12 ms·
A new form of brain stimulation relieved severe depression in a small study
- Ididntdothis 7y agoSounds interesting. I wonder what’s the best way to try such a treatment without first spending tons of money and energy dealing with insurance and doctors.
- Roritharr 7y agoThis. It sounds like this should be the FIRST thing to try, rather than the last. Sadly this is not very likely how it is going to be for a very long time.
- ChrisClark 7y agoThis is very similar to electro shock treatment. Causing localised seizures. I don't really think this should be the first thing to try.
- whatshisface 7y agoIt certainly sounds dangerous, but we really ought to wait for the phase 1 trial before proclaiming that it's dangerous for sure.
- trts 7y agoThe point of ECT is to cause a seizure. The point of TMS is to achieve the same effect without causing a seizure, though there is some risk of that.
- skat20phys 7y agoThe protocol is actually fairly intensive and expensive, involving tailored brain scans and all-day treatments over multiple days. It's the sort of thing that I could see in inpatients or partial hospitalization patients, or as an intensive outpatient protocol. You'd basically have to take off a week and go in every day all day. This is promising but it's not randomized or controlled so hard to make anything of at some level (you can see how this kind of protocol would induce massive placebo effects). If there is an effect, it may be that some kind of mild version of it, say, for a day or half-day or something might be useful in more mild forms of depression. But it's an intensive expensive treatment in its own way so might be hard to implement as an initial intervention. But I agree that if it works this well it might be worth it to take a week off or a couple of days or something.
- ceejayoz 7y agoEnroll in a clinical trial. Not only will you not deal with insurance, you'll get paid for it.
- taigi100 7y agoWhere do I sign up ? :rofl:
- gramontblanc 7y agoThis reads as extremely ethically dangerous. I'm not sure it's possible to justify any course of treatment leading towards individual neurocircuitry 'tweaks', even for an unambiguously good cause. Harkens too closely to 'scientist seeks to cure homosexuality through direct brain stimulation' in the 1950s. ( en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Galbraith_Heath )
- ceejayoz 7y agoEthics in human experimentation have come a long way since the 1950s.
- gramontblanc 7y agoIs there an outside definition of medical ethics that can really be impartially compared from generation to generation? I'm certain all previous generations thought they were acting in good faith as well. Progress towards 'changing people's minds' is dangerous for the same reasons across all times and places.
- whatshisface 7y ago>Is there an outside definition of medical ethics that can really be impartially compared from generation to generation? That's a legitimate criticism of doing anything, but the problem is that it applies to, well, anything. Anything you do today could be seen as a horrifying atrocity by future generations, unless there exists some kind of boundary on what ethical stances a culture might adopt. There could be limits, but in that case there is an outside definition of medical ethics. If there isn't an outside definition then maybe in 100 years haircuts will be seen as mutilation[0]. [0] There are some cultures with strict rules about facial hair, so even though this example might sound ridiculous it actually serves to illustrate the point.
- cat199 7y ago> Is there an outside definition of medical ethics that can really be impartially compared from generation to generation? well, doctors do take a form of the hippocratic oath which dates to ~400 BC, so ...
- sneak 7y agoIs there further documentation about this, or other papers I can read? This part in particular seemed counterintuitive to me: > “The less treatment-resistant participants are, the longer the treatment lasts,” said postdoctoral scholar Eleanor Cole, PhD, a lead author of the study.
