6 ms·
They already have the shiny button. They can compel cell phone companies to give this data to the government already, without you knowing about it. At least t
by jedberg 7y ago
They already have the shiny button. They can compel cell phone companies to give this data to the government already, without you knowing about it.
At least this way you will get some control of the info and you'll know what was collected and have control of it's disclosure (for now).
In other words, this is no worse than what the government is already capable of, it just makes it easier for you to share the data with health care providers.
The government already has all these abilities.
- driverdan 7y agoIt's much worse because it won't have judicial oversight.
- garmaine 7y agoUnfortunately neither does existing location data collecting.
- clairity 7y agothat isn't a reason to be complacent about furthering governmental/corporate surveillance capabilities. in fact, it should remind us to take away those prior surveillance capabilities, and demand any contact tracing system to give control to users and be fully off-limits to large power structures (e.g., only shared between users and researchers). and being hard to do so is no excuse. we have millions of people we can work on the problem if it's so important to warrant such massive effort.
- tastroder 7y agoPeople are working on contact tracing, this takes care of one of the harder parts without dictating central control in a pretty sensible manner. Being wary of privacy adverse interests in this context is good but in this context makes little sense. This specification only touches the question of data leaving the device in ways that restrict what the outside party, in an RFC manner MUST wording, can do with the data. It's pretty clear that we will get contact tracing applications in many parts of the world, regardless of any action Apple or Google might have taken. Might as well base it on something that does not compromise the user base wholesale.
- FartyMcFarter 7y ago> They can compel cell phone companies to give this data to the government already Bluetooth has a quite small range, which may give higher tracking precision (to anyone receiving the signal) than the data cell phone companies have.
- tastroder 7y agoThe capability of using the Bluetooth stack for tracking is not new, this proposal limits the way that data can be used. See the cryptographic specification linked below.
- simonsaidit 7y agoThe alternative would be GPS which some governments are looking at now. It might give higher precision with a grid of location data to enhance it, but I would assume the protocol prevents this eg by some randomization of ids?
- conradev 7y agoGPS is completely unidirectional from satellites to receivers and thus the satellites cannot be used to track the receivers
- skuhn 7y agoThe receivers can be made to report their GPS data back for tracking purposes.
- simonsaidit 7y agoWhat skuhn said. That is what the solution the Norwegian and Danish government is implementing is supposedly doing. Reporting the GPS data back to a central server. If you’re using iPhone. https://www.simula.no/news/digital-contact-tracing-qa#How%20does%20the%20app%20work https://www.simula.no/news/digital-contact-tracing-qa#How%20...?
- conradev 7y agoCurrently, yes, but "numerical results with a system operating at 39 GHz show that sub-meter 3D positioning accuracy is achievable in future mmW 5G networks" :) https://arxiv.org/abs/1803.09478 https://arxiv.org/abs/1803.09478
- takeda 7y agoThey can compel, but also what they typically do is to purchase from them the data. That way they don't even need warrants. We tally need stronger regulations about sensitive information like that.
- tossAfterUsing 7y ago> At least this way you will get some control doubt it.
- olliej 7y agoThe protocol is explicitly designed to not share information - the data does not contain location information, and the only thing that someone can do with that data is verify if they have seen some of the identifiers that were published by someone else.
- droithomme 7y ago> it just makes it easier for you to share the data with health care providers I don't want to share any more information with these corporate heath care providers based on real world experience with them. Is that "allowed".