3 ms·
My take on this whole offshoring / automation conundrum is that although the current crisis won't immediately constitute a boon for automation, it will certainl
by airstrike 7y ago
My take on this whole offshoring / automation conundrum is that although the current crisis won't immediately constitute a boon for automation, it will certainly pose the question in countless boardroom meetings. It's a question that's been asked before, but it's never been as top-of-mind as it is now, and that's first step to get the human and capital resources behind it to actually see this come to fruition.
From what I've heard in the manufacturing industry, automation is great conceptually but there are still many finer motor tasks for which the technology just isn't there yet, so cheap labor is the solution. Perhaps in hindsight these managers will find that concentrating all of that cheap labor in pretty much just one geography (China) isn't exactly the definition of redundancy, so supply chains in the long term will need to be redefined.
Slowly, geographies like Vietnam, Mexico, India and even the U.S. should benefit from this desire to diversify away from China. This "next generation" of factories will be smarter and pave the way for more advanced automation involving finer motor tasks.
> "The demand for smart factories is likely to grow with increased diversification of production locations – from China to Vietnam, India, and even the US." (Morgan Stanley Research. Investing in the Second
Machine Age – Picking the
Winners. July 19, 2019)
- kiba 7y agoNobody's going to buy or use a car if demand drops like a brick. All the automated factories in the world isn't going to help with the fact that inventories will just pile up, unbought and unused.
- airstrike 7y agoDemand will eventually recover. We're discussing what happens next, not what happens today. Supply chains and manufacturing in general, whether automated or not, don't change overnight.
- dillonmckay 7y agoWhy do you assume demand will eventually recover to prior levels? What if the recovery looks different?
- leptoniscool 7y agoThings usually recover; look at post-war Europe and Japan, post-soviet Russia, end of Great Recession, etc.
- bilbo0s 7y agoHN User dillonmckay has a point. Recovery happened in all the cases you mentioned because labor had income. Which in turn created demand. Which you satisfied by increasing production. Which, at that time, required more labor. Which gave labor more income. And so on cyclically. If we create even a sizable percentage of automated factories, then you don't necessarily need the same post-WWII levels of labor that you needed back then to get production increases. My own bet would be on inequality in the developed world actually accelerating. Businesses will be doing what's rational. Finding manufacturing locations close to coastal ports for the purposes of distributing their productive capacity across the globe in a bid for redundancy. Automating everything they can. And more. All of which will be completely reasonable actions. It's just that the result will mean even fewer jobs, and even more education to get those jobs. Probably good for the HN crowd if I'm being honest. But not so good for opioid infested flyover country.
- bluGill 7y agoThat argument goes back at least to the luddites mostly unchanged. Yet here we are with many times the world population, nobody running manual spinning wheels or looms (except hobbiests for fun) and there are more than enough jobs to go around.
- bilbo0s 7y agoSure. And if you're able to make a satisfactory living for yourself as a barista, grocery store clerk, or delivery driver, go right ahead. My only point is that in flyover country, even before, the available jobs were not giving people a decent living. A lot of them actually get more money by using the whole "disability" scheme. They're actually better off participating in that program, which is a major signal that something was wrong. My bet is that it will be more wrong in the future as measured by the number of people choosing the path of government assistance. It's easy to say there are plenty of jobs from the perch of your average HN User. You have the skills. I have the skills. Good for us. But from the perspective of people trying to get by in rural Wisconsin? Yeah. Not so much.
- kiba 7y agoDemand will crash every time a pandemic of this magnittude happens and for whatever bizarre reason, we did not prep properly.
- nradov 7y agoMost likely supply chain managers will establish "second source" policies, just like the US Defense Department has always done for many products. They won't necessarily move away from China entirely, but will build factories in other countries as well.
- airstrike 7y agoI agree, though in the long term this still means China represents a smaller percentage of the world's manufacturing.
- jrs95 7y agoThere is growing political demand to move away from China entirely though. I doubt its particularly popular with most people with influence, but if we've learned anything from 2016 it's that populism can be an unexpectedly potent force. If someone were to force the issue, the new GOP party line could very well end up being policy to move manufacturing away from China.
- bilbo0s 7y agoYeah, this crisis has illustrated beyond the shadow of a doubt that you need second-, third-, fourth- sources if you can. Especially for critical goods. Moving to Vietnam doesn't do anything to solve the fundamental problem. It may not even make sense to build a second- source in vietnam. You want geographic and, to the extent that it's possible, population isolation. So finding someplace along one of South America's coasts would be attractive. Australia would be extremely attractive if we could get automation right because labor costs there are just too high. Africa would also be attractive in the extreme. You wouldn't even have to take the resources off of the continent. Lowest labor costs around. Plus, two enormous coasts full of warm water ports. Anyway, the idea would be to set things up so that if one region goes to the dogs, you just switch to the other. EDIT: Now I think about it, there are some pretty large political issues in africa right now, so maybe africa wouldn't be the best place. Populism could easily end up landing you in the same situation as white farmers in Zimbabwe. Anyway, the fundamental idea still stands. Balance manufacturing from Asia and N America more towards S America, and Australia.