18 ms·
Coronavirus may mean automation is coming sooner than we thought
- hpoe 7y agoAs soon as this thing hit this was one of my first thoughts, once things recover there are going to be a lot of companies looking for ways to automate things because robots don't get sick, they don't have to worry about social distancing they keep going until you tell them to stop or the power gets cut. I do wonder however if this effect will be hampered by the number of unemployed. More unemployed people means a greater supply of laborers and that translates to lower costs. Of course on the flip side it may be that many companies are starting to see what is actually necessary for their company to operate and will run with a leaner staff moving forward. The future will be wild that's for sure. EDIT: When I say "translates to lower costs" I mean lower costs for labor, realized what I said could be ambiguous.
- dillonmckay 7y agoWell, I do not think we are at the point where AI powered robots can fully replace a human service worker, but, we can definitely have a hybrid solution, where remote workers can control the more difficult parts. So, jobs for the unemployed, and robots that can’t get sick.
- erikerikson 7y agoThis would produce excellent training data.
- baron_harkonnen 7y agoThe flip side is really the question: Where does the money come from to buy the things produced by the robots if people are no longer being paid to produce things? If you answer something like UBI, then you're just passing the buck and the obvious question is, "where does that money come from?" This problem is secretly baked into the structure of the current crisis. More automation is inevitable, I'm not arguing about that, but it will only exacerbate the problem.
- FeepingCreature 7y agoThe money is minted, which is to say printed, by the central bank. That is where the money comes from. That is where all money comes from.
- airstrike 7y agoThat's not where the value of money comes from, though
- mikepurvis 7y agoBut there isn't much value in people spending their lives driving delivery cars or bagging groceries either. The point of UBI proposals is that there is enough total value in our national economies to meet everyone's basic needs— the question of where the money/value "comes from" is simple, it comes from taking it back from where it's been concentrated over decades of inadequate taxation.
- vorpalhex 7y agoYou're conflating financial value with moral value. There's a lot of financial value in delivery or bagging even if there's no moral value. Printing money doesn't increase financial value it only increases liquidity. > it comes from taking it back from where it's been concentrated over decades of inadequate taxation. Again you're not increasing the financial value, you're changing how it's disbursed. Whether your fuel is in the form of gasoline or electricity you still have a finite amount of it and once you burn through it, it's gone unless you're adding more to the system.
- mrec 7y agoCould you expand on what you mean by "moral value" here? Something like job satisfaction, self-actualization etc? "Moral" as a descriptor seems likely to derail the argument here. There's nothing immoral about delivering groceries; it's providing a genuinely useful service, and can be intrinsically rewarding as evidenced by the hundreds of thousands of people volunteering to do it for free in the UK at the moment.
- airstrike 7y agoMy take on this whole offshoring / automation conundrum is that although the current crisis won't immediately constitute a boon for automation, it will certainly pose the question in countless boardroom meetings. It's a question that's been asked before, but it's never been as top-of-mind as it is now, and that's first step to get the human and capital resources behind it to actually see this come to fruition. From what I've heard in the manufacturing industry, automation is great conceptually but there are still many finer motor tasks for which the technology just isn't there yet, so cheap labor is the solution. Perhaps in hindsight these managers will find that concentrating all of that cheap labor in pretty much just one geography (China) isn't exactly the definition of redundancy, so supply chains in the long term will need to be redefined. Slowly, geographies like Vietnam, Mexico, India and even the U.S. should benefit from this desire to diversify away from China. This "next generation" of factories will be smarter and pave the way for more advanced automation involving finer motor tasks. > "The demand for smart factories is likely to grow with increased diversification of production locations – from China to Vietnam, India, and even the US." (Morgan Stanley Research. Investing in the Second Machine Age – Picking the Winners. July 19, 2019)
- kiba 7y agoNobody's going to buy or use a car if demand drops like a brick. All the automated factories in the world isn't going to help with the fact that inventories will just pile up, unbought and unused.
- airstrike 7y agoDemand will eventually recover. We're discussing what happens next, not what happens today. Supply chains and manufacturing in general, whether automated or not, don't change overnight.
- dillonmckay 7y agoWhy do you assume demand will eventually recover to prior levels? What if the recovery looks different?