- derefr 7y agoI'm not sure exactly why, but common sense would state that, with treatment-resistant participants, you already know "1000 things that don't work", and so you've narrowed the search space. If the way they're doing this treatment involves hitting the subject with magnetic stimulation in "all possible parts of the search space" that might potentially solve the problem, then if you've already half-treated a subject (stimulated one entire side of their brain, say) and it didn't work, that means both that they're "treatment-resistant" and that the second treatment should only focus on the other half of the brain.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stupidcar 7y agoI interpreted this as “The less treatment-resistant participants are, the longer the [effects of the] treatment lasts,” which would make more sense.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- skat20phys 7y agoIn the context of the press release it was a little confusing to me because the published paper doesn't really report on anything that would be considered long-term. I assume she meant something like "the less treatment resistant, the more pronounced the effect"? Treatment resistance probably refers to prior treatments, which is a sort of indicator of severity or, well, resistance to treatment. So it makes sense to me that people who were less resistant to prior treatments would show more immediate longer-lasting effects. But it's confusing. This is impressive but it's not a randomized controlled trial at all, and it's a fairly select group of patients, so it's hard to know what to make of it. TMS treatment of depression has kind of been plagued with publication bias effects -- not to say there's no effect but more rigorous meta-analyses have suggested that publication bias is significant in the area. Sometimes with very severe patients you see more regression to the mean, in that they have bigger apparent improvements in control conditions just because they can only stay the same or get better.
- uyuioi 7y agoDepression is one the single most important economic problems the world need fixed.
- katet 7y agoNot a moral problem? Humanist? Why can't we have nice things and do this out of simple human empathy for those who suffer?
- valuearb 7y agoProduction is the state's only problem, comrade.
- uyuioi 7y agoWell. If you have depression and you’re a business owner or small trader for example. It would be impossible to get out of bed some days and feed yourself. So id say it’s one of the most important financial fixes for every human. You took it as if it needs to be a fix just so people can be happy. Happiness doesn’t mean you’re surviving.
- musingsole 7y agoYeah, right after covid and monopolies!
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI would say before these. Depression robs people of their potential to do good things.
- KaoruAoiShiho 7y agoYeah I agree, depression is a bigger deal than those things. But there's also heart disease, obesity, etc that are along the same tier of health issues with massive impact. But the #1 biggest issue imo is the length of commutes. We would all be so much more productive if we would all move to perma-WFH.
- m_a_g 7y ago90% is really high. Like actually scary high. All the previous treatments were lower than 60%. I hope everything goes well with this treatment, and there will be no serious side effects. It can save many people's lives.
- penagwin 7y agoIt looks to be a form of TMS which has already shown a lot of promise for several mental disorders. I wasn't able to look at what they changed specifically, but TMS itself is rather safe.
- stevenwoo 7y agoInstead of one long treatment in a day repeated for up to six weeks, they made it higher intensity, ten times a day, ten minute treatments on a day, repeated with patients seeing difference in three to five days and they used an MRI to target an exact location in the brain for each patient.
- penagwin 7y agoInteresting! Not to get to into it - but last summer I had a bad episode and was recommended to ECT therapy and/or TMS (I have some other mental disorders that would also benefit from TMS). My biggest problem with both of them was that for TMS I'd have to travel a distance everyday for a month, with ECT it would only be a few times a week but somebody else would have to drive me, and it's not recommended to work during that time. So this would be a game changer for me - I can take a week off no problem. On safety: I'm no medical expert, my understanding is that why TMS works is not really well understood (similar to SSRI's and other antidepressants) - we just know it _tends to work_ and we have some theories for why. So from my naive perspective higher, more concentrated doses certainly sounds like it has the potential to be more dangerous - but that's just speculation.
- grugagag 7y agoDoes TMS affect long long term memory? Or is that ECT?
- valuearb 7y agoReproducibility crisis.
- jdm2212 7y agoEither this will win the Nobel Prize, or it won't hold up. (Guess which one is more likely.) A few reasons I don't think it will hold up: - this is a university press release - N = 21 - no control group - no blinding - university press release doesn't even claim it's a new approach, just incremental improvement on an existing approach - the paper (link below) is about evaluating safety, feasibility, and "preliminary efficacy" (i.e., they're not advertising this as a robust result) Paper available here: https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.19070720 https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.1... https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/581280v3.full https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/581280v3.full
- solinent 7y agoThe criteria for what "depression" is has changed over time, no wonder our results are changing. Almost everyone has depression given the current criteria [1]. Most people have 2,4,5,6,7. The criteria is so vague your study would have to control for each item on the list. Here, they're not even using that criteria, and instead just using a simple test which involves self-reports. Placebo could be a huge factor here. [1] https://www.psycom.net/depression-definition-dsm-5-diagnostic-criteria/ https://www.psycom.net/depression-definition-dsm-5-diagnosti...
