12 ms·
I wish I could leave. The tech industry nowadays is no longer about solving real-world problems and making the world a better place, instead it's all about scr
by Nextgrid 7y ago
I wish I could leave.
The tech industry nowadays is no longer about solving real-world problems and making the world a better place, instead it's all about screwing the end user in every single way possible, whether it's ads, stalking and privacy violations, spam ("marketing" as they call it) or just plain fraud where the company is happy to take the money but can't make it right if things don't go to plan and the customer is left holding the bag.
Most tech products nowadays aren't there to solve a real problem and aren't funded by customers buying them because they are good; instead they're funded by some VC scum and they're there to capture the market (or rent-seek) and prevent a legitimate business from starting (nobody can compete with free or below cost).
Technology-wise, we no longer use engineering as a means to an end to solve a business problem. Instead, engineering became its own thing and most companies encourage and reward those who opt for over-engineered solutions, which means you spend more time fighting with dozens of layers of abstractions and chasing the latest JS framework instead of actually delivering functionality. This is mostly a symptom of the previous point where showing "growth" and bragging about your (over) engineering is more important than actual profit.
Unfortunately there's just nothing out there that pays as well so I have no choice but to tough it out.
- s1k3s 7y agoI agree with everything but your last point. Having worked on software projects where nobody was thinking about how things are done and they were only thinking about deliveries, I can say that you don't need more than 6 months to make the solution a completely unmaintainable mess.
- JamesBarney 7y agoWhat are the things that you think other devs would label over engineering but was instrumental in your project not becoming an unmaintainable mess?
- s1k3s 7y agoAn example I often see is database normalization. Why use 5NF when we can simply do with 3NF? Fast forward this a few months later and you end up doing pattern matching on blocks of text instead of querying indexed columns.
- JamesBarney 7y agoAhh, it's far more uncommon for me to feel like a database is over engineered. It's much more common to find a codebase has 7 levels of indirection but the database fails to accurately and completely represent their business domain. When I do feel a database is over engineered it is almost exclusively adding complexities to the database to handle a contrived or rare examples. With the most common being "splitting one table into 2 because a one to one relationship is actually a one to many once every 5 years", or "adding a join table because in Joe's 30 year career there was that one time multiple companies jointly sold us a single product"
- adrianN 7y agoYou could always switch to a company that doesn't make its money with ads. For example I work for Snowflake and I don't feel like I'm building stuff to screw the end user at all. I just make our database better. I also worked for Siemens. There too I didn't try to screw any users, I just tried to make trains run cheaper, faster and more reliably.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- apohn 7y ago>I also worked for Siemens. There too I didn't try to screw any users, I just tried to make trains run cheaper, faster and more reliably. So I say this based on personal experience. The Siemens' sales force uses their size and influence (especially with existing customers) to absolutely screw over customers and smaller competitors with better products. Siemens is no different than many other big companies who can use all sorts of unethical (but legal) tactics to sell. It's very possible to work as an engineer in a big company and have zero idea as to what everybody else is doing to screw people over.
- uka 7y agoNot only that. Siemens bribes people from the governments in third world countries to get the work from the government and totally destroys the local competition an the taxpayers.of those countries.
- hobs 7y agoI also think B2B is a much less predatory place - most of the businesses have real money, want a real thing to help them make more of it, and are engaged in the process of making that work. There's plenty of bad actors (like any biz) but most of the time when I ship features everyone is happy, and no one is taken advantage of.
- Nextgrid 7y agoA friend of mine works at a B2B business. Every week they have a "lead forensics" meeting where they somehow figure out which companies visited their website and then spam them with unsolicited sales calls/emails.
- ehnto 7y ago> Instead, engineering became its own thing and most companies encourage and reward those who opt for over-engineered solutions, which means you spend more time fighting with dozens of layers of abstractions and chasing the latest JS framework instead of actually delivering functionality. I've been thinking about this in relation to the concept of incidental complexity lately. Every year there is more and more tooling and configuration to do before actually coding anything. I have always considered myself a full stack developer, but each field gets more specialized, and when issues arise I'm just not on top of the suddenly very complex nature of the surrounding ecosystem, even though the goal is to eventually write the same code in the same language I normally use.
