11 ms·
>The survivors/protagonists of the zombie plague are the viewpoint the audience is intended to empathize with, but their response to the shambling horde is as b
by Barrin92 7y ago
>The survivors/protagonists of the zombie plague are the viewpoint the audience is intended to empathize with, but their response to the shambling horde is as brutal and violent as any plantation owner's reaction to their slaves rising, and it speaks to a peculiarly American cognitive disorder, elite panic.
Elite panic is the phenomenon by which rich and/or privileged people imagine that in times of chaos all social constraints break down and everyone around them will try to rob, rape, and murder them. To some extent this reflects their own implicit belief that humanity is by nature grasping, avaricious, amoral, and cruel, and that their status depends on power and violence. It's a world-view you'd expect of unreconstructed pre-Enlightenment aristocrats, or maybe a society dominated by a violent slave-owning elite.
This is such a salient point. It's something I've noticed when someone recommended me The Walking dead years ago. It's horrendous how reactionary and borderline fascist that show is in its nihilistic display of humanity where tribal survival is all that matters and every individual encountered is almost certainly some sort of rapist or cannibal and just needs to be stomped out. At one point I was thinking if the show is actually pushing this narrative so hard as to parody it but it certainly doesn't seem to be viewed that way.
- biztos 7y ago“Fear the Walking Dead” deals with these questions very explicitly. One of the main characters is what you could call a zombie sympathizer.
- ilamont 7y ago"I am Legend" not only portrayed surviving humans as more sympathetic toward each other, but even humanized the infected zombies (to a degree). The zombies had a leader, and he was motivated not by a desire to kill humans, but by what appeared to be desperate love of someone taken from him. I won't give any more details, but if you haven't seen it, it's a great film.
- sigzero 7y agoThe book and the film diverge. It's still a good film. The alternate ending is way better.
- yellow_postit 7y agoThe alternate ending better lines up with the book.
- maxerickson 7y agoIn the novella, humans are treated quite differently than in the Will Smith movie.
- the8472 7y agoMost of the media zombie scenarios create very hostile environments and rapid breakdown of society. They're essentially engineered to create this situation. The zombies spread the disease actively. Near 100% conversion rate (immunities or asymptomatic cases are extremely rare). Incubating individuals will turn on those around them. And of course there often is a lack of genre awareness, the very concept of a zombie apocalypse is unknown. This converts almost the entire population into hostiles. If you don't get all combative you become part of the zombie horde. So there's a huge selection bias. This is hardly comparable to covid where essential functions of society are still working and the infected are not going out of their way to infect more people. And even now we're already seeing countries finger-pointing and adopting an everyone-for-themselves attitude around medical equipment.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoMost of the infected aren't going out of their way and infecting people. A small number of the infected are acting with, at least, reckless disregard for the possibility of infecting others.
- chippy 7y agoThere has been one study on the influenza virus that says that people who are asymptomatic are more social than normal. The simple hypotheses is that the virus wants the host to spread as much as possible.
- acdha 7y agoThat was a small evo-psych study (38 people) and it wasn’t a study of the flu but rather the vaccine so there are other possibilities. It’s certainly possible but I’d avoid giving it much weight without more data.
- rpiguy 7y agoHis observation is wrong. In all societies in which there is a power vacuum gangs take over. Witness Africa, South America, Burma, and the middle Eastern countries in which we have removed the “dictators.” Asia after WW2 was different because the West essentially sponsored state corporate Facism in Japan and Korea until they had 30-50 years to evolve into something resembling a true democracy. Even the term “elite panic” is lie. The elite are fine in a disaster and they know it. Look at Venezuela, the rich and elite simply moved behind walls and continue on. They have ways of isolating themselves and maintaining separation from the rabble. The panic strikes the middle class more than any other group, because their status is the most easily lost. Unlike the rich, their power goes away with their jobs. Their lifestyle, however much you’d like to mock trips to Starbucks, weekend shopping at Pottery Barn, and all that - it all goes away. The tenuous advantage they’ve built up vanishes. The truly elite use that fear. They aren’t afraid themselves.
- Veen 7y agoYes. Stross’ article is old-fashioned pre-Pomo Marxist literary criticism—and is about as insightful as that genre usually is.
- rpiguy 7y agoExactly.