- simiones 7y agoI would highly dispute that "almost everyone" experiences any of these symptoms (note that they must happen "(almost) every day"). You've also missed a very important requirement: "To receive a diagnosis of depression, these symptoms must cause the individual clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning." You might accuse this definition of being too subjective. But it is certainly not something that includes "almost everyone".
- solinent 7y ago> To receive a diagnosis of depression, these symptoms must cause the individual clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning. I'd say most of the lower class has this issue. > But it is certainly not something that includes "almost everyone". How do you know this? edit: maybe almost everyone is too much, I mean about 97% of the population.
- slothtrop 7y agoAs soon as I saw "magnetic stimulation" I was a tad skeptical as they've already achieved this with brain electrodes in the past. The difference is it could actually be practical, on psych visits. I see it as a stand-in for medication with all sorts of side-effects. Not a solution mind-you, just a way to bridge the gap to recover, which is what medication is meant to be. EDIT: a stand-out line: "One month after the therapy, 60% of participants were still in remission from depression. Follow-up studies are underway to determine the duration of the antidepressant effects."
- elric 7y agoTMS immediately dials my skepticism up to 11 as well. But there's some fairly good evidence that is helps people who suffer from migraines with aura. From what I understand, it has something to do with increased cortical excitability in migraineurs, and TMS is somehow able to reduce that effect. I don't know how this would translate to depression treatment, but it's interesting nevertheless.
- taurath 7y agoIndividual TMS is really interesting. My understanding was that most large-scale TMS was untargeted and not really that effective. I was about to write something about a side effect I had read, which was about people losing the ability to swim, but that apparently a DBS (deep brain stimulation) side effect for tremors from parkinsons.
- 0xcde4c3db 7y agoOne thing to note is that the study population consisted entirely of severely depressed people. As far as I've read about it, the current consensus seems to be that the more severe the depression is, the more likely it is to respond to medical interventions as opposed to psychological/behavioral ones. This ties in to a broader understanding that depressive disorders are considerably heterogeneous and no single theory or treatment target is relevant to all cases. So while this may be a genuine breakthrough, I hope people don't get the idea that it's the cure for depression generally.
- yboris 7y ago> the more severe [a problem] is, the more likely it is to respond to [some shock] I think there's a generalizable pattern - regression to the mean. In psychiatry, ECT (Electroconvulsive therapy) seems to be very effective in some severe cases: https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/electroconvulsive-therapy/about/pac-20393894 https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/electroconvulsiv... I'm hopeful that the Stanford technique becomes yet another tool we have to address some of the hardest-to-treat problems.
- starpilot 7y ago> As far as I've read about it, the current consensus seems to be that the more severe the depression is, the more likely it is to respond to medical interventions as opposed to psychological/behavioral ones. I've never heard this in my life, can you link? These test subjects were people with treatment-resistant depression though, which I have as well. My experience, along with others I've known with it, is that we're more likely to deal with nocebo effects. HN is tossing heaps of cynicism on this report but even for unblinded testing these results are remarkable. > “There’s never been a therapy for treatment-resistant depression that’s broken 55% remission rates in open-label testing,” said Nolan Williams, MD, assistant professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences and a senior author of the study
- 0xcde4c3db 7y agoI suppose consensus might not be the right word; maybe something closer to bias or even superstition might be appropriate. But basically, I'm synthesizing my own view of several trends here. That being the case, I don't have a link that neatly sums this up. Perhaps this is even my own little hallucination. I'm only an expert by comparison to the general public, in the sense that I periodically try to survey the literature with the most open mind I can manage. But the components I'm thinking of are mostly: 1) A sense that antidepressants tend to work better the more severe the depression is. This often comes up as a counterpoint to the anti-antidepressant talking point that SSRIs "don't outperform placebo" (often, in turn, in reference to studies that directly or indirectly exclude or otherwise under-represent people with severe depression). 2) A sense that the more severe a person's condition is, the less likely that psychotherapy is to be effective, at least as a first-line treatment. There's a lot of heat over whether or why this is the case, with a common refrain among advocates of psychotherapy being that some people need antidepressant drugs temporarily in order to be able to "do the work" of psychotherapy. 3) A longstanding belief among various people in the field that "melancholic" depression is both more severe/treatment-resistant/chronic/personality-based and more amenable to biologically-oriented interventions. There is a particular thread of HPA-axis (hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal) [1] dysfunction that has been a subject of research for decades and continues to attract interest, with a more specific clinical focus being the dexamethasone suppression test (e.g. [2]). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothalamic%E2%80%93pituitary%E2%80%93adrenal_axis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothalamic%E2%80%93pituitary... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27736954 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27736954
- loughnane 7y agoAnyone able to find the actual paper? I'm having a difficult time locating it. EDIT: Here it is [0] [0] https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.19070720 https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.1...
