7 ms·
West’s incompetent response to pandemic will hasten the power-shift to the east
- scoot_718 7y agoAnd what about China's incompetent response?
- monkeydreams 7y agoThat was mentioned in the article - it was described as disastrous, at least initially. Now? China has a firmer grasp on the problem of COVID-19 and are battling it on many fronts, including the geopolitical. Western governments (edit:those listed in the article such as the US and European powers), on the other hand, have been beset by decades of political parties attacking the legitimacy and foundations of the political system in order to score points against their rivals. This has led to a widespread unease and distrust among their voters, and a subsequent weakening of their governmental controls and regulations. I don't agree with all the points raised in this piece, and I suspect that this weakness of the West is part of a longer cycle. But, for now, there is some points raised in this article that we should ponder.
- rumanator 7y ago> China has a firmer grasp on the problem of COVID-19 Between covering up the fact that their death rate was a few orders of magnitude higher and deciding to intentionally leaving out infected but asymptomatic cases from their infection statistics while boasting that new cases occurred due to infected foreigners entering the country , it's patently obvious that the Chinese regime does not and never had a good grasp on the problem. And if that does not convince you, let's not forget that the Chinese regime's talking heads tried to pin the blame of their outbreak on Italy.
- vosper 7y ago> it's patently obvious that the Chinese regime does not and never had a good grasp on the problem. I think they had a good grasp on the problem, but the problem to them was (as it always is for China’s leadership) firstly about maintaining control, and at best secondarily about dealing with Covid.
- rumanator 7y agoBecoming aware of the true extent of their mess and having a good grasp on the problem are two entirely different things. Moreover, the only reason why China's covid19 outbreak threatened the Chinese regime's control over the population is because the Chinese regime failed to address the problem in a timely manner after intentionally turning a blind eye to the problem, and afterwards attacking it as a political threat instead of a public health crisis.
- furyg3 7y agoLet’s also not forget that it began there in the first place, and there is a serious probability that this particular disease could have been completely avoided in humans. People have been saying, for years, that the ‘wet markets’ of exotic animals are breeding grounds for inter-species diseases. The Chinese government did not listen to these complaints for many reasons, including the fact that ‘medicinal remedies’ made from exotic animals are a status symbol for upper-class Chinese.
- userulluipeste 7y ago"This has led to a widespread unease and distrust among their voters, and a subsequent weakening of their governmental controls and regulations." Yet, somehow, living in one of such "western" governed places, I don't feel that there is less governmental control than before. To give you two examples, I remember a time when digital fingerprinting of civilians was mandated only in a criminal context, but now one has to be fingerprinted just to get an ID (passport). Not long ago one could make easy anonymous calls (think of whistleblowing or whatnot). Not anymore, as the public phones aren't around any more and since not so long ago getting a cell phone number requires revealing one's identity. These may be anecdotal, but still.
- galaxyLogic 7y agoRight let us not forget that China tried to hide it all initially, attacking the whistle-blower. Such a thing as jailing whistle-blower happens more easily in autocracies than in democracies, one could assume. https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/03/19/818295972/chinese-authorities-admit-improper-response-to-coronavirus-whistleblower https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/0...
- thawaway1837 7y agoThe US, today, has a whole horde of influential people (including the President, probably) who are attacking Dr Fauci. At a time where the virus and its lethality is undeniable, and Fauci isn’t even just a random doctor, but probably one of the most decorated doctor in the past few decades.
- musicale 7y agoIt was a great shame when Dr. Fauci was imprisoned and forced to read a confession on Fox News, apologizing for disturbing the public order by correcting Trump.
- yostrovs 7y agoFauci has been a bureaucrat longer than most people on HN have been alive. And he's been in charge of a department of the US government that hasn't been responsible for anything before the current event. Perhaps he's being lionized a bit much.
- excalibur 7y agoIn the current administration, even a basic level of competence is remarkable and celebrated.
- 101404 7y agoDiscussing a topic controversially is just that, a discussion. When the Chinese government "attacks" somebody, that person disappears and often dies. Just wanting to remind people of the difference.
