17 ms·
Europe’s cities are making less room for cars after coronavirus
- dmitrygr 7y agoThat is a great idea. Push more people to crowded public transit where infections can spread easier.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoFrom the article it's clear that the intention is to replace car use with biking and walking, not use of public transport. e.g. (from the article): As a result, Milan is going big on cycling and walking. Over the summer, the city core will be partly remodeled to give over 22 miles (35 kilometers) of road space previously used by cars to bikes and pedestrians. Those cars that are allowed into the center must adhere to a new reduced 30 kilometers per hour speed limit. The aim is to make traffic more fluid and give pedestrians more space to spread out safely.
- makomk 7y agoSo basically, the idea is to substantially shrink people's worlds in real, day to day terms, reducing the distance it's practical to travel to work, socialize and shop? Why even live in a big city anymore at that point, if you're only going to be able to interact with a small corner of it?
- Mirioron 7y agoThat's how I understood it as well. This idea seems to be gaining popularity in a lot of places. I wonder how much this is going to cost their local economy in the long-term.
- ourlordcaffeine 7y agoBased on existing experience in Europe, it will significantly bolster local economies, as walkers and bikers often go into shops, often unplanned as they just saw an interesting shop during their journey. Net result was a big increase in purchases from brick and mortar stores.
- icebraining 7y agoWhat's the existing experience in Europe that cut down both on cars and on public transport?
- Noos 7y agoThese are two different use cases though. If you could bike or walk you'd generally do it; usually the car is for things where it's too much time to try.
- Heliosmaster 7y agoNot really. It depends a lot on the habit. Plenty of people in Italy take the car to drive less than a km to go a shop, and then come back, especially in mid-to-small cities
- eranimo 7y agoPublic transit is a lot better in Europe, and besides, this is a long term plan.
- patrickaljord 7y agoBetter in what way? I've in Paris for decades, people are jammed together all the time. Horrible conditions during a pandemic. Let's face it, cars are better in this case. Biking in Paris where it rains all the time and gets really cold, good luck with that (I'm a biker myself and use it all the time, just not feeling good about this knowing Parisians).
- bobthepanda 7y ago> Better in what way? It at least exists in a form that is usable. In the US, most people do not even live within a bus line that comes < 15 min frequency during the rush hour, let alone all day, or next to a rail line or something more substantial. If the local bus only comes four times a day I'm much less likely to use it, since missing one means I am screwed for quite a while or then have to cough up money I wasn't planning on spending on a taxi.
- hk__2 7y ago> Biking in Paris where it rains all the time and gets really cold, good luck with that (I'm a biker myself and use it all the time, just not feeling good about this knowing Parisians). Is it really worse than other big cities? Does it have a proven impact on bike usage? As some anecdata, it rains twice more in New York than in Paris 1,200mm vs. 600mm/year) and on more days (121 vs. 111/yr). Amsterdam, the well known bikes-everywhere city is colder and has more rain (900mm) than Paris. Berlin is well know for both frequent rains and a large bike usage.
- patrickaljord 7y agoAmsterdam is flat, not the case for Paris.
- 7y ago
- briefcomment 7y agoNope, the article says "Accordingly, says Milan Mayor Beppe Sala, the city plans to maintain its metro system’s capacity at less than two-thirds of its pre-pandemic activity. Instead of the 1.4 million average trips it saw daily before the pandemic, it will accommodate a maximum daily ridership of 400,000." Instead, they're focusing on supporting walking and cycling. "As a result, Milan is going big on cycling and walking. Over the summer, the city core will be partly remodeled to give over 22 miles (35 kilometers) of road space previously used by cars to bikes and pedestrians. Those cars that are allowed into the center must adhere to a new reduced 30 kilometers per hour speed limit. The aim is to make traffic more fluid and give pedestrians more space to spread out safely."
- jariel 7y agoThis is misleading - the city controls supply, not demand. By cutting service in specific routes, they're probably just going to increase density on them. The issue is less about 'net capacity / ridership' as much as literally density on each ride. Paradoxically, reducing density comes with increasing capacity. Cities/central planners do this kind of thing all the time, they change some thing over here and think that people's behaviour will change. Sometimes it does - but people still need to get to work, pick up their kids, etc. and if the choice is not public transport, it's often 'car'. Again, creating 'more supply' of biking routes may move the needle but it doesn't change the fact you live 12km from the office and biking is not practical for many people in those circumstances.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Symbiote 7y agoThere is nothing in the article to suggest they're reducing service. There's also nothing in your comment to suggest you read the article, so I don't think you're aware of what's planned. > the floors of metro cars and buses will be marked out with circles showing passengers the right level of distance to maintain. If the system looks like it will exceed the passenger numbers that makes this level of distancing possible, station entrances will be temporarily closed until congestion eases. + school times changed, shops open later, etc.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jasonv 7y agoI'm perplexed by the comments here. Some cities have seen greater business increases on pedestrian and bike converted through-ways because people in cars weren't just passing by. Bikers and pedestrians stopped and shopped in the areas they were traveling through. I, for one, look forward to making a choice to move to a place where I can live car-free and hope more cities accelerate plans like this.