- dang 7y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here. Especially not name-calling ones. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Veen 7y agoThere is no name-calling in my comment, which is merely an expression of my (rather obvious) view that the analytical framework Stross employs to critique zombie literature is drawn from Marxist literary theory, rather than, say, New Criticism, formalism, romanticism, structuralism, or any of the other analytical frameworks he might have adopted.
- setgree 7y agoWalking Dead starts out Rick-against-everyone but veers towards a story about scrappy, regular folk coming together to more or less form a democracy, against a backdrop of total chaos. I read this as retelling a certain story of America, with the zombies standing in for brutal nature (and Native Americans!) and the protagonists the Europeans, creating a few different outposts of "civilization". I wrote about this reading here: https://blogtarkin.wordpress.com/tag/walking-dead/ https://blogtarkin.wordpress.com/tag/walking-dead/
- sneak 7y ago> It's a world-view you'd expect of unreconstructed pre-Enlightenment aristocrats, or maybe a society dominated by a violent slave-owning elite. This really hit home for me. It has always struck me as supremely odd, the civilization-breakdown fantasies that people have when I suggest that everyone in a society, not just the police, have easy and unrestrained access to arms, as advocated by many throughout history. This seems to be their worldview: without the threat of cop (with superior firepower than any random person), that society will devolve into this immediately, every fender bender or bit of road rage turning into life or death conflict. It’s plainly wrong on its face, even without invoking the reality that there are many peaceful and prosperous places in the US wherein the private arms significantly outnumber those of the state. I have tried for a long time to understand this view, and Charlie just dropped in the missing puzzle piece. This almost makes up for how wrong he’s been about bitcoin.
- dane-pgp 7y ago> ... that society will devolve into this immediately, every fender bender or bit of road rage turning into life or death conflict. To provide context, here is some data on that: "cases of road rage involving a firearm — where someone brandished a gun or fired one at a driver or passenger — more than doubled to 620 in 2016, from 247 in 2014." https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/25/us/road-rage-guns.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/25/us/road-rage-guns.html That doesn't amount to "civilization-breakdown", but whether it's a level that's worth worrying about is something different people will feel differently about. I suspect it is a higher number of cases (per capita) than many other countries with stricter gun laws.
- throwaway894345 7y agoAny idea what the driver (pun not intended) is on that increase? Were more guns sold? Did people abruptly start driving more?
- sneak 7y agoHow many of those were would-be fistfights that were de-escalated to nonviolence by brandishing (literally: holding a weapon) by a victim? A lot of casually violent people become a lot more polite when they realize they don’t get to punch or beat whomever they like. That’s a good outcome, to me, but that figure lumps it in with violence where people get shot, mixing good gun-related outcomes with bad ones, as if brandishing is an end in itself to be prevented. You can’t really stop road ragers from getting out of their car with the intent to hit someone. You can indeed convince them that attacking armed strangers is a bad idea—without anyone being hurt. Providing context means, well, providing context, not just tossing out a composite figure without background or breakdown. A good actual context for that would be the not-gun-related road rage assault figures before and after, and what percentage of that increase is brandished (no one injured) vs shot/shot at (violence that should be prevented/reduced).
- ghufran_syed 7y agoThe original paper is pretty interesting, and much more nuanced than Stross’s summary. “Our claim is most controversial,and tenuous, regarding the idea of elite panic.We believe that elites panic just as non-elites do. Because the positions they occupy command the power to move resources, elite panic is more consequential than public panic.” The paper overall references the fact that that historically, people in authority assume the public will panic, and most data suggests that they don’t. And ‘elites’ in this context means those in authority, not “rich and/or privileged people”. They actually discus three possibilities: that 1) elites fear panic 2) elites cause panic 3) elites themselves panic However, the paper certainly doesn’t suggest that ‘elites’ are somehow more prone to panic than the rest of society. “Elites and Panic : more to fear than fear itself” Clarke and Chess Pdf at https://moscow.sci-hub.tw/2964/7c0b4f9dec1b897ad09a6565ffbfcb3b/10.2307@20430900.pdf https://moscow.sci-hub.tw/2964/7c0b4f9dec1b897ad09a6565ffbfc...