- squiggleblaz 7y agoMainland China lost a five thousand people and got less than 90 thousand infected without warning. Germany still receives praise for a "competent" response with so far the same number of dead and they're so far at more than 140 thousand infected. And that's one of the most praised responses in the West! China responded badly and recovered. West is still in an arrogant denial.
- sebwi 7y agoSo, you are confident that the numbers published by the Chinese government are accurate?
- Zenbit_UX 7y agoFYI China's numbers were fixed a few days ago, they were off but not by that much from the new total.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoChina's numbers were fixed in an incredibly suspicious way - their Wuhan death toll increased by exactly 50%. I don't think it's reasonable to believe the new numbers any more than the old ones.
- sebwi 7y agoYeah, that's what I'm thinking as well. I'm always amazed how careless people deal with statistics, particularly if these very statistics have poltical value to someone. While there are certainly naive people out there, most of the times it just seems like intentional misunderstanding to push a certain narrative.
- thawaway1837 7y agoChina’s incompetent response was at worse as bad as, say, the US, UK or the EU’s incompetent response at least a few months later when the scale and dangers of this virus were far more evident. Heck, in the US the President is still engaging in the kind of denialism and lies that we are calling China incompetent for because they engaged in it in the very beginning of the crisis, where the impact was not clear at all.
- vosper 7y ago> The crisis highlights the contrast between the competent responses of East Asian governments (notably China, South Korea and Singapore) and the incompetent responses of Western governments (such as Italy, Spain, France, Britain and America). The far lower death rates suffered by East Asian countries is a lesson to all. They reflect not just medical capabilities, but also the quality of governance and the cultural confidence of their societies. Ooh, can I do some cherry-picking, too? How about the incompetent response of the Japanese government, where it's gotten so bad that healthcare workers warned their healthcare system may collapse [0] Singapore's having their own Covid resurgence [1], related to those underpaid and exploited migrant workers, crammed into dormitories, which they'd like everyone to continue to pretend don't exist (in Singapore the streets clean themselves). In the Phillipines Duterte has used the pandemic to seize even more power for himself, heading in the direction of becoming a fully-fledged military dictator. [2] For Western governments, how about the lauded [3] response of New Zealand [4] and, perhaps to a lesser extent, Australia? This is an article that started with a thesis (China will use its power!), cherry-picks a tiny amount of supporting evidence to tie in with Covid (so topical right now), then wanders off down the well-trodden path of speculating about future Chinese influence (despite the initial mentions of Singapore and South Korea, this is article actually only about China) and the downfall of the West. [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-52336388 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-52336388 [1] https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/covid-19-new-cases-1426-foreign-workers-dormitory-citizen-pr-moh-12658250 https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/covid-19-new-... [2] https://edition.cnn.com/2020/04/20/opinions/duterte-covid-19-philippines-repression-hartung/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2020/04/20/opinions/duterte-covid-19... [3] https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/04/jacinda-ardern-new-zealand-leadership-coronavirus/610237/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/04/jacinda... [4] Disclosure: I'm a Kiwi, and think our government have done a reasonably good job responding to the pandemic. I also think foreign press lavishes far too much praise our on government and Prime Minister.
- ShorsHammer 7y agoNZ and Aus wasn't in flu season already, this has a big impact on outcomes, we got lucky in that respect with forewarning. Singapore's resurgence is pretty unavoidable, there's simply nowhere else for these foreign workers to go. Despite the case numbers deaths are remarkably low, basically all of these dorms are getting tested leading to resurgence in case numbers, it's tens of thousands of people. So despite all the socio-political criticisms in your post how about addressing the quoted comment? They are far lower death rates, it's undeniable. Singapore has had 11 deaths. Malaysia 90. South Korea and Japan ~230.
- aaron695 7y agoWhile Asia is hobbled by lockdowns for years the West has allowed it to go rampant and will just pop out the other end. Best case the West has also wiped out a generation of healthcare and pensions to pay. The West is also more nationalised than ever with a somewhat unified anti-China stance. The West has become more powerful relative to the East.