- yewenjie 7y agoImportant note: this result is not from a randomized controlled trial, and have been done on small number of subjects. The article mentions that the researcher are designing a larger and proper trial.
- propinquity 7y agoIs this the same concept as ECT?
- MelioRatio 7y agoHere is the published study including an abstract, for those interested: https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.19070720 https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.1... This new form of rTMS appears to have truly incredible potential to help people whose depression is otherwise resistant to treatment, which is sorely needed. Having over 85% of participants meet remission criteria is, to put it mildly, incredible, though with only 21 participants, sample size is too small to make conclusions regarding large scale effectiveness. As the paper notes, we now need double-blind trials. I very much hope that this treatment will be able to help people on a larger scale.
- GenericThrow123 7y agoThese incredible numbers will almost certainly drop in larger trials and once more medication resistant participants are included in a study. ECT is comparable to the efficacy of this small scale trial, but their novel approach and increased dosage could yield a major improvement to TMS. Also, here's the biorxiv link to the full study: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/581280v3.full.pdf https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/581280v3.full.pdf
- mattkrause 7y agoDefinitely need RCTs with good blinding. Placebo effects can play merry hell with depression, and even moreso when the patient is treated with fancy technology that has a noticeable side-effect.
- curiousgal 7y agoI hold the prejudiced opinion that most, if not all, psychology research is bogus. It's the one field with the most abuse of statistics and a crisis of reproducibility that dates back to the last century.
- mindfulplay 7y agoAgreed! Asking people how they feel and jotting that down on a piece of paper isn't science. Similar to social and nutrition "sciences" that gear more toward PR angle and "number of news outlets talking about my paper" than legit science. They should all be relegated back to the arts and crafts.
- solinent 7y agoIt's all based on self-reports, it's very hard to account for individual differences in how people answer the questions and to control for those factors. I agree wholeheartedly. However, certain types of severe depression seem to have a biological basis. Inflammatory cytokines may play a role. The "leaky gut" theory seems to be what's helped me personally.
- victorbojica 7y agoDid it help with your depression ? Can you give more details into your issue ? Thx.
- solinent 7y agoI had severe depression, almost unable to move, complete anhedonia. I was still doing well at work (until the unable to move part got worse), but literally nothing made me happy. There was nothing about my life situation that could have caused it. The doctors would tell me that I'm completely fine, except my optometrist, who found that my dry eye might have been caused by auto-immune issues. I followed up with a ER doctor (I'm in Canada, very hard to find a good GP) and he ordered a newer test which determined I have anti-ccp antibodies, which signal inflammatory cytokines. I was having stomach issues at the time, but I thought it was the depression, the primary symptom of depression is felt in the gut, or so I was told. I found the auto-immune protocol after talking with an elderly woman who had RA. I had to cut out quite a bit of food, and found it very difficult. Finally, I tried a ketogenic diet. Surprisingly, after one week I was feeling better! My depression lifted, though all my physical symptoms remained, I found myself running for 30 minutes or exercising without even willing it. I then switched to a pure carnivore diet, which is a subset of the ketogenic diet. I felt even better. I've heard the Wahl's protocol is another similar method to solve this problem. Right now, every time I eat too many vegetables, sugars, or anything high in fibre I have an issue. I think my issue was a combination of very high insulin resistance (I ate tons of pizza in my uni days) and some allergy. I think I'm allergic to dioxin and glyphosate which is sprayed on all vegetables these days. An alternative to the carnivore diet which seems to work anecdotally is the Wahl's protocol, it's just very difficult to procure and find that much variety of vegetables. There's this MD on youtube, Ken Berry. I've found the advice he gives to be tremendously helpful. Liver is a wonderful health food.
