5 ms·
Like with the death rate, I expect we'll seamlessly transition from "this isn't proof, in 2 weeks you'll see" to "this isn't news, everyone always believed that
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
Like with the death rate, I expect we'll seamlessly transition from "this isn't proof, in 2 weeks you'll see" to "this isn't news, everyone always believed that so it doesn't imply any changes in strategy".
- wegs 7y agoWell, it isn't proof. It is evidence, though. And in two weeks, we will have a lot more evidence. A lot of this is like Russian Roulette -- there's a huge amount about this virus which we don't know, and it could be super-bad or not-that-bad. It could also be there are bad and not-so-bad strains. Or it could be bad down-the-line. Until we do have proof, I'm advocating being conservative. In 2 weeks, we'll know if people are turning up in ERs or in morgues. In a few months, we'll know about lung damage, immune system damage, strokes, or a lot of the other potential consequences. In a year, we'll know about vaccine and long-term immunity. I think the key problem here is failure to understand risk management. I can believe one think, but act another way just in case I'm wrong. Or I can be unsure. And so on. That nuance is lost in the right/wrong discussions.
- Zach_the_Lizard 7y ago> A lot of this is like Russian Roulette -- there's a huge amount about this virus which we don't know, and it could be super-bad or not-that-bad. I think at this point we know enough to say: 1) For most of the population, the virus is not that serious 2) For a subset of the population the virus is seriously deadly. For example, ~20% of NY state coronavirus deaths were from nursing homes, ~37% are 80 or older. By contrast, there were 2 people under the age of 10 at the time of this post. [0] > I think the key problem here is failure to understand risk management I think another key problem is a failure to be frank about the cost-benefit of our actions. I have had to make stronger cases about changing the color of a button or optimizing a backend call than I've seen presented by authorities who are shutting down or reopening or anywhere in between. [0] https://covid19tracker.health.ny.gov/views/NYS-COVID19-Tracker/NYSDOHCOVID-19Tracker-Fatalities?%3Aembed=yes&%3Atoolbar=no&%3Atabs=n https://covid19tracker.health.ny.gov/views/NYS-COVID19-Track...
- edmundsauto 7y agoOn 1), what do you consider "not that serious"? IE, what are your metrics of choice, and what are the acceptable values? Regarding the cost-benefit discussion, my perspective is that people only want to discuss the downsides from a reduced economy. Second order effects include reduced vehicle deaths, reduced deaths from pollution, etc. IE, my discussions has felt agenda driven because it considers first order effects only. If we're going to compare apples-to-apples, I'm willing to have that conversation. If the conversation is limited to "people die during recessions", it's a pretty clear signal that agenda is driving and would not be a productive use of my time.
- alexbanks 7y agoIt seems kind of ridiculous to cite "reduced deaths from pollution" as an upside while people are also being forced into confinement, no?
- edmundsauto 7y agoIf the argument is that more people will die from economic recession, it's a necessary component. What's the rationale for excluding it? Without 2nd order effects, it doesn't seem like the correct comparison.
- sharken 7y agoWe are quite a lot of people that fear the operation will be successful but the patient is dead with the Corona actions being taken. Case in point, 26.5 million americans have sought unemployment benefits (https://vastuullisuusuutiset.fi/en/weben/women-bear-brunt-of-u-s-job-losses-in-coronavirus-crisis/ https://vastuullisuusuutiset.fi/en/weben/women-bear-brunt-of...). The deaths in New York are quite telling for who is at risk, see https://www.statista.com/statistics/1109867/coronavirus-death-rates-by-age-new-york-city/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1109867/coronavirus-deat.... Over 90% of the dead so far are old with comorbidites such as Hypertension and Diabetes, see https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-25/most-nyc-covid-19-dead-had-other-health-problems-city-data-show https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-25/most-nyc-.... So i agree that "not serious" is an accurate statement.
- tux1968 7y agoYou're completely discounting the risks associated with the economic lockdown. Maybe we should be more conservative with our economic livelihood.