7 ms·
I’ve often wondered what society would look like if optimized for saving people time. Just some quick thoughts: - Crosswalks and traffic lights would become no
by keiferski 7y ago
I’ve often wondered what society would look like if optimized for saving people time. Just some quick thoughts:
- Crosswalks and traffic lights would become non-existent and replaced with more pedestrian overpasses, turning/merging lanes, and other designs. Waiting for the light to change is a huge waste of time for both pedestrians and drivers. It seems like we might get this eventually with self-driving cars.
- Minimization of waiting rooms. If your appointment will be delayed, you’ll be informed of it ahead of time via SMS. Time slots are strictly enforced to avoid overlap.
- Purchase and checkout items while you shop, rather than waiting in line at a cash register. Or just skip shopping in person and order everything via delivery.
- Adoption of remote work and minimization of unnecessary commutes. Plus faster public transit in general. Japan is pretty good with this (the Shinkansen is impressive.)
- naringas 7y agothere are many pedestrian overpasses in some big cities (like the one I live in) but it's not so simple, because then you have to climb up stairs, which takes more time... you walk more steps add some heavy duty sun and people rather wait in the shade down below rather than climb up. Also pedestrian overpasses tend to be really narrow (read: uncomfortable) Also, why should we be so stingy with time? it's better (IMHO) to lived relaxed, otherwise we will end up under conditions similar (they say) to amazon warehouse workers which have their bathroom breaks measured in seconds.
- ReactiveJelly 7y ago> why should we be so stingy with time? Because it's fungible. If I save 10 seconds, maybe I get to keep those for myself.
- naringas 7y agoto each their own, I guess... I am just (strangely) reminded of Charles Dickens' classic a christmas story: "bah! humbug!".
- zdkl 7y agoI think an interesting question is whether we are respectively good judges on the "real" value of those ten saved seconds vs more abstract quality of life issues such as mental health or reductions in stress.
- bitcurious 7y agoThe idea that time is fungible is misleading. I can only drink coffee using my before noon time, or else I take away from the utility of my night time. I’m less productive in the time immediately after a big meal. I can only smell the roses for 30 or so consecutive seconds, and then need a break.
- tluyben2 7y agoThat sounds stressful...
- fragmede 7y agoAs human beings, time isn't really fungible. I can't wake up at 3am, choose to be productive for 45 minutes, go back to sleep, and then take a 45 minute nap later on in the day. If I stop myself from watching an hour of TV, it doesn't mean that I'll gain an extra hour of productive time tomorrow.
- keiferski 7y agoIdeally, the road would be at a lower level than the sidewalk. Then you wouldn’t need to spend time climbing up the bridge, and it wouldn’t be a big deal to have multiple wide bridges. Think Venice, except roads instead of canals. Presumably engineering tech will also get better and cheaper and some sort of rapid outdoor escalator or elevator could also solve the problem. Regarding stinginess: I understand where you’re coming from, but I also feel like there are time-intensive aspects of modern life which have little-or-no value, like waiting in traffic.
- kfarr 7y agoThe problem to solve is not how to make traffic faster, but how to reduce the need for traffic. Many books on the subject but the basic gist is we've designed our cities incorrectly and suburbs are inefficient for many reasons - time, energy, land use and even self reported happiness and satisfaction.
- blondin 7y agouncovered bridges and people being lazy... compared to saving lives and time, these sound like bad excuses.
- m-p-3 7y ago> Purchase and checkout items while you shop, rather than waiting in line at a cash register. Or just skip shopping in person and order everything via delivery. I believe this is starting to happen in some places, example (and an interesting video on RFID tags in general) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0QKrHi-G9WQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0QKrHi-G9WQ
- bestnameever 7y agoMore examples (Kroger handheld checkout scanners): - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3BcAZPh9nuA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3BcAZPh9nuA And of course Amazon Go - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rPZdWuOPaHY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rPZdWuOPaHY
- agumonkey 7y agoIt could be an interesting experiment. I cannot stop but see time wasted everywhere, people using things that actually slow them down.. Also I believe our brain is very very much tailored to enjoy rapid resolutions. Yet I still worry about overuse of the idea leading to more stress (faster faster faster).
- luckylion 7y ago> I’ve often wondered what society would look like if optimized for saving people time. No TV, entertainment etc, which basically exist only because we have more time than we know what to do with, so we pay people to kill time.