- lstodd 7y agoThis is equivalent to banging the brain with a sledgehammer. No thanks, I prefer ketamine. At least it feels like a gentler one.
- Natsu 7y agoThat's great until you find someone with underlying psychosis and the voices in their head after a few months of treatment tell them to take out a big knife and go for a murder/suicide. It's great for the people it works for, but Spravato/esketamine isn't for everyone.
- Jugglerofworlds 7y agoAs someone who has schizoaffective disorder, I take offense to your assertion that psychosis=murderer. Your claim only serves to perpetuate the stigma attached to psychosis, when the disease itself is already bad enough. Coincidentally, I happened to have taken ketamine infusions for depression long before I was diagnosed with schizoaffective.
- Natsu 7y ago> As someone who has schizoaffective disorder, I take offense to your assertion that psychosis=murderer. I did not mean to imply that. I was relating a real event that I personally observed.
- lstodd 7y agoYou seriously believe this magnetic thing is for everyone?
- Natsu 7y agoNo, and I cannot fathom why you would believe that could be implied by my response. Lots of people are reading things I didn't write. I merely asserted that there exist people for whom Spravato/esketamine is not the answer and related my own experience with having someone very close to me treated with it. That's it. Every other random implication is from someone reading things that I didn't write. And it's sad, because esketamine really looked like a good treatment at first. It made real improvements for a while. As you might imagine, it was discontinued immediately after that incident.
- PragmaticPulp 7y agoActual paper is available here: https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.19070720 https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.1... n=21, no control group, zero blinding. Placebo response is notoriously high in depression studies, so it's unacceptable that they didn't include a control group. This technique is a variant of rTMS, which has been around for a long time. We've had years of positive rTMS study results that failed to replicate in real-world conditions. There's some early evidence that it might do something positive, but it's not clear that it's a viable treatment option. In most major cities you can usually find at least one obscure rTMS clinic somewhere, but they won't offer the exact rTMS technique studied here. They also won't give you 50 sessions across 5 days as used in this study. It's very disappointing, even suspicious, that they didn't include a control group. It's trivially easy to include a sham rTMS treatment because the patients can't see the magnetic field. At minimum, they could have split the group into low-dose and high-dose to demonstrate a dose-response relationship. Yet they deliberately chose to avoid any control group or dose-response measurements. I can't access the full text, so I don't know when they measured the patients' depressive symptoms. If they scored the depression inventory on the final day of the 5-day treatment, this wouldn't be very promising as a long-term treatment. The real test would be how the depression remission holds up after the rTMS treatment is discontinued. If the remission persists for months, that would be truly impressive. On the other hand, if this only works with 50 in-office rTMS sessions per week, it's not a practical outpatient treatment. I would love to be wrong and for this to be the holy grail of depression treatment, but given the circumstances I think it's best interpreted as an outlier study unless/until someone else reproduces it. I don't think we'll all be going in for 50 sessions of rTMS across 5 days any time soon.
- ipunchghosts 7y agoHow do papers like this get published? This is a conference paper at best.
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> How do papers like this get published? This is a conference paper at best. The why is obvious: It's #1 on Hacker News right now, and spreading like a wildfire across my social media. People love to hear about promising new depression treatments, because we all know someone who suffers from depression. Strangely, most rTMS papers follow similar patterns: No control groups, small sample sizes, questionable methodology. The methodological issues would have been trivially easy to correct from the start, so I assume the omission of control groups is intentional. I think it's geared toward generating publicity and drumming up grant money. The core rTMS technique seems to do something for depression, so it would be great if someone could translate that into a practical, sustainable treatment.
