9 ms·
I will repeat a question I would love an epidemiologist to reply to: Where is the random background testing? Not testing "I feel unwell" presentations at random
by ggm 7y ago
I will repeat a question I would love an epidemiologist to reply to: Where is the random background testing? Not testing "I feel unwell" presentations at random, truly going into the field and testing the wider population at random, healthy (believed) or not?
You cannot model the IFR accurately from skewed samples and it feels like we aren't even doing skewed sampling.
- nitrobeast 7y agoI believe Wuhan government eventually went door-to-door to test the population exhaustively.
- starpilot 7y agoIt's in South Korea where there is an abundance of tests. Where tests or people to administrate them are scarce, we have to prioritize those with symptoms.
- sooheon 7y agoThere is an argument to me made for the exact opposite. Those who are already sick will be treated according to their symptoms, a diagnosis has little bearing on the treatment they will receive and therefore low value. Meanwhile, proper random sampling of the population will give more accurate prevalence numbers and trends, allowing for much better epidemic response. South Korea (and Singapore and HK etc.) had a specific policy of contact tracing instead of random sampling, which works if you start it early enough and can actually keep ahead of suspected contact spread.
- Skunkleton 7y agoSick people should be tested when they require medical intervention as it guides their care. It would be a shame to assume COVID when it might be something treatable.
- sooheon 7y agoI'm sure the decision tree is complex, and there are branches where what you say is absolutely true. However, given the testing kit bottleneck, if identification of "something treatable" is crucial, it might be better to test for those treatable diseases that are likely given presenting symptoms. In the extreme case, if you require a ventilator right now or you'll die, nobody needs to wait on verification of the specific viral cause to begin treatment.
- lutorm 7y ago"Those who are already sick will be treated according to their symptoms, a diagnosis has little bearing on the treatment they will receive and therefore low value." It is not low value for the healthcare providers, though, who can spare measures against getting infected to those who actually have COVID and thus both save time and scarce resources.
- projektfu 7y agoThe cost of false negatives would be too high. Hospitals have to treat all respiratory cases as potential COVID right now, even if initial tests are negative.
- petschge 7y agoBoth Munich and Prague have started such studies with several thousand random people in each. That should give us a much better estimate for the number of "silent" cases.
- mmmrtl 7y agoThere are a bunch of serological surveys going on right now in the US: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/04/unprecedented-nationwide-blood-studies-seek-track-us-coronavirus-spread https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/04/unprecedented-nation...
- fspeech 7y agoSanta Clara county did surveillance testing which likely saved California https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6914e3.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6914e3.htm despite the shortage of test kits. Just imagine if the nation had sufficient tests available.
- vanattab 7y ago"During March 5–14, among patients with respiratory symptoms evaluated at one of four Santa Clara County urgent care centers serving as sentinel surveillance sites, 23% had positive test results for influenza. Among a subset of patients with negative test results for influenza, 11% had positive test results for COVID-19." Seems to me like Santa Clara was just testing sink people to me
- maxerickson 7y agoIt continues: At the time the investigation began, testing guidance recommended focusing on persons with clinical findings of lower respiratory illness and travel to an affected area or an epidemiologic link to a laboratory-confirmed COVID-19 case, or on persons hospitalized for severe respiratory disease and no alternative diagnosis (1). At the time, the standard was to test people with travel history to affected areas or when they were hospitalized for unexplained respiratory illness. Compare that to testing people that went to urgent care because they felt sick. There's a difference.
- ssalka 7y agoStill, there's no reason to say that any of these selection criteria result in sample sizes big enough to be statistically relevant against larger populations. Also, testing "people with travel history to affected areas" does not amount at all to being a representative segment. Santa Clara's results are basically only useful for Santa Clara. _Maybe_ the Bay Area in addition, but not really any farther. So, we DO need surveillance testing, on a much wider scale, across the US and globally to be frank.
- 7y ago
- ineedasername 7y agoDr. Fauci addressed that the other day when asked about when schools might reopen. He hedged a lot, but basically said he thought it could happen for the Fall. At the same time he was talking about that as the time frame for wide-spread anti-body testing that would show just how far the virus had penetrated. (And that such testing and continued contact tracing etc. would be what facilitated cautious steps towards reopening society)
- rubber_duck 7y agoI think Iceland is aiming for full population test
- Medicalidiot 7y agoThis is probably what you're looking for: https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2020.25.10.2000180 https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.E...