- dmux 7y ago>Every year there is more and more tooling and configuration to do before actually coding anything. I've become increasingly worn-out from this as well. It's strange that as an industry we parrot the "premature optimization is the root of all evil" line, yet we build out our tech stacks as if we were all part of FAANG.
- collyw 7y agoI am going to start showing everyone the Stack Overflow architecture, a beautiful example of scaling up rather than the monstrosities generated by scaling out. There is the promise of cheaper hardware, but the developer costs must cancel this out, no? https://stackexchange.com/performance https://stackexchange.com/performance
- deedubaya 7y agoAnd here we have the product of today's VC backed tech. There is a whole other world of bootstrapped/profitable businesses out there where these things aren't a focus or problem. You might not even have to take much of a pay cut.
- wslh 7y agoI would add there is a conflict of interest in the software industry. Big companies which could invent products to (really) optimize software development would not do that because they will have less developers (business channels at the end) to sell their offerings. Most developers around the world are wasting time doing the same thing over and over instead of having good secure, robust frameworks and UX/UI builders/tools.
- augusto-moura 7y agoI think this a biased point, speaking specifically about startupish business models, there's a lot of different models around the world in a lot of places. There's work to be done with critical applications or slow paced startups, or niche applications on premises. All of them pay well too, maybe you are just saying what you are seeing, but there's a lot more options to it
- jwr 7y agoI can relate to your point of view, which is why I don't work for "the tech industry", but instead have my own SaaS. This lets me stay close to tech (I love programming in Clojure and ClojureScript!), do what I enjoy, and not have my soul sucked out by evilness and stupidity of today's adtech world. I have a product which solves a real problem and I'm getting paid by customers who appreciate that their workflow is somewhat easier with my tool. No tricks there. So, you do have a choice. I'm not saying it's easy or quick, but the choice is there.
- _davebennett 7y agoHow do you propose finding those real problems to solve? I know that every problem I encounter in my life (or work) has already been solved 100 times over.
- non-entity 7y agoYeah in honestly shocked at how many niche problems. I encounter that have ready solutions. If I ever find a truly unsolved problem, in likely to assume that its just too hard to properly solve at the time.
- jmstfv 7y ago> If I ever find a truly unsolved problem Why do you think you need to find a truly unsolved problem? If all you want is a profitable, sustainable business, look at what companies are already paying for, and build a product that solves one of those problems. It doesn't have to be a carbon copy of an existing product. You can differentiate by price or combination of features. Or you can target a different niche. Competition is a signal that there's money to be made in the market. It won't be easy, and you will have to learn sales & marketing. But it is doable. If there are X companies in the market, there's likely a place for another one (as long as this isn't a winner-takes-all type of market).
- ScottFree 7y agoSo solve it for the 101st time, but better. Everything is broken and nothing works. So, build something that isn't broken and does work. I just found out yesterday that AWS Amplify doesn't have a manual deploy button. It's only job is to build and deploy an app and there is nowhere on Amplify itself where you can press a button and kick off a build! Junk like this is everywhere now. It's a golden opportunity for people who know what they're doing.
- godtoldmetodoit 7y agoGet out of the VC backed world then. Plenty of stodgy old enterprises that make actual useful stuff need good IT talent, and they pay well enough. These environments come with their own set of issues, but I've never felt like I'm working for companies where I am scamming the end user. Just stop working for shit companies producing stupid shit, money isn't everything.
- scottishfiction 7y agoEven better, get out of the private sector (if you can). I'm very happy with what I'm contributing to the world at the BBC, and I'm paid 'well enough'.
- Nextgrid 7y agoThe BBC might be an exception here but typically government projects always go to some BS consultancy that will take lots of money and deliver a shitty solution, or sometimes the problem or spec itself doesn't make sense but you're not allowed to talk to them and clarify/rethink the spec because reasons.
- scottishfiction 7y agoThere are some notable exceptions aside from the BBC in the UK. The Government Digital Service is held in fairly high regard. I’m not sure about the states. There are no doubt examples at the BBC of what you describe, but mainly it’s pleasant smart people building useful things. There’s dysfunction, but it’s bearable.
