30 ms·
Thousand-year-old mill has resumed production due to demand for flour
- happytoexplain 7y agoSuggested title: Thousand-Year-Old Mill Producing Flour for First Time in 50 Years Due to Demand
- schnevets 7y agoHow about: Thousand-Year-Old Mill Producing Flour for First Time in 50 Years Due to Inability for Supply Chains to Divert Product from Shut-Down Commercial Buyers to Personal Customers
- epicureanideal 7y agoDoes anyone know why it is such a problem for our supply chain to shift from commercial buyers to consumers? I imagine there are people out there willing to buy in commercial sizes, if packaging is the problem...
- Scoundreller 7y agoSupposedly a problem in Canada was bags. Dunno why it took them so long to start shipping them in plainer bags though. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/robin-hood-flour-baking-yellow-bags-1.5541483 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/robin-hood-flour-baking-yel... Would prefer to pay a few cents less for all my goods instead of advertising for the product I just bought in my own home.
- peterwwillis 7y agoThe short answer is "because logistics".
- schnevets 7y agoThis is the best response. I like highlighting that this is a logistics problem, because humanity has become more adept at solving logistics issues since the start of the 21st century. I feel like people are becoming increasingly fatalistic about challenges like overpopulation while we have tools to help fix these problems that didn't exist 20 years ago. Yes, the world is changing at a speed that makes people uneasy, but the world that emerges out of this could be more resilient, better fed, and more environmentally sound as long as we continue to solve problems.
- epicureanideal 7y agoCan you share some of the advances in logistics since 2000? We've had shipping containers for a few decades before that, trucks and pipelines and so on. What's new?
- peterwwillis 7y agoBasically, digital technology. We now have access to so much raw data, with such immediacy, and the capability to process it, that we can identify and work around problems and find more efficient solutions faster and better than ever. The main way this shows up in society is probably the maximization of profits that leads to increased wealth/prosperity. That doesn't describe who is getting that wealth of course :), but it's there. So we have a better opportunity and capability to solve problems than ever before. The trick is getting society to adopt it properly. WRT the logistics of scaling a supply chain, we have the capability to identify supply chain inefficiencies and provide fixes. As a store sells out of toilet paper, it's possible for the store's database to be linked up to the toiler paper distribution company, so they know when a shortage is happening in real time. But how long does it take the manufacturer they buy from to spin up more TP? Too long. To fill the gap immediately, the store would need to detect that the original distributor won't be able to fulfill the projected increased capacity, and start filling orders with some other distributor somewhere else in the world to get more TP. But we also may be assuming that the whole world isn't having a shortage... if it is, is there enough cargo plane capacity to ship from these remote places? If not, more logistics is needed. The capability to automatically perform that logistical ninjutsu at each stage of the supply chain is now easier than ever. But nobody ever programmed their systems (much less signed the right business agreements) to actually do it, because nobody really needed TP to "scale". And this is the actually hard logistics problem: it's not enough to have the capability to do something, you have to actually implement it in your system. They haven't done that, so the supply chain doesn't automatically scale. But all of that ignores the impact of a global trade network on logistics. Assume you did this for coffee, and a shortage of beans (or price increase) from one country led you to automatically buy from another country with cheaper/more plentiful beans. The impact would be to automatically penalize one country's farmers for trade embargoes, drought, war, or some other issue. So while logistics are a very useful tool, they should be balanced against their potential side-effects if we really want to maximize their benefit on a global scale.
- bragh 7y agoI'm from Estonia, the usual problem when it came to industrial goods was that consumers don't have a VAT ID and are protected by Consumer Protection and Technical Regulatory Authority. In B2B, companies need to handle problems between themselves, so that means the need to offer 2 years of warranty per EU laws to consumers, labeling and instruction manual in Estonian and probably much more that I can't remember. But given these times, it's not a problem: I already know of at least 2 wholesale food suppliers who opened up their ordering systems to be used for B2C.
- timthorn 7y agoBut it's not producing for the first time in 50 years - it's just producing full time, whereas previously it was milling on a demonstration basis.
