27 ms·
I know this is a very tired topic, but does anyone have any good blog posts or articles about "what exactly is it that you all do?" Yelp having 6000 employees.
by Waterluvian 7y ago
I know this is a very tired topic, but does anyone have any good blog posts or articles about "what exactly is it that you all do?" Yelp having 6000 employees. I'm not surprised, I'm not mad. I just want to understand.
- TylerE 7y agoMarketing/sales
- mylons 7y agoModeration and marketing/sales were probably pretty big
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- scurvy 7y agoSales and account management are easier to hire and fire. That said I bet some engineers were let go. If you're not directly client facing or related to e-commerce, you're not essential right now.
- jstanley 7y agoBut aren't sales and account management precisely the people who are client-facing or related to e-commerce?
- scurvy 7y agoYes but they're the easiest to ramp up and wind down. Certain segments of the economy as devastated right now. Would not want to be a flight attendant, but airplane engine mechanics are probably still in demand as cargo flights replace passenger traffic (since we're ordering everything online now). Logically, that would extend to people whose job revolves around signing up restaurants to marketing portals. The restaurants that have an online business are already there. Those that don't have an online business are already closed.
- penagwin 7y agoAccording to flight aware, global air traffic is down 75%. So I'd bet mechanics aren't doing so hot either unless they were dedicated to cargo. Programmers arent as easy to replace because they already understand the system. Training takes time, and if there's not enough documentation then you'll end up contacting the previous programmers for help (I've seen it happen) anyway.
- ransom1538 7y agoYes. But now they have no one to call.
- hadlock 7y agoMarketing and SDRs are really easy to scale up/down; there are some things that are specific to each product but generally it doesn't matter what you are selling it is the same soft skills. Account Executives and Sales Engineers who provide long term support are a lot harder to replace though.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoExecs are even easier to fire as they are the furthest away from the front lines, but they're the ones doing the firing so too bad for everyone else.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoRealistically I would say a lot of engineers are easy to fire. You only need a certain amount of engineers to do maintenance.
- vinay427 7y agoI think they mean easy to fire in the sense of "easy to go through the process of firing and deallocating tasks/knowledge/etc.", not "easy to justify firing."
- dguaraglia 7y agoEngineers are easy to fire, but incredibly hard (and expensive) to hire, especially if you become known as the company that'll fire people immediately in a crisis. There's a fine line between saving money now and spending it later, and I'm sure Yelp - just like every other company out there - is trying to figure out where does that line lay.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoI don't think engineers have this as a specific trait. Every worker in any occupation has the attitude you describe above. The thing that truly influences "hard to hire" is supply and demand. With the influx of bootcamps Software engineering supply has increased and with COVID-19 decreasing demand Engineers may no longer have the luxury of picking and choosing like they used to. I'm an engineer btw. Just viewing the situation from a realistic lens.
- dguaraglia 7y agoI am an engineer too. I've helped hire engineers at two pretty big companies before and have done all the hiring for my current company. While the supply has increased, the number of senior engineers hasn't grown at the same pace. I know of companies who've fired even their senior engineers, but they've been hit particularly hard by this crisis (think 'business model is literally rendered invalid' level of affected). Most people who think they'll be able to weather at least the next six months will be reluctant to fire more experienced engineers, because they know how hard it was to hire them to begin with. While some of the options might be gone, chances are people who get laid off or are still in the market will look for companies with better chances of surviving this (think Google, Apple, Facebook, etc.), so the pool of experienced talent might actually be reduced for startups. In other words: people with 5 years of industry experience are playing in a completely different arena than more junior engineers, who are unfortunately in a more precarious situation.
- PunchTornado 7y agoa lot of them in sales, going from restaurant to restaurant and convincing them to buy yelp products.
- 013a 7y agoYelp's engineering isn't likely much more than ~150 people (I worked there ~2 years ago, maybe has grown since then but honestly, given their revenue situation even then, likely not by much). The mix there is just like most companies; you've got dedicated teams for each of their apps (which includes Android, iOS, web, business-facing, etc), you've got API teams, back office teams working on moving data around and business analytics, a very secretive abuse management team, IT, etc. Yelp also, given their age, wasn't (at some point) running their primary workloads in the cloud; they had (have?) a colo DC in San Francisco that hosted a ton of stuff, so there were people dedicated to that hardware. There was some movement to get rid of this as I remember. Surprisingly, or hopefully not, the vast majority of the company is more directly revenue generating; sales and customer acquisition. Its spread very globally; at least as of a few years ago, the SF HQ didn't house any sales people, though I think they had an office in Oakland which did. Point being, I always got the impression that their engineering team was very "right sized" given their revenue and product scope.