- netjiro 7y ago> Best case the West has also wiped out a generation of healthcare and pensions to pay. ? really? Are you actually proposing that killing off people when they retire is a good thing for society?
- indemnity 7y agoBut it is? Putting aside the morality. They’re no longer paying tax, they’ll free up housing when they go, and probably leave inheritances. We just can’t talk about it, but there are benefits to cleaning house.
- netjiro 7y agoDon't agree. Too simplistic. Even on the very narrow definition of some GDP-per-capita-like metric. Assume that one country decides to implement the 65y-killswitch. Everyone who possibly can will move to some other country. You just lost the vast majority of your skilled workers.
- squiggleblaz 7y agoHerd immunity from this coronavirus remains an unproven hypothesis, and most people claim it will only last 6-24 months. Is there any reason to believe we get can it through 60-80% of our society within 12 months? The death rate of people over 65 is still quite low. To say the West has wiped out a generation of healthcare and pensions is just incredible. Most of these retired people are still around. Wishful thinking.
- 7y ago
- Bayart 7y ago>Few will forget that in the same week that the Trump administration banned travel from Europe (without any advance notice), the Chinese government sent medical equipment including masks, ventilators, protective suits and doctors to Italy and Spain. This is why the Group of Seven countries resisted pressure by America to call covid-19 the “Wuhan virus” in a communique after a virtual meeting in March. No, we ignored Trump's spin because it's on the nose nonsense and we've got better things to do than turning everything into a tool for political gain. Nobody's blind regarding China's « help », and we'd rather do without.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aivisol 7y ago> Today the quality of governance in East Asia sets the global standard. The leaders who turned their countries around, such as Deng Xiaoping in China and Lee Kuan Yew in Singapore, planted the seeds of knowledge, internationalism and order in their societies. Am I reading The Economist or Pravda?
- perpetualpatzer 7y agoYou're reading the opinion section of The Economist, in which the featured opinion is that of outside contributor, Kishore Mabubani, a former Singoporean diplomat.
- indemnity 7y agoSingapore is probably going to have a worse time of it than most, in the post-globalisation future we’re hurtling towards.
- secfirstmd 7y agoWhere is the mention of Western countries that have manages it well like in New Zealand with Jacinda Ardern or Germany Angela Merkel?
- commandlinefan 7y ago"A policeman's job is only easy in a police state" -- Touch of Evil
- tradewarsonlyn 7y agoIs someone taking bets on whether this will happen? I would happily wager real $ against this wildly cultivated opinion. Autocratic, authoritarian regimes will never command global acceptance over democracy. I have that much belief in humanity.
- secfirstmd 7y agoI'm inclined to agree. There is a thesis, I think it's Samuel Huntington, that democracy moves in waves, two steps forward and one backwards. Right now we are in a backward phase from the perception of the West. Having said that I am fortunate enough to spend a lot of working with democracy activists in the rest of the world and my sense is that there is an ever increasing desire for that, just look at the small pockets of increasing hope in Asia and Africa.
- pasabagi 7y agoI'm also pretty optimistic about democracy. The problem with autocracies is that while any given dictator can be dynamic and capable, and the administration can work well for a while, autocratic regimes tend to stagnate because there are no checks and balances to stop corruption and nepotism. Also, democracy reduces the amount of violence necessary to keep a state going in tough times. While violence itself isn't a problem in strictly pragmatic terms, it does create a sort of moral malaise that leads to a dispirited, cynical and corrupt governmental culture, that ultimately leads to regime instability. People often forget that autocracy is what democracy replaced - and the autocracies were replaced not just because they were bad in a moral sense, but that they were also badly run, dysfunctional, and uncompetitive.
- foolzcrow 7y agoChina welded poor people in their homes and told black people to stay out of public all together. McDonalds had to apologize for having "no Africans allowed inside" signs at their locations in china. Very pathetic. New numbers show covid 0.1 death rate. ie a 99.9% survivability rate.