- cafxx 7y agoI live in Tokyo and I can assure you that living car-free is lovely. I used to love driving, then moved here and stopped caring altogether when I realized that public transport here is significantly faster (and cheaper) than using your car to go from point A to point B.
- briefcomment 7y agoAnd probably safer
- cafxx 7y agoQuite so. And, I forgot, you can use the time commuting for something that requires your complete attention - like reading, studying, or even just deep thinking - that you simply can't do when you're driving. So not only it's faster, it actually frees up time for other things.
- 05 7y agoUnless you’re a woman
- KirinDave 7y agoActually that's a very interesting question. Is the rate of sexual assault on Japanese Trains higher or lower than their average auto injury rate?
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- daenz 7y agoAnecdotally, where I live in Seattle, the people who are still driving are driving like maniacs...speeding, ignoring stop signs, lights, etc. There may be more room for cyclists, but it doesn't really feel safer.
- SECProto 7y ago> Anecdotally, where I live in Seattle, the people who are still driving are driving like maniacs...speeding, ignoring stop signs, lights, etc This is likely similar everywhere. Traffic controls idiots speeding. For another anecdote, check out these statistics from Toronto [1], approx 460% year-over-year increase in stunting charges ("stunting" being the charge when someone is going more than 50km/hr over the speed limit.) One person recently was going 270km/hr in a 100km/hr zone (cops caught them because a tire blew). [1] "Between March 16 and April 22, police have issued 6,978 speeding tickets and 224 stunt driving charges. In the same period last year, police issued 5,504 speeding tickets and 40 stunt driving charges." https://www.toronto.com/news-story/9960534-toronto-police-charging-more-drivers-during-covid-19-crisis/ https://www.toronto.com/news-story/9960534-toronto-police-ch...
- def8cefe 7y agoIt's not just because of less traffic. Police are over-stretched right now, as is the entire justice system due to Covid-19. A lot of people are taking advantage of this and many types of crime are way up. (I'm also Toronto area)
- ornornor 7y agoToronto has a huge road violence problem, on top of an enforcement problem. Traffic laws are almost never enforced, the police is complacent, and road violence goes unpunished. It is absurd and hard to believe, you have I see it to believe it. Drivers know that and have no problem intimidating pedestrians and cyclists because they know absolutely nothing at all will happen. Either the police won’t even bother to take the complaint seriously, they’ll turn a blind eye (can’t count the number of times I’ve seen someone break the law in their car right next to a patrol car and the cops just carried on), or they’ll get caught but not see a judge because the system is overloaded and so the charges automatically dropped. I’m not even mentioning drivers using bike lanes as a stopping lane. Toronto is pure madness and is has terrible quality of life as a result. They do however have once a year, for about 8h, car free streets (only 4/5 but still). It’s such a delight on these days. Everyone is out and about, cops are at every intersections to turn cars away, and you can even hear the birds sing!!! But yeah that for a grand total of maybe 10 km of main streets, 16h a year.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoThis (specifically car/bike traffic) may be the first real-life example of a Giffen Good I've come across: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giffen_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giffen_good You'd think that people avoiding public transport would result in increased car traffic. But in a scenario where the roads were already at or near capacity, that's impossible. Not only would a number equivalent to those switching from public transport have to use bikes. Because bikes also need (some, but less) space on the roads, car traffic actually needs to decrease.
- SECProto 7y agoI'm having a lot of trouble trying to conceptualize how "car/bike traffic" could be a giffen good. "A product that people consume more of as the price rises". Raising/creating tolls for cars decreases usage. Raising bus prices also discourages use. Could you help clarify what you meant? As for road space usage, generally bike lanes are added by adjusting street parking, narrowing lanes, etc. Eg I worked on a recent project where two 4m lanes were turned into a 3m middle lane and 3.5m curb lane and a 0.5m buffer and a 1.0m bike lane. I can't think of many situations where bike lanes were added by removing capacity from roads that had usage approaching capacity.
