4 ms·
It's true that regions are different, but I don't see how that translates. Can you be specific? How would a plan for Queens County, NY differ from one for Wau
by ajross 7y ago
It's true that regions are different, but I don't see how that translates. Can you be specific? How would a plan for Queens County, NY differ from one for Waukesha WI, except in trivial stuff like dates?
Some outbreaks are smaller, but you'll note that they all leveled off at roughly the same time and on the same schedule. That's because we locked down on "New York's schedule"[1]. If we didn't, these places which seem to have "handled" the outbreak would look like New York.
The plans should absolutely be regional in that the lockdown rules should be based on infection rate thresholds, etc... But to do that they all need exactly the same per-capita testing resources. It's the same plan.
[1] Really that's not true. We locked down on Seattle's schedule, because they moved first on most things. Seattle had by far the biggest early outbreak, but peaked earlier, peaked lower, and is now one of the better managed areas in the country. Cuomo gets all the attention but it's really Jay Inslee who saved us all.
- bcrosby95 7y agoJay Inslee and the Seattle Flu Study. Without the flu study going against medical guidelines (along with the guidance of the CDC to adhere to those guidelines) and testing some of their samples for COVID-19 (which isn't what they were collected for), Washington's timeline would have been pushed much further back.
- 333c 7y agoDon't forget Newsom, who issued the first state-wide shelter in place order. That has been invaluable in keeping California safe(r).
- timr 7y agoDifferent regions have dramatically different population densities, and don't necessarily need shelter-in-place rules. In NYC, shelter-in-place is probably the only feasible way to reduce social interactions when case-count is exploding, but in Boise, where people mostly live in detached housing and drive cars and cases are measured in the hundreds, it might be sufficient to eliminate large gatherings and shut down restaurants. It's not just a matter of thresholds. For all the various politicians are talking about "following the science", there's very little actual science backing up these measures. We're pretty much making it up as we go, and you would be hard-pressed to find "scientific" justifications for most of what we're currently doing.
- ajross 7y ago> don't necessarily need shelter-in-place rules Is there a cite for that? Because that's not the way the data looks. Everywhere was growing with roughly the same exponent before lockdown. The numbers were bigger in NY because it grew longer pre-detection, but there's no reason to believe that everywhere else was any different. Really this disease's growth constant looks shockingly consistent almost everywhere in the world. > It's unclear to me why we're making these policies at a federal level. We... aren't. Literally every existing lockdown regime is being enforced at the state level or lower. For the Boise example you mention, the relevant regulation is a stay in place order from Gov. Little in late March. Edit to show the point better: Go here (easily the best visualization site, FWIW), scroll to the bottom where you can see a log chart of per-capita infection rates normalized to a single "start time" metric, and compare the Idaho chart with the New York one. https://91-divoc.com/pages/covid-visualization/ https://91-divoc.com/pages/covid-visualization/ They are almost exactly the same chart, modulo a vertical offset and a kink in NY data in the second week (which consensus says is the testing backlog finally catching up). If Idaho's detached housing and automobile dependence was reducing its rate of infection spread, it should be visible in the slope of this line. And it clearly isn't.
- timr 7y ago"Everywhere was growing with roughly the same exponent before lockdown." No, they weren't. You're just asserting that this is true. There's effectively no way to know what the doubling rate was in a place like Boise before the national lockdown, because the numbers were in the low single digits: https://covid-19.direct/metro/Boise?tab=glance https://covid-19.direct/metro/Boise?tab=glance But even ignoring that...the site you're linking to shows a wide range of slopes on the per-state graph. You just think they look the same, because the log Y-axis compresses dramatic differences in scale, particularly near the origin. New York, NJ, Michigan and Louisiana are well above the diagonal line, while states like Wyoming, Montana, Vermont, Maine etc. are all well below it.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoOne of the things we urgently need to figure out is how to prevent bad data visualization from leading to bad conclusions. Statistical malpractice isn't just a meme phrase anymore.
- djrogers 7y ago> except in trivial stuff like dates? Dates are not trivial when people's very livelihoods are at stake.
- ajross 7y agoYou know what I meant. You can write the same plan for different regions with parameters. There's no inherent regional interest that requires every county government in the US staff its own disease control department.