10 ms·
In part because all the headline numbers we've seen are CFR numbers which suffer from huge adverse selection bias -- and aren't directly comparable between regi
by arcticbull 7y ago
In part because all the headline numbers we've seen are CFR numbers which suffer from huge adverse selection bias -- and aren't directly comparable between regions for a lot of reasons.
As I've mentioned before, using CFR to determine fatality rate of the disease is like trying to determine the fatality rate of skydiving by measuring the ratio of people who go to hospital with skydiving injuries over those who recover. Obviously you'd think skydiving kills basically everyone who does it, but it just doesn't.
It's starting to become clear that the infection fatality rate of COVID is in the lower quartile of the range 0.25-1%.
And yeah, a huge portion of New York likely has it. It's super contagious.
- aero142 7y agoDefine "huge portion" because will still have to square this with the negative test data from NYC.
- joe_the_user 7y agoYeah, trying to do the basic math on the implications of these figures...[Not claiming they're true, that's a different question] The article says 221,000 infected at a 2.8% rate, in "early April". So they're assuming a 7,892,857 population. Currently, we have 601 Deaths total in LA[1], which we can assume are a result of early april event on April 20. So a 0.002% "fatality rate" relative to total exposures, "Woohoo" (NOTE, this is an optimistic figure implied by this study, the standard 2% [edited] previously claim but still not equivalent to the flu, which has 0.2% [edited] relative people who get sick). Now, with weekly doubling: 221,0008 = 1,768,000 infection now = 22.4% - > 4808 deaths. However, past 10%, we can ask whether we start reaching saturation/diminishing returns. But that is a key question. -- Let's look at NYC. There we have 14,500 Death. Using the article's implied figure, 14,500/ 0.002 = 7,250,000 infected on April 1, out of 8,398,748. So this implies an infection rate of 7,250,000/8,398,748 = 86.32239%, which, in fact, seems very implausible and which implies; a higher death rate among "vulnerable people". Maybe we're about to hit full saturation with NYC and see an immediate decline. Now, the other bad* scenario is the possibility that a lot of sickness and death NOW is being driven by reinfection, that exposure isn't giving much immunity at all and instead of the unexposed dying, what we're seeing is the re-exposed dying and with this dynamic, the death rate settle into a steady and unacceptably high level. Note that Italy, which has seen a high death rate, hasn't a strong drop-off at all, just gradual plateauing. IE, guess what, one possibility is "herd immunity" just doesn't exist for this virus. Anyway, time will tell, literally a week will tell if NYC has enough fatalities to make this 0.002 exposure-to-death rate numerically impossible. [1] covid-19.live Edit: corrected conversion ratio to percentages.
- zucker42 7y agoI think that number should be 0.2% (2 / 1000) and not 0.002% (2 / 100000).
- joe_the_user 7y agoYeah, 2% is the standard and more plausible in many ways than 0.002% [edit, WRONG ,missed a decimal point, should be 2% & .2%]. My comments above are about what this study implies, this something new. Italy has had 24114 deaths. If take those as being in Northern Italy with a 27,000,000 population, that's 0.8931 % of the entire population. Even adjusting for age, that can't squared with 0.002% death rate [wrong wrong, it's 0.08931%, which is possible but with a huge infection rate, which maybe].
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jsnell 7y agoI think you've misunderstood the comment by zucker52: your post is using 0.002 and 0.002% interchangably. It's quite hard to figure out what you mean when the numbers are off by two factors of magnitude in places. For example: > So a 0.002% "fatality rate" relative to total exposures, You appear to be deriving this from the computation 601/221000. That gives .27%, not 0.002%. > Italy has had 24114 deaths. If take those as being in Northern Italy with a 27,000,000 population, that's 0.8931% of the entire population No it's not. 1% of 27M is 270k, not 27k.
- joe_the_user 7y agoDamn, I am being sloppy, Yeah, 0.08931% of the population of Italy experienced fatality. If we assume .2% fatality rate, that implies 50% of the population was infected (which might make sense with an extremely contagious virus but that's more than even the cruise ships).
- 7y ago
- heartbreak 7y agoThere’s clearly a lot of false negatives produced by the PCR testing we’re doing nationwide.
- edoo 7y agoAccording to the New York data, the fatality rate is about 0.5% for tested persons without underlying conditions. Considering the gross selection bias it likely means actual death rates in the healthy population close to that of the flu. It is this data that shows the lockdowns were a complete illegal overreaction. Locking down nursing homes would have fixed most of it. https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/imm/covid-19-daily-data-summary-deaths-04172020-1.pdf https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/imm/covid-19-d...
- arcticbull 7y agoIllegal, no, but a massive overreaction. This is why the Swedish model (of telling people to take reasonable steps like not getting too close, and staying home when sick, and away from old people) is proving so successful. They've even started to see a flattening of the curve alongside the rest of the world without lockdowns. [1, 2] [1] https://fee.org/articles/sweden-s-top-epidemiologist-covid-19-infections-flattening-under-policy-of-individual-responsibility/ https://fee.org/articles/sweden-s-top-epidemiologist-covid-1... [2] https://aatishb.com/covidtrends/?location=Canada&location=Sweden&location=US&location=United+Kingdom https://aatishb.com/covidtrends/?location=Canada&location=Sw...
- edoo 7y agoQuarantining the sick is legal but otherwise the freedom of assembly clause in the 1st amendment does not say "except when there is a pandemic or other fear". If you don't believe that should be the law fine, but since it is law and is incorporated to the states via the 14th amendment it qualifies as illegal.
- bobthepanda 7y agoNot quite; you'd have to drag this through court to get any sort of legal determination on it.
- asdf21 7y agoAnd I think they would just say it was "reasonable" given the information known at the time.
- jsinai 7y agoWhat is CFR?
- arcticbull 7y ago"In epidemiology, a case fatality rate (CFR) — sometimes called case fatality risk — is the proportion of deaths from a certain disease compared to the total number of people diagnosed with the disease for a certain period of time." As compared to the IFR: "The term infection fatality rate (IFR) also applies to infectious disease outbreaks, and represents the proportion of deaths among all the infected individuals. It is closely related to the CFR, but attempts to additionally account for all asymptomatic and undiagnosed infections." [1] One's the risk that given you show up at a hospital, you die. The other is the risk given that you get infected, you die. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Case_fatality_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Case_fatality_rate
- nickff 7y agoCase Fatality Rate; the rate of people who are confirmed to have COVID-19, and die. The problem is that the people most likely to be tested are those in the worst condition.