4 ms·
I worry that the modern definition of "astroturfing" is so broad that it can be applied to any kind of large-scale organizing. It shouldn't be surprising to dis
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I worry that the modern definition of "astroturfing" is so broad that it can be applied to any kind of large-scale organizing. It shouldn't be surprising to discover that the anti-shutdown movements in various states have ties with each other and with anti-shutdown politicians.
- baxtr 7y agoThis and that they literally started over night. Since the lockdown is new I find this reasonable.
- grey-area 7y agoThe original link above is saying that there was a website for every state started at the same time by the same person (by looking at whois info): https://www.reddit.com/r/maryland/comments/g3niq3/i_simply_cannot_believe_that_people_are/fnstpyl/ https://www.reddit.com/r/maryland/comments/g3niq3/i_simply_c... Many of these so-called grassroots movements are not spontaneous.
- makomk 7y agoThere was a claim going around that those were actually registered by someone who opposed this movement to stop supporters from registering the names. Which is, of course, the trouble with claims of "astroturfing" - anyone can spot a movement in its early moments and take actions like registering domain names.
- takeda 7y agoAstroturfing is actually appropriate. The movement pretends to be grassroots. This looks like it was organized in multiple states (possibly even countries) by the same organization, that's not grassroots.
- scollet 7y agoI would take it at face value for now. I think astroturfing can be emmergent and dangerous regardless of political execution or oversight.
- ashtonkem 7y agoAstroturfing by its definition cannot be emergent behavior. If it’s emergent, then it’s grass roots and not astroturfing.
- scollet 7y agoYou are right. I suppose I am too loose with my understanding of action as a byproduct of external influence versus direct sponsorship. As an example, the former would be a vague cultural sublimation of influence from a position of power, and the latter would be an immediate demand from a position of power.
- koheripbal 7y agoI would say almost all modern protests are like that - driven by specific politicians and their media colleagues.
- take_a_breath 7y agoBased on what evidence?
- jeffdavis 7y agoIt's kind of a grey area and debatable. A group of people starts protesting on a small scale, and then quickly gets a lot of professional and political help, along with a lot of attention from media that wants to push a narrative.
- carapace 7y agoBased on what evidence?
- jeffdavis 7y agoMy point was that, for something that is fairly grey such as the coordination versus spontaneity of protesters, you're not going to get solid evidence. Any disinterested search for truth here would involve reams of original-source facts. This is probably not the right forum for that. FWIW I did not make the claim for which you are requesting evidence. I just don't think asking for evidence in this case will be very fruitful.
- carapace 7y agoFair enough.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThere is a distinction between “having ties” and “all the domains were registered in very short order, and the signs have similar typography”
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI'm not sure I agree. Consider the example of BLM. You can tell two equally true stories: * Black Lives Matter was a grassroots movement, where a bunch of individual people across the country organically discovered the #BlackLivesMatter hashtag and felt it summarized their thoughts on current events. * Black Lives Matter was a organized effort by Alicia Garza, Patrisse Cullors, and Opal Tometi to drum up public support for their preferred economic and social policies. They learned how to do this at BOLD, a little-known organization teaching people how to shape the public's anger in ways that serve their political goals.
- notacoward 7y ago"Ties to each other" is one thing. The same person registering all the domains within minutes of one another, and populating them with cut-and-pasted content, is quite another.