- happytoexplain 7y agoAh - unfortunately I can't think of a more concise way to put it than the article does: "Back In The Flour Business".
- devmunchies 7y agoSo much flour will sit in people’s pantry and go bad, never opened.
- guerrilla 7y agoBased on...? It may do nothing but drive down future demand as people use up what they have.
- blihp 7y agoThe reality that many people buying it don't know how to cook, let alone bake. I'd bet that most of the people clearing out the baking aisles are doing so as an insurance policy (i.e. buy the raw materials now 'just in case' and learn how to use them later, if needed. Maybe, if they have kids they're baking some cookies.) The crisis will pass with the majority of the flour purchased just going bad. Regarding driving down future demand: not likely more than in the very short term... flour has a fairly short shelf life. Have you ever used/tasted rancid flour? While it's not the end of the world, it's not something most people are likely to want use in a recipe more than once given a choice.
- guerrilla 7y ago> The reality that many people buying it don't know how to cook, let alone bake. Based on? > not likely Again, based on what? Your intuition? You have some data correlating flour purchases with people unable to bake (and apparently unmotivated to use a search engine or read expiration dates)? Storing flour in a sealed container extends its lifespan. Freezing it even more so. Anyone can easily learn these facts if so motivated.
- blihp 7y agoBased on a lifetime of anecdotal evidence and the application of logic and common sense. Not everything in this world requires citing references and applying the scientific method.
- Bang2Bay 7y agopeople who are used to eating out have now bought a lot of grains and flour.
- rjpn 7y agowhy is this on HN?
- oh_sigh 7y agoI can't really understand how this is economical. After 10 days, they produced 200 3-lbs bags of flour. I don't know what they sell for but I can get flour in a supermarket for 30c/lbs so maybe 60c/lbs since its artisanal? So that's $360 out the door, but how much did you pay for the wheat itself, to the grocer(if not direct to consumer), and for operating the mill?
- hinkley 7y agoFrom what I understand, in at least some areas of the world the mill was a service model, not a manufacturing model. You'd bring your grain in, they would mill it, and keep a fraction of the product as a fee. Sure, they're still selling flour for goods and services, but it's a fraction of the volume versus buying grain and selling flour. The overhead is tiny, but the distribution area is, too.
- Gibbon1 7y agoWhat I understand is that's how it worked everywhere. Lots of small mills that took a cut as payment. Friend of mine mentioned a while back one of his 12 year old nieces in India getting bread. Started with measuring out a wheat into a bucket. Then going down the street to a place that ground it into flour. Then to a place that turned that into dough. A place next door that beat it into shape. Finally to the baker. Each place took a bit as payment. This isn't like way back when, it was a couple of years ago. BTW: There is a working gristmill in St Helena, closed till further notice of course. I think they run it a couple of times a year. https://napaoutdoors.org/parks/bale-grist-mill-state-historic-park/ https://napaoutdoors.org/parks/bale-grist-mill-state-histori...
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoThat's how things still work in Pakistan to some extent. Especially if you want maize/barley/etc flour, you bring the seed, they will mill it for you.
- pjc50 7y ago> I can get flour in a supermarket for 30c/lbs Per the rest of the thread: you can't get it at that price in the supermarket in a lot of places. There's an empty shelf with that price tag on.
- londons_explore 7y agoIn 10 days of operation, they have 200 3lb bags of flour. Each would be worth $1.50 in walmart, and due to anti price-gouging laws, it would be illegal to charge more than that. So after 10 days operating, with presumably at least a few people on-site, they have produced goods which can sell for $300, or a revenue of $30 per day. I think this is more a publicity excercise than a commercial operation...
- starmftronajoll 7y agoYes. This is a charming story of kindness, community, and cultural heritage. It is not a business story.
- dv_dt 7y agoNot that there aren't serious questions, but it's common for prototypes and early production runs to easily cost 100x vs optimized production runs. And if it's meeting a need, I would suggest that the immediate cost isn't the primary concern or benefit here.
- pjc50 7y agoI suspect they were selling it for a higher price before the emergency as a souveneir.
