4 ms·
Every article I see about people testing asymptomatic is followed by comments insisting they were asymptomatic when tested, with no idea of whether they stayed
by crazygringo 7y ago
Every article I see about people testing asymptomatic is followed by comments insisting they were asymptomatic when tested, with no idea of whether they stayed asymptomatic or whether virtually all of them had symptoms a few days later, thus basically invalid.
But this doesn't seem like a hard problem to solve, folks. Is nobody bothering to follow up with the asymptomatic people a week later? Just take their mobile phone number, and text them en masse with a quick Y/N question as to whether or not they got sick?
This stuff baffles me. This is literally a matter of life-and-death, and yet the most basic questions seem to be unanswered. (Or are these follow-up surveys being done but the media just refuses to report them because it now feels like week-old news? I'd love to know.)
- lukevdp 7y agoYes, one study when the diamond princess was tested it was originally 50% asymptomatic and then later on that had gone down to under 20%
- graeme 7y agoA lot of the asymptomatic cases had pneumonia in their lungs too. They were however still able to expel CO2 and so did’t feel shortness of breath.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoI've heard this more recently that it's a characteristic which means that people who think they're getting better will then suddenly have a turn for the worse, because they don't feel as sick but their blood oxygen level is actually quite low -- they try to exert themselves, go upstairs say, and then faint. Happened that way to a close friend of mine.
- Symmetry 7y agoAnd this can also happen if there's a liquid nitrogen or liquid helium spill in a place without sufficient ventilation. As happened to an acquaintance of mine. If that happens get out even if you don't feel any shortness of breath.
- wk_end 7y agoSomeone else mentioned those numbers in a cousin thread but as far as we can tell there's no source for that. Do you happen to have one? See the comment thread here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22981423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22981423
- nradov 7y agoThe USS Theodore Roosevelt situation was discussed here several days ago. At this time about 60% of the crew who tested positive are still asymptomatic. Enough time has passed that we can be confident they aren't just presymptomatic. Numbers are pretty solid since they were all quarantined and tracked. Infection fatality rate was about 0.1%, however that's probably not representative of the general population.
- edmundsauto 7y agoAlso, how should we weight the validity of the data, given the political leadership issues surrounding this situation.
- nradov 7y agoThe data is valid, at least to the extent that the tests are accurate (there will be some false results). The Navy has openly published their numbers. If they didn't want us to know they would simply classify everything as a matter of operational readiness instead of lying. https://navylive.dodlive.mil/2020/03/15/u-s-navy-covid-19-updates/ https://navylive.dodlive.mil/2020/03/15/u-s-navy-covid-19-up...
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago>they would simply classify everything as a matter of operational readiness instead of lying // Do you think, it seems that not releasing data would be a clear sign they're hiding something - given the public nature of the situation - releasing distorted figures is very difficult to find as you'd need to take a census of sailors ... which the navy/politicians would simply not allow. And the people involved themselves mightn't even notice if the figures were just massaged. Appreciate your citation and input.
- jdietrich 7y ago>Infection fatality rate was about 0.1%, however that's probably not representative of the general population. That's something of an understatement - deployed naval personnel are almost exclusively young and healthy, putting them at exceptionally low risk of becoming seriously ill from COVID-19.
- jariel 7y agoIt's truly disorienting. We need good data, badly, and we have an entire world as our Petree dish and yet can't seem to get it. You'd think the CDC would be sending out questionnaires, forms, coordinating such tests, giving guidelines, collating results etc.. Literally the worst economic shock maybe ever and we can't count marbles to save ourselves.
- jacobush 7y agoCDC don’t seem to have permission to communicate with the public
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoThe CDC, AIUI, just advise medics and governments? It's up to the politicians to enable it - eg by putting medics in charge!?
- azakai 7y agoThe CDC is working on this, for example https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/04/cdc-launches-studies-to-get-more-precise-count-of-undetected-covid-19-cases/ https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/04/cdc-launches-studies-to-...
- vosper 7y ago> Just take their mobile phone number, and text them en masse with a quick Y/N question as to whether or not they got sick? I've been wondering why this isn't just being done for everyone in the country, every few days? "The main symptoms of COVID-19 are X, Y, Z. If you think you may have COVID-19 please respond "Yes" to this text message. This is free. Your response is private and used to understand the spread of COVID-19 in our country. Please visit http://some.link http://some.link for more information" If someone responds "yes" you could follow up with some more questions, if that was useful. And then text them a few days later to see if they're feeling better or worse, or maybe ask them to describe how they feel. There are lots of problems with this idea: people lying or not taking it seriously; people not responding; not everyone has a cellphone; some people will be worried about privacy, etc etc... But surely there'd be something useful to learn from it? And it seems like it should be easy to do, really, if you got the mobile providers on board (or just order them to help).
- alexis_fr 7y agoDo you even need to be an official to do that? Perhaps a newspaper could do it, to accurate news.
- notatoad 7y agoI saw it suggested on Twitter yesterday that the political polling firms should be doing some coronavirus polling, tracking trends in self-reported cases the same way they track public opinion. I'm not sure if that would be scientifically useful in any way, but it sure would be interesting.
- jackcosgrove 7y agoSee my reply to GP.
- CydeWeys 7y agoIn Italy they're personally tracking every confirmed case. Meanwhile, here in NYC, I called 311 to report my suspected case and that wasn't even a thing they were tracking. We just don't have our shit together over here, not at a state or national level.
- ShorsHammer 7y agoIt is being done though, virtually everywhere. Huge amount of testing worldwide is confirming case recovery. You are conflating armchair epidemiologists on HN with the reality on the ground. What people say here doesn't reflect what is being done.
- standardUser 7y agoWhere is the follow up data? Is there a link or reference? Or do you have inside information?
- ShorsHammer 7y agoCan you show me the original data sources first? I'll happily send off emails to the various authors and report back to you on what their follows up are.