- hkmurakami 7y agoI have no inside look and can only comment as a user, but isn’t a company like gusto providing a genuinely valuable service? As a small time startup operator I was happy to pay for their product.
- Nextgrid 7y agoCompanies like that are relatively niche and usually already have all the talent they need. Not to mention, even if it looks good on the surface there could still be bad things hiding under the hood. A friend of mine works at a niche business selling network hardware, sounds innocent enough - and yet they are using creepy analytics to infer which companies visited their website and then spam them with sales calls.
- aqme28 7y ago> Technology-wise, we no longer use engineering as a means to an end to solve a business problem. Instead, engineering became its own thing and most companies encourage and reward those who opt for over-engineered solutions, which means you spend more time fighting with dozens of layers of abstractions and chasing the latest JS framework instead of actually delivering functionality. This is mostly a symptom of the previous point where showing "growth" and bragging about your (over) engineering is more important than actual profit. This seems to vary company-to-company. I've seen the extremes on both sides of this. I recommend finding a new company that shares your views on tech-debt and pragmatism.
- tom-jh 7y agoMaybe join my company, or another company like us? We're funded from customer revenue. Privacy focused. No VCs, so no moral flexibility needed on our end to meed VC expectations. We don't do any dark patterns. All remote. There's GitLab, Wikimedia, Cockroach Labs, etc.. there are opportunities out there if you make it a real priority to work at such place.
- southphillyman 7y agoThis seems like an issue which is heavily skewed towards start ups and tech companies, which are ironically generally viewed as the most attractive companies for tech workers to work at. The pay will be lower but there are opportunities out there where you can genuinely work towards helping people with technical solutions. Both the local research hospital and world class children hospital in my area always have data science openings and positions like that for instance
- ruffrey 7y agoThis describes a lot of software. No doubt. It's depressing and disturbing. But not any of the systems I've worked on over 10 years. You may not get the absolute top salaries working on more meaningful projects, but there's plenty of them. Here are some examples that I worked on. To a fault, most of these places over-focused on the business and under-focused on exceptional engineering. Nonetheless, there's a lot of money to be made solving real business problems. - Optometry practice management software - Insurance benefits processing and customer service systems - Professional soccer/football training iPad apps - phone/pbx, Audio and video communcations, tie in with the web - mapping systems to evaluate water scarcity and agriculture water use - government benefits systems Again, user Nextgrid isn't wrong. If you're willing to take say, up to 90% of the highest salaries available, rather than only the top 10% of salaries, there are huge amounts of non-advertisement problems to solve. Rightfully, this comment exposes the depressing cynicism which develops when building manipulative software.
- Nextgrid 7y agoCurious, how do you get jobs/contracts around these examples? My understanding is that most of these industries already have the talent they need (or have a preferred supplier they work with).
- __s 7y agoYou apply. Talent is always wanting
- sopooneo 7y agoI freelanced for a few months for a local high-end cabinet maker. I helped them integrate their online ordering system with the automated fabrication equipment. It was, by far the most I have ever enjoyed programming. Coordinating with super skilled crafts-people to help them eliminate the redundant parts of their work was just so cool. And by weird coincidence to this post I've recently been browsing around trying to find any other type of traditional businesses looking for equivalent help. But I've mostly found boutique places that wouldn't have need for a full-time developer. Any tips on places to look for opening greatly appreciated.
- wackget 7y ago>Technology-wise, we no longer use engineering as a means to an end to solve a business problem. Instead, engineering became its own thing and most companies encourage and reward those who opt for over-engineered solutions, which means you spend more time fighting with dozens of layers of abstractions and chasing the latest JS framework instead of actually delivering functionality. This is mostly a symptom of the previous point where showing "growth" and bragging about your (over) engineering is more important than actual profit. And yet, some kind of new and improved framework gets upvoted to the top of this website every week. Seriously though, it truly disgusts and depresses me to browse Github and see projects which could have been accomplished with (literally) a single file being split into 10, 15, 20+ files, all wrapped up in some god-awful package managers. No, developers; your JavaScript snippet does NOT need to be accompanied by two dozen .grunt, .yaml, .composer, .gulp, .jenkins, or .fellatio files.