- tomxor 7y agoThankfully this is in a tiny village in beautiful Dorset, England with a modest local population, and no there is no Walmart... so none of that applies.
- flatline 7y agoOpening this page pegged one processor in firefox :/
- tomxor 7y agoSomething very daft going on inside a requestAnimationFrame loop causing lots of css style re-computation with no discernible affect, pretty sad.
- gorgoiler 7y agoI had no idea about the businesses that are part of this word until we had to start hunting for bread flour and ended up finding: 1/ our city has an industrial wheat varietal breeder that makes a novel new brand based on Paragon, 2/ it also happens to be grown on an organic farm just west of us, 3/ and is milled and distributed by a nationwide famous windmill about 20 minutes to the north east. It’s a whole little world of actually quite new tech in the area I had no idea existed, with this weird overlap with technology hundreds and thousands of years old.
- dv_dt 7y agoI wish there were a commerce directory that would enable search and discovery for local businesses like this.
- frandroid 7y agoSomething printed on yellow paper, maybe!
- dv_dt 7y agoYou jest, the yellow pages online are a travesty of interface woes, but I guess I was able to enter flour and a number of companies did come up. But I think they are missing out on listings for products, resource, or manufacturing inputs & waste connecting angle that would be really interesting. The best thing they have is maybe industry category keywords.
- rhizome 7y agoThe entire business model of the Yellow Pages is to sell entries to businesses, and any value you get out of that is (at least) secondary. It's basically a gym subscription model, except its hosting costs and transit that eat into their profits. Just like the most profitable way to run a gym is to sell subscriptions to people who never visit.
- 7y ago
- aazaa 7y agoThose talking about the economics appear to live in areas with abundant flour. In many places in the US at least, it's very difficult to find any. It has been this way for weeks. Supermarkets get it and it flies off the shelves.
- eatonphil 7y agoWhere are you? At the big stores in Brooklyn for a while there was no flour. But now going to smaller stores I see it no problem. Seems like less of a shortage issue than just that most folks in my area are all inefficiently picking their grocery store.
- nickthegreek 7y agoIn Columbus, Ohio here. Last week was the first time we have had flour back on the shelves and the types were limited. Still haven't seen any yeast available.
- ghaff 7y agoI don't need any more so haven't made a real study but I'd note that both King Arthur and Bob's Red Mill are out of their main products online. (But they're somewhat artisan so they probably have more capacity constraints than the bigger players do.)
- lostapathy 7y agoI wonder how much of that is because they are out vs it's just a lot more efficient to send it by the pallet to grocers instead of one bag at a time to end users. I've seen this in other industries too - manufacturers will sell retail direct when times are "normal" because it's easy profit and they can fulfill out of "slack in the system". But when demand skyrockets they lack the slack energy to deal with retail-direct, so they just send everything through distribution.
- onetimemanytime 7y agoIn a lot of countries villagers plant their own wheat, mill it and bake bread for the entire year. Others buy 50-80lbs bags of wheat. Wheat is great for hard times, it fills your stomach and relatively cheap. It's a peace of mind as well, no matter what happens we have something
- zabil 7y agoI live in London, it's been four weeks since I last saw a pack of flour on the store shelf. The demand is that high.
- lb1lf 7y ago-Do you have yeast? Over on the other side of the North Sea, we've got more flour than we know what to do with on the shelves, as there is no yeast to be had - haven't seen a yeast cube in a month! (good thing sourdough is a thing!)
- zabil 7y agoYes! I managed to find a block of yeast last week. But, I can't use it as I got no flour :(
- lb1lf 7y agoWe need to talk, then. :)
- systemvoltage 7y agoGet flour from Centralmilling company: https://centralmilling.com/store/ https://centralmilling.com/store/ Order a 50 lb sack and you're good to go. They still have it in stock.
- benibela 7y agoIn Germany, I have flour, but no yeast I made a sourdough starter. It is kind of working, but some parts are tasting odd. There was also mold buildup at the margin
- lostlogin 7y ago> There was also mold buildup at the margin Throw that bit away and give it more flour and water (I use a 70g flour/100g water ratio). It'll be fine.
