8 ms·
As per the title, I don’t think now is comparable to 2009. In 2009, the economy collapsed because of bad loans. In 2020, the economy is shutting down because
by refurb 7y ago
As per the title, I don’t think now is comparable to 2009.
In 2009, the economy collapsed because of bad loans. In 2020, the economy is shutting down because we shut it down.
That’s said, our shutdown could certainly snowball into serious issues with the economy where the pre-existing economic activity doesn’t come back.
- dmix 7y agoThis also shouldn't be treated as a signal for a market correction, for ex: from 'bad' behaviour in the marketplace, and making the subsequent moral hazards that were abundant in the various bailouts of the post-2008 crisis less likely (depending on your tolerance for 'rainy day' funds I guess, which for most small/medium-businesses is pretty unrealistic beyond a 2 months lockdown IMO, larger firms slightly less so). I'm curious how this will influence economic research on the matter, possibly providing greater insight into 'force majeure' scenarios instead of merely propping companies and executives who helped cause the crisis in an effort to offset even worse consequences.
- empath75 7y agoA lot of loans are about to go bad because we shut the economy down. Do you think people are going to be keeping up with car payments and student loan payments and credit card payments?
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoThe economy was showing cracks before the shutdown happened. Now it's also due to bad loans but not for housing like in 2009 but corporate debt(stock buybacks anyone?) but it's just easier for the economists and politicians to point fingers at a new enemy without a face than to accept that the economy boon was a bubble. The Coronavirus shutdown was bad timing but it's not the main culprit, it just accelerated the inevitable bubble burst.
- fallingfrog 7y agoExactly! And now they’re going to reinflate the bubble and make the problem worse instead of the deleveraging, wealth redistribution, and regulation that we need to move forward.
- chrissnell 7y agoI am quite confident that it will come back. Demand is there. My dad owns a chain of bicycle stores. Sales have been absolutely through the roof during quarantine (they are "essential"). Like, blowing-away-previous-sales-records good. His customers represent all walks of life in the city he serves. He has stores in the wealthy areas and stores in the poorer areas; all are doing well. People want to spend money and they are desperate for places to do it. I predict that we will see a retail boom if we can find a way to reopen the economy and still be safe (masks everywhere, distancing). The trick is figuring out that safety. It starts with PPE and cleaning commodities. We need universal availability of good face masks, hand sanitizer, and effective cleaning wipes. We need to flood the world with so many masks that you get one for free every time you walk into a store. Figure that out soon and this economy will rebound.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoI think it's way too early to see the negative effects. Wait a few months then let's see how bike sales go.
- save_ferris 7y agoWe’re already seeing record lines at food banks across the country[0], and some are already warning of food shortages. We’re already seeing the negative effects, our society just doesn’t want to pay attention to what’s happening to the poor. We’re at serious risk for community starvation not seen since the Great Depression. 0: https://www.motherjones.com/food/2020/04/these-photos-show-the-staggering-food-bank-lines-across-america/ https://www.motherjones.com/food/2020/04/these-photos-show-t...
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoFood banks are stressed right now, but I'd bet they can hold out for the month or two it's expected to take to get (mostly) everyone back to work.
- 7y ago
- pmorici 7y agoThere were troubles in the debt markets brewing before this whole virus thing happened. I don't think every thing that is happening in financial markets and the economy is because of the virus. It will be blamed but it was merely the trigger for a trap that was already set in some sense.
- pbourke 7y agoYeah the yield curve was inverting and repo market freezing up months before the coronavirus crisis
- beforesnstblvd 7y agoThe US never 'recovered' from the 2008 crisis, we just printed money and used it to pay those 'bad loans'. That bad money is still in the economy, and since the loaning didn't stop, there are even more bad loans now. That is the reason for this crisis, it is why not even one week after the virus started hitting the US everyone was asking for a bailout. People and Companies have no savings, they live paycheck to paycheck, loan to loan. This crisis is way worse because the loans are way worse and involve everybody.
- adrr 7y agoThere's the looming CLO debt crisis that just got accelerated. That will be bigger that the CDO crisis in 2009. Corporate debt is 50% of GDP, the highest it's ever been.
- burrows 7y ago> In 2020, the economy is shutting down because we shut it down. “We” didn’t shut the economy down. Governments used (threats of) violence to shut it down.
