5 ms·
Maybe I'm not understanding something but why do they consider paying dividends as something bad? They are essentially excluding the majority of businesses usin
by Nextgrid 7y ago
Maybe I'm not understanding something but why do they consider paying dividends as something bad? They are essentially excluding the majority of businesses using this criteria.
- Angostura 7y agoThe rationale would be that they would expect tax payers to be paid back, ahead of shareholders.
- peterwoerner 7y agoIf they have excess cash to pay a dividend, why do they need a bailout?
- ucosty 7y agoIf a company can still afford to pay out dividends it probably isn't really in need of aid.
- elric 7y agoIt's probably a bit more nuanced than that. Dividends are often scheduled months in advance, based on (for instance) last year's profits. Having made a profit last year, and having promised a dividend months before corona doesn't mean you won't be struggling now.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoIs the promise of dividends binding? I don’t think so.
- brewdad 7y agoTo my knowledge, it isn't. There is a date of ownership where the dividend eligibility is determined and then it is paid out a few weeks later. I would imagine those payouts are binding but a planned dividend for June could easily be rescinded without legal penalty. However it is priced into the value of the stock. Slashing dividends will tank the stock price. C'est la vie.
- nradov 7y agoEliminating a planned future dividend by itself would have no effect on the stock price. What would affect the stock price is the management explanation that comes along with cancelling the dividend. If they say that profits will drop even more than analysts had expected, then that would tend to cause a share price decline as it would be new information to the market. Stock prices usually drop after a dividend is payed out because each share now represents a claim on fewer assets.
- anonymousDan 7y agoIt's not. The stock price will likely take a hit, but such is life.
- benburleson 7y agoSo, the business then has the choice to use last year's profits to keep the business afloat or pay investors. Seems like an easy choice unless your only motivation is lining investor pockets.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> lining investor pockets Investors are often normal people like you and me, using dividends and the sale of shares to put food on their families' tables.
- elric 7y agoIndeed. The fallacy that all investors are all fat cats, swimming in money is pretty galling. When interest rates on savings accounts dropped, many regular folks took some of their savings and put into dividend paying companies. I'm sure most of them are aware that this is an investment and isn't without risk. I'm certainly not advocating for companies to pay out dividends no matter what. But the lack of nuance bothers me. Not all dividend paying companies are greedy, and not all dividend investors are wealthy.
- calcifer 7y agoI've never once met a person who would otherwise go hungry if they didn't get dividends, have you? What you really mean is those "normal people" would have to sell their third car or maybe rent out their summer home without that dividend, which is just fine by me.
- 1123581321 7y agoI know a bunch of retirees who live modestly off of dividend income, couldn’t afford a significant cut and couldn’t easily return to work. I don’t think you have broad enough experience to assume no one earns a few thousand a month from dividends and needs most of it to help pay bills.
- strictnein 7y agoA semi-common retirement setup is to buy relatively stable stocks that have good dividends and supply you with a 4-6% annual return.
- KillerDiller 7y agoIt's actually way simpler than that: the owners of a company facing crisis have the choice between providing it with additional liquidity or putting its future (and thus their stake) at risk. This is the one core manifestation of the risk they are bearing, and for which they allegedly deserve the dividends in the first place. Getting a dividend for last year's performance is the opposite of providing liquidity. If they get the cash because it was scheduled, they need to immediately put it back. If they take the cash and run, they failed to act in their own interest, and do not deserve to have their investment protected.
- chrisseaton 7y agoPaying a dividend is paying a person. It's like you're saying that 'as long as they can afford to keep paying employees' they don't need aid. Would you rather they stopped paying people but didn't take aid? The whole point of the aid is so they can keep going and keep paying people.
- throwaway2048 7y agoReturn from investment is nothing like salary.
- chrisseaton 7y agoMany workers are paid a majority of their income in the form of stock from the company they work for.
- Agathos 7y agoSuing your employer for wage theft because 1. They are still paying your salary, and 2. They are still granting you stock, but 3. They have suspended dividends on the shares you were granted seems like a reach. I'd definitely be interested in reading about it if someone actually tries it, though!
- chrisseaton 7y agoNot sure who you're replying to. I didn't mention suing anyone or any idea of wage theft.