- 7y ago
- jvm_ 7y agoWe've moved into a real-world board game. This tile over here has wheat, if you go get it and then move to this tile, you can process it and gain bread - but your bread resource declines by 1 loaf per day.
- TLightful 7y agoFunny, as there is no shortage of bread on the supermarket shelves.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI think I read that only 4% of flour ends up in the shelves in normal times. Most of it goes direct to bakeries.
- verytrivial 7y agoTangential: The mill a mile up the road from my house was was listed in the Doomsday Book in 1089AD (though has likely burnt down a few times.) And when "attached" the local cathedral it produced the original hot crossed buns. It was printed in a visitor centre leaflet so it must be true.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- myself248 7y agoDomesday
- verytrivial 7y ago.. yeah. Thanks autocorrect/HN edit lockout. Grumble.
- sriram_sun 7y agoBuy a mill folks! The one I bought for 10 years back cost me about $350. Steep, yes. Considering all that freshly ground flour in the proportions that I wanted, it was a no-brainer in hindsight. I cannot for the life of me find reasonably priced wheat kernels at this time. So paradoxically for the past 2 months it has been sitting idle!
- bovermyer 7y agoWhen I first read this, I somehow thought you meant an actual building, and not the in-home type. Must be the whole Friday evening thing.
- jagannathtech 7y agoYou are not alone
- sriram_sun 7y agoHa ha ha! Sorry for the confusion. My mind kept saying "don't endorse a particular brand". So I was "carefully" optimizing my response for that!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rmason 7y agoThis crisis has had an energizing effect not only on thousand year old mills but startups as well. So there's a Michigan startup that makes... bamboo toilet paper. I don't know what kind of demand there is for bamboo toilet paper. A week after toilet paper became unavailable at any price they got a story written about them. They were having a warehouse sale where you could pick it up at the plant. https://heybippy.com/ https://heybippy.com/ The next day the paper had a picture of a woman in a brand new Mercedes full to the brim. She couldn't see out of the back window, the passenger seat was full and she had some on her lap! Now apparently they're selling it as fast as they can make it as long as their bamboo supply holds. I know someone whom I believe is an investor and I will check in with them later this summer. I am curious once the shortage is over and the supermarkets are stacked to the ceiling with Charmin will they still have a business? Will people develop a fondness for bamboo toilet paper? If they do that founder will have the pandemic to thank.
- trhway 7y agoTP is a bit unexpected. The local store got bamboo paper towels which supposedly can be washed and reused multiple times. That advantage would still be there even after pandemic. Probably they can always pivot from TP to towels. Wrt. the original article - cool, the [cold] stone grounded flour is better then the industrial fast (and importantly - hot) crush which thus affects the floor's carbohydrates state (and resulting yeast action, etc.).
- renewiltord 7y agoYou're supposed to wipe your butt with these and then wash the dirty cloth? Why on Earth would I do that? Am I supposed to be saving money with this or something?
- fiblye 7y agoPaper towels aren’t for your butt. They’re for wiping up things in the kitchen, your floor, dust, etc.
- Jerry2 7y agoAnecdotal: In the city where I live, my family hasn't been able to buy flour for the past 4 weeks. It's always out of stock. I hear from clerks that they get it occasionally but it sells out in under an hour. My closest grocery store also allots the first hour after they open to seniors and others who are vulnerable and most of the time, the flour is gone during this hour. Since we export so much grain every year, I'm amazed that there's such a massive shortage of flour. I don't know if it's the shortage of grains or mills.
- GuB-42 7y agoFlour have been in short supply at the nearby grocery store. First it was pasta and toilet paper, then flour and eggs, now it is mostly back to normal. My guess is that many people cook more than usual during the lockdown. I don't think there is a significant shortage of the raw material, but maybe there is not enough of it packaged for grocery stores.
- lostlogin 7y agoWhere I am (New Zealand) there is no shortage of flour, but a shortage of packaging. The vast bulk of flour was previously sold to bakers and other buyers in bulk - 25kg sacks. Now demand is for 1-5kg bags. The flour is here, but it's in the wrong bags and the suppliers have no staff or materials. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=12321873 https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&object...