- ghastmaster 7y agoAutomation requires investment. Recession means less capital for investment. The estimate of $12 dollar meal implies that people would be spending the time they use to cook the meal to work instead. That is idealistic. People generally do not work every waking moment of their lives. As we get to the bottom of the article we find the real point is to push UBI. When money is created and given to people who do not work, that money becomes worthless. What manufacturer is going to invest in robots to create products for people who have monopoly money?
- SubiculumCode 7y agoCould have had Yang.... Edit:well you could have...but hey. Enjoy your temporary stimulus funds.
- lnsru 7y agoThe automation is here and is used everywhere right now if it makes economically sense. Good overview of the pricing here: https://blog.robotiq.com/what-is-the-price-of-collaborative-robots https://blog.robotiq.com/what-is-the-price-of-collaborative-... Basic robot $50k, advanced application - $100k. One can hire lots of workers for the money. Especially during recession.
- devit 7y agoAren't these robots so expensive only because they are sold in low volumes? It seems to me that if mass produced, they should at lesat cost less than entry-level cars, since they are a similar size/weight and simpler, so less than 15k. And it also feels like they should cost a similar amount to premium versions of appliances like dishwashers/washing machines/etc., so in the 1-5k range.
- the8472 7y agoRobots are mass-produced. Fanuc press material says they're doing 7000 robots arms per month (that's two of their locations, they have more doing other industrial automation).
- m_ke 7y agoPeople are working on cheaper arms and we should soon have ones for under $10K. Ex: Pieter Abbeel from UC Berkeley https://news.berkeley.edu/2019/04/09/meet-blue-the-low-cost-human-friendly-robot-designed-for-ai/ https://news.berkeley.edu/2019/04/09/meet-blue-the-low-cost-... https://github.com/berkeleyopenarms https://github.com/berkeleyopenarms
- drawkbox 7y agoWe've already had massive automation events, the computer, the internet, mobile, self-checkout, etc. Everytime these steps made life better mostly, and more automated or at least allowed most people to be more independent. The last mile of automation is costly, where the first ones were money savers. Building physical robots and tuning them, maintenance, cleaning, updates, security, new versions etc etc. This last phase of robots, drones and self-driving vehicles will take a long time to get right and it is much more costly to enter it. The speed of innovation also makes it quickly out of date when you do commit to it. The automation remaining involves mostly hardware which is more costly, the initial ones were software that saved lots of money and wasted time.
- ChefboyOG 7y agoI don't fully understand the arguments in these kinds of pieces. Haven't businesses always been economically incentivized to automate everything, because that's just how labor costs work? It seems implausible to me that the bottleneck to mass automation (or rather, more widespread automation) is the willingness of corporations to invest in it. The more feasible blockers—the fundamental technology even existing, the cost of research/production, etc—don't seem correlated to Coronavirus.
- ashtonkem 7y agoSurprisingly, no. When companies are making easy money, there is very little incentive to improve efficiency, and a lot of incentive to continue the status quo. It’s only during tight times do companies actually begin to seek out new efficiencies. Example: automated oil rig machines have existed for quite a while, but they really didn’t see a lot of usage until the oil crash in 2016[0]. After this crash the number of oil rig workers remained at low levels, even as oil rigs starting to produce again. Those jobs were already vulnerable to automation, it just took a financial crisis to trigger it. [0] https://medium.com/basic-income/the-real-story-of-automation-beginning-with-one-simple-chart-8b95f9bad71b https://medium.com/basic-income/the-real-story-of-automation...
- ChefboyOG 7y agoThat's fascinating, and makes sense. I didn't think of it until you brought it up, but the risk/reward of investing in automation vs. maintaining current margins certainly flips when current margins plummet.
- ghastmaster 7y agoPurchases made with leveraged money that is all but disappearing. We are no longer in a 2016 scenario. Your link is to another article that is pushing for UBI using fear of automation that has no historical backing. Automation has been taking place since the dawn of man and people magically still have jobs even though the population has exploded. This is nonsense.
- user5994461 7y ago
- cronix 7y agoI've thought about this too. A lot of businesses will come back to the US from China. They'll likely be building new state of the art plants. Automation tech has become quite abundant in the recent years. I mean, hobbyists are making industrial-ish robot arms with arduino/rpi's for under $2k. The programming is becoming much simpler as well using encoders and physically moving the robot and having it record the moves instead of coding it all from scratch. Here's one I've been looking at building: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cfJn7T4D-6k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cfJn7T4D-6k
- dillonmckay 7y agoWhere do all the parts and materials come from?