- ct520 7y agoThis is pretty much my life to the extent of how much I can control it in society. I never do any singular thing with the exception of work. I won’t leave the house unless I can divide and group that time into multiple objectives thus spreading the overhead of time lost against many achievements. If not in a meeting I have my pleasureable conversations via car phone when I commute some where. If I’m not in a meeting when commuting or talking to friend / family I’m streaming a new pluralsight tutorial over Bluetooth. I work through any meeting that doesn’t maximize my output to 100%. (I’m remote most of the time) I listen to self growth audio books when I shower. When I head to the bar if I’m not killing two birds with one stone networking or meeting a client I’ll bring my laptop to get work done. Tasks that I cannot streamline and time intensive I pay for. Blah blah I can go on and on. Ironically the one thing I haven’t mastered is how to delegate to achieve bigger goals leveraging employees.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoMake sure to stop and smell the roses. Research shows people on their death bed always regret working too much and not enough time with loved ones (if you’re a data driven sort of person).
- ct520 7y agoThanks for the comment. I do have a large family I take care of them as single source of income. I found I have to make a conscious effort to ensure I spend time with them. Since I have done that my quality of life improved greatly while still maintaining a hefty work schedule. A couple years back I audited how much time I was spending with my family/kids. It was embarrassing. Besides our normal routines I made the effort to take them to each of their extra curricular activities. 6 days a week 3 kids. I spend individual time with them each week and we go on vacation 3-5 times a year. I’m learning to have my cake and eat it too. But the family life is a conscious effort I have to make to avoid the (I wish I slowed down). Not a day that goes by I don’t love what I do and my life. Given the above I hope I don’t regret it. Time will tell.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago
- nemetroid 7y ago> - Purchase and checkout items while you shop, rather than waiting in line at a cash register. In Sweden, this has been a thing in most larger grocery stores for more than 10 years, e.g. https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.coop.se%2Fbutiker-erbjudanden%2FTjansterEfter-kopet%2FShopExpress%2F https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...
- IggleSniggle 7y agoThis has also been a thing at many US grocery stores for many years now, but inexplicably, many people don't use them.
- mikestew 7y agoI don’t use them because I just assume it’s going to be a personal information harvest fest, and it won’t work as advertised anyway. Like most other software-driven things these days.
- viceroyalbean 7y agoPersonal information is a fair point, though that goes for any loyalty program (which I presume you also don't use), but what do you mean by "won't work as advertised"? The function that's advertised is that you can scan items as you walk through the store and once you get to the checkout the only thing you do is pay, which is exactly the function that's provided.
- IggleSniggle 7y agoIt's basically the same technology that's used at the register. You pick up a barcode scanner, you scan your items, and the scanner produces a hash of your items that can be scanned at checkout to reproduce the list. Super simple technology. The store could gather how much time it took you to scan between items and in which order, but you can pay with cash if you're worried about personal privacy.
- madengr 7y ago
- amelius 7y agoInteresting thought. The GDP would be replaced by GDTS, gross domestic time saved and the country with the highest GDTS would have the most flourishing economy. An ounce of gold would be worthless.
- anticensor 7y agoGDP is an input measure by definition. The corresponding output measure is GNC (Gross National Consumption), so is GDTS/GNTS.
- t0mislav 7y agoWe could optimize (probably we will) lot of things like you mentioned. But then, we will still waste 20 times more looking at stupid things on internet.
- keiferski 7y agoProbably. But at least I try and spend some of my phone time doing Anki cards.
- ezoe 7y ago- Most of the regulation of prior permission paperwork submit is abolished. Whether somebody meets the regulation standard will be evaluated after it was done. - Customer service is not free of charge after used the up free quota. - Telephone, video/voice chat are deprecated because these communication require people to use time at specific point rather than in the convenient time they choose.
- qqssccfftt 7y ago> - Customer service is not free of charge after used the up free quota. Oh yeah, that definitely won't make companies just wait until you're in the paid period before giving you service.
- bumby 7y ago> Most of the regulation of prior permission paperwork submit is abolished. Whether somebody meets the regulation standard will be evaluated after it was done. I’m not convinced this one would optimize for time unless it’s also optimizing for items falling through the cracks. If non-conformity is actually being caught it means the work has to be done twice to bring it in line with regulation after the fact. Recent example: Boeing Starliner was not meeting requirements but oversight seemed inadequate ultimately requiring a multi-million dollar re-do once the gaps were caught after it was supposedly finished Edit: down votes are fine but please extend the courtesy of explaining so as to add to the conversation
- burlesona 7y agoWhy these things don’t (always) happen is more related to the top sibling comment: there is a trade off in space or energy with each of the things you described, and the value in time saved must be less than the space and energy cost of the alternatives, or else they would happen.