- Agathos 7y agoYou suggested paying a dividend was similar to paying employees. When throwaway2048 challenged this, you brought up stock-based compensation. Surely if such compensation (including dividends) was an obligation in the same way as wages, then the employee would have some recourse when it's interrupted. In other words, they could sue.
- _se 7y agoNo, they are not. The vast majority of companies do not pay dividends.
- rsync 7y agoYou are correct that the vast majority of publicly traded companies do not pay dividends. However, that is a small minority of all firms and I hope you will find it interesting to learn that many, many small firms' owners (Doctors offices, car dealers, liquor stores, carwashes, etc.) take regular compensation in the form of dividends. Further, I will point that in the United States, if you are an "S Corp" (and millions are) you cannot, for the most part, carry over liquid cash from one year to the next. You are forced to distribute any leftover cash, typically in the form of distributions to owners (dividends). That being said, receiving state aid on condition of suspending dividend payments makes very good sense and is the first condition I would add to such aid - you shouldn't need state aid if you are distributing profits.
- mikorym 7y agoWhy do a majority of publicly traded companies not pay dividends? I've noticed before that for many companies by identifier (ISIN, SEDOL, CUSIP, take your pick) that there are no dividend histories. The only example that I know the reason why is Amazon. [If you buy Amazon stock you either 1) expect dividends at some later stage or 2) plan on selling the stock for a higher price.]
- wingspar 7y agoSome companies 'reinvest' profits in their operations and don't pay dividends. Others avoid dividends, as dividends are profits that are taxed twice. (Once for corporate income taxes, and again for individual income taxes.) Selling the stock for a higher price has opportunity for favorable tax treatment at the lower long-term capital gains vs dividends taxes as regular income.
- vonmoltke 7y ago
- Ididntdothis 7y agoIf they have the money to pay out dividends then they shouldn’t need bailouts.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- FartyMcFarter 7y agoI guess it depends on whether that restriction is for past dividends or ones after the crisis has started? I certainly don't think it would be appropriate to bail out a company that's throwing money out the window unnecessarily.
- DCKing 7y agoThese measures don't imply that paying out dividends is "bad" at all?
- tsbinz 7y agoYou pay out dividends or buy back shares if you have surplus cash, and it's hard to convey to voters that businesses with surplus cash need help I guess.
- formercoder 7y agoNot sure if these are loans or grants or exactly how it works, but I could see prohibiting dividends for some period after the aid. Firms should not be making distributions when they are receiving aid. But prohibiting any firm that has paid dividends is insane.
- nokicky 7y agoThe thinking goes: A business should have enough cash to weather a storm. If you've paid out cash you have more than enough to weather a storm (and therefore don't need money). If you need money and have paid out dividends than you shouldn't have, you didn't have enough cash reserve.
- rsync 7y agoNo, that's not the thinking at all. As your sibling points out: "The article does a bad job at explaining it, but companies that take aid cannot pay dividends or buy back stock until they return the aid." So it has nothing to do with historical dividend payments - you just can't pay dividends while receiving the state aid.
- JoshTriplett 7y agoThe implication is that companies should not be using the aid money to pay dividends or buy back stock, because the aid is intended to help pay employees or otherwise remain operational, not to pass through to stockholders. The article doesn't make clear whether they're using past behavior (what they did with previous government aid), present behavior (are they currently a public company established as paying dividends), or future behavior (an agreement not to pay dividends or buy back stock, in order to receive aid).
- tartrate 7y agoPerhaps the aids are to prevent insolvency, and perhaps dividends are illegal during insolvency. Not being sarcastic, I genuinely don't know.
- kilo_bravo_3 7y agoThere's a lot of misinformation about this out there. The article does a bad job at explaining it, but companies that take aid cannot pay dividends or buy back stock until they return the aid. This is so that aid is not redirected into the pockets of shareholders and is instead used to keep people employed. >The Government and all parties to the Parliament agree that the extended and extended fixed cost scheme introduces a condition in the Compensation Orders that applicants, as a condition of receiving compensation for the extended period, must declare by faith and laws, that the companies will not pay dividends or buy back shares for the financial years 2020 and 2021. The condition will apply to companies that receive more than DKK 60 million. in compensation in 2020 in the compensation scheme for fixed costs. Companies will later be able to free themselves from these restrictions by repaying paid aid under this scheme in excess of DKK 60 million. Translated from: https://www.fm.dk/nyheder/pressemeddelelser/2020/04/regeringen-og-alle-folketingets-partier-er-enige-om-at-justere-og-udvide-hjaelpepakker-til-dansk-oekonomi https://www.fm.dk/nyheder/pressemeddelelser/2020/04/regering... DKK 60 million is about 8.8 million dollars. If you have money to pay dividends, you have money to pay back your government aid.
