8 ms·
How do we KNOW it's controlled? Asymptomatic people are not, as a rule, tested, so actual infection rates could be massive.
by TylerE 7y ago
How do we KNOW it's controlled? Asymptomatic people are not, as a rule, tested, so actual infection rates could be massive.
- dboreham 7y agoBy lack of a pile of bodies.
- grandmczeb 7y agoIf there’s a lot of uncounted asymptotic cases the IFR is correspondingly lower.
- vkou 7y agoOnly 25% of the positive-cases on the Diamond princess turned out to be asymptomatic after 4 weeks. The much-higher, 50% numbers that were being thrown around were obviously overestimated - precisely because it takes a week or two or three for some people to start showing symptoms. As such, it's incredibly unlikely that the # of real cases is some large multiplier of the number of confirmed cases in any areas that are regularly testing people with flu-like symptoms.
- grandmczeb 7y ago> Only 25% of the positive-cases on the Diamond princess turned out to be asymptomatic after 4 weeks. Are you referring to [1]? As far as I know that's the only follow up, but your summary doesn't match their results. [1] https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2020.25.10.2000180 https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.E...
- easytiger 7y ago> As such, it's incredibly unlikely that the # of real cases is some large multiplier of the number of confirmed cases in any areas that are regularly testing people with flu-like symptoms. For example?
- analog31 7y agoI think that the reported numbers of deaths place some bounds on the kinds of hypotheses that are tenable, including those suggesting that there is already a protective level of herd immunity, or a vanishingly small death rate. For instance, one early hypothesis was that the virus was endemic in our population for a long time, but that doesn't explain why the death rate shot up suddenly over the past month. And 15000 people dying per week could not have escaped notice, even a month ago. Many of those hypotheses coincided with claims that the lockdown was unnecessary or excessive.
- aaron_m04 7y ago> Many of those hypotheses coincided with claims that the lockdown was unnecessary or excessive. This is it. The (short-term) financial incentives to opening up the economy are _massive_. Anyone trying to support that will jump all over some weakly supported hypothesis like this.
- concordDance 7y agoAs are the social incentives for those of us who are lonely and bored. A hypothetical young healthy man might be quite happy to accept 0.37% of people dying (the vast majority of whom are old and/or near death any way) if it means he doesn't have to put his life on hold for a year and can start dating again. Young males routinely take much higher risks for mating opportunities. I'm honestly surprised at the level of compliance so far, but I doubt it will last.
- aaron_m04 7y agoTrue, and that 0.37% number is probably the number with adequate hospital resources. If everyone caught this at once, there will be triaging of patients and the overall mortality rate would be higher.
- scott_s 7y agoBecause their hospitals are not overwhelmed beyond capacity despite having positive cases just as long as other places.
- henrikschroder 7y agoNo country except Iceland or South Korea knows how many are infected, everyone else's numbers are horribly wrong. But death numbers and hospitalization numbers don't lie. Sure, different countries are counting deaths differently, making it hard to compare them to each other, but the trajectories don't lie. And if you look at growth trajectories, no country is experiencing uncontrolled exponential growth at this point: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/covid-daily-deaths-trajectory-per-million?country=BEL+DNK+FRA+ISL+ITA+NOR+SWE+GBR+USA https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/covid-daily-deaths-trajec... If deaths are on a downward trajectory, it means that infections have been on a downward trajectory for weeks. And that's how we can know that it's controlled, without knowing how many have it or have had it, while being asymptomatic.
- wbl 7y agoThe timeline matches aggressive control measures that reduced infection.
- tapland 7y ago> but the trajectories don't lie Except for when they do. Easter just passed and the the trajectories are plotted up to and including today, when Sweden for example is adding deaths to dates two weeks back every day, and the last 5-7 days _ALWAYS_ looks like a downward trajectory. The last little spike there from before easter has grown by 35% since after easter and is still growing daily. You can't draw conclusions based on the trajectory of the last few days when an absolute majority of cases are added days, and up to weeks after.
- henrikschroder 7y agoSure, but in that chart Italy for example has had a declining graph for over two weeks, which means you can be reasonably sure it's not growing exponentially there. And in Sweden's case, if you also look at the number of ICU admissions, they've been flat for weeks, and those numbers have very little lag. I'm not saying everything is fine, I'm not saying we're over the peak, but I am saying that it's not the case that any country is experiencing uncontrolled exponential growth and is going to turn into a zombie wasteland in a couple of days.
- bosie 7y agoBy testing 100% of a city and realising that neither the current infectio rate is high nor a large number of people with antibodies is found?
- maxerickson 7y agoThere's like 5 or 6 data points that all point at the infection rates being reasonably close to the published estimates. (Veneto, Gangelt, Telluride, Iceland, the Diamond Princess, the Theodore Roosevelt)
- coliveira 7y agoYou can only know after a few weeks from death numbers.
- ck2 7y agoThere's a hospital that was testing all women coming in for pregnancies regardless of symptoms and they found a huge number had it. We really need a cheap and easy test. Probably won't happen for many months. So far only endless promises and lies.
- hcknwscommenter 7y agoCitation needed.
- NamTaf 7y agoI don't agree with that. If you look at how many negative results are returned, that is a good indicator of whether you're sufficiently testing. For example, the average here in Australia is that 1.7% of tests yield positive cases. That suggests that you're probably testing enough, especially considering if people are self-selecting to be tested when they think they have symptoms. In that case, you'd expect there to be minimal additional asymptomatic cases, or you'd be catching them in the negatives. Compare that to some states in the US, where it's a full 30% positive rate, and it's obvious the testing there isn't sufficient.
- mkl 7y ago> people are self-selecting to be tested when they think they have symptoms. In that case, you'd expect there to be minimal additional asymptomatic cases, or you'd be catching them in the negatives. How does that follow? The asymptomatic people won't self-select to be tested.
- steveeq1 7y agoIf that were true, then we'll have herd immunity in a month.