- ghastmaster 7y agoProduction is not going to come back to the United States when we have draconian labor laws. That is the reason it left in the first place. We are going to be more dependent on foreign cheap labor as time goes on. We cannot weaken our currency and tighten our labor laws and expect investment in manufacturing at the same time.
- tialaramex 7y ago"Draconian labor laws" make no difference if you don't have any labor. That's key to grasping how different heavy automation makes things. Additional overhead of (let's pick a nice round guess) $5000 per worker adds up fast in a factory with 500 workers ($2.5M). But when you're only paying a maintenance technician and a security guard it's ten grand, and there are a lot of things a business might reasonably choose to do that cost ten grand without flinching.
- ghastmaster 7y agoMy point is that the US industry has no compelling reason to invest in automation when foreign labor is so cheap. It is cheap because labor here is expensive. It is expensive because of regulatory and statutory intervention. You are correct that we do not have any labor(somewhat hyperbolic of course). I understand why in some cases automation makes total sense on the micro and macro level. Are you trying to say that because it is expensive to employ labor here automation will fill in the gap? If so, why? Labor is cheap in other regions and money is getting tighter as we speak. Automation requires heavy upfront costs.
- noarchy 7y agoI can't be the only one who has noticed the huge influx of articles and comments for UBI in places like reddit and even HN, of late. It seems that the ongoing crisis is fuelling a lot of agendas.
- symplee 7y agoCome on, you know the routine. No matter what your cause is: Never let a crisis go to waste.
- searchableguy 7y agoSome of that make me pretty sick. I saw some startups pop up with public recruitment going through competitions and abusing the volunteers to push themselves to work for the cause so they can get funding from the investors for their "covid" cash cow project. I didn't have words when the guy made few announcements threatening people about unemployment, mentioning how rich they can get if they just follow him, if they don't follow him all's left for them is recession, unemployment and lot of nasty manipulating shit. Calling people losers and patting themselves on the back for solving the problem by introducing yet another surveillance clone.
- Slippery_John 7y agoIf a crisis exposes a weakness in a system and you're making a good faith suggestion is that really a bad thing? The US government's attempts to keep people afloat have pretty clear major issues, for instance. Is it really a bad thing to suggest that we should have a system in place to handle these sorts of events, even on smaller scales, rather than trying to rush something out when every day counts? I'm not arguing for UBI per se, but if somebody thinks it's the right solution then is it a bad thing to argue for it when an example of its usefulness is fresh in everybody's mind? Obviously there are plenty of bad faith suggestions going around too, but I can't help but think platitudes like this do more to shutdown good ideas than bad.
- noarchy 7y agoStimulus cheques handed out at an actual time of crisis is not the same thing as an unending flow of such cheques during times of low unemployment and economic stability. I think that distinction is being lost in this discussion. A lot of people who are in favour of some kind of intervention right now aren't necessarily going to want to turn this permanent.
- ck2 7y agoAll I know is self-driving cars are going to be killing a lot of passengers and pedestrians when corporations and programmers now get government liability waivers, rush out the project and just say "oops" when the spot the bug in the code. I mean who goes to prison when a car runs someone over and no-one is driving? What is a developer's motivation to be careful and defer to safety? We've already proven a good chunk of the population are sociopaths, they don't care who dies as long as they get their paycheck.
- steveeq1 7y agoAnd what if the self-driving cars end up causing fewer deaths than human drivers?
- perl4ever 7y agoIf you assume something will automatically happen, without a particular mechanism, how likely is it to? Seems to me that is a popular cargo cult few are immune to.
- carlmr 7y ago>If you assume something will automatically happen, without a particular mechanism He didn't mention it, but there are some pretty obvious mechanisms for this to be true: 1. Automated drivers don't get tired. 2. Automated drivers may "see" more of their environment than a human can. Human sensors aren't upgradeable. 3. Automated drivers don't get drunk. 4. Automated drivers don't have emotions. 5. Automated drivers aren't distracted by the infotainment system, the children in the back seat, or even some thought about what just happened at work. 6. With time, automated drivers can be improved, while human weaknesses stay constant. There are of course drawbacks: 1. Humans have intuition about situations they've never been in. Most AI/machine learning still generalizes poorly. 2. The programming may be buggy. 3. The datasets may be inadequate. So what will happen is definitely out there, but there are clear mechanisms for this to happen.
