5 ms·
> "the internet when he first conceived it, he thought it was a place that we would all leave the world and go to. Whereas in fact, it came here." This is a co
by ashtonkem 7y ago
> "the internet when he first conceived it, he thought it was a place that we would all leave the world and go to. Whereas in fact, it came here."
This is a common mistake utopians of all stripes; the short comings of the world as we know it isn't a consequence of external forces imposing badness on us, it's a consequence of the fallibility of humanity. Unless if you have a concrete plan on how you're going to organize society differently, any attempt to start something fresh will end up recreating all of the ills that drove you from "society" in the first place.
- monknomo 7y agoPretty sure Neuromancer isn't a utopian novel, and that Gibson isn't a utopian.
- ashtonkem 7y agoArguable; I’m not enough of a literary person to argue it out. But the sentence above is a very escapist attitude, and I’d argue that my original point still holds; escapists often fail to recognize the source of the problems they’re escaping from, and recreate them wherever they escape to.
- the_af 7y agoIt's not really arguable. Gibson wrote punk literature, at least back then; he identified himself as a punk subculture writer, and punk isn't utopian. He was not describing a desirable future, but a depressing one where soulless corporations rule the world. > But the sentence above is a very escapist attitude Escapism can be pessimistic, as in Gibson. It's not him who "escapes", it's the denizens of the soulless world he described, and the "world" they escape to can be just as alienating. It's no triumph to "escape" to Gibson's matrix, and his world continues to be a crapsack [1][2]. ---- [1] https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CrapsackWorld https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CrapsackWorld [2] https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/CrapsackWorld/Literature https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/CrapsackWorld/Literat...
- Apocryphon 7y agoThe setting as a whole is dystopian, but the possibilities of the net as a free space for people to flee into and become empowered there- isn't that a utopian enclave, a refuge? Regardless of post hoc genre classifications like cyberpunk vs. postcyberpunk, you can still have pockets of hope within a generally dystopian setting, and perhaps Gibson's cyberspace was the place in Neuromancer.
- the_af 7y agoI'm specifically arguing about Gibson, Neuromancer and his related works, not about the cyberpunk genre at large. Gibson self-identifies -- or did, anyway -- as a punk writer. Cyberspace is not really a pocket of hope in his stories. The ending of Neuromancer itself is ambiguous and not exactly optimistic. Many of his short stories are similarly dark and depressing, things seldom ending well for his characters. I'm not speaking of cyberpunk in general. Note that Gibson himself has stated the modern "cyberpunk" genre largely misses the point, mistaking a novel counter-cultural idea for its visual trappings.
- duskwuff 7y ago> but the possibilities of the net as a free space for people to flee into and become empowered there- isn't that a utopian enclave, a refuge? That theme isn't really present in the Neuromancer series. From the perspective of our viewpoint characters, the matrix is primarily a place that one goes to do a job, not a place to hang out; it's seen primarily as the domain of megacorps and mysterious AIs, not a human space.
- gpderetta 7y agoIt is present in the follow up Count Zero though. Also while Gibson focuses on characters at the fringe of society, the world itself is not significantly more distopian than our world (or the '80s), which is probably one of the author's points. I still wouldn't call it escapism though.
- 7y ago
- ilaksh 7y agoI think what's really going to a create a different sort of world, not a Utopia but still vastly different, is trans-humanity and post-humanity. Gibson and many others have tried to imagine the transition from human to post-human which is largely about the power of brain computer interfaces. To me, the convergence of advanced and/or general purpose AI, high bandwidth brain computer interfaces, and new levels of immersion in virtual/augmented reality provided by the new BCIs have a potential to transform the qualitative nature of human existence and so there is plenty of room left for science fiction along those lines. Although I will admit that I have not in any way explored much of that genre. One idea is of a type of video game that involves high-bandwidth neural input enabling a type of waking lucid dream, where the AI reads your brain and modifies the scene to align with it. Maybe several people and advanced AIs are involved in this game. And suppose that there is a type of almost-human level AI being simulated as characters. Or maybe real humans plugged in and acting without lucid dreaming powers but the ability to affect the environment if they activate certain types of triggers recognized by an AI. That is pretty far-fetched, but I think I have described a scenario where gods and magic are real.