4 ms·
The ridiculous thing is that nobody would have batted an eye if they did this with Green/Blue drives, especially if they just owned it upfront. I still don't pa
by mindslight 7y ago
The ridiculous thing is that nobody would have batted an eye if they did this with Green/Blue drives, especially if they just owned it upfront. I still don't particularly get the difference between Red/Green, or even Red/Blue for that matter, apart from opaque firmware tweaks about power saving, and some hand waving about chassis vibration. SMR/PMR would have been an obvious partition.
I still can't fathom how companies can be so oblivious about their actual customer market. People speccing individual hard drives are integrating their own systems and want to care about the details, not just some colorful indicator of "good/better/best".
- ethbro 7y agoYou're talking about an industry that has no problem shipping known-unreliable drives for decades at a time. They likely rebate / warranty their important hyperscale cloud, enterprise, & OEM customers. According to whatever custom contract they've negotiated. And don't really care about the retail segment, given the margins. Most people probably won't notice. And those that do won't be able to do anything.
- mindslight 7y agoThey apparently still care enough to create all those Red/Green/Black/Blue/Purple/Gold lines. Even if those are really just a few different #defines and different ink in the label printer, they're still additional SKUs. Also the margins seem plenty high given you can shuck 8TB Easystores for $130, with the retail version at ~$200. And yeah individuals can never really do anything in the short term. Eventually there will be a suite of best practices to test a new drive to make sure it's not SMR, and likely some tweaks to filesystems to ratelimit rebuilds, based on knowing which drives are actually SMR. But they're arbitraging away brand loyalty to WD Red, for a short gain. Given the goodwill they enjoy(ed) from that Blackblaze study creating a refrain of "don't buy Seagate", this just seems foolish.
- sitkack 7y agoNo file system should be doing random writes, and when you have a cluster, there is always an open stream you can append to. I agree this is a bogus move, but tech with analogous limitations but also similar enhancements will make it into more things. If risk and failure were spread more evenly, systems would behave more like gas and less like a ceramic.
- tracker1 7y agoYou expect a networked file system accessed by multiple users to not have random writes?
- sitkack 7y agoFor some value of expect, yes.
- wtallis 7y ago> No file system should be doing random writes, A typical size for a SMR zone is 256MB, and any writes that aren't appending sequentially to what's already been written to that zone count as "random writes" on a SMR drive. That's an absolutely massive block size to expect filesystems to work around, and I doubt there are any commonly used filesystems that can store their metadata in a SMR-friendly way.
- sitkack 7y agoMetadata belongs in persistent storage (PMEM or flash), file contents can striped onto a magnetic disk. Flash suffers from the same problem. Rewriting a file should be appending binary diffs to a log and reapply the writes against the first version into a new location on the cluster. SMR is extremely painful for anyone except those that can handle distributed storage systems. I think the only place where SMR makes sense for home users is in a DVR, or game assets where a virtual disk is streamed down from a cloud provider in a single pass, and no interior mutations.
- wtallis 7y ago
- ethbro 7y agoThe product lines were driven by the fact that margins were low: attempting to decommodify via artificial use segmentation. Shucking has always had weird economics. I think mostly because it's used by the manufacturers as a release-value for excess capacity, in an attempt to somewhat avoid the memory chip boom-bust cycle.
- novok 7y agoI though the red drives had more physical vibration dampening (rubber?) than the other ones.