7 ms·
Remdesivir is an analog of adenosine, one of the four building blocks of RNA. Just look at the main structure and you'll agree they look similar. It turns out t
by kccqzy 7y ago
Remdesivir is an analog of adenosine, one of the four building blocks of RNA. Just look at the main structure and you'll agree they look similar. It turns out the mechanism of action of this drug is that it's supposed to be confused with adenosine, so that the viral RNA replication process uses remdesivir instead of adenosine, which later breaks the RNA†.
Our body, or really, all biological processes can synthesize incredibly complicated molecules that can take human chemists a huge amount of effort to synthesize. It really is amazing how awesome our body is.
†: My description here is a dumbed down description. For a more precise description see section 2 of Arguments in favour of remdesivir for treating SARS-CoV-2 infections, Wen-Chien Ko et al, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0924857920300832 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092485792...
- nbabitskiy 7y ago>> look at the main structure and you'll agree I don't know much about RNA, but this sentence is pure bs. How would I know where to look in RNA sequences?
- cma 7y agoI think he means look in the structure of the adenosine molecule, not the structure of the virus's RNA.
- numpad0 7y agoLet’s call it the Ocean’s Eleven Phenomenon, the moment when two or more experts be like “See that? There.” “Yeah, Christ, that’s totally that” “yeah... 5 years old would notice” and you just stand in between dumbfounded
- Aloha 7y agoI've been stuck in this uncanny valley before, and caused the phenomenon to happen to others too.
- nbabitskiy 7y agoI could certainly believe that "similar" molecules behave alike, but it would be a cheap belief, like e.g. some of my friends believe in psychics. There would be no discovery, just a pseudo-scientific bullying.
- kccqzy 7y agoWell you can look at the structures on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Adenosin.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Adenosin.svg and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Remdesivir.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Remdesivir.svg See how both of them have a ribose ring? And then the functional group attached to be 1' carbon, that's also similar to adenine.
- GavinMcG 7y agoNext time, before you state that a sentence "is pure bs", consider applying the principle of charity and wondering whether you might be in the wrong. Here, you misread. OP said "they look similar" and "they" refers to remdesivir and adenosine, from the prior sentence's clause "Remdesivir is an analog of adenosine".
- dang 7y agoThis comment broke the site guidelines. Even if you're right, it is a problem to address another user this way, because the container isn't strong enough to hold that level of (let's call it) energy. When you post like this, you're breaking the already-weak bonds that hold this community together, which is what makes it a moderation issue. Would you mind taking a look at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules when posting? Those rules are all there because of past problems in the threads. Note this one: "Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine."
- nbabitskiy 7y agoI agree, and I'm sorry. I can see how this kind of reaction to a nonsense statement can become problematic, if everybody uses it.
- dang 7y agoAppreciated!
- heurifk 7y agoNormal cells also use RNA during protein synthesis. Why doesn't remdesivir disrupt that too and kills healthy cells?
- est31 7y agoThere is no RNA cloning machinery in our cells. The RNA is instead copied from the DNA in the nucleus. Viruses like the coronavirus actually bring their own RNA cloning machinery that's assembled by the cell. Remdesivir only blocks the RNA cloning proteins of the virus.
- rocqua 7y agoDoesn't that mean that Remdesivir would essentially defeat _all_ RNA viruses? Or is the effectiveness dependent on the exact RNA cloning mechanism used by the virus?
- rwmj 7y agoYes, it was originally invented to treat ebola, but it's thought to have general antiviral properties against RNA viruses.
- lisk1 7y agoThere are a lot more RNA virus specifically targeting antivirals surprised that most of them are not yet tested.
- malwarebytess 7y agosounds like we should get on it
- rwmj 7y agoAccording to this radio programme[1] I was listening to at the weekend, scientists have been warning about the potential of coronaviruses to cause a pandemic for a long time, and saying we should work on general antivirals for them. Obviously that didn't happen. [1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000gvd1 https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000gvd1
- ashildr 7y agoThis mode of action is fascinating, some HIV medications work in a similar way. What I’m curious about is why this huge group attached to the adenosine-like group is needed. It seems to be rather complex for being a shoe to be thrown into cellular gear. Do you have an idea or pointer into the mode of action of this group?
- DrAwdeOccarim 7y agoI'm not familiar with the synthesis development of remdesivir, but typically those side groups are discovered through a process called Structure Activity Relationship (SAR). The basic idea is you start with a bunch of different compounds (like 1000's) and look at their ability to interfere with a specific enzyme in a high-throughput screen. When you rank the 1000's of compounds, some will work better than others. Then you compare the structures of the top hits and look for similarities. So in this case those huge groups attached to the adenosine likley improve binding to the enzyme because they're greasy/hydrophibic. So then you add different greasy groups to new compounds and screen those. So will be worse, but sometimes some will be better. Then you look at the better ones, like having a nitrile group off the 1' position of the ribose and maybe that started as an amine (I'm making shit up here) and they decided to make it stick further out (IDK). Anyway, I did some quick looking at it seems like remdesivir is a prodrug that gets modified by other enzymes to become triphosphorylated and then incorporated into the RNA genome of the virus (https://www.nature.com/articles/nature17180/figures/1 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature17180/figures/1). So they got super lucky finding it! Check out that paper for the story.