- Nextgrid 7y agoI half-jokingly suggest that we need package managers for Javascript package managers to abstract them away too.
- collyw 7y agoI have been dealing with this at work today. Docker on Google cloud with a VPN. A two line change took at least half an half an hour to test out. Then log into the container and I can't even run less on the logs to try and work out what was wrong. I can't even remembr the problem that docker was supposed to be solving but someone added it in.
- naringas 7y ago> we no longer use engineering as a means to an end to solve a business problem. Instead, engineering became its own thing I hadn't though about why we over-engineer things this way. But I agree I might add, based on the over-engineered (and, in general, badly designed) software I have worked with, that it usually comes about because it's never possible to change any aspect of the underlying architecture with the purpose of simplifying things. We wind up with over complicated 'solutions' because we are simply unable to go back to simplify anything ever for any reason. The 'stake-holders' just don't think it's priority. So all that's left is keep stacking clever solutions on top of bad decisions such that every new clever solution makes it even harder to go back to simplify.
- Nextgrid 7y agoIn my case the problem is less about changing things because the product became over-engineered after several years, and more about products starting out over-engineered because some idiot wants to put React and Kubernetes and "managing a large team" on his resume when the business problem at hand could be solved by a handful of PHP files sitting on a shared host (not saying you should go to such extremes, random PHP files and shared hosts are bad for other reasons).
- collyw 7y ago"Perfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away." Antoine de Saint-Exupery
- jcbrand 7y agoIMO you should be spending time on refactoring and simplifying code without asking permission for it. Improving the code-base is part of the job and you should be setting aside about 20% of the time you estimate for new features to do so. There's no need to ask management for permission, your estimate is simply 20% larger.
- dominotw 7y agoall the top responses seem to be ppl who haven't actually left but speculating why ppl might leave :\.
- anm89 7y agoMoralizing that, scumbag vcs this, screwing users that. Unfortunately although everyone else is terrible and I'm a victim, I'm not willing to stop any of it because I love the money!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eastbayjake 7y agoTwo threads from replies here that are helpful: look at B2B SaaS or join enterprise IT. There are a lot of companies that are trying to modernize their tools and adopt agile ways of working, and if you're coming from a startup background you will bring a really valuable perspective and set of skills. I know Fortune 500 developers who are working on super cool DevOps enablers and internal libraries using modern tech. The good places are not your dad's IBM WebSphere configuration shop anymore.
- dvirsky 7y agoI worked for a good B2B SaaS, and while I was able to tell myself I'm not doing anything unethical or immoral, and while some of the customers were indeed very valuable (in terms of value to their customers) Fortune 500 companies - a large chunk of customers were adtech, dodgy mobile gaming, etc. So you're still just providing infrastructure for these guys and not really contributing anything useful to the world, you're just one level removed from that, and hopefully you have enough customers who actually do good.
- eastbayjake 7y agoIf the bar is "I don't want any code I write to be used for purposes which I do not personally endorse" then yes, it's probably a good idea to go work for a mission-driven non-profit and never make open source contributions to anything ever again
- dvirsky 7y agoOr just work in a company that is ethical and provides something useful. I'm just saying working for B2B SaaS is not necessarily covering that base.
- noelsusman 7y agoYou have a choice. These companies pay so well specifically because of all of the terrible practices you mentioned. You're currently choosing to prioritize your lifetime earnings over these other priorities, which IMO can be a fine choice to make, but it is a choice.
- kdkdijr999 7y agoSRE/ops especially feels like a huge job security grift. Every cloud provider is wrapped in HTTP REST APIs but the cloud era version of a UNIX neckbeard has a DSL or CLI tool to peddle. Sorry, gang. Doing just fine with a monorepo of JS, Python, and Go packages that wrap the APIs for a variety of providers. New infra is just a new language dependency file away, and I don’t have to learn your semantic wank. So glad you had a job at FAANG, but outside ITs reality distortion field, we’re plenty productive and you’re just another human.
- codewithcheese 7y agoany tips for managing a multi language mono repo like that?