- DesiLurker 7y agoThis, unless we do that there is no way to establish true IFR so we wont know until its in hindsight how deadly the covid is? I dont know why this is not the priority 1 for the CDC. on the similar lines, Germany is doing something clever, they are mixing samples to do a kind of binary search with covid tests so they can clear a large number of people with few tests. we should do that without waiting for antibody tests etc. it should be noted that this approach would only work if the infected sample set is very small so the window of doing this is going to close soon.
- lmm 7y ago> I dont know why this is not the priority 1 for the CDC. What actions would we do differently based on the result? Not knowing is frustrating for everyone, but we should save our resources for stuff that's actually going to improve outcomes.
- DesiLurker 7y agoIFR is a really important peice of information as it effects the overall management of outbreak. consider these scenarios: A) IFR is really low and most people dont seen anything past slight discomfort, so given the number of 'cases' being treated now it would mean a much larger portion of populus is already infected. translation we can reach herd immunity faster & more safely. B) IFR is high (closer to CFR), which means the current case count is more or less in line with actual infected people. which means we really need to focus on lockdown and slow the growth so we can manage the hospital capacity. as you can see both of these scenarios have different optimal responses but we cannot decide unless we get this info. so far we only have a few biased sample sets (from us pov) diamond cruise & skorea which dont shed much light on our situation.
- Skunkleton 7y agoTesting should be saved for two purposes: 1) to guide care in a hospital setting. 2) to determine the current status of the population. Randomized testing would give us a view into where the virus is spreading and allow us to allocate resources effectively. It would also give us a view into what percentage of a given population is a carrier, or has already recovered. All of these data would be greatly helpful. What isn’t helpful is using tests on people who aren’t either part of a study or under active care.
- nyczomg 7y agoNot an expert, but this is something I've been wondering about too. But then I had another thought, What happens if people refuse the random test. Even if those who refuse are only a small amount of people who get drawn in the covid testing lotto, that likely introduces a serious compounding variable. So then the question is, do you go out into the general population with law enforcement, and force people who were drawn in the testing lotto to be tested at gunpoint if they don't comply? I think the answer is that we don't have the will to do that. And perhaps even if this would be incredibly valuable data, it would be morally wrong to gather it in the way we'd have to gather it to have a truly random sample without such a confounding variable. I am not a doctor, not an epidemiologist. Just some random thoughts.
- mrob 7y agoJust pay them, e.g. 500USD each, or however much is enough to reduce the number of refusals to a negligible proportion. It's cheap compared to the cost of making incorrect decisions because you don't know how many people have the virus.
- toomanybeersies 7y agoThat's a perverse incentive. You'd have to pay everybody $500 each, not just the refusals, since everyone is going to refuse in order to gain $500.
- dorgo 7y agoYou can even refuse 500USD in hope to get 1000USD...
- IAmEveryone 7y ago60-80% of people routinely hang up when being called for political surveys, yet surveys still manage to get within 2 or 3% of election results. This is a non-issue.
- egberts1 7y ago
- usrusr 7y agoSo far only PCR tests are available at scale. Those PCR tests are very sensitive (e.g when detecting traces of long broken virus on surfaces) but even they are only reliably positive for a few days into the infecting. Apparently, the immune system wins the battle for the upper throat quite easily, even in patients who later die from pneumonia. If you did a random sample study with a test that only identifies a positive for a short time you'd still have a huge uncertainty from not knowing reliable averages about how long someone infected "lights up" in the test. There just isn't much information upside from background sampling PCR, particularly when serological tests (those than detect who already had the virus) will soon be available. Those are not useful at all to combat spread anyways, so they can be used for background testing without competing for more immediate use cases.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoAt the moment, that data would not make any significant difference on the actual decisions that are made today. Or can you think of anything you would change with the knowledge that 20% of the population have been infected, versus 2%? As long as thousands die each day, there really is no alternative to the current strategy. It would possibly help planning for the next phase. But mostly it would feed our curiosity. Contrast to using limited tests to find the greatest number of infected people: every additional person knowing without a doubt that they are infected is one more person doing their best not to spread it further. It’s wasteful to test randomly until we are able to test high risk groups every day or so. Cashiers, for example are at high risk of infection, and ha e possibly hundreds of contacts per day. For population-randomized testing, antibody tests should be far superior anyway. They allow detection of. It just active cases but also past infections.
- w3mmpp 7y agoSure, let's just keep the economy closed, who cares if the death rate is 10%, 1% or 0.1% (seasonal flu), what difference does it make right?
- IAmEveryone 7y agoGreat job not getting it. Hope your unique skills are transferable to viruses.