- greendestiny_re 7y agoIf you're feeling depressed, you might be helped by a—warm bath. A 2017 Freiburg study [1] took 36 moderately clinically depressed patients and assigned 17 to 30-minute, 40 °C hyperthermic baths, with 19 as control. After bathing twice a week for four weeks, the study claims the 17 patients had a "moderate but significant improvement". [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5371197/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5371197/
- saltyfever 7y agoPeople must not want to hear the truth, hence your downvotes. Most forms of depression can be cured with self-care. "In health care, self-care is any necessary human regulatory function which is under individual control, deliberate and self-initiated."
- lukifer 7y agoI think Johann Hari has the gist right: in the vast majority of cases, depression is a signal from the body of some biological/social/emotional needs that aren't being met, rather than necessarily being an immutable medical condition. For n=1, I've struggled with (manic) depression and anxiety most of my life. And while I've used a variety of strategies to cope (Seligman's "Learned Optimism" and a potpourri of Buddhist ideas were incredibly helpful), the secret sauce was getting off of sugar and junk food. When I'm staying on a whole-foods, keto-ish diet, mood swings and unwanted negative thoughts have their volume is turned down by 90%, making the remainder relatively easy to process. Everybody's different, so YMMV; in some cases, medication are an appropriate tool. But there are some universals that basically benefit every human: drink more water, get more sleep, go for a walk in the sunshine, eat your vegetables, and the less sugar (probably) the better.
- gramontblanc 7y agoThe phenomenological impact of poor diet and harsh glycemic index ASDR cannot be overstated. 'refined sugars negatively impact mood and emotional well-being' might be one of the most rock solid universals of human nature. All medical interventions should include the no-brainer diet, vitamins, exercise, self-esteem interventions.
- TheLegace 7y ago> Intermittent theta-burst stimulation (iTBS) is a noninvasive brain stimulation treatment that has been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for treatment-resistant depression. If this is anything like Neurofeedback treatment, it wouldn't surprise me that it is effective. Neurofeedback treats 3 major frequency ranges of the brain, Delta, Theta and Alpha. Although this treatment seems passive whereas Neurofeedback treatment requires active modulation and stimulation by the person getting the treatment. Going through Neurofeedback treatment myself and seeing the incredible life changes because of it and now seeing the similarity of the affected brain regions in this study shows that there might be some consensus reached on treating these conditions without medication one day.
- elric 7y agoThat sounds interesting. Do you have any links with more information regarding that neurofeedback treatment?
- TheLegace 7y agoI found out about it in this book The Body Keeps the Score[1]. Its a massive book, so I would just focus on the Neurofeedback section. But it doesn't have the first hand experience so mileage may vary. By co-incidence the researcher that pioneered this breakthrough treatment was located in the same city as me. You can see some of the videos[2], but it will be difficult to understand and appreciate unless you spend a lot of time reading papers and learning about the brain. I will say its worth it to learn, especially if you want your ability to focus to go from below average to far above average. Feel free to email me if you want details, I had to become well versed at it out of necessity more than anything. [1]https://www.amazon.com/Body-Keeps-Score-Healing-Trauma/dp/B00OBT7KAO/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=Trauma&qid=1586284274&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.com/Body-Keeps-Score-Healing-Trauma/dp/B0... [2] http://addcentre.com/page-34/page-28/media.html http://addcentre.com/page-34/page-28/media.html
- pyryt 7y agoDo I understand correctly that they basically: 1. find the subpart of your brain that causes you to be depressed 2. use TMS to essentially block that region from being so active ? Wonder if you could use this one day also for the regions that cause me to e.g. procrastinate...
- ck2 7y agoum, where does 90% come from? Only about HALF of patients who undergo this treatment improve, and only about a THIRD experience remission from depression. and then One month after the therapy, 60% of participants were still in remission from depression this isn't a magic wand but one tool in a toolbox
- backtoyoujim 7y agoyeah like i want the only thing that has stayed with me my whole life to leave.
- szczepano 7y agoI was 100% sure it is weed.
