instance was Apple. I’m not sure if I enjoy the idea that any given company can
by Aeolun 7y ago
Wow, I’m a bit surprised that the one with the ability to say yes or no in this instance was Apple. I’m not sure if I enjoy the idea that any given company can overrule the government of the country it operates in...
- Reelin 7y agoAgreed. I certainly appreciate Apple's stance on privacy lately, but it doesn't seem reasonable for a corporation (particularly one based in a different country!) to be willing or capable of forcing the government's hand.
- teruakohatu 7y agoTurn it around, does it seem reasonable that an overseas government should be able to force a US company to make changes to their OS and add functionality it was never designed to have? If Germany really needed it, they could take Apple to court. I am sure Siemens would be horrified it it was turned around and the US govt started demanding they modify their industrial controllers, famously targeted by stuxnet, to allow them to be tracked more easily.
- Reelin 7y ago> does it seem reasonable that an overseas government should be able to force a US company to make changes to their OS and add functionality it was never designed to have Yes, it actually does. I certainly don't like the idea of such an action being taken in practice, but isn't dictating that certain arbitrary requirements must be met in order to do business within a jurisdiction kind of a large part of the point of having a government in the first place? What's concerning to me about this case is that end users aren't even capable of opting in at present and that due to the time constraints involved Apple would appear to have a distinct advantage. Note that the previous (somewhat similar) controversy in the US involving Apple was an issue specifically due to questions about constitutionally protected rights and federal government overreach.
- bpodgursky 7y agoThis is not Apple overruling the government. Germany is perfectly free to ban Apple products. They did not. Government / company interactions with multinational corporations are simple: the government makes rules, and the company is free to either operate in the locale or quit. Germany decided that they would rather have an Apple which refused to play by the proposed rules, than no Apple at all, so they figured out new rules.
- chimprich 7y ago> This is not Apple overruling the government. Germany is perfectly free to ban Apple products. They did not. That makes no sense. Maybe, in theory, if you had five years to play with, Germany could move towards restricting Apple products. In practice the window of opportunity to affect the course of this epidemic using technology is weeks or months. That restricts your options to using existing infrastructure; realistically that means working with Apple or Google. Germany could ban Apple and Google products, but that would leave them nothing to work with. This is going to raise questions about national security and sovereignty going forward. I suspect this will be a subject of controversy after the pandemic dies down.
- chopin 7y agoHopefully this will be a conversation about how a government uses a crisis to expand its surveillance powers.
- BillyTheKing 7y agoas mentioned above, I think the headline really is a little misleading here... there was a ton of backlash against using a centralised system for this contact-tracing app from the opposition, privacy lobbies, the CCC, universities, researchers, programmers that worked on it, etc. and on top of all of that also from Apple (though I doubt they would've put up much of an opposition if the EU had pushed their own solution and forced apple to adopt it - can you imagine the backlash apple would've faced if they denied co-operation for such an app during a pandemic, _had_ that app been the popular app of choice in the EU? It wasn't, however). The way this is reported/seen in Germany is mostly that the government realised it would be difficult for an app to achieve wide-spread adoption without the support of privacy-advocates. For better or worse, those privacy concerns are usually taken fairly seriously!
- tastroder 7y agoApple did not make the decision here, the German government did. The government would have been free to try to force Apple's hand with sanctions or any other tool available to them. Time will tell but I feel like reducing this to the technical decision of Apple is slightly one sided. The PEPP-PT proposal was a pseudonymous, centralized, social graph of all users in the app with a rather opaque power structure behind it. The government got pushback from many sides on this issue and several EU neighbours publicly endorsed the decentralized DP3T. This is a complementary tool for an epidemiological use case that heavily depends on public adoption, while PEPP-PT tried to push this narrative of "Apple vs France/Germany" over the last week through lobbying I do not think it's an accurate/comprehensive depiction of the decision making process in a democratic government.
- dx034 7y agoThere was very strong lobbying from CCC and others. Apples decision will have played a role but the project would've suffered from a lot of distrust even if Apple had allowed it. We won't know why exactly it was abandoned but I would give the CCC more credit than Apple.