- XFrequentist 7y agoEpidemiologist here: you're right. Testing resources are in short supply, so testing is being performed to guide clinical decisions (ie sick people) rather than public health/science (ie random sample). The handful of serosurveys that have been performed have been quite valuable, but there aren't nearly enough. Hopefully this changes as testing capacity ramps up.
- ggm 7y agoFollow up question: are you guys seeing a drop in norovirus, rotovirus and D&V? I would expect social distancing has reduced opportunistic infection rates: no swimming pools, less interactions at large.
- bjoli 7y agothe Swedish state epidemiologist used that measure as a way of measuring the effectiveness of the social distancing and quarantine measures. apparently, the number of people receiving hospital treatment or dying from yearly virus infections like the flu has dropped significantly.
- neilwilson 7y agoI have anecdotal evidence from a hospital saying that wards usually reserved for norovirus and C. difficile at this time of year have not been required this year due to the lack of those infections.
- nibles_and_bits 7y agoDo you have any insight into the validity of the Nasopharyngeal covid19 PCR test? I suspect I got a false negative. Get to have a "conversation" with HR tomorrow since I am essential.
- projektfu 7y agoFor samples with coronavirus particles, sensitivity and specificity are around 100%. (1) The issue is that many samples do not contain virus. As far as I know, that has not been quantified outside of China. (2) 1. https://www.fda.gov/media/136151/download https://www.fda.gov/media/136151/download 2. https://www.mdmag.com/medical-news/comparing-rt-pcr-and-chest-ct-for-diagnosing-covid19 https://www.mdmag.com/medical-news/comparing-rt-pcr-and-ches...
- gentleman11 7y agoIn Alberta we are only testing pretty sick people until this week, but are high in the global rankings for tests per capita. About 2% of cases have been positive. Widespread, random testing would not make as good a use of resources, since the chemicals to make the tests are becoming a little scarce until Chemical manufacturers catch up
- Reelin 7y ago> the chemicals to make the tests are becoming a little scarce until Chemical manufacturers catch up To the best of my knowledge this isn't true. Only specific product lines by specific manufacturers are approved for clinical use by most governments. As far as I know, the reagents used for RNA extraction and PCR are cheap and readily available.
- gavreh 7y agoThis doctor from Stanford agrees with you and is trying to run this type of test: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UO3Wd5urg0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UO3Wd5urg0
- athenot 7y agoThere was a town in Italy, roughly 10k population, where they tested every single person regardless of symptoms. The result highlighted how many asymptomatic people tested positive. AFAIK the test was not repeated so there was no data on evolution / spread. But it was still an eye opener. (My apologies for not citing the article, I had read it in the paper edition of the NY Times, and failed to find it online.)
- eugene2012 7y agoI remember reading this story in NYT also. Are you thinking about the town of Vò? If so, here is a related article about how they tested everyone there: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/18/scientists-say-mass-tests-in-italian-town-have-halted-covid-19 https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/18/scientists-say...
- dr_zoidberg 7y agoRecently in Argentina there were news of a case were 400 people in a boat were exposed, quarantined and then tested. From official government sources, of all that tested positive, 70% were asymptomatic. Edit: I rechecked, the numbers are right but apparently this has been the first test. It hasn't passed enought time to see if those that tested positive, but were asymptomatic, later on develop symptoms.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- neffy 7y agoRandom testing here in Iceland over the last week showed 0.6% infected. https://grapevine.is/news/2020/04/06/random-sampling-reveals-0-6-of-icelanders-infected-with-covid-19/ https://grapevine.is/news/2020/04/06/random-sampling-reveals... This is a useful albeit very small data point, because Iceland received its cases from both Europe (alpine ski cluster) and the US. So it puts a very loose upper bound on the incidence in the US up to the point travel to Iceland was effectively halted.
- milesvp 7y agoYou might check out https://seattleflu.org/ https://seattleflu.org/ I don’t know if they’re the only ones doing random testing, but my understanding is that they were able to put pressure on the CDC when no one in the US was legally allowed to test other than the CDC. they were somehow able to circumvent testing restrictions by claiming research status since they were in the middle of a two year flu study. In any event, I suspect the cost and difficulty of good randomized is why they needed such good funding for only a 2 year study.
- zouhair 7y agoAs said by someone else, tests are in short supply. So other ways are being tested, like testing wastewater[0]. [0]: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/03/200331092713.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/03/200331092713.h...
- bromuro 7y agoI also don’t get it - shouldn’t work better testing a random population sample and interpolate the numbers?