- seppin 7y agoIf you are referring to the US shutdown, there are no punishments or even fines currently for violating shelter in place orders. If you're just seeking to contextualize this in some libertarian dystopian manner, move on.
- Leherenn 7y agoSweden, which has pretty much no lockdown to speak of, is expecting a massive drop (-4.2%) in GDP this year. https://www.government.se/497453/globalassets/government/dokument/finansdepartementet/pdf/varbudget-2020/key-indicators-forecast-15-april-2020.pdf https://www.government.se/497453/globalassets/government/dok... I think this is comparable with economies with a lockdown. The economy was going to be shut one way or another.
- fidelramos 7y agoEven countries with no lockdown will see their exports hurt, damaging their economies.
- _delirium 7y agoDomestic demand as well. Sweden hasn't formally closed wide ranges of things, but many Swedes have chosen to avoid them anyway. For example, restaurants are open, but their business is way down.
- burrows 7y ago> The economy was going to be shut one way or another. That might be true. But there is an ethical difference between choosing to sleep at 9pm and an 8.30pm government enforced Ambien.
- nostromo 7y ago> In 2009, the economy collapsed because of bad loans. There are a lot of credit defaults coming if quarantine doesn't end very soon. The crunch could make 08 look mild.
- greedo 7y agoThis is an incorrect way of looking at it. The quarantine isn't the proximal cause of the economic problems, the virus is. If we didn't do any of the social distancing, group limits and shutdowns, if we had just pretended like the virus was a flu that will disappear, then the economy would still have been devastated. People dying en masse have a tendency to make people stay home.
- james_s_tayler 7y agoFrom a systems point of view of "stocks and flows" the problem is we didn't shut it down. We shut _part_ of it down. For example rents are still due. So money is flowing out of business and individuals stock and for those affected by layoffs or paycuts there isn't any flowing back in to replace it. This is the really problematic part that creates trouble for people. That creates it's own knock-on effects.
- DSingularity 7y agoDo you really think this president will issue a moratorium on rent?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wyre 7y agoI dont think anyone thinks hes going to
- pen2l 7y agoIgnoring whether or not he will, what might be the mechanics of something like this? Is there any precedent of this in history? What’s a good way in which this might take place?
- _delirium 7y agoA lot of states have de-facto made it optional to pay your rent (and in some cases mortgages), by banning evictions, banning foreclosures, etc. Mine has also banned any late fees during the state of emergency, so there is really no penalty to just not paying the rent. You still accumulate it of course, and at some point after the emergency ends, everyone is supposed to pay up the back months of rents and mortgages they owe, or face reopened eviction/foreclosure processes. That's where it gets dicey, to see who is left holding which bags. Non-zero chance of at least some cascade: if a bunch of your tenants never pay 3 months of back rent (b/c they have no jobs), and you were already a very leveraged landlord without much of a cash cushion, you're not going to be making your 3 months of back mortgage payments either, etc. Less leveraged landlords will just eat some losses. If the economy recovers quickly, maybe some of this will be papered over by repayment plans (you can pay your 3 months of back rent/mortgage over the next 12 months or something, and nobody has to admit any official losses). How big all of these categories are will make a pretty big difference to whether it cascades into foreclosure waves, banks with junk loan problems, etc.
- grey-area 7y agoThe 2009 crisis started in 2007, lasted a few years till 2010 or so and was mild compared to the effects of a complete global shutdown. There were signs of problems in 2019 (yield curve inversion, failed IPOs, US QE restart), and this will take years to work out. The US stock market is currently priced as if this will be over in 1 month and everyone/everything will bounce back. Unfortunately if it goes on a few weeks more (which looks likely) the economic impacts are going to last years and no sector of the economy will be untouched.
- jayd16 7y agoI'm not sure its useful to phrase it as "we shut it down." It implies that we had a choice and because it was a choice we can turn it back on at will. We could social distance and slow GDP or we could get sick, lose lives and still slow GDP. This isn't a self inflicted wound and we won't bounce back as quickly as we shut down.
- tarsinge 7y agoMy understanding is that it has already snowballed for a lot a small businesses, and I'm not sure loans to certains industries are saner, without even talking about the government debt of some countries.
- fallingfrog 7y agoThe Coronavirus was just the trigger for the corporate debt bubble to pop. Why do you think the fed is printing trillions of dollars and using it to buy junk bonds?