- yeahthi999 7y agoAll media should be viewed as satire It’s so emotionally compressed into one vibe and hyper stylized visually how anyone can sit down with the intent of making real sense of it is bizarre. It’s highly customized to satisfy a target audience. Not generalized like so much other media. Go interact with real people, or create your own. I’ve been curating a space opera for a decade. 3,000+ typed pages. I have no desire to give it up to the public and find it almost meditative. Haven’t seen any of the new SW movies, or sci fi in the last decade. I borrow ideas as Lucas, etc did. It all just flows. I don’t really owe society a financial return on my endeavors either. Grew up this way though. I honestly don’t care if anyone ever finds value in my efforts. Putting in work to satisfy others isn’t why I get up in the morning. Let go of market economics and free yourself to be a multi disciplinarian.
- wken 7y agoIf all media were satire, we would call it satire and not media.
- WalterBright 7y agoYou don't have to guess at what happens when governments collapse. Just look at what happened to Europe in 1945. https://www.amazon.com/Savage-Continent-Europe-Aftermath-World-ebook/dp/B006ZL9C8E https://www.amazon.com/Savage-Continent-Europe-Aftermath-Wor... It's very ugly, but not what you describe.
- lonelappde 7y agoThat book describes the same civil wars that happened for the hundreds of years before 1945 too.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- coliveira 7y agoIn the US there is the well-known phenomenon that during big catastrophes the media will concentrate on looting, as if this was a big problem and not the reasonable response to closed stores, full of products that people need.
- devdas 7y agoSpecifically, back people loot. https://www.aclu.org/blog/smart-justice/mass-incarceration/black-people-loot-white-people-find https://www.aclu.org/blog/smart-justice/mass-incarceration/b... https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/hurricane-katrina-looters/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/hurricane-katrina-looters/
- hpliferaft 7y agoYesterday I read an article that claims an opposite of elite panic -- working class denial? -- of the virus is happening in my city [0]. The thesis is that a community (euphemistically termed a "subculture") of older African Americans in Philadelphia refuse to participate in the quarantine due to their skepticism of the federal government's public health directives due to previous medical conspiracies, namely the Tuskegee Experiments. 0: https://6abc.com/health/expert-says-subculture-still-thinks-covid-19-is-hoax-/6069785/ https://6abc.com/health/expert-says-subculture-still-thinks-...
- lonelappde 7y agoYou're missing an adjective in there. It takes a special kind of mind to cite a case of government disregarding the health of African-Americans, as rationale for the thesis there is no health risk.
- phkahler 7y ago>> To some extent this reflects their own implicit belief that humanity is by nature grasping, avaricious, amoral, and cruel, and that their status depends on power and violence. A lot of that sounds like projection.
- sershe 7y agoAs someone who grew up outside of the USA, I feel like the problem in America is the diametrically opposite one. People have too much faith in "normality", rule of law and relative stability and don't realize that stuff like that breaks down and stops working very easily, with even minor disruptions. Power plants are suddenly not supplied with oil, being stopped by a cop can be scarier than being stopped by a robber, and if you confront someone trying to break down a building door in the middle of the day their response is "so what are you going to do? go away before you get in trouble". etc. Or as some guy from Argentina described, if someone steps in front of your car you hit the gas, not the break. Heck, the order broke down in NO after Katrina - and it was a small, short-lived, localized inconvenience by developing world standards. The "elite panic" is spot on and should not be confined to the elites, especially given the non-existent safety net, and the widespread accessibility of firearms.
- perl4ever 7y agoI was surprised when a lot of people started expressing concerns about lawlessness recently, because it wasn't obvious to me why this crisis should lead to that. But are they wrong?
- philwelch 7y agoWhile I've never seen The Walking Dead, I'm a little puzzled why someone would balk at a post-apocalyptic "nihilistic display of humanity where tribal survival is all that matters and every individual encountered is almost certainly some sort of rapist or cannibal and just needs to be stomped out". Without civilization and culture this is what human beings are like. It's the "state of nature" Hobbes wrote about, and much of it fits with observed behavior of hunter-gatherers as well as chimpanzees. I'm not saying you and me and all the nice friendly people you know are like this, deep down. I mean, some of us probably are and are just good at hiding it, but many of us aren't. But in a Malthusian scenario where survival is at a premium and the material abundance of modern civilization is no longer here, who do you think is going to survive?