- londons_explore 7y agoSo why don't these conditions apply to all the aid, not just the aid after 8.8 million dollars? Otherwise it seems ripe for my company to claim 7 million dollars of aid as unsecured loans, then pay out nice big dividends claiming you are in a strong financial position because you are forecasting lots of business next year, then in 2 years time when the loan repayments become due, go bankrupt.
- freeone3000 7y agoBecause most companies want to exist longer than two years.
- nerdponx 7y agoBankruptcy does not mean the company dissolves.
- thisiswarry 7y agothe market is supposed to understand risks.
- nabla9 7y agoDept payments before dividends is just a one way for a lender to secure their loans in limited companies. It counters "Heads I win, Tails you lose" -strategy where the risk of business is offloaded to lenders while owners take profits. It's common tactic in distressed companies to load the company them with debt and suck the firm try with huge dividends. Lenders are left with nothing when the company goes bankrupt.
- virvar 7y agoI’m Danish so I can chip in who this is targeted at. A few of our larger corporations like Danske Bank (the one from the money laundering scandals) aimed at paying out its stock owners 8,50dkr per share while simultaneously planning to fire hundreds of employees to pay for their mishaps and Covid problems. Other companies that are less evil planned similar things. Now Danske Bank is planning on using those money to secure their business going forward, and we expect some companies to follow this route. Others will go a head with their firings, like Vestas, to make sure share holders get richer. Now this is not something we actually want in Denmark. I know it’s capitalism, but our most recent election results showed a record support of our social democracy. We’ve never had less support for liberalism (which is our branch of capitalism) than we do now since the end of WW2. So we value people keeping their jobs above shareholders making money. I personally think we should be even tougher on taxing the rich. If we know companies sit in tax-havens then we should really do something about that, shouldn’t we
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- boublepop 7y agoIf a company goes “Omg, we won’t make it this year, we need 2 billions in aid just to keep going with business as usual, not even takeing our normal 10% growth into account!?” then the government will still not pay a dime to that company if their “business as usual” includes 15 billion buy backs. The point is that companies need to take the hit on their owners and shareholders pockets first, and only then if they still need aid to survive, then the government steps in. It’s aiming to protect the bottom, not the top.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI think of it more as somebody trying to hold a raft together, spread-eagled on the deck hanging onto the mast, the tiller, the log decking, hoping the storm passes and it all hasn't broken up yet.
- ajross 7y agoDividends are, literally, the profits you're distributing to your owners. Buybacks, likewise, are giving corporate money directly to your owners (who then divest from the company in the process, of course). This isn't "bad", it's fine. It's the basic idea of how the stock market is supposed to work, we buy shares in companies we think will make money. But by definition if you have cash to distribute to your owners, you could be using that to pay salaries instead and delay or avoid layoffs and furloughs. So it's very reasonable that a government bailout policy designed to prevent job losses (and not to shore up shareholder value) would incentivize giving money to the people who are targetted and not shareholders.
- Agathos 7y agoIt sounds like you may be assuming the dividend is required, like a debt. It isn't. A company can stop paying its dividend at any time, so Denmark isn't excluding any company. Investors will grumble when the dividend stops, but so what? The taxpayers are grumbling too. Of course some banks have recently argued that their dividends are something like debts. They argue that cutting the dividend would cause investors to panic, so they must be essential to the financial system. This is a weird argument, but if you took it seriously you would have to include dividends in their post-2008 stress tests. You would require regulatory approval before they increased the dividend, as you would if they increased their debt-to-asset ratio. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-04-06/a-virtual-internship-just-isn-t-the-same https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-04-06/a-virt...
- BurningFrog 7y agoThis is only about future behavior. If you paid dividends up to last week doesn't matter. They don't want to pay out aid to companies that then just hand the aid money out to investors.