- tobylane 7y agoLondon’s Embankment from Westminster to Blackfriars (and the rest of CS3 on other roads) added a bike lane by removing car capacity despite it being full every rush hour. The road as a whole has higher throughput now. https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-cycle-lane-superhighway-embankment-new-thames-101637783.html https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-cycle-lane-superhighway-em...
- madeofpalk 7y agoOh, I recently rode through there the other day for the first time as I went from East London to Hyde Park! It was really nice to have a dedicated cycle way like that.
- SECProto 7y ago
- Igelau 7y ago> If the system looks like it will exceed the passenger numbers that makes this level of distancing possible, station entrances will be temporarily closed until congestion eases. Now you still have close crowding: it's just outside the gate and not getting anywhere. I guess it's more about metro companies being able to say "didn't happen on our trains".
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoThis seems really short-sited given the reality of pandemics. Walking or biking or high utilization of public transport implies high density. In a pandemic, the more people you encounter, the higher the chance of contracting the disease. Cars decrease density by increasing the effective area where people can work/shop/live. The area accessible grows as the square of the distance you can travel. In addition, in a car, increased travel time does not increase exposure. With walking or public transport, your exposure increases the longer you travel.
- esoterica 7y agoI don’t think density matters as much as you think it does. The evidence seems to be that people are mostly contracting the virus in indoor spaces like offices, restaurants, theaters and churches, and people in low density areas go to offices, restaurants, theaters and churches that are just as crowded as the ones in cities. In high density areas people live in smaller apartments that are stacked on top of one another, but it’s not like the virus is percolating through the walls and ceilings of your dwellings. The only real difference in exposure to the virus is public transit.
- Consultant32452 7y agoI have some control over selecting grocery stores, churches, and even employers who have better social distancing/health policies. Public transit, by its very nature, is a monopoly. I have no choice, in particular if you take the individual car fall-back option.
- asveikau 7y ago> This seems really short-sited given the reality of pandemics. Your comment is literally short-sighted because in the long view, the pandemic will end, but health and economic benefits of greater density and less car-dependent life will still be a thing. Why should we optimize for an exceptional circumstance (a pandemic) and miss out on the benefits of density in more normal times?
- ollo 7y agoWalking or biking does not always imply high density! On the other hand, public transportation can easily get crowded. That is one reason why European cities are moving away from public transportation in favour of bikes, scooters and so on. Finally, I agree that it would be better to encourage car usage during a pandemic. One reasonable reason not to do so is that parking spots are limited.
- anigbrowl 7y agoSan Francisco and Oakland have implemented a 'slow streets' initiative, gradually closing off some streets to through traffic (residential/emergency vehicles only) to allow more room for exercise. Predictably people have begun to deploy street furniture of their own (flower planters and so on) to make it more permanent. Nobody wants all the traffic and associated pollution back. Hard to predict how this will pan out as the necessity for social distancing recedes.
- throwawaysea 7y agoThat’s obnoxious. Cars and vehicles are necessary for many people and many purposes and cities should not use this crisis as a Trojan horse to force changes hastily. Deploying furniture to make it permanent sounds like the doing of a renegade cycle club and not everyday people, however.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThat street runs both ways. Car culture is already amazingly pushy and obnoxious in the degree to which it makes life difficult for pedestrians, cyclists, etc.