- perl4ever 7y ago
- zerotolerance 7y agoI have taken almost the opposite insight away from this whole ordeal. Automation is inelastic. Retooling is expensive and slow. It depends on lots of upstream suppliers having elastic production. Humans are on the opposite end of the spectrum. They're great for on-demand additional capacity at a cost.
- lostapathy 7y agoWorth noting that a lot of niche industries only work today because we have better automation to support oddball things that aren't truly "mass produced." More and better automation will enable even more of these segments to exist. Mechanical keyboards are a good example. There's a wide variety of plates, cases, and circuit boards available today that would be infeasible to make by hand, and were not cost effective to make just a few years ago. But here we are today with an appreciable hobby and market that wouldn't exist if not for improvements in manufacturing efficiency.
- jellicle 7y ago> Automation coming sooner I'd predict the opposite. The world will shortly have an international depression, and to the extent that businesses are allowed to be open, there will be 1000 applicants for every position. Wages will collapse. Demand for products generally will be low, dampened by the fact that a huge number of possible buyers are flat broke. Those are conditions to retard the growth of automation, not increase it. You're going to spend a zillion dollars automating to produce a product people can't afford to buy while there are thousands of people outside your factory saying "we want to make your shit by hand for nearly free"? Next couple of years will be a LOW time for automation, not a high time. (Which doesn't mean zero, obviously certain products are still going to be produced by increasingly cheap automated processes.) But some big surge in the rate of automation? No way.
- noelsusman 7y agoI think most of the predictions about permanent changes caused by the virus will turn out to be wildly wrong. Companies will view this as a rare event that's not worth spending significant resources to prepare for. The march toward more automation will press on just as it did before the virus, governed largely by the price of labor vs. the price of automation.
- AWildC182 7y agoI agree 100%, though in reality these events happen almost yearly at this point, just not quite this widespread. In just the past few years we've seen tons of localized outbreaks such as the ebola and zika scares. It's a pretty dangerous thing to assume as a one-off.
- test6554 7y agoI think we will see a cottage industry focused on getting companies and employees certified as essential so they don't miss out on income next time around. Also around limiting companies liability in the event their policies cause employees to become infected by the next pandemic.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoThat's interesting. In Europe nobody with a full time job missed out on income. Most pople were at home and kept getting paid.
- tathougies 7y agoHe's talking about companies not people. Most unemployed Americans are getting paid their full wage. Some even get more than they would be making working.
- TheAdamAndChe 7y agoDo you have a source for this? Anecdotally, most family I know that has lost their jobs haven't had their income replaced.
- Zenst 7y agoCertainly seems like an automated stream of Coronavirus riding agenda's. Anything that has "Coming soon" or "Than we thought" always triggers a level of credibility erosion in me, this just went full on. Thing is with automation, what do you do with all those excess humans who are no longer needed to work as I do recall the 70's champion the future would see us all spend most of our time on leasure and 3 day working weeks. Seems a case of some people end up working 6-7 day weeks and others none. But automation has been on it's way for so long, it's not an overnight shift, but a gradual one. Then the net result is never what is expected. Heck other day people read abour Rumba and how ealy models failed sooner as people was using them daily instead of weekly as previously. So the time saved in one area of interacting with cleaning shifted to another of almost gamified interaction, marking out area's, playing with it and stats. So whilst some automation can do wonders, it can often shift the problem into something else and still not save overall.
- xster 7y agoThis was all exactly what Yang was running on. His campaign must be fairly bummed to have not stayed on message and instead making the various faux pas with is supporters such as endorsing Biden and saying Asian Americans must be more American in face of discrimination.
- anpago 7y agoThere will be many Covid survivors with lung damage who once the air pollution starts to increase find they struggle badly. In fact many of us may struggle if as predicted levels dramatically and quickly increase as lockdowns are lifted. Plenty of us may also struggle with the noise pollution also. There will be a massive push for clean air and possibly a more quieter world.