- derwiki 7y agoI think your 150 estimate is very low— we had 80 eng when I left, nine years ago.
- 013a 7y agoYou may be right. I never counted nor directly asked, that was just the number I overheard. It felt right; afaik, all of the engineering happened in SF, except one remote office in (IIRC) Germany. I know there were a few companies they had acquired (Eat24 and SeatMe) which remained somewhat isolated from the primary Yelp engineering teams (with their own floors of the building and everything), definitely possible the numbers I heard were not counting them.
- pc86 7y agoBut he was there 7 years after you so his estimate is probably closer, no?
- ssk2 7y agoWhen I left last August, we had around 600 in engineering, around 900 in product and engineering. Engineering was mostly based in SF but with satellite offices in London and Hamburg. It looks like they were expanding in a large way into a Toronto office too. Infrastructure was around a fifth of that total but included verticals like search and machine learning infrastructure. Yelp turned off their last datacentre in early 2018 (IIRC) - and is entirely on AWS.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoMost consumer technology products are much more complicated under the hood than they appear to be to regular consumers. Even most programmers -- who are well aware of the hidden complexity of the products they themselves work on -- usually seem to believe that this must not hold true for the products of other companies. For every feature you're aware of on a random consumer tech product or service, there are probably ten or twenty more that don't concern you, that you haven't seen, or that you don't care about.
- xenospn 7y agoI read somewhere (can't remember where) that Airbnb had a dedicated team of 13 engineers and designers working on the welcome email alone. Getting the CTA "just right" resulted in a huge difference in conversions.
- Scoundreller 7y agoAnd the nice thing is that’s all public. So if you’re designing your own CTA, just copy Wal-Mart’s or Amazon’s or Airbnb’s and voila. In a way, I wish I got to work at Wal-Mart or McDonalds just to get a 1st-Hand view of their processes. Would beat any “LEAN” course.
- xenospn 7y agoOh if only it were that simple :) I don't think Airbnb's CTA will work for anyone but Airbnb.
- dickjocke 7y agoThat's a great point I always struggle with coming up with UIs for side projects, but really everything I come up with will always look cheap compared to the efforts of 13 experts.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoIf I had a week to think how to design a good button, I would design a good button.
- rimlicker 7y agoIt has a very large extortion department.
- stronglikedan 7y agoThis is exactly why I'm having a hard time mustering sympathy for the layoffs. If anything, they will use this as a stepping stone to a more ethical career choice. I do still feel for them on a human level though.
- Waterluvian 7y agoEthics is a luxury. In a bad economy, people are probably more ready to take on less ethical jobs.
- luckylion 7y agoThey were very ready & happy to take the unethical in a very good economy though.
- carlineng 7y agoYelp is a public company, and their SEC filings will give you insight into where they spend money. In 2019, over half of their expenses were Sales and Marketing, so we can infer that many of the 6000 employees are likely in roles dedicated to Sales and Marketing. http://d18rn0p25nwr6d.cloudfront.net/CIK-0001345016/360caaf2-1804-462c-a5db-460952da09e2.pdf http://d18rn0p25nwr6d.cloudfront.net/CIK-0001345016/360caaf2...
- duskwuff 7y agoAnd it'd make sense that the sales team would be first on the chopping block. With small businesses under pressure, and many closed down entirely, publicity services like Yelp are a very hard sell.
- quaquaqua1 7y agoNot exactly, if they just so happen to be spending a lot of money on purchases of ad-space, or advertising services. For example, just one marketing VP with a salary of $120,000 could have an advertising spend budget of a few million. But in Yelp's specific case, they do have a ton of sales/customer service people who most definitely are among the first to go, along with engineers who are working on projects that are not related to keeping the website from 404ing
- gabagool 7y agoEven more precisely, 3844 of 5950 Yelp employees on Dec 31, 2019 were members of the sales force. That's 64%. Page 5: "Our sales force consisted of 3,844 employees as of December 31, 2019..." Page 12: "As of December 31, 2019, we had 5,950 employees globally."