- jonathanwallace 7y agoSounds like mesmerism!
- Huijaaja42 7y agoNot almost everyone can be depressed or then the definition of depressed is incorrect.
- alexandercrohde 7y agoSince this isn't double-blind, I wonder if there's reason to upvote it to the top of HN now versus after the research progresses a little more. Sometimes early signal, even if inaccurate, is very valuable (e.g. bitcoin). With alleged medical advances, I almost never find that to be the case (I can't recall the number of times I've read about cancer being beaten here).
- markroseman 7y agoReading some of the comments is a good reminder that solid and meaningful mental health research is very tough and expensive, just based on the sheer variability, which can't be meaningfully captured by 99.9% of studies. Each needs to be seen as one piece in a much, much larger puzzle. I wrote up some of the problems with doing/interpreting mental health research here: https://mhnav.com/lies-and-evidence/ https://mhnav.com/lies-and-evidence/
- starpilot 7y agoThis is some of the worst HN commentary I've seen. Boundless cynicism on an early study which is actually showing unusually high success rate. What's noteworthy is that the these results are good among unblinded studies on depression treatment. They are doing a double-blind study right now, mentioned in the second sentence. These were patients with treatment-resistant depression, which is defined as people who have undergone multiple treatments without success and are rife with nocebo tendencies. These are not people who are hopeful about their nth medication or round of talk therapy. They are tough nuts to crack. That the treatment is showing any success with this group is worth doing further studies.
- fallingfrog 7y agoIf stimulating some part of the brain can increase neural activity in a lasting way, could you use this to, say, make yourself better at math? Or, could you use it to suppress unrest by making everyone happy? If this works there are a lot of larger implications.
- jnaddef 7y ago> The researchers are conducting a larger, double-blinded trial in which half the participants are receiving fake treatment. This second sentence from the article is enough: let us not comment on an experiment that had no control group. I will be interested in the results from the second trial though.
- markroseman 7y agoI agree. There's not a chance that it will be enough to change practice at this early stage, but it will be interesting.
- steve76 7y agoI want to see if they can restore circulation for a low risk non-invasive treatment of hemianopsia. I saw sometimes when circulation is restored for an unrelated treatment of more critical need, sometimes hemianopsia goes away. No one will risk it when they can just turn their head. If magnetic stimulation gets to this point, would it be more of a risk than just precise surgery? Would it still be hit or miss? Is restoring circulation actually doing it or something else? If you get to the point where you can restore site through electromagnetism, would it less risk and more reliable to use genetics? Take someone's genome, recreate a model of the trauma, and personalize a blood thinner like they personalize chemotherapy?
- cbsmith 7y agoHN click bait. Actual title is: Stanford researchers devise treatment that relieved depression in 90% of participants in small study.
- cpeterso 7y agoHere is a short interview with comedian Neal Brennan about his personal experiences with (40 30-minute sessions) of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation. He says it was more effective and longer lasting than Ketamine Therapy or Zoloft. He was able to stop taking Zoloft. https://youtu.be/vB9DHMOiojE https://youtu.be/vB9DHMOiojE This is an excerpt from a longer interview about his depression: https://youtu.be/FfsUxrGmbdU https://youtu.be/FfsUxrGmbdU
- johnward 7y agoI've done transcranial magnetic stimulation for my bipolar depression. Didn't seem to help. It's a pain to try to work and go for treatments every day. Meds work better for me.
- awaythrower 7y agoAssuming, on the off chance, that this isn't some sort of quack treatment ploy, anything that works significantly would be a plus. I'm on my 13th antidepressant now that is yet-again not working well and I'm starting to wonder if my condition is inflammation-mediated rather than receptor- or neurotransmitter-caused as only mirtazapine (also a powerful antihistamine) ever helped me significantly, but only for a limited time.
- 1_player 7y agoObvious disclaimer that every depression is different. My depressive symptoms have never been medicated yet I'm pretty sure are inflammation-based: changes in my diet drastically affect my mental and physical well-being. Exercise, lifestyle changes help, but diet seems to be the primary cause and solution in my case.