- throwawaysea 7y agoI find this type of anti car narrative to be disingenuous, because it doesn’t pass a sanity check of the common sense reality around us. Pedestrians are not impeded in getting around as long as sidewalks or enough roadside space is available. And cyclists are an exceedingly small minority in most places compared to car drivers. That’s because cars are the fastest and most convenient way to travel from point a to point b. They are faster than bicycles, lack the wait time of public transit, are protected from the elements, and let you move goods and family around. Almost nobody who has a family would want to lug their children around in bicycles - spare me the cherry picked example of Amsterdam. As for which culture is pushy and obnoxious: the roads were funded by taxpayers’ money for the purpose of vehicular traffic. Commandeering it for a thin minority with the luxury of time to burn is pushy and obnoxious. Not the other way.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThis preprint from Italy claiming to have detected SARS-cov-2 on particulate matter offers the intriguing hypothesis that the outbreak in Lombardy may have been exacerbated by the region's higher levels of pollution. https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.15.20065995v2 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.15.20065995v... Some additional interesting links in this summary article: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/apr/24/coronavirus-detected-particles-air-pollution https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/apr/24/coronavi...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe current city doesn't work anyway. A lot of our development patterns were born of seeds planted in the 1950s during an era when the nuclear family -- with a male breadwinner, female homemaker and 2.5 kids -- was the assumed standard basic "economic unit" and one male breadwinner provided adequate money, healthcare benefits, etc for multiple other people. Suburbs grew out of the idea of a separation of the public and private spheres. Please note the assumption there is that it separates them for the male breadwinner. The female homemaker de facto worked at home. Most women's work -- cooking, cleaning, raising kids -- is done at home and is generally not assumed to be anything like paid work that needs to be regulated as a profession. Yet it is essential work, critical to the health, welfare and productivity of the world. With people living longer, marrying later, having fewer children, living many years after the kids grow up and move out, etc. this model breaks down. As the world has generally moved more towards two-earner couples, a house in the suburbs has gradually turned into a nightmare we don't know how to escape because, at least in the US, it's our default assumption for a good home looks like and most of our financing and tax benefits etc are aimed at that type of home, so it is a large share of our good housing stock. Attempts to find alternatives, such the Tiny House movement, have largely not worked all that well. We need to re-envision our social fabric. This baked-in, unstated assumption that most people are part of a nuclear family with multiple children and one partner doesn't need a full-time paid job is very much out of date. It's mostly no longer true and, unsurprisingly, the built environment we created to accommodate that lifestyle works rather poorly for all too many people today. So that's where we need to start. And it is very much bound up with car ownership and car use because the single family detached house in the suburbs assumes you have a car and assumes a family of five only needs one car. When mom and dad both work and the neighborhood has a dearth of children for your only child to play with, the social fabric that lived when I was a child in a neighborhood full of kids cease to exist and the road are congested and people are both time stressed and financially stressed. This is the crux of a lot of the problems with the world today. We built a world for the parents of the Baby Boomers, in essence, and we haven't updated it. Demographics have changed, yet we continue to try to force-fit this shoe and wonder why it pinches so very badly, to the point of being crippling for many people.
- covidSurvivor19 7y ago
- naskwo 7y agoI'm still missing London in this discussion.
- ProZsolt 7y agoPlease, explain why
- gorgoiler 7y agoA bunch of climate change protesters shut down a major city interchange during the last half term. Three main routes were closed for a whole week. It was wonderful — who knows if there’s any unbiased truth to it but it certainly felt like there was a huge reduction in stress cycling around. Even where it’s perfectly safe to interact with cars — bike and pedestrian route in the park quickly crossing a road into another park on the other side — it was just such a relief not to have to eye roll at the traffic jumping the lights as they turn red or be glared at by angry van drivers who had to stop for the hippy on his push bike! It feels a bit like that now. Even more so really with the grater number of cyclists I see at all different times of the day (I’m out on the bike more than most, doing PPE deliveries.)
- acd 7y agoI hope we remove cars from city centers in Europe and replace them with more bike lanes and public transport. Ie the small particle pollution from cars is making pedestrians and cyclist sick. I hope we put car parking centers outside the city center and offer good inbound public / private transport. I would say clean air is an example of Tragedy of the commons, where the pollution is an externalized cost. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons#Examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons#Example...
- pimeys 7y agoAs an asthmatic person, I hope this too. Berlin is quite bad on some streets, especially due to people's love for diesel cars. This also includes trucks and diesel buses.
- choeger 7y agoI don't want to trash your hopes, but the particles are pretty much independent from traffic nowadays (see how Stuttgart is doing these days). The drought around Berlin will probably kick way more fine particles into the city than all Diesel cars together. The only thing that could help would be more trees and less dense cities.
- adreamingsoul 7y agoMy family (child, spouse) and I live car free in Oslo, Norway. It’s amazing. We used to own two vehicles when we lived in the States. I did take public transportation during the week, but still had to drive almost everywhere else. When everything is designed around cars, it can be extremely difficult to try and go without. Oslo was mostly built before cars, so roads are smaller and highways go below or around the city. Oslo is slowly making it harder for cars to be within the city, and actually changing streets to be car-free. Having a car here is not a need, but a want. I like that.
- jononor 7y agoThe highways today mostly go below the city. But that is a quite recent thing, the last parts of the Opera tunnel for example was opened only 10 years ago. Car traffic was a big problem in the 1970-2000. Making modern Oslo nocar-friendly and Oslo center pedestrian/bicyclist friendly is the result of massive investments in infrastructure over several decades.