- pixiemaster 7y agoSales reps without a clue, product marketing juniors (glorified blog post re-writers), partner channel manager (like an smtp server between companies but with less reliability), crm data cleansing specialists (all needed because of the former), etc
- overrun11 7y agoI was never satisfied with answers like "actually it's way harder than you think" but this article helped me understand: https://danluu.com/sounds-easy/ https://danluu.com/sounds-easy/
- deminature 7y agoI wondered this before joining a large tech company. As it turns out, a lot of engineering is done on experimentation to optimize the product. Only a small portion of users might see the experiment, and many don't succeed. An example might be complying with food and alcohol law in a single region, which you would never see unless you lived there. Another example might be a complete experimentally gated refactor that shaves 1 second off loading time. A lot of effort would go into simply making sure the change can be turned off, and verifying with unit tests, which takes time and effort. These projects might be pointless on a small app, but in a large business might be worth millions to the company. Another aspect is your changes often have to be approved by a lot of people, which is not the case on small projects. Your projects are also analyzed by data scientists, to make sure they're not harming the business - and if they are, your work might be thrown out, which contributes to even less visible change to outsiders. All of these in concert slow things down, and necessitate staff.
- madamelic 7y ago>Another aspect is your changes often have to be approved by a lot of people, which is not the case on small projects. So you need more engineers because you hired more middle managers? That's a little absurd in my opinion but I am likely wrong in this assumption. It just seems like the reaction to "We have lots of approvals" should be figuring out how to reduce the amount of approvals needed, not hiring more engineers to increase velocity.
- neltnerb 7y agoI think you need as many approvals as your risk tolerance allows for... they're not pointless. If they are pointless then sure, get rid of them. But I don't know how you'd guess that number without deep knowledge of the business. It is sometimes better to go slower than you could and be more confident that the product is acceptable. Approvals can but don't necessarily help with that.
- deminature 7y agoThe approvals usually come from other engineers. It stems from having to modify highly-sensitive code which usually has an owner you need to work with to get an approval.
- fred_is_fred 7y agoA company like Yelp needs a lot of boots on the ground type staff to work with restaurants on the sales side. Their infra may scale but that function doesn't.
- bduerst 7y agoGlobal companies employ regional sales and marketing people, since those are typically the most effective workers in those roles. Once you start layering on countries, there are also administrative roles that get added.
- hyperpape 7y agoThis isn't specific to Yelp, but here's a general essay on the subject: https://danluu.com/sounds-easy/ https://danluu.com/sounds-easy/.
- dasil003 7y agoWhat happens is that when a pure software company is a startup it is severely constrained in what it can execute on. As it gains traction, it receives funding and revenue that allows it to invest in more people to get more done. In the beginning the marginal ROI of each hire is high, but as they grow it slowly decreases and may become dominated by communication overhead if proper structure isn't added. But as long as growth is on pace, they will keep hiring to stay ahead of the curve and squeeze as many gains as possible. When VC money is at play, management will be pressured to grow at all cost, and worry less about the downside because the investors are looking for the grand slam. There's never any shortage of internal stakeholders who will have ideas of where to put heads to good use. In short: they have 6000 because that's what leadership thought they could afford. Obviously a 10-year bull market leading up to the current lockdown situation puts them in a rough spot.
- saluki 7y agoI agree, working on small teams and on bootstrapped apps it's just hard to imagine 1000 engineers or even 100 engineers working on a web application.
- matchagaucho 7y agoMost likely Sales. Yelp's business model requires a lot of cold calls to small businesses.
- alasdair_ 7y agoI believe a lot of Yelps employees are outbound sales - they cold call small businesses and try to convince them to pay Yelp money. More generally, it's kind of amazing that any company with 178 million unique "customers" only has a few thousand people working there. I know this is the norm nowadays due to the power of computers and the Internet, but I imagine how many people would have been employed to perform the same tasks fifty years ago and suspect it would have been three orders of magnitude higher (and completely uneconomical to do). Progress is a pretty impressive thing.