- fnord77 7y ago> replaced with more pedestrian overpasses, vegas has pedestrian overpasses and they are a tremendous waste of time - much worse than crosswalks. A better approach would be to keep the pedestrians at grade-level and have car under-passes
- gofarup 7y agoThere’s other ways to do it them having gigantic concrete bridges like Vegas. In downtown SF, you could put lower diagonal street bridges which would save an infinite amount of time for people driving.
- allannienhuis 7y agoSeveral large cities in China that I've been to tend to use pedestrian tunnels at many large intersections. It works pretty well - subway-like staircases at each corner, and nice wide hallway/tunnels going around the whole intersection. Occasionally with some shops. It has the advantage of being easy on the eyes above-ground. I can imagine in places with serious homelessness issues there could be problems, but the ones I experienced were fairly nice - some more plain than others, but generally graffiti free, well lit, and well used.
- torstenvl 7y agoHarvard Square has this, by happenstance. There are entrances to the T on both sides of Mass Ave. and you don't have to go through the turnstile to cross from one to the other.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThese are fine if you're perfectly abled. If you are disabled (permanently or temporarily), old, have strollers or luggage, then level-changes add quite some time in the best case or are completely unusable in the worst case. In my experiences traveling with Asia, usually these systems were not outfitted with elevators.
- 7y ago
- bestnameever 7y agoall of the above currently exists in some form. I'm sure more of it will come.
- pipingdog 7y agoThe pedestrian signal is a time set aside to meditate on one's humility and patience.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bo1024 7y agoWhereas the car signal is time set aside to check one's texts and notifications.
- elwell 7y agoI wonder if it would be more fruitful to optimize not for saving time but for patience capacity. Somehow I was more accepting of having to wait 20 years ago than I am now.
- iso1210 7y agoRemoval of adverts
- kgwgk 7y ago> Minimization of waiting rooms. If your appointment will be delayed, you’ll be informed of it ahead of time via SMS. That would be great! Then I can keep working until the last minute and, if no SMS was received, teleport myself directly into the doctor’s office. > Time slots are strictly enforced to avoid overlap. Then everyone will be scheduled, and charged, much more time than the expected duration of a consultation.
- WalterBright 7y ago> I’ve often wondered what society would look like if optimized for saving people time. It would look like what it is today. Sure, there are still inefficiencies, but we have a high standard of living because it is optimized for time. For example, it used to be that 95% of people worked on the farm to raise enough food. Now it's like 2%. Nobody spends time anymore making cloth, which used to be the bulk of "women's work". > Or just skip shopping in person and order everything via delivery Isn't that what we do now? I've been doing nearly all my shopping online since long before this quarantine, exactly because it's a huge time saver. I think I visited the mall once in the last year, and that was for a social reason, not shopping.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Waiting for the light to change is a huge waste of time for both pedestrians and drivers That's because it's designed and run by the government, which has no interest in saving time. How many hours do we all waste waiting for a light to change when there's no cross traffic? having a "platoon" of cars come to a halt to let one car cross? having a light turn yellow at the last moment to slam on the brakes? How much gas has this cost, too? By mounting cameras on the lights and a little AI programming, and an optimization algorithm, I bet the lights could be a major factor in reducing gas consumption, smoothing traffic flow, reducing accidents, and saving time. In fact, the AI could be self-learning, like the fuel injection systems on cars.
- copperx 7y agoRoundabouts could replace most, although not all, instances of traffic lights. They're so pleasant to use.
- loco5niner 7y agoI used to think so, then I married a gal who gets car-sick anytime we go through more than one round-about in a row. I suppose it could have to do with the design of the roundabouts in our area. They are quite small.
- teleforce 7y agoThis. Instead of obsessing on level 5 autonomous car that we probably will never achieve in our lifetime, why not optimized the AI for level 5 equivalent of traffic lights and control. Imagine having Waze like system integrated with city wide dynamic and intelligent traffic lights for seamless urban travel.
- clairity 7y agobroadly speaking, you could argue waiting (in lines or other queues) in many instances is an externalized cost placed on consumers to the benefit of commerce/bureacracy. it allows the business/agency to optimize its operations at the expense of the customer. this isn't generally considered when making productivity and efficient allocation arugments in politics/economics.