- adreamingsoul 7y agoThanks for sharing. It is impressive to me that a city of Oslo's size was able to achieve that. I know of one similar sized city in the States that has similar high-level plans to re-route major roads and highways, but they never make much progress beyond committee meetings.
- jeltz 7y agoHm, I think most of Oslo was actually built after cars. Oslo has about twice the population today as it had in 1950.
- doktrin 7y ago> Oslo has about twice the population today as it had in 1950. That's a weird supporting argument. Can you name any urban centers that have not seen significant population growth since 1950?
- vinay_ys 7y agoThe framing of this city planning problem in my mind is like this: The appeal of a big city is potential to connect with lots of people from different backgrounds, skills and culture. This enables richer commerce and social interactions. This doesn't happen without huge amount of commute and lots of social gathering places like offices, schools, restaurants, malls, bars, sports, gaming, park etc. A city fundamentally has to make it possible for a lot more number of N x k connections – where N is city population and k is number of people any one person can potentially meet – for much larger N and much larger k. THis is the fundamental difference between a big city vs a cluster of small towns/villages which are fairly disconnected from each other. Basically, towns and villages scale down both N and k. Okay, so the question is how do we make it possible for such a large number of N x k commutes to happen? To support large N and large k the commute has to be faster and over longer distance. It has to solve for flexibility of hours of the day and also be accessible for young/old, men/women, kids, disabled etc. There are cost affordability considerations too. In some countries, like US, they have social culture where young and old don't live together, those with kids have different lifestyle than those without etc. Then in others like India, young and old do live together along with kids. Solving for high N x k for mixed demographics in a large urban sprawl is fundamentally more challenging.
- lnsru 7y agoIt’s completely wrong discussion. Remote work should be prioritized, so the people don’t need to move to overcrowded cities. Less people in the cities, less problems with their cars and crappy public transport.
- hnarn 7y agoUrbanization has been going strong as a trend for more than 100 years and I think it's reasonable to assume it won't stop anytime soon. If that's correct, density in cities will only increase, and most remote workers will not be outside of the city anyway. People enjoy having an entertainment-dense area to be in during the weekends and evenings, and they enjoy being able to go there without taking their car for an hour. So even with remote work, I don't think it does much to alleviate the problems associated with urban density. Remote work is a great idea for many reasons, if nothing else it lessens unnecessary load on infrastructure systems, but having grown up in Europe with the "public transport mindset" I can't help but feel that a society centered around highways, car ownership and isolated suburbia feels almost a bit dystopian. I believe the future is in cities, and for cities to work people need to be able to get around efficiently without having to each own a separate car that mostly just stands around taking up space and costing money.
- lnsru 7y agoI wish, there would be a way to make this urbanization less extreme. For example, real estate prices in Munich are absolutely insane. Kindergarten and other state owned employers can’t find personell. People just can’t afford living in the city.
- ProZsolt 7y agoI could have worked fully remotely in the past 3 years, but I choose to live in a big city and only work from half the time. There are way more things to do in the city than just work. Cinemas, restaurants, museums, stores. Everything in cycling distance. It's easier to network, find people with mutual interests. All these things won't work without the economy of scale. What it can bring is lower average house prices cities and gentrification of neighborhoods farther away from the city center. People could move farther from the city center because they don't have to commute to work every day. (This is EU specific)
- papito 7y agoEurope's cities had room for cars?
- collyw 7y agoI am just thinking of the metro here in Barcelona. Rush hour is fairly packed. No chance for social distancing. (I cycle the majority of places, as its faster provided you are willing to bend the rules).
- mamon 7y agoSo, in response to epidemic cities are limiting the only transportation mode that is safe during the epidemic - yes, that makes perfect sense :)
- stunt 7y ago"Cities are making less room for cars" Is this really corona related? I'm hearing this for many years now.
- ProZsolt 7y agoCycling skyrocketed after social distancing started. People realized cycling is not that bad if you don't have to be afraid to be hit by a car. Currently, there is less car on the roads because people working from home.
- goatinaboat 7y agoCramming people in on buses and trains is sure to slow the next pandemic spreading facepalm
- cwhiz 7y agoThe only city in America that is even remotely capable of going car free is NYC. And really it’s just Manhattan because in the other boroughs the train service starts to get spotty. Bus service in NYC would suffice if they killed off most of the other vehicle traffic. It is sometimes faster to walk than take the bus. Honestly, the amount of vehicle traffic in NYC right now is perfect. They should just cap it at current levels.