- ahuth 7y agoI forget where, but somewhere I read that at large companies relatively small optimizations can be worth millions of dollars. Because of that, it's worth it for these companies to apply a lot of engineering resources to optimization problems (including developer experience). I know you're not saying this, but I'd caution anyone against saying things like "<company>'s product is just a glorified <something simple>". It's very hard for people not working directly on a product to truly understand its complexity and everything that goes into it. EDIT: here's where I read that https://danluu.com/sounds-easy/ https://danluu.com/sounds-easy/
- sct202 7y agoA lot of jobs exist to cover some broken process that could be fixed but costs way more or requires a lot change to actually fix versus throwing a body at the problem. Then things bloat a little bit, but in my opinion there's a lot of things that seem like waste to an outsider that are value added when you consider the system that they exist in.
- LordFast 7y agoI believe something like 80% of their workforce are Sales + G&A.
- adrr 7y agoLet say there are 500k restaurants and businesses that pay for services on yelp. Let’s say an average sales person services 100 of these places. You’ll need 5000 sales people.
- 1024core 7y agoWait till you see that AirBnB has 14,000 employees. That's fourteen thousand! For a site that's barely a step up (in complexity) from Craigslist (which has .... 50 employees).
- vishnugupta 7y agoSpeaking from experience[1] I attribute this to the "empire-building" mindset that sets in once a company gets funding. It begins innocuously enough. It takes just one or two mid-level manager empire-builders to join the company. Thanks to the funding, the product and business want growth at all cost which means everything needs to be built and launched yesterday. The engineering-managers say well sure, I need 100 engineers. And so the game begins; the early empire-builders get promoted to dizzy heights. It doesn't take much time for others to take notice that they need to build an empire to get promoted and every mid-level manager is hiring like there's no tomorrow. In no time you have an incredibly bloated org. In this environment not building an empire is not an option; teams with fewer than 10 members don't get new-shiny projects and are brutally sidelined. [1] I've been on both sides. The start-up I was working in got acquired by a behemoth that had skilled empire-builders. My team got massacred. In my next gig I had learned my lessons so hired like crazy and in no time had 40 engineers reporting (direct/indirectly) to me 15 of whom had any real work to do. The rest were building random CRUD apps. In the end, realized that empire-building is not for me; I enjoy running a small tight knight team producing high throughput and impactful work.
- carapace 7y agoI once spoke (well, listened) to a retired old-school Silicon Valley hardware engineer once who told me that ~80% of the projects he worked on never saw the light of day, never became products. Eighty percent, of hardware. It put things in perspective for me as a software guy.
- zelly 7y agoClearly they were doing nothing useful, because despite them being laid off, I can still open my Yelp app right now and browse around just fine. Most office jobs are "adult daycare", even in tech (blasphemy, I know).
- sizzle 7y agoDoes anyone have the role breakdown of those let go/furloughed? e.g. marketing, dev, design, sales, etc.
- Melting_Harps 7y ago> "what exactly is it that you all do?" Yelp having 6000 employees. I'm not surprised, I'm not mad. I just want to understand. I'm sure the Owner of Botto Bistro [1] is having a proper side-splitting laugh right about now hearing this news given all he [2] has gone through. 1: https://thehustle.co/botto-bistro-1-star-yelp/ https://thehustle.co/botto-bistro-1-star-yelp/ 2: https://youtu.be/qwF9ehhEoss https://youtu.be/qwF9ehhEoss
- PeterStuer 7y agoSame as in any other large company: empire building and pfiefdom staffing. That is what people do. I find it curious how this is allowed to be completely, completely absent in the standard narrative on private business, and yet so ridiculously obvious to anyone that has ever worked in one. There is this canon dogma about 'market efficiency keeping things lean and fit', which is so obviously false and disproven by every single Corp out there, and yet is allowed to stand. Curious.
- dmode 7y agoI don’t get why this question gets repeatedly upvoted in HN. I just responded to a similar question on Airbnb in another post. Do people not work for large corporations here ? Yelp’s business model is to sell ads to local businesses. And ads don’t sell themselves. For that you need to hire army of inside and outbound sales folks in every region, geo, market. This also means there is a whole account management team who is managing relationships with the thousands of advertisers. And then there is an ad tech team that is integrating these ads, but also reconciling payments and payouts in multiple currencies. I wouldn’t be surprised if majority of Yelp’s employees are in sales, sales ops, ad ops, and advertisement side of the business
- mlrtime 7y agoI wonder how many engineering hours they use to strip the mobile web version of features to force you into their app. That is one reason I'll never install their app and won't miss them when they're gone.