- ashildr 7y agoThanks, I’ll have some reading to do on easter, now :-)
- ImaCake 7y agoSo looking at the wiki page image of Remdesivir [1] I can see that this looks a lot like the sugar-phosphate backbone that is integral to DNA and RNA. If you imagine DNA as a curling ladder, the nucleoside (adenosine) is the steps, and the sugar-phosphate pairs make up the rails on either side of the steps. The adenosine bit is attached to a five carbon sugar (pentagon with O at top) which is identical to the sugar it would be attached to in RNA. The next thing along is a phosphate with some oxygens double bonded to it, which is part of the "backbone" of DNA. The stuff attached to that phosphate is nothing like DNA or RNA. Hope this makes sense and provides a little insight for you :) 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remdesivir https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remdesivir
- xg15 7y agoOut of curiosity: We seem to have a very good understanding how synthesis in biological processes works (from DNA to the eventual molecules), we are able to create DNA/RNA molecules with arbitrary content and we're increasingly able to simulate what molecule a particular nucleotide sequence would produce. So, putting the three together, would it be possible to use actual biosynthesis for designed molecules by basically writing your own DNA/RNA and inserting it into a cell? (Or is this already what's being done?)
- SanderSantema 7y agoI'm no expert, but I believe it's indeed what they're already doing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_bacteria#Pharmaceutical_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_bacteria#... But if I could make a guess I'd say that it in theory it might be relatively straightforward or easy to do but it's probably a lot harder in practice. That's often the case anyways.
- joyj2nd 7y agoShort answer: Yes Long answer: No. It would be an incredibly complex undertaking.
- cowboysauce 7y agoin theory it's possible, in practice it's not. DNA encodes the information on how to produce to proteins. Proteins can catalyze chemical reactions. But there's no straightforward to look at a nucleotide sequence and figure out what it's corresponding protein does. Nor can we design proteins with arbitrary functions. The entire thing is so unimaginably complex. For example, for a lot proteins that are catalysts (aka enzymes) the actual catalytic part is a metal ion and the protein mostly provides scaffolding. A nucleotide sequence alone doesn't directly tell you what ion is needed. In some cases, multiple ions can fit, but only one actually results in the protein work. This the basis for how a lot of toxic metal exert their toxic effects. It's also not as simple as a nucleotide sequence codes for a protein and that's it. Proteins fold into their final shape from the chain of amino acids that DNA encodes. Protein folding in general is a hard problem. Biological proteins may have other proteins (called chperonins) that help them fold into their proper configuration. Then proteins may also be modified after they've folded (again by other proteins). Some proteins are made up of multiple sub-units as well.
- pfdietz 7y agoThere has been exciting work on directed evolution of enzymes for drug synthesis, particularly for transamination (conversion of a ketone to an amine). This is I believe being used commercially now, for example for the production of the diabetes drug sitagliptin. https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2010/10/06/chemical_biology_engineering_enzymes https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2010/10/06/ch... https://chemistry-europe.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ejoc.201500852 https://chemistry-europe.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002...
- koboll 7y agoThis is such a great description. Compare how Wikipedia describes the same process [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adenosine#Research https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adenosine#Research]: > The adenosine analog NITD008 has been reported to directly inhibit the recombinant RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of the dengue virus by terminating its RNA chain synthesis. This interaction suppresses peak viremia and rise in cytokines and prevents lethality in infected animals, raising the possibility of a new treatment for this flavivirus. Absolute gibberish to someone with limited knowledge of biology.
- whatshisface 7y agoGibberish to someone with limited knowledge of biology, but significantly more informative for someone who is using Wikipedia as a reference source and not a textbook.
- javajosh 7y agoI'm not so sure about that. I've read wikipedia articles about subjects I know well and found the language to be needlessly packed with jargon such that it could at least momentarily dazzle and confuse the inventor of the subject himself! Rigorously precise language (e.g. "jargon") is almost never needed for a top-line description of a thing, and I think should be discouraged, in general. Yes, highly technical descriptions targeted toward professionals and academics in the field have their place in wikipedia, but ought to be relegated to periodic additions to the body of the article. That's just my opinion, of course, but as such I think its quite correct and admirably justified!
- prewett 7y agoFeynman shared your opinion, so I’d say you’re in good company!
- vikramkr 7y agoI agree in general, but in this case the extra information is sort of irrelevant - do we really need to say "in this flavivirus?" Something much better as an overall description might be "Remdesivir is an adenosine analogue that chain terminates RNA dependent rna synthesis, inhibiting viral replication" or something like that. Use the molecule name instead of a label, general instead of specific, and if you are talking about dengue in particular - why refer to it as a flavivirus? Who cares in this context? Just say "dengue" again instead of "this flavivirus." And, I don't think the drug has been empirically demonstrated to inhibit cytokine storms etc, that should qualify the description of the imputed mechanism of action by clarifying that it's the hypothesized effect the drug will have.