- one2know 7y agoMy outfit has five separate teams to protect us helpless devs from SRE/Ops cloud CLI's and dashboards: devops, appops, SRE, infosec, and IT technology. The things is cloud providers and cloud wrapper companies all pay bribes to managers. The company becomes all about SRE/ops instead of app development. The infosec team is currently running the company's cloud strategy, lol. App developers are not even allowed to deploy code. Naturally though, on-call pages still come to us. I just look at the errors and think, "that's nice, whelp I can't deploy anything so I will close this." I would quit but Covid-19.
- hoophoop 7y agoI fully agree - but the problem is not just in the tech industry. Everything you describe is about capitalism: putting profit before any other priority.
- agumonkey 7y agoI'd argue that it's also contextual. The previous generations were probably helped a lot by the capitalist lever, but it seems that since the 90s we're putting the lever first and the needs second, trying to find growth beyond anything else, which leads to the equivalent of p-hacking at the economic level.
- agumonkey 7y agoTime to regroup on other domains. There are probably a lot of things that could benefit from good tech but not through mainstream channels and trendy ideas.
- hinkley 7y agoYour points remind me of something I've been saying for a while: We don't have a shortage of developers. We have too many developers and so they are all working on the same things for different companies, or on boondoggles. (Also, I would really, really encourage you to invest some time and effort into living below your means. It's easier to retire or take a more fulfilling job when you only 'need' 75% of your salary and you already have a big chunk of the surplus sitting in an account somewhere. On the flip side it's made me complacent wrt to demanding raises I deserve)
- lutorm 7y agoMaybe take a look at https://www.spacex.com/careers/list?field_job_category_tid%5B%5D=761 https://www.spacex.com/careers/list?field_job_category_tid%5.... (We don't screw our users, because the users are us. And all that counts is solving real problems.) But if your criterion is zero pay cut to make the move, then you're placing zero actual value on all those things you complain about.
- dantheman 7y agoThere's tons of good tech work out there - go into the B2B and less B2C.
- notquiteacop 7y agoYou neglected to mention screwing the company workers, and screwing the company partners.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- _bxg1 7y ago> The tech industry nowadays is no longer about solving real-world problems and making the world a better place, instead it's all about screwing the end user in every single way possible I think you're overstating it. This is true of much of the industry, maybe even most in certain bubbles like San Francisco, but it's far from all. > Technology-wise, we no longer use engineering as a means to an end to solve a business problem. Instead, engineering became its own thing and most companies encourage and reward those who opt for over-engineered solutions I think there's more truth to this, although I still think it's far from all of the industry. There's also a little bit of a good reason for it: tech companies have figured out that when you let engineers work on things they find interesting or exciting, they tend to work much harder and longer. In some sense this isn't a bad deal for those programmers either, if they're getting to do something they love instead of something they hate. What it does lead to is a weird situation where doing something in a way that's only 80% efficient in terms of effort because of over-engineering, may still end up being economical because it leads to 200% effort from the people working on it. I think this is the root of a lot of the technology decisions being made today. Which, again, is really weird and seems questionable, but it also seems to work out pretty well for all parties most of the time.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ken 7y ago> The tech industry nowadays is no longer about solving real-world problems and making the world a better place Your complaints are legitimate problems with the industry, but it should come as no surprise that a free market does not always make ethical decisions. > Unfortunately there's just nothing out there that pays as well so I have no choice but to tough it out. You always have a choice. Nobody ever promised that a choice which "makes the world a better place" would necessarily be the one that's best for any individual's own wallet. It usually isn't. As long as tech workers continue to choose to do work purely based on salary, even when it "screws the end user in every single way possible", employers are incentivized to continue to pay them to do so. The job market works both ways. It's hard to muster much pity for someone who uses "toughing it out" to describe making a great salary and (by their own admission) screwing their customers.
- gofreddygo 7y ago> there's just nothing out there that pays as well Tech pay will flatten out/drop in the next decade. Skill requirements are diverging. Tech skills are being commoditized by influential, huge, monopolistic companies. There is no licensing body to keep supply in check (like doctors, lawyers do) and there isn't one likely to be either. Put that together and you have a recipe for excess skill supply, replaceable talent and incredible effort required to switch roles. One effect of that is lower pay.